Former Mossad chief: Israeli attack on Iran must be stopped to avert catastrophe
Meir Dagan speaks out against military offensive on Iran, expresses concern that Defense Minister Barak believes Israel only has less than a year to carry out an attack.
By Amos Harel Tags: Iran Iran nuclear Mossad Ehud BarakFormer Mossad chief Meir Dagan warned Thursday against an Israeli attack on Iran, saying such a move would likely lead to a regional war involving Hezbollah, Hamas, and Syria.
"I'm concerned about possible mistakes and I prefer to speak out before there is a catastrophe," Dagan said in an interview on the Israeli television program “Uvda."
|
Mossad head Meir Dagan. |
| Photo by: Tomer Appelbaum / BauBau |
"I think that engaging, with open eyes, in a regional war is warranted only when we are under attack or when the sword is already cutting against our live flesh. It is not an alternative that should be chosen lightly."
Dagan stressed that though he cannot predict how many casualties an attack on Iran would yield, he said, "I have to assume that the level of destruction, paralysis of every-day life, and Israeli death toll would be high."
He said that he has no interest in hiding his fervent opposition to an Israeli attack on Iran from Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Defense Minister Ehud Barak.
Dagan said he was worried about Barak's past comments on Iran, saying Barak believes Israel has less than a year to carry out an military strike.
"I am very concerned," he said. "My understanding of Barak's comments is that Israel must act within this timeframe, but I don't believe this is accurate."
Earlier Thursday, Barak responded to comments by U.S. Joints Chiefs of Staff General Martin Dempsey, who said that he did not know whether Israel would alert the United States ahead of time if it decided to take military action against Iran.
Barak said Israel isn't looking for war with Iran and said that he would be pleased if diplomatic moves and sanctions sway Tehran away from its contentious nuclear program.
Barak's comments came after Israeli intelligence sources told the Times of London on Wednesday that a recent explosion in the western Iranian city of Ishafan was not an accident, as Iranian officials had claimed, and that the local uranium conversion plant had been damaged in the blast.
The intelligence officials told the Times that updated satellite images showed smoke billowing from the direction of the conversion plant.
According to the Israeli sources, there was "no doubt" that the blast had damaged the nuclear facility, and that the explosion was not an "accident."
"This caused damage to the facilities in Isfahan, particularly to the elements we believe were involved in storage of raw materials," one source told the Times.
Read this article in Hebrew: דגן מודאג: מדברי ברק עולה שישראל חייבת לפעול באיראן תוך פחות משנה
Why Facebook Connect?
Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.
- Latest
- Most Viewed
- Most Rated
- Open all
it will happen and soon you will see cloud on many location in iran. time for mulahs to run or hide like rat in the bunkers or roch motel of sadam .the 72 virgins are waiting .
I am sure meir is well informed of irans progress...and yet, is it at all possible that iran may produce a nuclear weapon before dagan estimates? Is it possible that by the time his proverbial sword cuts flesh, there will be a bright flash ? Personally, I think that iran has been sanctioned now for how many years? how long has this conversation been goin on? has iran stopped? have they respected the international community? no...they just get closer and closer... I am quite certain that meir KNOWS that sanctions wont work...and if that is in fact the case, then waiting makes no sense while they harden defenses and activate cells....it makes no sense.
Some of us in the Middle-East would love to see Bibi attacking Iran , I am one . It will not be a quick war , it could easily last 3 or 4 years . Israel , if any of it is spared , would look like Gaza today . If Israel uses nukes , nothing and no one will be spared .
israel attacks iran, iran and syria declares war against israel, USA attacks iran and syria, and.. BOOM Russia and china on the stage..
Would David have shirked from defending Israel in G-d's name, out of fear? Israel has a right to exist. It's a kill or be killed world, and there is no mercy for the weak in the middle east.
Peace is possible between Israel and Iran. The way to thwart crisis is thru a sustainable peace solution to the Palestinian-Israeli issue. I assure you no one is seeking their destruction thru MAD, not Israel and not Iran.
cause the middle east to explode... i been saying for long time... let women be in charge and handle diplomacy men only know to blow things up either out of proportion or like pretty firework... not like anyone listen
Right now, the version is, for a lot of people, "Iran will get a bomb soon, and use it, if there is not intervention". In fact that narrative may be motivated more by internal Israeli issues than anything involving Iran. Another point. When a person says "let's build a consensus to fight", they are dangerous to their own side. When a person says "we must never fight", they are similarly dangerous. What does Dagan say? ("when we are under attack or when the sword is already cutting against our live flesh").
Is this man planning to run for public office? Why is he pushing his agenda forward? We know there are are inherent risks in striking Iran in order to prevent a future Iranian Jihad nuclear holocaust. We all know this, but the alternative is worse. If Syria, Iran, Hamas, and Hizbollah attack Israel, Israel will defend itself with every means possible.
run for office and give me the honor of voting for you.
Barak is a joke.
you won't fight alone - the entire free world will stand with you shoulder to shoulder
Americans by the super-majority would rather kill the person(s) that get them into the next war than any so-called enemy. WE DON'T WANT WAR. WE WILL NOT SPARE A SINGLE SOLDIER FOR ISRAEL'S PHONY WARS OF HEGEMONY.
what sort of back up do you propose here. prayers, a juju? LOL. too bad paul the octopus died , a prediction would have been useful:-)
Fight your own wars!!