Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., June 16, 2008 Sivan 13, 5768 | | Israel Time: 11:37 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Peres Conference Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 11:34 16/06/2008
When smart countries - like Israel - go dumb
By Bradley Burston
Tags: Hamas, Olmert, Burston

The dedicated observer of Israel may well wonder if this is a smart country which at times conceives and implements policies of particular stupidity, or if this is a dumb country which at times brings off acts of brilliance. Recent examples:

  • Seven Gazans, recipients of Fulbright grants for advanced study in the United States, are barred from leaving the Strip. An unnamed official has included them in the terms of the Israeli blockade on the Strip, meant to be a response to Hamas rule and daily rocket and mortar attacks.

    The case attracts immediate interest and condemnation worldwide, not least because Israel has pledged that the embargo will not apply to humanitarian cases.

    "I am against Hamas. Their acts and policies are wrong," one of the students, Abdulrahman Abdullah, declares openly.

    "Israel talks about a Palestinian state. But who will build that state if we can get no training?" he tells The New York Times. "If we are talking about peace and mutual understanding, it means investing in people who will later contribute to Palestinian society."

    The ban attracts the attention of U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, who voices surprise and disapproval. In a matter of days, with little fanfare and no explanation, an Israeli military spokesman announces that the Gazans will receive exit permits after individual security checks are complete.

    And, just to render the policy entirely opaque, between 600 and 1,000 other Gazans will remain stranded, keen to study in foreign institutions but unable to leave the Strip.

  • Israel's leaders threaten that they are on the verge of ordering a major ground offensive in Gaza. Then they threaten again. And again.

    A member of a southern kibbutz is killed while at work, the victim of a mortar barrage from neighboring Gaza, and the fourth Israeli to die in the shelling this year.

    "The military blow against Gaza is closer than ever," Defense Minister Ehud Barak says, touring the site hours after the shelling. Echoes Ehud Olmert, an offensive appears to be "very close."

  • Unnamed Israeli official tells reporters that Israel is furious with Palestinian Authority Prime Minister Salam Fayyad, strongly implying that Israel's failure to hand over $75 million in tax revenues owed the PA was "punishment" for Fayyad's having appealed to the European Union against upgrading its relations with Israel.

    The tax revenues, which Israel collects on the PA's behalf, are a central pillar of the often shaky PA government, which Israel has nominally promised to support as a bulwark against the Fatah-led PA's rival Hamas.

    The tax funds pay the salaries of more than 165,000 government employees in the West Bank, and thus are a main means of support for a large percentage of Palestinian extended families.

    Fayyad had protested to the EU over continued settlement construction and West Bank IDF roadblocks, asking the European body and the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) to refrain from closer ties until "abides by international and human rights laws."

    What does Israel do next? Without explanation and without a great deal of logic, the Finance Ministry forks over most of the money a week late, keeping a bit to cover debts it says the PA owes Israel for utility bills.

    It is difficult not to discern a pattern here. Unable to decide between two mutually exclusive policies, Israel goes ahead and does both.

    In so doing, it maintains the delicate fraying-tightrope act which allows both Ehud Barak, who is not even a member of Knesset and whose own sad party has had quite enough of him, and Ehud Olmert, whose chances of re-election are about the same as his chances of becoming the next Pope, to stay in office.

    They will clearly sacrifice anything to this effort - peace prospects, Sderot and the western Negev, Gilad Shalit, the people of Gaza, the Israeli economy, what's left of their own integrity.

    It may well be their only hope.

    Too bad it robs us of what's left of ours.

    _______________

    Previous blogs:

