The Anti-Defamation League has lashed out at rock star Roger Waters, claiming imagery used in his latest tour is anti-Semitic.
The Anti-Defamation League has lashed out at rock star Roger Waters, claiming imagery used in his latest tour is anti-Semitic.
thank you
Your talkback has been submitted successfully.
If selected for publication, it will appear as soon as possible on Haaretz.com.
How disappointing, the English Waters turns out to be a bigot. Talking about land grabs, Canada, USA, the Falklands, Australia and so on, Mr Waters?? What on earth are you up to? Why dont you pull your folks out of Australia, or, show some integrity.
And he has trouble pronouncing the word Arab-Muslim terror.
I was at opening night in Toronto. Foxman does not mention that the plane also drops Islamic and Christian symbols as well as Shell Oil and Mrecedes Benz. The message purely being one of religious intolerance and mass consumerism which tend to enslave most of us in fear and greed. Open your eyes next time and accept that its not all about you.
as most anti-Semites are.
Roger Waters has lost his impact on the world opinion. his main audience in israel were mostly lefty apologists
So interesting that, in a world of sorrows and tears and injustices, Mr. Waters' imagination has been captured by Israel. The story of how that one country came to dominate his political landscape is surely worth hearing.
since the wall or fence has been installed i believe that Israel citizens have not been killed by Arab terrorists, which proves the need of the wall. Why are Israel detractors not concerned about the thousands of missiles fired by Hamas and their unwillingness to allow for peace negotiations? I think their anti-Semitic nature is showing & who real cares what a sixty old fossil thinks?
What's with these aging 'former rock stars with too much money? At least Ozzy has the integrity and intelligence to stick to what he does best; rock'n roll! Waters is washed up and pathetic and is using Israel's life-saving wall to sustain his diddy about a wall. What a goof!
the blood cult called israel is being exposed by good people; yeah pink floyd
the blood cult called israel is being exposed by good people; yeah pink floyd
and I was sickened by his anti semitic messaging towards the end of the show. I have to say, while I love pink floyd, I was not there to be preached to about politics, of which roger waters knows precious little. His justification is that he was once shown great courtesy by a family while in lebanon, some 30 yrs ago. Hospitality is great, but when you then go on to believe everything your host says and it then becomes your world view, you got issues. At least he should keep his politics out of the concert tours, this way, people who pay good money to see him dont feel preached to in any way.
How can using the Star of David to represent Israel bombing whatever is represented in the cartoon be construed as anti semitic. As he is using a symbol that is central to Israel to represent Israel as an agressor. And since when was the dollatr symbol representative of the Jewish State. When in this context it represents the funding by the American taxpayer which enables Israel (represented by the Star of David a part of the Israeli flag) to bomb whatever is depicted in the cartoon. Foxman yet again trying to silence critics of Israel by tarring them with the brush of anti semitism and therefore supporters of Hitler and all that represents. There must be mid terms coming up a nice little story to stop the politicians going for votes by pointing out the cost of supporting Israel per annum and how they would stop it.
By this logic I can put up images of the Islamic crescent together with suicide bombings, beaten women and executed homosexuals and claim that this is just a political criticism of countries that feature a crescent in their flag
You have finally admitted that Israel is the "JEWISH STATE." It's a start
Anti-semitism has been used and abused to the point that no one pays any attention to it anymore. Foxman and the ADL quick trigger use of the anti-semitic phrase is achieving the opposite results.
get used to it. and much more like it on the way. you no longer control the narrative
The US is finishing a 1200 mile wall along its border with their ally, Mexico; EVERY Arab and Eurabian state have border walls. ONLY Jews are not allowed. How apt!
