Defense workers exposed to chemical agents develop cancer
Authorities refuse to recognize full extent of disabilities; employees say warned against going public.
By Haaretz StaffTroops and officers who were exposed to chemical warfare agents have fallen ill with cancer and other diseases, but the authorities are refusing to recognize the full extent of their disabilities.
The soldiers say they have also received threatening visits from members of the Defense Ministry's security department - MALAMB - after they launched a campaign to have their disabilities recognized for compensation.
One former soldier who fell ill was warned not to tell his story to the media, while another patient's doctor and lawyer both had their computer hard disks seized.
The story was uncovered by Channel 2 television's "Fact" program, which will air Thursday night.
The Defense Ministry said in response: "[MALAMB chief] Yehiel Horev never spoke with any of those mentioned in this affair. Any effort to link his name with the matter is slanderous and misleading."
Captain Avi Meshulam worked in a laboratory at the Tzrifin base that developed and tested protective fabrics against chemical and biological agents. He was exposed for years to mustard gas, nerve gas and other hazardous substances.
"We would simply take fabrics and drip substances such as mustard gas on them - small quantities meant only for this purpose," he said. "We wanted to see how long it took them to penetrate the protective fabrics."
He said the workers ate in the lab, which no longer exists, and food was stored in the lab refrigerator.
The defense establishment evidently knew that the experiments were dangerous, because a letter sent to the lab head ordered that they be stopped "until a safety permit is obtained." However, the work continued for several more years, with workers wearing only ordinary rubber gloves, Meshulam said.
The experiments were conducted in sealed glass rooms, and the poisonous fumes were supposedly funneled outside by ventilating hoods. But one former employee, who asked to remain anonymous, said that the hoods "were not the best," and some gas escaped. Meshulam also said he now realizes that the poisonous gases were recirculated through the room by the ventilating system.
The second employee added that during his two years at the lab, he cannot recall ever having been given a medical exam.
Meshulam began developing health problems during his service, and they worsened after his release. He had respiratory problems that eventually developed into severe asthma, contracted an eye disease, and then, in 1993, was diagnosed with cancer.
But the defense establishment said that for security reasons, Meshulam could not see a doctor of his choice or even tell his physicians where he worked and to what substances he had been exposed. And while it recognized his respiratory and eye ailments as work-related, it refused to recognize his cancer as linked to his work at the lab.
In a different case, an officer developed serious physical and psychological problems - including chronic pain, palsied hands, memory loss and rage attacks - following an accidental nerve gas leak.
The defense establishment recognized the physical ailments, but not the psychological ones. The officer was denied access to his medical file or given any documentation of the accident.
After the officer sued the defense establishment, MALAMB confiscated documents from him and seized the hard disks from his doctor's and lawyer's computers.
Regarding the hard disk seizures, the Defense Ministry said: "This was an exceptional case in which the plaintiff and the lawyer had possession of classified documents that they removed from the defense establishment without authorization, in violation of the law." The confiscators had a search warrant signed by a judge, it added.
|
Yehiel Horev, left, head of the Defense Ministry's security department. (Archives) |
Why Facebook Connect?
Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.
- Latest
- Most Viewed
- Most Rated
- Open all
it is your nature
This is what happens when state security rates higher than citizens safety. This is what happens when medical or scientific research is performed under substandard conditions. This is what happens when the government ignores its responsibilities toward the citizen. The problem is not the research, but the fate of the workers, who are not accused, Soviet style, of defaming the state or revealing state secrets.
Dan : yes !!
Now this is what I call "true democracy"! Way to go Israel, way to go!
We all have WMD's in our weapons arsenal - US, UK, France, Israel etc etc The DIFFERENCE IS...we dont use them or threaten chemical attacks on other countries on a weekly basis....
In addition to Israel having nuclear arms, it is also heavily involved in chemical stuff. People from the south of Lebanon who lived through the last war could have given you information on Israel's work with chemicals such as the phosphorus bombs. We saw pictures of Israeli soldiers, without protective clothing handling uranium bunker buster missiles last July and it's only a matter of a few years before you start seeing problems developing with these people. All this chemical stuff that Israel is playing with could one day fall on Israel itself.
Do I need to list the countries? Hey, call me crazy but for us, Jews, one time was enough.
It seems that the only person who knows how to get more than adequate disability compensation in Israel is Tartman, so perhaps these guys could learn a thing or two from her.
Sounds like IDF is building and holding stocks of chemical WMDs.