Changing the rules - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Sat., July 05, 2008 Tamuz 2, 5768

Israel Time: 16:56 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Rosner's Domain

Diplomacy

Defense

Jewish World

Opinion

National

Print Edition

Car Rental

Books

Peres Conference

Business

Real Estate

Easy Start

Travel

Week's End

Anglo File

Last update - 09:25 01/07/2008

Changing the rules

By Yoel Marcus

Tags: Israel, Ehud Olmert

All the ministers knew that Eldad Regev and Ehud Goldwasser were no longer alive. All the ministers knew that Israel had agreed to free the murderer of the Haran family, Samir Kuntar. They all knew he would return home, sated and satisfied, with his bushy mustache and his potbelly, as a Lebanese national hero, in exchange for the bodies of two of our kidnapped soldiers. The whole country knew what the government's decision would be. Only Prime Minister Ehud Olmert played Hamlet.

Photos of a meditating Olmert, posed like Rodin's sculpture "The Thinker," appeared all over the media. The cabinet convened, and his associates intimated that he hadn't reached a final decision yet about whether to go ahead with the deal. Only in the course of the meeting was it reported on the news that the prime minister had resigned himself to releasing the Nahariya murderer.

As if he had a choice. In practice, Olmert was in the same position as then-defense minister Yitzhak Rabin in the Ahmed Jibril deal. In that swap, on May 20, 1985, 1,150 Arab prisoners, among them some of the most vicious killers, their hands literally dripping with blood, were freed in exchange for three Israeli captives. Rabin later confessed that the pressure of the families was more than he could bear.

	Advertisement

Even if Olmert's indecision was partly an act and partly caused by a genuine fear of Israel's security services, which were not happy with the deal, he really had no choice. He would have brought Regev and Goldwasser home at any price - and I think justifiably - because of public pressure, and even more so, the pressure of their families, who had the public rooting for them.

In the wake of this miserable affair, Israel must wake up to the sad fact that 60 years after its establishment, we are looking at a crueler, more cannibalistic, less humane Middle East. During World War II, even Nazi Germany abided by the conventions governing prisoners of war, at least in the case of American and British POWs. Letters could be sent and received through the Red Cross. The families at least knew whether they were dead or alive.

In this ongoing war against the dark forces of fundamentalist Islam in our region, we must be prepared for the possibility of more kidnappings, more POWs and more cynical abuse of families by withholding news of their loved ones. Aware of the supreme value Israel attaches to human life, Hezbollah played a cannibalistic game with us, refusing to provide even the most basic information on the fate of soldiers who had fallen into their hands.

For two whole years, there was no sign of life from Regev and Goldwasser, yet they led us to believe they were alive. This tragic saga now coming to an end, which has driven the families and the whole country insane, cannot be allowed to repeat itself.

Israel knows that its wars are not over yet. No matter how much we try, and no matter how careful we are, there could be more kidnappings and more soldiers taken prisoner. No one can guarantee that something like this won't happen again. In light of this threat, the question is whether the time hasn't come to establish a new set of principles - principles that are better suited to dealing with the kind of brutal enemy we confront. We need to be tougher. We need to stick harder to our guns. We need to lay down ultimatums and insist on receiving information about prisoners or captive soldiers immediately, whether they are dead or alive.

The other side banks on the assumption that Israel is softhearted and will give in, sooner or later, to all its demands. And they love to toy with us. Listening to Nasrallah talk about haggling with Israel over body parts, with that cynical, self-satisfied smirk on his face, is enough to drive anyone up a wall. Religious cannibalism? I'm not even sure the Prophet Mohammed would sign on the dotted line.

This cruel horse-trading, exploiting the sensitivity of Israelis to the preciousness of human life, is a wake-up call to Israel to toughen its stance. It must refuse to take part in this sale of human beings. The current deal must be the last in the Israeli government's decades of bargaining to bring home its boys. Another question that begs to be asked is why the defense establishment saw fit to play by the heartless rules of Israel's enemies and pretend that Regev and Goldwasser were alive.

In view of the developments in recent weeks, I believed it was too late to play hero. Looking at the suffering of the families, I said this sad story needed to be brought to an end at any price. But from now on, Israel needs to take a new tack in its approach to kidnappings and those responsible for them.

We need to be tough when toughness is called for, and pragmatic when pragmatism is called for. If they kidnap your people, you kidnap theirs, and grab people so high up on the totem pole that it shocks them out of their minds. Let them be the ones on the begging end. It's time they played by our rules.

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	'Colombian Entebbe'
	Israelis contributed to the dramatic Colombia rescue of 15 hostages.


	Handshake controversy
	Iraqi MPs voice their rage at President Talabani for shaking the hand of Ehud Barak.




