• Published 19:21 07.06.10
  • Latest update 19:21 07.06.10

Israel to appoint state panel to investigate Gaza flotilla raid

Government source: Committee to comprise top justices and two international observers; Barak: Panel to make sure Gaza siege is lawful.

By Barak Ravid Tags: Israel news Gaza flotilla

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was expected to announce on Monday or Tuesday the creation of a state panel of inquiry to investigate the Israel Navy's deadly raid of a humanitarian aid flotilla bound for the Gaza Strip last week.

A senior source in Jerusalem said the panel would comprise top justices experienced in matters of international and marine law. Two international justices – at least one of them American - would be invited to participate as observers, said the source.

Israeli forces approaching Gaza flotilla

Israel Navy forces approach one of six ships of an aid flotilla bound for Gaza on May 31, 2010.

Photo by: Reuters

In addition to investigating the circumstances surrounding the Israel Navy's seizure of the Turkish-flagged Mavi Marmara, the committee will also be charged with looking into the legality of Israel's closure of the Gaza Strip and its naval blockade.

Netanyahu's forum of top seven ministers decided to create the internal investigative panel on Monday, after days of deliberation. An official announcement on the matter was awaiting approval from the attorney general, to ensure that there were no conflicts of interest among the potential members of the committee.

The forum of seven ruled in its decision that the panel would not be allowed to interrogate soldiers or officers who took part in the commando raid, which left nine Turkish activists dead and several people wounded. It was not yet clear whether senior Israel Defense Forces officials – including IDF Chief of Staff Gabi Ashkenazi and Israel Navy Commader Eliezer "Chiney" Marom - would be investigated by the panel.

The ministers' decision comes on the heels of a United Nations proposal to establish an international committee comprising representatives of Israel, the U.S. and Turkey to investigate the incident.

Despite growing international pressure, Netanyahu had balked at the proposal, claiming Israel has the right to investigate itself.

Defense Minister Ehud Barak told Knesset on Monday, in response to a no-confidence motion submitted by the opposition with regard to the raid, that Israel would examine ways to minimize friction in enforcing its blockade of Hamas-ruled Gaza.

"We intend to achieve an investigation of the events," Barak said, without giving details about the format of the probe.

He did say that the state panel would serve in addition to a separate military investigation, and that it would seek to establish whether Israel's four-year blockade of Gaza and its raid "met with the standards of international law".

"We will draw lessons at the political level [and] in the security establishment," Barak said. "Since the event we have heard and read mountains of talk and questions and without a doubt in the coming months we shall discuss lessons ... perhaps additional ways to achieve the same goals of the blockade, by reducing as far as possible the potential for friction."

  • Print Page
  • Send to a friend
  • Share
  • Text Size +|-
 
 
TalkBacks

Why Facebook Connect?

Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.

Add a comment

Add your reply

  • 14. 70 4
    Impartiality?
    • Cesare
    • 07.06.10
    • 20:24

    I am investigating myself about myself that will be very impartial!

  • 13. 59 3
    Whitewashing
    • Froy
    • 07.06.10
    • 20:24

    Anybody expects anything form this "panel" but absolute support for the official Israeli version of events?

  • 12. 32 4
    Whitewashing
    • Froy
    • 07.06.10
    • 20:23

    Anybody expects anything form this "panel" but absolute support for the official Israeli version of events?

  • 11. 47 3
    The committee mandate
    • omri
    • 07.06.10
    • 20:14

    So, in other words, the mandate is to exonerate Israel, and prove that they act by the law and that IDF has highest ethic standards. I wonder if they are going to give the committee all the videos and the cameras with the films that they stool from the activists?

  • 10. 31 3
    The committee mandate
    • omri
    • 07.06.10
    • 20:14

    So, in other words, the mandate is to exonerate Israel, and prove that they act by the law and that IDF has highest ethic standards. I wonder if they are going to give the committee all the videos and the cameras with the films that they stool from the activists?

  • 9. 49 3
    Will the 2nd International Observer
    • Rose
    • 07.06.10
    • 20:04

    have the same "special relationship" with Israel as America has? If so then the cover up commences.

  • 8. 55 5
    An impossible restriction on the investigation
    • Logios
    • 07.06.10
    • 19:58

    The Forum of Seven ministers did not yesterday come to a decision on the format of the investigation, except for one guiding principle: "IDF soldiers shall not be investigated". Fine, the soldiers will be protected, but if they are not interrogated how would it be possible to establish WHAT ACTUALLY HAPPENED on the ship? And this is what Turkey wants to find out, how did the raid end up with 9 dead Turks?

  • 7. 46 1
    Whitewash.
    • Bazmann
    • 07.06.10
    • 19:50

    "The forum of seven ruled in its decision that the panel would not be allowed to interrogate soldiers or officers who took part in the commando raid". Whitewash. At least, give it the appearance of being a credible panel.

  • 6. 36 2
    Whitewash.
    • Bazmann
    • 07.06.10
    • 19:50

    "The forum of seven ruled in its decision that the panel would not be allowed to interrogate soldiers or officers who took part in the commando raid". Whitewash. At least, give it the appearance of being a credible panel.

  • 5. 75 6
    Your credibility is already zero
    • John, another American
    • 07.06.10
    • 19:38

    ... you want to make it go negative?

  • 4. 68 6
    "won't interrogate IDF commandos'. Farce and a whitewash.
    • Michael UK
    • 07.06.10
    • 19:38

    What's the point of an investigation that doesn't investigate? All this is supposed to be is a panel that will come back and say that attacking the flotilla was legal.

  • 3. 70 6
    " Not Permitted To Question IDF Soldiers" - Are You Kidding??
    • chet - Canada
    • 07.06.10
    • 19:36

    This condition will give the world confidence in the findings of the inquiry.

  • 2. 88 6
    Not good enough
    • Chet
    • 07.06.10
    • 19:36

    Without the IDF's being question there is no way to have an impartial hearing. This is Israels way of trying to cover up their crime. An International probe is the only way to find the actual facts.

  • 1. 17 54
    panel to investigate
    • Edifice
    • 07.06.10
    • 19:31

    A UN panel should be set up yo investigate the alledged sinking of a Sth Korean sub by Nth Korea. A panel should also be set up to investigate Syrian and Iranian arms smugglin to Hezbollah in defiance of a UN resolution.. PAnels should also be set up to investigate genocide in Dafur, Turkish Genocide in Armenia, etc, etc.