Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., July 10, 2008 Tamuz 7, 5768 | | Israel Time: 16:04 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Peres Conference Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Comments:  248
Last update - 20:34 03/07/2008
Baby's mother killed by Jerusalem terrorist who was shot, but kept going
By Anshel Pfeffer, Haaretz Correspondent and Haaretz Service
Tags: Israel, terror attack 

The Palestinian terrorist who killed three people in a stolen bulldozer in Jerusalem on Wednesday had been shot, but rallied despite his injuries, and launched a second rampage, taking the life of 33-year-old Bat-Sheva Unterman.

Unterman had been driving with her five-month-old daughter when Hussam Duwiyat plowed into their car. Duwiyat had passed out when he was shot by a policewoman and a security guard after killing Elizabeth Goren-Friedman, 54, and Jean Raloy, 68.

But he regained consciousness when someone threw a rock at him, and set off on his second killing spree, hitting the Untermans' vehicle. Bat-Sheva was killed instantly but her child was unharmed. Passers-by pulled the infant from the car moments before Duwiyat smashed into the vehicle for a second time.
Advertisement
Dozens of other people were wounded when the Palestinian construction worker deliberately plowed into a crowded bus and a string of cars on Jaffa Street in downtown Jerusalem.

The Untermans tried for many years to have a child, and five months ago their dream came true when Efrat was born. On Wednesday, Bat-Sheva was making her way back from a medical clinic near Jaffa Street, with Efrat by her side in the baby seat, when Hussam Duwiyat began his rampage on the busy Jerusalem street.

When Bat-Sheva turned onto Jaffa Street, it appeared the rampage had come to an end - the bulldozer was standing still and several people were clamoring around the wounded driver. But that dud not last for long.

"The bulldozer crushed the front of the car," said Jeremy Aharonson, 20, who witnessed the attack. "The driver was shot at and then he drove backwards a little. We ran to the vehicle, me and two other people. We saw the driver lying there behind the wheel, with a baby seat next to her. We saw the baby inside, who looked healthy, she wasn't even crying."

"We tried to open the door but it was bent. They were shouting at us to stay back, that the car might explode, but two of us managed to pry the door open and take the baby out," Aharonson recounted.

A moment later, the terrorist again rammed his bulldozer into the car with Bat-Sheva still inside, this time crushing it completely. It was the last vehicle he collided with before he was shot dead moments later.

Efrat was delivered unscathed into the hands of paramedics nearby. A rumor soon spread that her mother had saved her from the wreckage of her car just before she died. A team of medics checked the warped wreckage of the car to see if Bat-Sheva was still alive inside, but she no longer had a pulse.

Unterman was a resident of Jerusalem and had worked for years as a kindergarten teacher at the Har Homa neighborhood. She was born in Israel to Rivka and James Lubenstein, a couple who emigrated from Holland.

She was married to London-born Ido Unterman, whose grandfather, Isser Yehuda Unterman, was chief rabbi of Liverpool and Tel Aviv before becoming Israel's chief rabbi between 1964 and 1973.

"Neither of them, Efrat and Ido, gave up on their dream to have children," said Meira Schwartz, a family friend. "Before Efrat was born, she treated all the kindergarten children like they were her own. She was a graceful kindergarten teacher with the utmost patience for each and every child."

After the attack that killed her mother, Efrat was taken to Shaare Zedek Medical Center, where she was examined. "The whole two hours we had her she was in the children's ward, in the hands of one of the ward's secretaries, showered with attention," said Amalia Oren, the director of the Kestenbaum Department of Social Work at Shaare Zedek.

Bat-Sheva's husband Ido, an investment banker, was at work all day and had no idea that his wife had an appointment that put her at the site of the attack. He was only told that she had been killed hours after the event.

Efrat was delivered into her father's arms seven hours after the attack, which took place at noon. Around 20 minutes after he was reunited with his daughter, Ido set out for the morgue with his brother to identify his wife's body.

