Jewish World News

In Christmas address, pope praises France's chief rabbi's essay against gay marriage

Pope Benedict describes gay marriage as a 'crisis' that 'threatens' Western society; in his study, Rabbi Bernheim says homosexual rights groups 'will use gay marriage as a Trojan Horse' in a wider campaign to "deny sexual identity and erase sexual differences.

Pope Benedict XVI delivers his message on the occasion of the exchange of Christmas greetings
Pope Benedict XVI delivers his message on the occasion of the exchange of Christmas greetings with the Roman curia, in the Cleme... / Photo by AP
By Reuters and JTA
Published 11:37 22.12.12

more from this blog

In his Christmas address to Vatican officials, Pope Benedict praised an essay by France’s chief rabbi on the negative effects of gay marriage. Specifically, the pope described as "profoundly moving" a study by Rabbi Gilles Bernheim that has become the subject of heated debate in France.

Bernheim, also a philosopher, argues that homosexual rights groups "will use gay marriage as a Trojan Horse" in a wider campaign to "deny sexual identity and erase sexual differences" and "undermine the heterosexual fundamentals of our society."

His study, "Gay Marriage, Parenthood and Adoption: What We Often Forget To Say," Bernheim argues that plans to legalize gay marriage are being made for "the exclusive profit of a tiny minority" and are often supported because of political correctness.

Throwing the full weight of his office behind a study by France's chief rabbi on the effects the legalization of gay marriage would have on children and society, the pope said, "There is no denying the crisis that threatens it (the family) to its foundations - especially in the Western world." The family had to be protected, he added, because it was "the authentic setting in which to hand on the blueprint of human existence."

During his Christmas address to Vatican officials, the pope blended religion, philosophy, anthropology and sociology to illustrate the position of the Roman Catholic Church. He also signaled the Vatican was ready to forge alliances with other religions against gay marriage.

In his speech, Pope Benedict repeated some of the concepts in the Bernheim study, including an assertion that children raised by gay couples would be more "objects" than individuals.

A 'threat to the family'

The Vatican has gone on the offensive in response to gains for gay marriage in the United States and Europe, using every possible opportunity to denounce it through papal speeches or editorials in its newspaper or on its radio station.

In his latest denunciation of gay marriage, the 85-year-old pope, speaking in the frescoed Clementine Hall of the Vatican's Apostolic Palace, said the family was being threatened by "a false understanding of freedom" and a repudiation of life-long commitment in heterosexual marriage.

"When such commitment is repudiated, the key figures of human existence likewise vanish: father, mother, child - essential elements of the experience of being human are lost," the leader of the world's 1.2 billion Catholics said.

In the speech, one of the most important the pope gives every year, he said people could not "dispute the idea that they have a nature, given by their bodily identity, that serves as a defining element of the human being."

The "pre-ordained duality of man and woman" had to be respected, he said, if families and children were not to lose their place and dignity.

People could not become what he called "abstract human beings" choosing for themselves what their nature would be, added.

Religious alliance

In some countries, the Catholic Church has already joined forces with Jews, Muslims and members of other religions to oppose the legalization of gay marriage, in some cases presenting arguments based on legal, social and anthropological analyses rather than religious teachings.

In response to the pope's speech, Franco Grillini, a leader of Italy's gay community, called the pope's words "great foolishness," saying, "Where gay marriage has been approved, there has been no consequence on heterosexual marriage".

Last month, voters in the U.S. states of Maryland, Maine and Washington state approved same-sex marriage, the first time marriage rights have been extended to same-sex couples by popular vote.

Same-sex unions have been legalized in six states and the District of Columbia by lawmakers or courts.

In November, Spain's highest court also upheld a gay marriage law, and in France the socialist government has unveiled a draft law that would allow gay marriage.

Thank you

Your talkback has been submitted successfully.
If selected for publication, it will appear as soon as possible on Haaretz.com.

please wait...