Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., October 06, 2008 Tishrei 7, 5769 | | Israel Time: 19:37 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 14:27 26/06/2008
Bradley Burston / Perhaps we killed Christ after all
By Bradley Burston, Haaretz Correspondent
Tags: Jesus Christ, Bradley Burston 

It's been some time since the actions of a mainstream Christian church were so deeply offensive as to be able to bring Orthodox, Conservative, Reconstructionist and Reform Jewish leaders closer together.

But you have to hand it to the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.). In publishing a church document whose expressed purpose was to promote Presbyterian vigilance against anti-Jewish bias, it has done just that.
Advertisement

What would it take for a dozen of the most prominent U.S. Jewish organizations to state collectively that they were "deeply distressed" and "profoundly hurt" by the actions of the largest Presbyterian denomination in America?

What would it take for Jewish leaders who believed that their years of painstaking dialogue with the Presbyterians had finally resulted in mutual understanding, only to sense in shock that they had been stabbed in the back, betrayed by a quietly rewritten church position paper that now smacked of understanding for depictions of the Jew and the Israeli as Christ killer?

What it would take is this: An official church text which acknowledged Presbyterian expressions of anti-Jewish sentiment, released in May to warm praise by leading U.S. Jews, was quietly and without explanation withdrawn, deleted, and replaced this month with a document that a broad coalition of major Jewish groups then publicly denounced as "infused with the very bias that the original statement condemned."

The new text, lurching to a curious and condescending finale, maintains moral neutrality in the face of suggestions by some Christians, that if the Jews may not have killed Christ some 2000 years ago, they may be doing so now.

When Christian liberation theology considers "a situation of oppression in which the oppressing power is a state that is Jewish, with a population and leadership predominantly made up of Jews," the revised report reads, "Christians suffering oppression at the hands of the Jewish state, its army or its citizens, identify with Jesus in his suffering.

"Sometimes Palestinian Christians liken their experience to the passion of Jesus, or describe themselves as being crucified as Jesus was crucified," the text continues. "The implication of such descriptions is that the state of Israel and its policies are the crucifying power."

What does the paper view as the problem here? "Such a characterization of the situation is inevitably construed by most Jews as an echo of the classic anti-Jewish accusation that all Jews everywhere are guilty of killing Christ."

Leaving alone the issue of whether these Jews have misconstrued the characterization, the statement begs a second question: If not all Jews everywhere are guilty of killing Christ, are some Jews somewhere, in fact, to blame?

We read further. "For Jews this is terrifying, because the narrative of the passion and crucifixion has been used as a theological basis for the ghettoization, denigration, and killing of Jews for nearly twenty centuries."

Still no definitive word on whether we killed Christ, then or now. But that remains beside the point. This situation, it turns out, poses a dilemma for the church.

"As Presbyterians, we have a very difficult but very important differentiation to make. On the one hand, we are called to support the efforts of Palestinian Christians to speak theologically about what is happening to them at the hands of Israel and as a result of its policies. At the same time, we are also called to discern echoes of, and to confess our own complicity in, the historic condemnation of Jews as 'Christ-killers,' and to eschew any such anti-Jewish teaching."

Therein the answer. A tie. No decision.

This week, the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) is holding its General Assembly in San Jose, California, The church, facing eroding membership and "disaffiliation" of some of its 10,000 congregations, as well as theological rifts over gay ordination and the true nature of Jesus as lord and savior, will have little time to spend on relations with the Jews.

A committee on peacemaking did take one step, narrowly defeating a resolution which called for a temporary suspension of U.S. military aid to Israel "because of documented atrocities committed against Palestinians."

But after the delegates head back home this weekend, they might take a moment to consider that there is a difference between seeking peace and seeking punishment for the perceived guilty party. They might consider that there are many of us here in Israel who despise the occupation and are working for justice for Palestinians, and even so, would like to see a church secure enough in its teachings to be able to do without the Jewish Christ killer.

