Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., June 11, 2009 Sivan 19, 5769 | | Israel Time: 04:43 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Focus U.S.A. Travel Week's End Anglo File
Share |
Last update - 00:00 07/07/2008
Dead Sea tablet suggests Jewish resurrection imagery pre-dates Jesus
By Ofri Ilani, Haaretz Correspondent
Tags: Jesus, Christianity 

The premise that the Messiah died and was resurrected after three days is considered the foundation of the Christian faith, one which differentiates it from Judaism. Through the generations, this belief stood at the center of the debate between Christians and Jews. But now, a mysterious tablet from the time of the second temple has led researchers to believe that this premise of messianic resurrection is not unique to Christianity, but rather existed in Judaism years before Jesus was born.

The tablet, which has been dubbed "Gabriel's vision" because much of its text deals with a vision of the apocalypse transmitted by the angel Gabriel, was discovered eight years ago, but a large part of it is illegible and researchers have had difficulty interpreting its meaning.

Israel Knohl, a professor of Bible studies at Hebrew University in Jerusalem, has offered a new interpretation of this text recently, which has sparked interest in the Christian realm. Knohl's interpretation could shed light on the history of Jesus and the way Christianity grew out of Judaism.
Advertisement

"Gabriel's vision," a previously unknown prophetic text written in the first century B.C.E., was written on a large gray limestone tablet. In the center of the text, which includes quotes from the Bible and prophetic verses, there is an image of the angel Gabriel. The tablet was not discovered in an organized archaeological excavation, therefore the location of its discovery is not clear. Some believe it was found in Jordan on the eastern shore of the Dead Sea.

The New York Times reported recently that the tablet was bought from a Jordanian antiquities dealer by an Israeli-Swiss collector who kept it in his Zurich home. When an Israeli scholar examined it closely a few years ago and wrote a paper on it last year, interest began to rise. There is now a spate of scholarly articles on the stone, with several due to be published in the coming months.

"I couldn't make much out of it when I got it," said David Jeselsohn, the owner, who is himself an expert in antiquities. "I didn't realize how significant it was until I showed it to Ada Yardeni, who specializes in Hebrew writing, a few years ago. She was overwhelmed. 'You have got a Dead Sea Scroll on stone,' she told me."

Yardeni and fellow researcher Binyamin Elitzur published a long analysis of the text in the Hebrew-language history and archaeology quarterly "Cathedra". However, Professor Knohl interpreted one of the words in the text differently, changing the meaning of the text entirely.

"This is a revolutionary text," Knohl said when presenting his research at a conference marking 60 years since the discovery of the Dead Sea Scrolls held this week at the Israel Museum in Jerusalem. "The text changes the way we look at the historical Jesus, and provides a missing link connecting Judaism and Christianity," he added.

"I identified a previously unrecognized Jewish notion that the blood of the messiah is necessary in order to bring about national redemption. The idea of a tortured messiah who was resurrected three days after his death was adopted by Judaism before the birth of Jesus. The main ideas of the Jesus myth existed in Judaism," Knohl went on to say.

