Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., June 29, 2008 Sivan 26, 5768 | | Israel Time: 20:23 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Peres Conference Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Comments:  55
Last update - 02:13 26/06/2008
IDF Chief: It is our duty to bring the hostages home
By Amos Harel, Barak Ravid and Yossi Melman, Haaretz Correspondents
Tags: Israel, Eldad Regev 

Israel Defense Forces Chief of Staff Gabi Ashkenazi said on Wednesday that it was Israel's duty to bring the captive soldiers back home and voiced hoped that they would soon be returned.

"I would like to emphasize, as the commander of the Israel Defense Forces, that it is our moral and long-time obligation to do everything in our power to bring back all our soldiers that have been captured by the enemy while performing their duties as fighters and protectors of the state of Israel," Ashkenazi said, referring to Ehud Goldwasser and Eldad Regev who were captured by Hezbollah in July 2006, and Gilad Shalit who was kidnapped in Gaza the month before.

Ashkenazi added that it was the duty of the army as well as the state to secure the captives' release, amid turmoil in the political echelon regarding a prisoner swap deal with Hezbollah.
Advertisement
"It is the duty of the Israeli society and it is our duty as an army," he went on to say, "I am full of hope that it won't be long before we have the privilege of seeing them among us again."

Meanwhile Wednesday, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert confirmed that the cabinet would vote on the prisoner exchange deal with Hezbollah during its weekly meeting on Sunday, saying that returning abducted soldiers to Israel was the state's top priority.

"I have decided to bring the issue to the cabinet for a decision at its next meeting on Sunday," Olmert told the Knesset during a special session, called after a late-night deal was consummated to stave off a coalition crisis.

Meanwhile, a Lebanese newspaper editor apparently familiar with Hezbollah's thinking warned Wednesday that if the prisoner swap with Israel is not consummated soon, the Shi'ite organization would increase its asking price for the two Israeli soldiers it has held captive since July 2006.

Olmert had spoken of the imminent vote in a meeting with the wife of one of the two Israeli reservists abducted by Hezbollah in July 2006. The prime minister said he has not yet decided whether or not he supports the swap.

The families of abducted soldiers Ehud Goldwasser and Eldad Regev had been pressuring Olmert to bring the matter to a cabinet vote, and plan to convince the ministers to support the deal.

"I haven't yet decided what my position is on the issue of the prisoner exchange deal with Hezbollah," the prime minister told Karnit Goldwasser, Ehud Goldwasser's wife, in a nearly hour-long meeting at the Prime Minister's Residence in Jerusalem on Tuesday. "We're in the middle of the talks and are trying to clarify most of the details. When the agreement is ready, I will decide and bring it to the cabinet, apparently on Sunday."

Karnit Goldwasser said she hopes the prime minister will carry through on his promise to bring the prisoner swap to a vote.

"In my eyes, this is the first relevant opportunity to bring Udi and Eldad home," she said.

It appears that a majority of ministers would vote in favor of the swap if it is brought to the cabinet for a vote, although the composition of the cabinet could change drastically if Olmert dismisses the Labor ministers for voting to disperse the Knesset.

If they remain in the cabinet, the Labor ministers are expected to vote in favor of the prisoner swap, as are the Pensioner ministers. Kadima ministers are split on the issue and Shas is not expected to vote against it. So far, the government has never approved a prisoner swap opposed by the prime minister.

Israel will release some Palestinians but only after the rest of the deal takes place and Goldwasser and Regev are returned to Israel. The release of the Palestinians will be described as a humanitarian gesture.

However, several ministers said this week that they cannot form an educated opinion on the prisoner swap because they have yet to be officially informed of the details. Olmert said he was interested in providing them with all the necessary information.

The deal, which is essentially closed and has been put into writing, states that Israel is supposed to release four Hezbollah militants who were taken captive during the Second Lebanon War; Samir Kuntar, who has been imprisoned since 1979, when he killed the members of the Haran family in Nahariya; and the remains of eight Lebanese citizens buried in Israel.

According to the agreement - reached with the help of German mediator Gerhard Konrad, who was working on behalf of the United Nations secretary general, Israel will also release several Palestinians serving prison sentences here, and Israel can be the one to determine the names and number of Palestinians who will be released.

Political and security sources said Israel has informed Hezbollah, via the mediator, that it will not release Palestinians responsible for Israeli deaths.

