Amid nuke talks, Barak says Iran must halt uranium enrichment
Defense Min. calls draft nuclear agreement 'mixed blessing,' says talks must have limited duration.
By Haaretz Service Tags: Ehud Barak Israel news Iran nuclearDefense Minister Ehud Barak said on Thursday that Iran must halt enriching uranium, in the most senior Israeli response to an internationally backed draft plan that calls for Tehran to ship its uranium abroad for enrichment.
"I repeat that the cessation of enrichment by Iran is needed, and not just the removal of the enriched material... and a short and limited time for discussion is needed," Barak said at the closing ceremony of the second Peres Presidential Conference in Jerusalem.
"This agreement - if it is ever signed - will manage to turn back the accumulation of the enriched material in Iran by about a year. But this is a mixed blessing."
The defense minister added that if Iran did not stop the enrichment, the only consequence of the agreement would be that the Islamic Republic would have received legitimacy for enriching uranium on its soil for civilian purposes.
This would be, Barak said, "in clear opposition to the understanding of the parties dealing with [Iran], and their understanding of the real program: to reach a nuclear capability."
Barak's comments came after Israel's national security adviser instructed all government officials involved in the Iranian nuclear issue not to respond to media reports on the draft agreement.
Uzi Arad, who heads the National Security Council, issued the directive to officials in the Foreign Ministry, the Atomic Energy Commission, the Defense Ministry and the Israel Defense Forces.
A senior political source in Jerusalem said the directive was issued because Israel wishes to ascertain the details of the draft agreement and to ensure media reports on the deal are accurate.
Despite Arad's instructions, Deputy Defense Minister Matan Vilnai said Wednesday that the campaign to pressure the Islamic Republic seems to be bearing fruit.
"This proves how important international pressure is," Vilnai told Army Radio. "Iran is more susceptible to pressure than we may believe."
Even if Iran agrees to the plan to reduce its stockpile of enriched uranium, world powers need to keep pressure on Tehran to prevent it from developing nuclear weapon capabilities, he said.
Vilnai said Israel would examine the UN draft agreement cautiously, "paying attention to every detail," to make sure Iran was not just trying to buy time.
Israel would also like to verify whether the deal reflects the positions of the International Atomic Energy Agency, the United States and European countries.
Defense officials and intelligence experts are still trying to understand the basis for the agreement, which was presented by IAEA chief Mohammed ElBaradei.
A senior defense source said the entire story seems strange, and it remains unclear how this agreement came about.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu met Wednesday with European Union foreign policy chief Javier Solana, who is spearheading talks with Tehran on behalf of the Western powers.
Officials in the prime minister's bureau refused to state whether the reported deal came up in Netanyahu's talks with Solana.
Netanyahu discussed the Iranian issue in his conversation with the U.S. ambassador to the United Nations, Susan Rice.
Rice, who addressed the President's Conference in Jerusalem on Wednesday, said the U.S. would not allow Iran to obtain nuclear weapons, and would not ease pressure on Iran over this issue.
Why Facebook Connect?
Comment on Haaretz.com articles with your Facebook login, and share your thoughts on your own wall.
- Latest
- Most Viewed
- Most Rated
- Open all
Why has there been no discussion of Israe's not so secret nuclear weapons and enrichment????
very well said m8.
"A senior defense source said the entire story seems strange, and it remains unclear how this agreement came about" yes what is not engineered by you must seem strange to you Israelis.lol
that Iran must be a nuclear power.
was a nuclear energy expert and involved in the talks with Iran? Wonder how he fell 40 meters?
Isreal is not in a position to dictate the debate as long as they are not the signotory NPT. It it time Isreal stop being hypocritical and sign NPT. Get rid of your nuks other wise shut up.
I can only support what the majority in this forum are saying: Barak, as representative of a country that is not a signatory to the NPT and one that consistently acts in contravention of international law, is in no position to comment in any way on the discussion in Geneva. His words are as significant as autumn leaves falling on the ground.
...Barak. We've all had enough of your bleating on Iran. Double standards at play are almost offensive.
Abbas and Barak are in the same boat. One has no control over Hamas, and the other over settlers. While Abbas can no longer hide his dismal situation, Barak still has a go. He will continue to try and shift the focus on Iran/Palestinians or whoever, while at the same time emotionally blackmailing US. Unfortunately for Barak, the arrival of the Goldstone report a UN will spark a riot which will focus attention right on Barak's head.
Israel should halt and destroy it's nuclear program first! Who is Israel to dictate to a country more than 10 times it's population and size what they can and can't do... Israel in is defiant of over 40 UN resolutions and have been convicted of war crimes recently, the whole world should go after Israel and disarm them of Nukes.
"What about Israel's nuclear proogram?" Harumph-harumph.
Shut up Barak! Israel is not even a member of NPT it has no legitimacy no right to interfere. If anything the P5 sould demand Israel opens its nuc sites to the world.
...to dictate to other countries that they cannot have nuclear power when Israel is loaded with nukes? Israel still exhibits that arrogant "we are special and can do anything we want and the rules don't apply to us" mentality that makes people the world over hate them. Unless Israel is ready to sign the NPT and open up to international inspections of their nuke facilities, it has no right to dictate to a signatory of the NPT that they have to give up the rights they clearly have under the NPT. And if Israel wants no nukes in the Middle East, then it needs to get rid of its own because Israel is the only nuclear-armed country in the Middle East. It's no wonder Iran wants nukes to protect itself, given how many times Israel has attacked, invaded and/or occupied other countries in the region.
I guess the 3+2 have a pretty good idea of what they are doing. The EU has made its red lines clear from the outset and it looks to be coming to the conclusion they wanted. Bibi, Barak and Lieberman jumping up and down in the wings doesn't adds anything, their aggressive utterances are only a red rag to a bull where Iran is concerned. It would be more useful if Israeli politicians did what Uzi Arad said, keep their mouths shut at this critical juncture - and keep off the stage please..
Israel has nuclear weapons. Israel should let inspectors take a look at their Nuclear facilities before they cry about Iran.
Prove me wrong?
Clap clap for Barak - what a statesmen.
Iran is in the dog house because it violated the NPT. When it is again in TOTAL compliance with the NPT and the Additional Protocols, then the UN will no longer have a problem with Iran's enrichment. As a non-signatory nation who refuses to allow any safeguards and inspections Israel is in no position to object.
Barak can say what he wants, but the NPT says that Iran has the inalienable right to enrich uranium. So who the hell does Barak think he is, to dictate to a sovereign nation what it can or cannot do? Would Barak accede to Iranian demands to open up Dimona and to destroy every nuclear weapon that Israen has? Of course not. Israel is not a signatory to the NPT, therefore has a right to develop nuclear weapons without monitoring. Iran is a signatory to the NPT and has a right to enrich uranium and nobody has the right to demand otherwise.
He can't even deal with the Palestinians. The only thing in which he seems to be quite effective is contending with unarmed settlers in the middle of the night !
The US and the P5+1 should just ignore him. If a deal is achieved with Iran, so much the better. Barak has NO SAY. If Israel wants a different deal with Iran, make one yourselves.