They might look again, as the original church document did, at the exclusive assignment of blame on Israel, the characterization of the nation's actions as the single evil at the root of the conflict, and how that impacts on peacemaking. "Many Presbyterians have become aware," the old text stated, in a passage missing in the new one, "that strains of an old anti-Jewish tradition are present in the way we ourselves sometimes speak" regarding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Or they might just consider that there are not one, but two peace-loving peoples in the Holy Land. And that both peoples, not one, should be held accountable for the violence they cause. And that the theme of the San Jose conference, "Do justice, Love kindness, Walk humbly with your God," suggests that church doctrine, once revised, can be revised again
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Forgotten peace
French FM: I fear distracted world may forget Mideast peace process.
Settlers vs. Shin Bet
Daniela Weiss: Shin Bet behind attack on left-wing advocate prof. Sternhell.
  1.   THERE IS NO "PERHAPS," BRADLEY 14:54  |  indrajaya 26/06/08
  2.   who is this self-flagellating d-bag? 14:56  |  Denise Thompson 26/06/08
  3.   i guess technically it was the jewish leaders and romans 14:59  |  augustine e johnson 26/06/08
  4.   Interesting 15:05  |  FOX 26/06/08
  5.   look within israel.... 15:11  |  ravi 26/06/08
  6.   When as a kid I learned from some boy on the street that 15:21  |  17 26/06/08
  7.   MEL GIBSON WAS RIGHT ALL ALONG 15:22  |  indrajaya 26/06/08
  8.   RAVI.Having the most popular Arab say he wants to kill all Jews 15:26  |  PETER SM 26/06/08
  9.   and the jews still think theyre the promised people 15:27  |  noor 26/06/08
  10.   BRADLEY is there no depth to which Haaretz will sink 15:28  |  PETER SM 26/06/08
  11.   #2 Denise Thompson `has Arab friends` you know 15:36  |  Keith 26/06/08
  12.   Truth? 15:37  |  Deborah 26/06/08
  13.   To 2: Denise, the cut and paste queen 15:40  |  Palestinian in UK 26/06/08
  14.   Bunch of hypocrites 15:42  |  x-ray 26/06/08
  15.   # indrayaya - 1 THERE IS NO "PERHAPS," BRADLEY 15:43  |  17 26/06/08
  16.   # 9, NOOR 15:50  |  indrajaya 26/06/08
  17.   Whoever killed Jesus Christ... 15:50  |  Anne 26/06/08
  18.   sons are not fuilties for fathers acts 15:51  |  Manolo 26/06/08
  19.   petersm... get ure facts right 15:51  |  ravi 26/06/08
  20.   No one "killed Jesus", HE LIVES!!! He GAVE His flesh for us. Not 15:52  |  possible for Him to 26/06/08
  21.   the presbys are waiting for the end of days so their Lord can ris 15:53  |  Susanna/Shoshana 26/06/08
  22.   Get over it 15:54  |  Avrum 26/06/08
  23.   Bum Rap 15:54  |  Natallie Durson 26/06/08
  24.   Thompson racist! 15:58  |  Manolo 26/06/08
  25.   RAVI so you do not "know"what your brothers are doing next door 16:02  |  PETER SM 26/06/08
  26.   Isaiah was death in Jesus time 16:02  |  Manolo 26/06/08
  27.   Close their Churches 16:03  |  Ofer 26/06/08
  28.   If you`ve ever commited a sin, you have a personal part in the 16:03  |  crucifixion of 26/06/08
  29.   this is bs 16:03  |  Mattai 26/06/08
  30.   Cross, sure 16:05  |  Manolo 26/06/08
  31.   All of us must face the Changing Faces of Jesus by Geza Vermes 16:23  |  HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH 26/06/08
  32.   Christians don`t like to be out-martyred! 16:24  |  Allan 26/06/08
  33.   Punching Bag 16:25  |  Me Who??? 26/06/08
  34.   Jesus didn`t identify himself with ultrajews 16:26  |  Manolo 26/06/08
  35.   # 1, you don`t think the U.S. had their own self preservation in 16:26  |  mind? Just as 26/06/08
  36.   Burston and the Paranoids should re-read the Presbyter statement 16:28  |  Tosefta 26/06/08
  37.   don`t argued waht if, please 16:32  |  Manolo 26/06/08
  38.   Stupidity reaching unbearable limits 16:42  |  ScotGuy 26/06/08
  39.   Jesus H. Christ! 16:45  |  Jeff Northridge 26/06/08
  40.   Funny, at school, they accused ME of killing him! 16:46  |  Harvey (Chaim) 26/06/08
  41.   Mr Burston about Presbyterians/Calvinists who originated in 16:49  |  KATHY 26/06/08
  42.   unmitigated gall 16:52  |  soggy liberal 26/06/08
  43.   Well said, Bradley: fair is fair! 16:55  |  Jim 26/06/08
  44.   christianity,cycle of saving 16:58  |  montgomery rosen 26/06/08
  45.   Just In Time Indrajaya Read... 17:02  |  Yosemite 26/06/08
  46.   #9 My goodness, noor... 17:07  |  Beitcafe 26/06/08
  47.   It Doesn`t Matter 17:14  |  Yosemite 26/06/08
  48.   Whining again 17:15  |  Edithann 26/06/08
  49.   If the Jews possibly did kill the Christ the Church 17:18  |  Jew- and Bookburner 26/06/08
  50.   Where is the role of Islam in all this? 17:23  |  Pilly 26/06/08
  51.   # 31 Read Geza Vermes.Very Enlightening &Iinformative.A Must Read 17:24  |  KATHY 26/06/08
  52.   Stop confusing Israel and judaism! 17:26  |  Spider 26/06/08
  53.   And I thought the article about interfaith porn was in bad taste 17:28  |  Aphemia 26/06/08
  54.   It is totally irrational to "blame" anyone 17:30  |  Lynn 26/06/08
  55.   anti-semitism is inherent in christianity 17:34  |  yonatan 26/06/08
  56.   Killing of Christ Prophesied Well in Advance 17:35  |  Gary 26/06/08
  57.   And they call US Speculators!!!! 17:59  |  Ronnie Wolman 26/06/08
  58.   # 9 Noor - what Jews think about themselves is their 18:03  |  17 26/06/08
  59.   Romans helped him on his way, he`d have died anyway. 18:04  |  Harvey (Chaim) 26/06/08
  60.   Lynn #54- If it was preordained 18:08  |  ave 26/06/08
  61.   3 SIMPLE QUESTIONS! 18:13  |  Sam 26/06/08
  62.   Jeff Northridge #39 18:14  |  Roo 26/06/08
  63.   mad dogs 18:17  |  Shmuelshachor 26/06/08
  64.   # 45, YOSEMITE 18:24  |  indrajaya 26/06/08
  65.   That`s a sick titile 18:29  |  Gina 26/06/08
  66.   what I think as an aetheist 18:33  |  mehmet 26/06/08
  67.   #23 Durson the L.A. rabble rouser... 18:36  |  Pastor Joseph 26/06/08
  68.   Jesus voluntarily went to the cross... 18:39  |  Pastor Joseph