In the "Gabriel's vision" text there are 87 lines. Toward the end, on the 80th line, there is an unclear sentence containing the words "shloshat yamin" (three days). The next word is broken up, and when the text was first published, three dots were used in its place. However, Professor Knohl recognized it as "Hayia", which he interpreted to be the command form of the work "Hai", to live, concluding that the text is describing the angel Gabriel as someone who raises from the dead the prophet leader named "Minister of ministers" three days after his death. He associates this minister with a historic figure-a Jewish leader named Shimon who declared himself king and led a failed rebellion against Herod in the year 4 B.C.E. until he was killed by Herod's army.
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Holocaust Memorial
Elderly gunman named as white supremacist opens fire on guards at D.C. memorial.
Why 'Jewish' state?
A.B. Yehoshua argues that the many qualifiers of Israel's name do more harm than good.
  1.   haaretz belated reporting 10:40  |  yoram raanan 07/07/08
  2.   A Jewish "scholar" reveals his bias 10:54  |  Clickfool 07/07/08
  3.   So, maybe Yeshua (Jesus) var the Mashiach after all then... 10:56  |  Maamina 07/07/08
  4.   Israel Knohl theories on biblical tablet 11:07  |  Alan Abbey 07/07/08
  5.   THERE GOES CHRISTIANITY!!! OOOPS! 11:23  |  Samy 07/07/08
  6.   explosive stuff, should not be in Haaretz 11:32  |  dyinglikeflies 07/07/08
  7.   Guess what 11:33  |  Sorry but... 07/07/08
  8.   Read again Samy 12:18  |  Josef Mica 07/07/08
  9.   So what`s new? 12:45  |  Sherlock Holmes 07/07/08
  10.   On the back it has a report on the Nadal/Federer Final 13:03  |  Ronnie Wolman 07/07/08
  11.   Missing Link? 13:04  |  Miriam 07/07/08
  12.   This confirms Christianity 13:05  |  Petru Ion 07/07/08
  13.   What bias? FOOL @2 13:11  |  Joe Moer 07/07/08
  14.   Difficulty in interpreting its meaning 13:13  |  Michael Cecil 07/07/08
  15.   A n australopithecine theory 13:27  |  A thinking Jew 07/07/08
  16.   # 3 and the sky is pink with green spots 13:28  |  Jew 07/07/08
  17.   Ok click fool they pre-existed in ISLAM 13:29  |  just for you... 07/07/08
  18.   To #6: It was in the NYT. Yesterday 13:37  |  reader 07/07/08
  19.   New research of Christianity?s accepted facts 13:38  |  H.H.M 07/07/08
  20.   ONLY CLICKFOOL.... 13:45  |  Brant 07/07/08
  21.   #5 13:57  |  Christian 07/07/08
  22.   New research of Christianity?s accepted facts 13:57  |  H.H.M. 07/07/08
  23.   Resurrection 14:03  |  NK 07/07/08
  24.   Clickfool #2 14:12  |  examiner 07/07/08
  25.   Dead Sea Tablets 14:31  |  Abraham Habash 07/07/08
  26.   Several Messianic cults and sects of Judaism existed. 14:43  |  The Equalizer 07/07/08
  27.   #5 - seems like you totally understand what is being said? 14:57  |  redmike 07/07/08
  28.   of course it does. old news 15:05  |  Jos 07/07/08
  29.   jesus 15:45  |  jem 07/07/08
  30.   p.s 15:56  |  jem 07/07/08
  31.   yeshua and the dying messiah texts 16:20  |  augustine e johnson- 07/07/08
  32.   #24: Jesus Doesn`t Fullfil OT Prophecies but rather Typologies 16:26  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 07/07/08
  33.   # 11 Dear Miriam The Missing Linc? 17:10  |  KATHY 07/07/08
  34.   Various messianic concepts 17:15  |  Mariano 07/07/08