'It's difficult to speak about her in past tense'

Elizabeth Goren-Friedman, originally from Austria, was a resident of Katamon who worked as a teacher in a school for the blind. She was laid to rest at 10:30 P.M. in Givat Shaul.

Goren-Friedman was divorced and the mother of three children: Yael, 16, Issachar, 19, and Zvi, 23. Both of her sons were students at the Horev hesder yeshiva in Jerusalem.

Her friends described her as a "wonderful person," who volunteered regularly at the Hadassah Ein Kerem Hospital.

Rachel Sakrovish, who worked with Goren-Friedman, said her colleague was an excellent teachers. "It's hard to speak about her in the past tense. Lili was a wonderful person. There was not a student that she did not help progress on a personal, educational, and rehabilitative level. We knew that if a student was retreated or having difficulties, Luly was the teacher who would do the fundamental work to help him advance."

"When I think of her, I remember the phrase, 'a woman of valor, who can find,'" she said.

'Family was the first thing with Jean'

Jean Raloy, an air-conditioner technician who lived in the Gilo neighborhood, was the third person killed in the terrorist's murder spree.

His nephew said "family was the first thing with Jean ." Raloy, who was born in Iran, was married to Hanna and the father of two daughters
and a son, and was to become a grandfather in about a month.

More videos from the scene of the attack:
Jerusalem terror attack: Clip 2
Jerusalem terror attack: Clip 3
(Please note that some of the images in these videos are of a graphic nature)

