Can Orthodox Jews ask gentiles to press the 'walk' button?
A deadly traffic accident on Yom Kippur raises an important halakhic question.
The incident this past Yom Kippur involving a woman in Jacksonville, Florida who was killed while crossing an intersection with dangerously fast cars was very tragic indeed. It not only left the 16-year-old daughter who was with her with life-threatening injuries, it left her orphaned, for this young lady had lost her father many years earlier.
The tragedy brings up a halakhic question: In an area where the traffic light poses a danger in crossing because it is green for too short a time to cross safely, would it be permitted to ask a gentile to press the button?
The prohibition and its reasons
Generally speaking, the sages forbade asking a gentile to perform an otherwise- prohibited action on the Sabbath or on a Jewish holiday. The prohibition is called “Amira l’Akum” and is found in Shabbat 121a, where we learn that it is forbidden to ask a gentile to extinguish a (non-life-threatening) fire.
The explanations given for this prohibition are many.
Rashi (Avodah Zarah 15a) explains that the Rabbis felt that it would be a violation of v’daber davar (Isaiah 58:13) — speaking about prohibited things. Elsewhere, (Shabbos 151a) Rashi explains that the sages made it as if the Jew was performing the violation himself through the concept known as “shlichus.”
Finally, the Rambam explains that the Rabbis were concerned that a Jew who asks a gentile to do something forbidden may take the Shabbat lightly himself and come to a violation himself.
Exceptions to the prohibition
There are times when exceptions were made to this rabbinic prohibition. Some exceptions pertain even to a biblically forbidden restriction, while other exceptions only pertain to a rabbinic restriction. For example, during Friday night’s twilight one may ask a gentile to perform a biblical prohibition for the needs of Shabbat. When there is fear of a significant loss of money, one may ask a gentile to perform a rabbinic violation — but not a Biblical prohibition.
The rationale is that under these four circumstances, the Rabbis never made the restriction of forbidding one to ask a gentile to perform an action that will remedy the situation.
Avoiding danger is a mitzvah
It is this author’s view that when faced with a dangerous intersection, ensuring that one crosses safely is a mitzvah. The Torah tells us (Devarim 4:15) to be careful with our souls (“Take ye therefore good heed unto yourselves”) and, earlier (Devarim 4:9), to watch ourselves (“Only take heed to thyself, and keep thy soul diligently”).
The Rambam (Hilchos Shmiras HaNefesh 11:4) rules that these verses teach of the mitzvah to remove dangers. Rav Chaim Kanievsky Shlita (in his responsa 24-30 as cited in Nesivos Chaim p.17) rules that, in fact, one fulfills two mitvahs by abiding by these Psukim.
For a mitzvah, one may ask a gentile to perform a rabbinic violation
The Rambam (Hilchos Shabbos 6:9-10), Mishna Brurah (307:23) and Aruch Hashulchan (OC 276:16) clearly state that for the needs of a mitzvah, one may ask a gentile to violate a rabbinic stricture. Other modern Poskim (Dayan Weiss Minchas Yitzchak Vol. VIII #57) rule this way too, and a minority of Poskim even permit asking the gentile to perform a full-fledged biblical prohibition when it is a Tzorech Mitzvah (See Mogain Avrohom 276:2).
Nature of traffic lights
The Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD) is a document issued by the United States Department of Transportation to specify the standards by which traffic signs, road surface markings, and signals are designed, installed, and used. In the United States, all traffic control devices must conform to these standards. The manual is used by all state and local agencies as well as private construction firms to ensure that the traffic control devices they use conform to the national standard. Traffic light bulbs are incandescent bulbs and most traffic departments across the country have not yet made the switch to florescent or to LED displays.
Most Poskim rule that florescent or LED displays are a rabbinic violation, but turning on or off an incandescent bulb is, generally, a Torah prohibition according to virtually all Poskim. A good argument can be made, however, that asking a gentile to press the pedestrian button is, in fact, permitted.
Why one may permit asking a gentile
Why might this be the case? The pressing of the button in most of the older systems that still fit the MUTCD does not happen instantly. Indeed, at certain times, depending upon traffic and timing, pressing the button does not cause a change at all according to the MUTCD guidelines.
Certainly, however, there is a delay of the changing of lengthening of the crosswalk timing as well as in turning the light to oncoming traffic red sooner. This delay would very likely be viewed by some Poskim as a “gram hadlaka” (see Shmiras Shabbos K’hilchasa Vol I 12:25 citing the view of Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach zt”l).
The Biur Halakha in 334:22 rules that gram hadlaka is permitted under certain circumstances, which clearly indicates his view that it is only a rabbinic violation.
Even according to the other Poskim
However, the author of the Maaseh Choshev (Vol. I #30) disagrees with this view and considers even a delay in the switch as “maaseh byadayim mamash,” actual and direct action, and thus would look at it as a biblical violation. Here too, one can make an argument that when the issue concerns a matter of even a small risk of life, the lenient opinions cited earlier in the Magain Avrohom can be relied upon. There is even another reason to be lenient — here we are dealing with two mitzvos, not one, as explained by Rav Chaim Kanievsky Shlita.
When this author presented the case to permit asking a gentile to press the crosswalk button to some leading Poskim, the Poskim agreed to the underlying rationale. They also agreed that the leniency can be promulgated in their name. The Poskim were Rav Moshe Heinemann Shlita from Baltimore and Rav Shmuel Fuerst Shlita from Chicago.
Rav Heinemann Shlita added, however, that one should try to ascertain whether the person being asked is truly a gentile. Although one could perhaps rely on the majority of people that one comes in contact with in such circumstances are gentiles, there is also a principle of “efshar levarer mevarerin,” - when we can easily ascertain the facts, we do.
This article first appeared in the Five Towns Jewish Times.
Yair Hoffman is an educator and former pulpit rabbi who has authored several halakhic works including “Around the Year – a Guide to the Jewish Holidays.”
Like us on Facebook and get articles directly in your news feed