1.	Yoel Marcus presents the old argument for continued failure	09:47	\|	Natallie Durson	01/07/08

2.	"It`s time they played by our rules."	09:50	\|	Maureen Ann	01/07/08

3.	It`s always "from now on..." (never) we`ll do the right thing.	09:59	\|	S	01/07/08

4.	Your share of the problem	10:00	\|	Marwan	01/07/08

5.	you can change the rules now	10:09	\|	joe	01/07/08

6.	Now, no more Mr Nice Guy......	10:12	\|	Clickfool	01/07/08

7.	You reap what you sow!	10:22	\|	Vinegar Hill	01/07/08

8.	Marcus, Yesher Koyach!!!!!!!!!!!	10:22	\|	Harvey (Chaim)	01/07/08

9.	More like changing the rules back	10:27	\|	Softwalker	01/07/08

10.	#1 You are so beside the facts	10:34	\|	A mother	01/07/08

11.	#4 Marwan : The source of the problem?	10:38	\|	Proud Israeli	01/07/08

12.	Tuff choices	10:40	\|	A mother	01/07/08

13.	Set up a Kidnapped Israeli Ethics Committe	10:57	\|	Proud Israeli	01/07/08

14.	A Mother - You live in a small world, I live in the big world	11:05	\|	Natallie Durson	01/07/08

15.	# 8 Harvey/Chaim Blind leading blind	11:10	\|	Vinegar Hill	01/07/08

16.	Excellent Article	11:21	\|	ScotGuy	01/07/08

17.	there should be a new policy on hostages	11:34	\|	Cipora Julianna Kohn	01/07/08

18.	Go After Their Leaders	11:38	\|	US CITIZEN	01/07/08

19.	#1 nutullie and the usual idiot conclusions	11:38	\|	victor hardman	01/07/08

20.	Good Article	11:40	\|	Nicole	01/07/08

21.	Hypocrisy	11:43	\|	Choni Davidowitz	01/07/08

22.	Natallie Durson - 1 don`t kid yourself	11:43	\|	ChanahS	01/07/08

23.	#1, Durson	11:44	\|	Cipora Julianna Kohn	01/07/08

24.	#14, Durson, a very self serving peace of nonsense	11:48	\|	Cipora Julianna Kohn	01/07/08

25.	#14 yeah and....?	12:45	\|	A mother	01/07/08

26.	natallie durson, no. 1	13:03	\|	saul a. readner	01/07/08

27.	marwan - two for tango	13:04	\|	saul a. readner	01/07/08

28.	vinegar hill, no. 7	13:06	\|	saul a. readner	01/07/08

29.	Just Suppose there was ....	13:31	\|	Buzaglow	01/07/08

30.	where is the human rights council of the un...	15:34	\|	scallywag	01/07/08

31.	the media must change their behaviour	16:52	\|	Robins	01/07/08

32.	where is the human rights council of the un....	17:24	\|	scallywag	01/07/08

33.	Change the laws on capital punishment	18:14	\|	Cathy	01/07/08

34.	vinegar hill	18:47	\|	scallywag	01/07/08

35.	Israel can can whatever it wants	22:21	\|	Nomad	01/07/08

36.	Excellent comments, Julianna Cipora Kohn # 17	23:32	\|	Fortuna Benmayor	01/07/08

37.	#14 Natalie	23:57	\|	Marc	01/07/08

38.	#14	02:50	\|	Dale Davis	02/07/08

39.	Natalie the commedienne	19:59	\|	Phil S	02/07/08

40.	Changing the Rules	16:19	\|	Paul Winter	05/07/08

Read & React


	Barak orders demolition of Jerusalem, yeshiva terrorists' homes
	Responses: 381



	Mother of Kuntar victim: This monster will be a Lebanon hero
	Responses: 147



	Peres: No chance of peace with Palestinians
	Responses: 189



	Iran: Any attack on our nuclear facility will be beginning of war
	Responses: 272



	Colombia hostage rescue: the Israeli angle
	Responses: 117

More Headlines
16:13 Iran: Our nuclear program remains unchanged


16:32 French, Syrian FMs meet to prepare Assad-Sarkozy talks


19:59 Barak orders demolition of Jerusalem, yeshiva terrorists' homes


05:47 'Police called us smelly Bedouin, then they started to beat us'


04:10 Israel lobbies UN as Ban mulls appointment of new human rights chief


15:22 Man rips off head of Hitler wax figure at new Berlin museum


13:50 Syrian rights group: Political prisoners butchered in clash with warders


22:02 Hundreds take part in mass water fight at Rabin Square


15:12 Hamas suspends Shalit talks over closure of Gaza crossings


13:49 Iraqi MPs voice outrage after president shakes Barak's hand


13:38 Iran: Any attack on our nuclear facility will be beginning of war


02:50 Police arrest Bedouin man suspected of smuggling drugs worth millions


15:08 MK Barakeh reportedly met with Hamas' Meshal in Abu Dhabi


14:33 Hamas vs. hummus: Guess who's on the loose in Middle East?