Foxman acknowledges that criticism of Israel does not mean antisemitism, but stereotyping of Jews and money is. BTW- Where is the "fair minded" Mr. Waters criticism of the terrorism that made construction of the barrier necessary in the first place?
the zionist or the Palestinians.....who stole who land...who has been cleansing others off the land....... who who who
Uhhh - If you honestly study history, the answer to all your questions above = The Arabs ... sorry to reveal the truth to you. Read the Massacre of Hebron (not the fairy tale one in Jenin)
The vocal and vociferous ADL has spoken.... gibberish. The dollar sign is I suspect a reference to the seemingly never ending support of the American administration for their proxy in the ME. The ADL just doesn’t seem to understand that anti Israel vis-à-vis settlers, land theft illegal occupation and a physical barrier constructed on someone else’s land is not the same as anti Semitism. What do you think? I’m just curious.
It's not anti-Semitic to speak out and show the crude, brutal reality in the Palestinian territories.
The crude, brutal reality of pitched battles between the Fatah and Hamas factions, the summary execution of Arabs who chose to sell land to Jews, the discrimination against Christian Arabs which has caused so many of them to emigrate. The brutal reality of Iranian support for terror in Israel, in Lebanon elsewhere. And you want to create yet another Islamic fundamentalist state? The vision of world peace held by most leftists calls for the destruction of the U.S. and Israel. Only then, they belive, can there be true peace in the world.
Waters has lost any credibility he might have had by resorting to such odious stereotypes. Not surprising though considering the overt anti-semitism so prevalent among the UK left.
you sure you meant to insert that qualifier? c'mon, say what you really mean! That is, anti-semitism is so prevalent in the UK, the US, the EU, Asia and anywhere else a critic of Israeli policies might be found
Roger Waters has lost his impact on the world opinion. his main audience in israel were mostly lefty apologists
Just look at Israel's boycott of Wagner's music... it has done Irreparable damage to that composer and his music.
good luck with that one :DD
try again... We should all get ONE THING STRAIGHT before continuing this discussion: It is not a "FENCE". It is a WALL. It's a 8 metre high, re-enforced concrete WALL.
The Berlin wall was officially called 'anti-fascist security barrier' in East Germany. Oh, and the swastika is just an ancient, benign and religious symbol. Who'd associate the Star of David with war? Crazy.
Strong borders make for good neighbors!! Just look at the 1200 mile long 20 foot high barbed wire covered WALL the US is building between the US and Mexico. And they are friends. Build it high build it strong!
Too much LSD I guess.
...you dumbass!
The sad thing is there are some real anti-semites out there, but Foxman has just become a mouthpiece for right-wing Zionism. If he criticises someone it's impossible to know whether they're really anti-semtic or just insufficiently fanatical in their Zionism for Foxman's liking.
The truth hurts. What else did you expect for your behavior? Flowers? Roger Waters is an artist not a politician. Why should he lie to you? There’s nothing “anti-Semitic” there anyway. Get a life!
Inasmuch as it has been, it can hardly be claimed use of it in a negative context is necessarily anti-semitic. How else is he supposed to represent Israel?
the ADL is referring to the dollar signs.
News: Diplomacy and Defense | National | World | Middle East | Features | Opinion | Israel weather | Maccabiah 2013
Jewish World: News | Rabbis' Round Table | The Jewish Thinker Culture: Books | Food and Wine | Arts & Leisure
Haaretz.com Blogs: A Special Place in Hell | West of Eden | Diplomania | Routine Emergencies | Jerusalem Vivendi
The Axis | Strenger than Fiction | East Side Story | Modern Manna | The Fifth Question
Haaretz.co.il: ספרים | ספורט | מפלס הכנרת | ביקורת מסעדות | בלוגים | חדשות חוץ | גלריה | מזג אוויר | חדשות | הארץ
FAQ | Contact us | Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy | Management | Editorial | Employment Opportunities | Advertise on Haaretz.com | Haaretz News Widget
Design by Roni Arie | Accelerated by cotendo
The Jewish World edition of Haaretz.com and Haaretz Newspaper offers extensive coverage of Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora, Jerusalem, Sephardic and Ashkenazi Jews, European Jewry, British Jewry, French Jewry, American Jewry, synagogues, Jewish museums, Kashrut, kosher food, Reform, Orthodox and Conservative communities, the Holocaust, Jewish conversion, circumcision, marriage and intermarriage.