Related articles:
  • Three dead, dozens hurt in Jerusalem terror attack
  • Bradley Burston / Palestinian terrorism as a natural act
  • Jerusalem bus driver: Terrorist looked me in the eye and drove at me
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    By the numbers
    A study shows Jewish Israeli men live almost four years longer than Israeli Arabs.
    Local threat
    The Shin Bet arrests two Bedouin, accused of supplying information to al-Qaida.
      1.   i am very sad ,but 23:45  |  fayza 02/07/08
      2.   May their memories be blessed 23:51  |  Rony 02/07/08
      3.   It is not enough to demolish terrorist`s home 00:00  |  Genuine Tosefta 03/07/08
      4.   One moment you go to work, the next you die 00:15  |  Tulip 03/07/08
      5.   Israel Is At War But Still Doesn`t Get It 00:34  |  Dave Levy 03/07/08
      6.   Tosefta from Tveria 01:05  |  Tulip 03/07/08
      7.   David Levy and Israeli Arabs 01:08  |  Tulip 03/07/08
      8.   5.Dave levy,counsels of desperation! 01:27  |  lakshmi 03/07/08
      9.   Sadisti Narcisists 01:33  |  Molly 03/07/08
      10.   demolish this man`s home today 01:38  |  hal tripp 03/07/08
      11.   what happened is aweful! 01:53  |  bashar 03/07/08
      12.   our blood is not cheaper than yours 02:13  |  Bilal 03/07/08
      13.   Unterman`s baby saviour named 02:34  |  News Flash 03/07/08
      14.   Fayza 02:35  |  Meir 03/07/08
      15.   this was the work of evil 02:41  |  nizam 03/07/08
      16.   Senseless 02:59  |  Baz Mann 03/07/08
      17.   bile of Beirut 03:06  |  Absolute Israel 03/07/08
      18.   to fayza 03:12  |  muggi 03/07/08
      19.   Fayza, your words ring true 03:37  |  Gilles 03/07/08
      20.   tulip 03:39  |  Genuine Tosefta 03/07/08
      21.   To Genuine Tosefta 03:46  |  Gilles 03/07/08
      22.   Actually Muslim and particularly Arab blood is much cheaper than 03:47  |  Genuine Tosefta 03/07/08
      23.   Condolences 04:51  |  Shmuel 03/07/08
      24.   Muslims cheapen themselves 06:30  |  Soldier of Above 03/07/08
      25.   apparently those who feel it is always Israel`s fault will blame 06:39  |  Big Sur 03/07/08
      26.   Response to I am sad but 06:40  |  Yosefa 03/07/08
      27.   Bilal @12 The world sees plenty.since 48 you have not let the Isr 06:43  |  Big Sur 03/07/08
      28.   All Arabs OUT of Israel 06:44  |  Shoshenet 03/07/08
      29.   terror attack 06:46  |  mary 03/07/08
      30.   terror attack 06:55  |  mary 03/07/08
      31.   to # 12 : Nah Muslim`s Blood is not cheaper ! :) 08:11  |  Bilal 03/07/08
      32.   no time to point out fingures 08:23  |  Antoine 03/07/08
      33.   What are the chances of peace? 08:33  |  Jean Van Daem 03/07/08
      34.   Fayza, shame on you ! (#1) 08:58  |  Benjamina 03/07/08
      35.   Don`t jump to conclusions 08:58  |  Yonatan 03/07/08
      36.   My condolences to the bereaved families 09:00  |  Benjamina 03/07/08
      37.   Bulldozer VICTIM: Rachel Corie 09:15  |  Mark 03/07/08
      38.   Rachel Corie 09:16  |  Mark 03/07/08
      39.   #14 MEIR TORONTO 09:21  |  SYD 03/07/08
      40.   MARK bulldozer SUICIDE Rachel Corrie.Normal people move away 10:10  |  PETER SM 03/07/08
      41.   Nobody offered themselves as sacrifices here 10:27  |  x-ray 03/07/08
      42.   Civilised people arrest, offenders. They shoot only if necessary 10:29  |  Freedom 03/07/08
      43.   #35 Yonatan. "Don`t jump to conclusions." 10:36  |  Maureen Ann 03/07/08
      44.   my condolences to the families of all three... 10:50  |  eric 03/07/08
      45.   barberic,backward terrorist 10:58  |  nic 03/07/08
      46.   Jail those who preach incitment 11:09  |  arun 03/07/08
      47.   Arabs 11:30  |  Peyman 03/07/08
      48.   Re: Soldier of Above: Israelis who cheapen themselves 11:50  |  Guy From NYC 03/07/08
      49.   Tosefta #3 I`ve always wondered what Haaretz considers printable 11:51  |  S 03/07/08
      50.   Eric 12:13  |  zionist 03/07/08
      51.   Terrorist got his just deserts 12:15  |  Adrian de Klerk 03/07/08
      52.   Fayza, talk is not enough, we need action 12:16  |  Joe Sittizen 03/07/08
      53.   Freedom 42 12:21  |  ChanahS 03/07/08
      54.   that is intensive coverage 12:21  |  pitcher 03/07/08
      55.   tulip 12:39  |  merre 03/07/08
      56.   freedom, he stole a cop`s gun 12:48  |  from jerusalem 03/07/08
      57.   The deadly seed within Judaism 12:58  |  K 03/07/08
      58.   alternative explanation for attack? 12:59  |  Reuben Jacobs 03/07/08
      59.   My prayers for the families, how very sad. 13:06  |  Virginia 03/07/08
      60.   I CAN FEEL THE ANGER OF THE MAN 13:27  |  indrajaya 03/07/08
      61.   Reuben Jacobs 58 13:31  |  ChanahS 03/07/08
      62.   #58........Nice choice of names Limey from londonistan 13:32  |  Ari ben Yisrael 03/07/08
      63.   Alternative explanation? 13:39  |  Reuben 03/07/08
      64.   Reuben jacobs: Columbine 13:40  |  Guy From NYC 03/07/08
      65.   #2 reply 13:53  |  observer 03/07/08
      66.   # 1...fayza... do the israelis care? 14:06  |  ravi 03/07/08
      67.   to Giles in Montreal 14:19  |  Hilda 03/07/08
      68.   INDRAJAYA can you feel the anger of victims of Islamist terror 14:30