  35.   Clickfool you sad puppy 17:18  |  Harvey (Chaim) 07/07/08
  36.   Jesus 17:33  |  BILL 07/07/08
  37.   Ressurection is alluded to in Daniel 18:10  |  Simeon 07/07/08
  38.   Can we bury the Meshiah for eternity? 18:19  |  Joe Hulllitse 07/07/08
  39.   quibble 19:02  |  potobac 07/07/08
  40.   No so surprising 19:24  |  MichaelF 07/07/08
  41.   To Clickfool #2 19:52  |  Peter 07/07/08
  42.   Its always like that 19:59  |  Shek 07/07/08
  43.   To # Miriam - correction 20:00  |  David 07/07/08
  44.   Belief 20:02  |  shekar 07/07/08
  45.   It is difficult to may you understand. 20:04  |  shekar 07/07/08
  46.   that is your inrpratation 20:06  |  shekar 07/07/08
  47.   All religious stories were stolen from earlier.... 20:12  |  Deborah 07/07/08
  48.   Very convenient, writing on stone, so it cannot be dated -- This 20:14  |  Absalom 07/07/08
  49.   #5 Samy 20:28  |  Jim 07/07/08
  50.   #9 Sherlock Holmes 20:54  |  Jim 07/07/08
  51.   #21 Christian 21:14  |  Jim 07/07/08
  52.   For Brant # 20 21:16  |  Clickfool 07/07/08
  53.   For Peter # 34 21:19  |  Clickfool 07/07/08
  54.   Pro Jesus 21:22  |  Follwer of Christ 07/07/08
  55.   This strengthens Christianity 21:27  |  Terry 07/07/08
  56.   no reason to get excited, the thief he kindly spoke... 21:29  |  frenz 07/07/08
  57.   #23 NK 21:34  |  Jim 07/07/08
  58.   Christianity is false; Islam speaks of the true Jesus 21:42  |  Ex-Christian 07/07/08
  59.   Applied Ignorance 21:49  |  A thinking Jew 07/07/08
  60.   #32 Alb 22:22  |  Jim 07/07/08
  61.   Judeo-Christian talks back 22:51  |  Mike 07/07/08
  62.   #37 Potobac 22:59  |  Jim 07/07/08
  63.   # 54 frenz Has Anyone Heard of The Gnostic Gospels? And.. 23:10  |  anonymous 07/07/08
  64.   #51 Clickfool 23:12  |  Jim 07/07/08
  65.   #52 Follower of Christ 23:15  |  Jim 07/07/08
  66.   #56 Mike 23:24  |  Jim 07/07/08
  67.   Jesus in the Dead Sea Stone 23:32  |  CharlaX 07/07/08
  68.   Christians, rejoice!. This confirms our faith in Jesus 23:59  |  Yaakov Sullivan 07/07/08
  69.   Myth # 60 00:18  |  Clickfool 08/07/08
  70.   Click: explain the difference 00:50  |  kevin 08/07/08
  71.   Instead of showing his disdain I`m sure Click 02:27  |  Free Gilad Shalit 08/07/08
  72.   Kevin #70 02:31  |  Free Gilad Shalit 08/07/08
  73.   #58 02:54  |  Christian 08/07/08
  74.   The greatest identity theft of all time! 04:02  |  Eliyahu 08/07/08
  75.   huh? 04:51  |  Josh 08/07/08
  76.   Yeshua (Jesus) THE MASHIACH 10:09  |  Saby 08/07/08
  77.   Mashiach is Yeshua 10:13  |  Saby 08/07/08
  78.   Yeashua Mashiach 10:17  |  Saby 08/07/08
  79.   tablet 13:24  |  follow the evidence 08/07/08
  80.   76 et al think stuttering helps? 19:34  |  Sorry but... 08/07/08
  81.   second temple period beliefs 00:39  |  Doug Gibson 09/07/08
  82.   Yeshua LORD 01:08  |  Marco 09/07/08
  83.   How can we draw conclusions? 09:04  |  Amanda 09/07/08
  84.   no decay/third day - - "Scriptures concerning himself" 00:36  |  cory 10/07/08
  85.   Tablet 03:46  |  Linda 10/07/08
  86.   3 Days 05:26  |  Shin-Tov 10/07/08
  87.   Jesus was a symbol for pre-creation promise 10:46  |  king of Israel 10/07/08
  88.   a matter of faith 12:23  |  Manolo ME expert 10/07/08
  89.   Apotheosis = Ascenssion 12:39  |  Manolo ME expert 10/07/08