The chief military rabbi began deliberations this week on whether Goldwasser and Regev can be declared killed in action. He will judge based on intelligence information and Jewish law, a move criticized by the soldiers' families, but his determination will likely be made only after the cabinet meeting.

Although sources close to the talks with Hezbollah over a prisoner swap say the move means the deal is off, Olmert associates said the prime minister has repeatedly said he has not made a final decision. They said the decision to allow the chief military rabbi to assess the situation is meant only "to minimize the question marks to a minimum."

"We don't want Hezbollah to torpedo the deal," an Olmert associate said. "That's not true. We just want the ministers to have as much information as possible."

Defense Minister Ehud Barak spoke in favor of the prisoner exchange on Tuesday.

"We have a responsibility to bring the captives home, even if they are dead," said Barak. "The [rabbinic] declaration process that has begun, even if it develops fully, shouldn't in any way stop the deal."

A committee of intelligence officials including the heads of the Mossad, Shin Bet security service and Military Intelligence has reached the conclusion that Goldwasser and Regev are dead. The assessment was based on an examination of intelligence information that was analyzed separately by each of the intelligence organizations.

Related articles:
  • Israel's spymasters concluded weeks ago: Troops seized by Hezbollah are dead
  • Families of soldiers snatched by Hezbollah: 'We've waited long enough'
  • Most ministers back Hezbollah prisoner swap
  • PMO: Prisoner exchange with Hezbollah not likely next week
  • Negotiator heading back to Cairo for indirect talks on Shalit
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    A fateful week
    We shall see whether the truce will help bring Gilad Shalit home.
    Munich anticipated?
    A German professor says Israeli athletes willfully sacrificed themselves.
      1.   Future hostages will be killed! 05:31  |  MARK KLEIN, M.D. 25/06/08
      2.   Negotiating, but we don`t know for what!? 05:35  |  Aussie Michael 25/06/08
      3.   Lebanese sweet revenge... 12:15  |  ClearCut 25/06/08
      4.   Numbers 1 and 2 are valid questions 12:23  |  S 25/06/08
      5.   Olmert... uncertain?! 12:35  |  northern neighbor 25/06/08
      6.   CLEARCUT clearly ignorant.The Lebanse/Israel border was quiet 16:04  |  PETER SM 25/06/08
      7.   If it doesn`t involve him is `opportunistic`... 16:34  |  Ulf 25/06/08
      8.   Doubtful mixture with crime and politics : Olmert must leave 16:40  |  Pierre Le Loup 25/06/08
      9.   # 1 MARK KLEIN, M.D. 16:57  |  17 25/06/08
      10.   Olmert`s legacy... 17:05  |  bat yam 25/06/08
      11.   And you #3 are an efidiot if you believe all you wrote, 17:09  |  Pervert 25/06/08
      12.   And you #3 are an efidiot if you believe all you wrote, 17:09  |  Pervert 25/06/08
      13.   Really, Olmert`s Top Priority should be a Palestinians State 17:15  |  Markus 25/06/08
      14.   I undertand but it was obvious that they were dead 17:22  |  mehmet 25/06/08
      15.   His only priority is to remain dictator 17:24  |  Arie 25/06/08
      16.   Ulf #7 You are really something! 17:38  |  S 25/06/08
      17.   NO! Priority is to prevent, snd if not go in and kick their asses 17:42  |  dav 25/06/08
      18.   #3 Clear Cut the criminals are Hesbulloh even Lebs hate them 17:45  |  Robert/Montreal 25/06/08
      19.   Precedents, and Kuntar`s release 18:10  |  Tosefta 25/06/08
      20.   Samirele did some killing (S; previously) 18:12  |  Tosefta 25/06/08
      21.   #8 Pierre le Loup Artiste Quebecois Olmert is tired 18:22  |  Robert/Montreal 25/06/08
      22.   #19 Kunt should never be released. He murdered Israeli children 18:26  |  Robert/Montreal 25/06/08
      23.   Tosefta lives up to his name, adding more and more repetitions 18:29  |  x-ray 25/06/08
      24.   Peter SM, Pervert, Robert in Montreal 18:33  |  ClearCut 25/06/08
      25.   # 14 A million of ahmeds should have been killed in levant in... 18:41  |  misha 25/06/08
      26.   #24 I called your sassociates Idiots you are only Blinded 18:52  |  Robert/Montreal 25/06/08
      27.   Arabs will give in! 19:04  |  Paul 25/06/08
      28.   Our top priority: Sending Olmert Home 19:04  |  Jewish State 25/06/08
      29.   They are dead! 19:09  |  4:20 25/06/08
      30.   Gaza Police 19:11  |  Matthew Houston 25/06/08
      31.   misha ya misha 19:13  |  ClearCut 25/06/08
      32.   Idiocy - The Hallmark Of Present Day Israel 19:15  |  Tod Zuckerman 25/06/08
      33.   Olmert`s motives 19:17  |  Vladimir 25/06/08
      34.   CLEARCUT 19:18  |  JOJO 25/06/08
      35.   Shocking Israely political class 19:20  |  CM 25/06/08
      36.   SWAPS, A JEWISH TRADITION 19:34  |  JOJO 25/06/08
      37.   #24 Clewarcut I answered you Post #26 did youread and Understand 20:00  |  Robert/Montreal 25/06/08
      38.   # 31 Here comes another MORON with no name... 20:28  |  misha 25/06/08
      39.   Mark Klein is Right 21:08  |  Dan 25/06/08
      40.   Israel`s top priority should be 21:48  |  Sidney 25/06/08
      41.   I hope this deal fails 21:51  |  J K 25/06/08
      42.   Israel`s top, only priority must be-"Removal of OLMERT & his ILK" 22:48  |  common sense 25/06/08
      43.   Olmert Trying to be a HERO now,,,,, 23:06  |  Dolly 25/06/08
      44.   No, quite wrong 23:11  |  Schtarker Yid 25/06/08
      45.   Insane and costly to trade corps for terrorists 00:28  |  David 26/06/08
      46.   swap 01:31  |  czech man 26/06/08
      47.   Odd, just yesterday 01:50  |  Mark Lincoln 26/06/08
      48.   Dear Misha, 02:21  |  royzer 26/06/08
      49.   Hezbollah THE WINNER 02:43  |  Ezequiel Levy 26/06/08
      50.   removal of olmert & Co. 02:44  |  Rozz 26/06/08
      51.   Dear IDF, you purpose is to defend Israel period!! 03:08  |  Moshe 26/06/08
      52.   Olmert Insane? 03:10  |  Rozz 26/06/08
      53.   IT IS ISRAEL`S TOP PRIORITY TO BRING HOME SOLDIERS;MERT`S:PIECE 03:37  |  glenna 27/06/08
      54.   #47 Let me explain it to you, Mark Lincoln 04:09  |  Johnboy 27/06/08
      55.   #51 Amen! 01:47  |  DesMnsDave 29/06/08
     Read & React
    German prof.: Israeli athletes willfully sacrificed themselves in Munich massacre
    Responses: 124
    Cabinet approves Hezbollah prisoner exchange
    Responses: 140
    Harel and Issacharoff: Five myths about prisoner swaps
    Responses: 40
    Former Israeli spymaster: Israel has one year to bomb Iran
    Responses: 99
    Rosner's Domain
    When Sheldon Adelson met Bush (WTR)
    Poll: Hezbollah swap - good or bad?
    Can Israel legally strike Iran with nukes?
    Is Time's Joe Klein being honest when he criticizes Joe Lieberman?
    "The war in Iraq was inevitable" (WTR)


    More Headlines
    20:00 Olmert: We know for sure captive troops are dead
    19:42 Regev, Goldwasser families: Bring swap deal to swift conclusion
    17:53 What does it mean? An outline of the prisoner exchange deal
    19:55 Hezbollah: Approval of swap deal shows our word is supreme
    10:13 ANALYSIS / Five myths about prisoner swaps
    15:45 Hamas won't recognize Abbas presidency past January 2009
    14:07 Israeli film wins people's choice award at Moscow Film Festival
    16:27 Former Israeli spymaster: We have year to hit Iran nukes
    10:12 Report: Hamas rejects Israeli bid to free 450 prisoners for Shalit
    12:32 Israel reopens Gaza crossings after closures over Qassams
    07:14 Bereaved father: Who will protect my sons once terrorists are released?
    13:30 VIDEO: Amy Winehouse's explosive performance at Glastonbury