Reply to Amira - Comment - Israel News | Haaretz Daily Newspaper
  • p.TextOutput { R static java.lang.String = ''; R static java.lang.String p.publicInterfaces = ''; R static java.lang.String p.beanClass = ''; RW java.lang.String value = '0'; R transient java.lang.Object _data = ''; },ModelStore=com.polopoly.model.ModelStoreInMap p.TextOutput { R static java.lang.String = ''; R static java.lang.String p.publicInterfaces = ''; R static java.lang.String p.beanClass = ''; RW java.lang.String value = '0'; R transient java.lang.Object _data = ''; },ModelStore=com.polopoly.model.ModelStoreInMap
    • LS
    • 20.11.12 | 02:15 (IST)

    You can argue that the international community should never have sought too establish a Jewish homeland - but it did. You can wish that it was otherwise, you can hope that it will be otherwise, but as you write Israel does exist, so surely it is better to address issues based on reality rather then on wishful thinking. Yes, if my home had been taken from me I might hold an enduring hatred for those who were responsible or after 60-plus years I might decide to come to terms with it and try to achieve the possible rather then continuing to want to wage war over it. After all, holocaust survivors lost everything and started again. My own family were kindertransport children. The way they dealt with the tragedy that befell them was not to hate but to study hard in school, go to university and carve out successful lives for themselves. I accept that Palestinian refugees would not have had the same opportunities, but they could have had more of the same mind-set. Instead of focusing so much on what they perceived to be the enemy, they could instead have chosen a more pragmatic path. It is not entirely Israel's fault that the Palestinians have never come to terms with the Nakba that befell them and did not re-balance their energies towards achieving a new state rather then the destruction of Israel. You argue that Oslo never gave the Palestinians real hope for a state of their own. On that I don't agree with you. Maybe I am wrong - and you are right - but there is much evidence to suggest that Arafat was never really an honest "player". Regardless, I agree that most Israelis are willfully ignorant of the evils of the occupation or even believe it is a blessing - others of us believe that it is corrupting Israel's soul as is so much of what Israel does - your example of how Israel treats the Bedouins is very pertinent. Regardless, I find it hard to understand why you cannot take a more balanced view of how things are in the region. Iran, Hamas and Hezbollah have all declared many times that they wish to see Israel destroyed, at least as a Zionist state. These are not the words of people who simply want to see an end to the occupation and a less repressive Israel in other areas of life. These are people who have said they will stop at nothing until Israel is destroyed. Do they not therefore have to take some responsibility for how things are today or at least share that responsibility with the current government in Israel which does not wish to see the Palestinians achieve any form of viable statehood and nurtures the fanatics within its own society? It seems to me that when you have extremists on both sides setting the agenda, then both sides are to blame for what is happening today. Not just Israel!

    from the article: Israel's 'right to self-defense' - a tremendous propaganda victory
    First published 04:06 19.11.12 | Last updated 04:06 19.11.12
Haaretz Headlines
IDF soldiers in the West Bank village of Awarta, June 26, 2014.

Israeli officer wounded in shootout with Palestinians

IDF forces, accompanied by members of a police counterterrorism unit and Shin Bet security service, come under fire in West Bank town while attempting to conduct arrest.

A partial view of Israel's Dimona nuclear power plant in the southern Negev desert.

Israel asks Egypt to drop nuclear challenge at IAEA

Efforts to advance resolution at International Atomic Energy Agency's upcoming General Conference have been a source of tension between Israel, Egypt.

Yenta the matchmaker in "Fiddler on the Roof"

The dating shame: Orthodox obsession with externals

As a married woman, I get to see the other side of the dating world these days – that of the ‘matchmaker’ – and wonder what message is being sent to my generation of bright, religiously passionate women

Palestinian boy looks at  school yard in the village of Sour Baher in East Jerusalem. March 5 2002.

How many schools has Israel built in East J'lem?

Statistics released by the municipality last week don’t correspond with data recently given by various council departments to a local NGO.