  90.   Jesus was not `a true jew` 12:53  |  Manolo ME expert 10/07/08
  91.   Nothing of that can changes us 13:07  |  Manolo ME expert 10/07/08
  92.   some `church echoes` before Christ 13:27  |  Manolo ME expert 10/07/08
  93.   Caius suetonius dixit 13:36  |  Manolo ME expert 10/07/08
  94.   Was Jesus a carpenter or a sailor? 13:40  |  Manolo ME expert 10/07/08
  95.   What if jewish is a myth 14:00  |  Manolo ME expert 10/07/08
  96.   Be `religious` toda is a nonsense 14:18  |  Manolo ME expert 10/07/08
  97.   The river of life, the son of man and understanding God Ezekiel 4 16:53  |  Simon 10/07/08
  98.   To Miriam from Stockholm 21:04  |  Shoshana Thomasson 10/07/08
  99.   Jewish Sect 23:30  |  Ann 10/07/08
  100.   The river of life, the son of man and understanding God Ezek 47:9 13:03  |  Simon 11/07/08
  101.   Response to samy 17:25  |  ally 11/07/08
  102.   A myth, a legend, just like Zeus, Apollo, Isis etc. 19:11  |  Galit 11/07/08
  103.   Jesus, Apollo, Isis, the Cat in the Hat, Myths and all Legends. 19:46  |  Galit Shachar 11/07/08
  104.   #101 22:04  |  Ann 11/07/08
  105.   the Stone 02:21  |  Jeri 12/07/08
  106.   To Galit 02:47  |  Rebecca 12/07/08
  107.   This Confirms Anointed Son 05:44  |  Sha`ul ha Yahudah 12/07/08
  108.   To Jem 10:45  |  George 12/07/08
  109.   To support Galit 19:21  |  JMK 12/07/08
  110.   JMK WANTS TO SPREAD THE HATE??? 00:16  |  Rebecca 13/07/08
  111.   SEEKING GOD`S TRUTH? 01:53  |  Rebecca 13/07/08
  112.   Worship Satan! 22:30  |  illuminist 13/07/08
  113.   Jews coveting Jesus too... 00:43  |  Edithann 14/07/08
  114.   O.T. 20:36  |  T. Blake 14/07/08
  115.   To illuminist... 09:29  |  Rebecca 15/07/08
  116.   Edithann 23:59  |  Rebecca 15/07/08
  117.   Dead Sea Tablets 12:56  |  Kai 16/07/08
  118.   Interesting but not earthshattering 03:21  |  PastorGadget 16/08/08
Special Offers
Advertisement
hotel Jerusalem
David Citadel Hotel, come stay at the finest of Jerusalem hotels.
ISRAEL ARMY SURPLUS STORE
IDF insignia,Uniforms, Paladium Boots Watches, Israel Army T-shirts & Collectibles
Dead Sea Skin Care
Quality cosmetics from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 12% off!
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
More Headlines
03:35 Neo-Nazi kills guard at U.S. Holocaust Museum
03:35 WATCH: Obama 'saddened' by attack at U.S. Holocaust Museum
03:32 Background / Holocaust museum shooting suspect's history of seething anger
02:26 Report: Two Israeli Arab sisters arrested in Lebanon
04:12 Obama to Mubarak: Netanyahu fears peace moves will ruin coalition
04:18 Erekat: Palestinians in position of strength for first time
21:33 Carter to hold rare meeting with settler leader
19:55 Yishai urges Netanyahu to cancel Tel Aviv gay parade
20:58 WATCH: Daily news round-up from Israel
00:00 Special ed teacher suspected of threatening students with rifle
12:50 A.B. Yehoshua / Why do we insist on a 'Jewish' state?
19:09 Ahmadinejad calls rival Iran candidates 'Hitler'
16:18 Woman mistakenly junks $1 million mattress
19:26 Former Liberian warlord Charles Taylor 'converts to Judaism'
16:50 Cabinet to IDF: Respond to any attack from Gaza
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
| Israel 2009 election results | Makom: Engaging on Israel
| Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved