This article sounds like it was written in five minutes. But after a few readings I think I got the idea... The largest flaw in this entire argument assumes that a young Jew's learning about Israel stops as soon as he/she leaves the country. That assumption is the real insult to the intelligence of young Jews. Birthright is an introduction, not a comprehensive history/academic lesson into the nuances of Israeli culture and society.
from the article: Birthright Israel tours are insulting young Jews' intelligence