    When smart countries - like Israel - go dumb
    The talkbacker as terrorist
    The Palestinians' time is running out.
    We owe the Palestinians a state
    60 years of Nakba, 60 years of nothing
    Our Defense Forces, our war crimes, our terrorism
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Snoop Dogg in Israel
    American rapper Snoop Dogg slated to perform in Ramat Gan.
    Late date
    Scientists revive 2,000-year-old date seed found at Masada.
      1.   I usually disagree with Mr. Burston but he nailed it this time 20:05  |  Josh 10/06/08
      2.   to Josh #1 04:56  |  zeev 11/06/08
      3.   It ius kinda unfaire to say all israeli faults are errors of this 07:00  |  Kris Lazar 11/06/08
      4.   To Zeev #2 08:06  |  Josh 11/06/08
      5.   Let Egypt care for Gaza students 11:59  |  Rick & TC 11/06/08
      6.   to Josh #4 14:13  |  zeev 11/06/08
      7.   To Zeev - We don`t recall Jordan getting the West Bank 14:33  |  Rick & TC 11/06/08
      8.   to Rick & TC #7 15:08  |  zeev 11/06/08
      9.   To Zeev #6 16:09  |  Josh 11/06/08
      10.   This is not amatter of being dumb 17:34  |  Michael N 11/06/08
      11.   to Rick & TC #7 19:42  |  zeev 11/06/08
      12.   To Zeev #8 20:34  |  Josh 11/06/08
      13.   Most Israelis oppose new terror state in our heartland. 02:23  |  Chaim 12/06/08
      14.   well-put, Chaim 03:29  |  Israeli 12/06/08
      15.   to Josh #9 06:40  |  zeev 12/06/08
      16.   to Josh #12 - (1) 06:43  |  zeev 12/06/08
      17.   to Josh #12 - (2) 06:51  |  zeev 12/06/08
      18.   NO, ISRAEL DOESN`T GO DUMB 10:45  |  indrajaya 12/06/08
      19.   So what do you want to do, Chaim? # 13 10:47  |  Clickfool 12/06/08
      20.   Save Israel from itself. 10:53  |  Michael 12/06/08
      21.   How can a people be only "dumb" when it comes to politics...???? 11:02  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/06/08
      22.   I was hoping that Bradley would cite some examples of brilliance 11:04  |  Natallie Durson 12/06/08
      23.   To Zeev #15 11:20  |  Josh 12/06/08
      24.   To Durson #22 11:46  |  Jan Vlaming 12/06/08
      25.   To Zeev #15 (2) 11:52  |  Josh 12/06/08
      26.   To Zeev - Syria gives up land claims 12:19  |  Rick & TC 12/06/08
      27.   to Josh #23 12:43  |  zeev 12/06/08
      28.   Israel wants Palestinian suffering, underlying fact 12:44  |  mehmet 12/06/08
      29.   U know the joke - 2 Jews and 3 synagogues 12:58  |  just a jew 12/06/08
      30.   Does both? 13:08  |  Tenar 12/06/08
      31.   When smart reporters - like Burston - go dumb 13:30  |  As usual for Burston 12/06/08
      32.   The problem of Likud short range vision 13:35  |  Tosefta 12/06/08
      33.   Olmert & Livni are "Dumb and Dumber"- leftist defeatists 13:37  |  HENRY MANN 12/06/08
      34.   To Zeev #27 13:42  |  Josh 12/06/08
      35.   To Zeev #27 13:42  |  Josh 12/06/08
      36.   Mehmet- You are sadly mistaken 13:52  |  Elihu 12/06/08
      37.   Well said 14:00  |  Marilyn 12/06/08
      38.   Bradley Burston too knows how to play dumb (regarding Slowman) 14:19  |  Bursting Brad 12/06/08
      39.   Hey SWISS DINO, Turks 2 Suisse 1!!!! 14:49  |  FOX 12/06/08
      40.   DUMB AND DUMBER 15:57  |  B 12/06/08
      41.   #19 Clickfool. Israeli concessions don`t bring peace. 16:09  |  Chaim 12/06/08
      42.   #14 Israeli. Thank you. MOST of us want to live, apparently. 16:17  |  Chaim 12/06/08
      43.   Swiss on Faking Turks! 16:18  |  FOX 12/06/08
      44.   Turkey Wants Kurdish suffering, underlying fact #28 16:28  |  FOX 12/06/08
      45.   Turkey Lording over other peoples 16:33  |  FOX 12/06/08
      46.   write on B 16:36  |  Israeli 12/06/08
      47.   For Chaim, spinning for Israel # 41 17:16  |  Clickfool 12/06/08
      48.   # 39 FOX, good chance for me to bolster my reputation...... 17:29  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/06/08
      49.   Josh is in fantasy land. 17:32  |  Ibrahim 12/06/08
      50.   Swiss Dino...allow me to explain. 17:37  |  Ibrahim 12/06/08
      51.   bradley, you are more stupid today than normally 17:40  |  vladimir 12/06/08
      52.   To cousin Ibrahim 18:03  |  Josh 12/06/08
      53.   Josh, you will need to do better than that. 18:28  |  Ibrahim 12/06/08
      54.   Swiss Dino, your excitement makes me Yawn! 18:59  |  FOX 12/06/08
      55.   Israel - a country in decline 19:00  |  Nathaniel 12/06/08
      56.   Ibrahim, Lies, Fabrications & Humiliation #50 19:13  |  FOX 12/06/08
      57.   to zeev and josh 19:17  |  Said 12/06/08
      58.   Israel is not dumb, maybe the author? 19:26  |  Tali 12/06/08
      59.   Swiss Dino! Do not reserve that rite for Israelis plz! 19:42  |  Roxana from IRAN 12/06/08
      60.   FOX lives in a DARK BOX 19:43  |  Ibrahim 12/06/08
      61.   #21 Swiss(Dino): Answer: Over Exposure to Pal. Politics. No Joke. 19:53  |  JP 12/06/08
      62.   Nathaniel, Minneapolis is in decline 20:03  |  JP 12/06/08
      63.   In WW2, did Allies allow Germans with scholarships to study abroa 20:07  |  Burstonian Logic 12/06/08
      64.   # 23 Josh..After seeing Zeev here,I am Off! because. 20:14  |  KATHY 12/06/08
      65.   To Ibrahim #53 20:32  |  Josh 12/06/08
      66.   To Said #57 20:33  |  Josh 12/06/08
      67.   Michael N, thats not accurate either 20:36  |  Scharker Yid 12/06/08
      68.   To Kathy #64 20:39  |  Josh 12/06/08
      69.   Yes it is humiliation Ibrahim 20:39  |  FOX 12/06/08
      70.   #64 Josh An Addendum..re:Zeev 20:47  |  KATHY 12/06/08
      71.   To Kathy #70 20:56  |  Josh 12/06/08
      72.   Roxana, confused yet poignant 21:12  |  FOX 12/06/08
      73.   To Josh 21:14  |  noor 12/06/08
      74.   To Chaim, the ignorant fool 21:20  |  noor 12/06/08
      75.   # 50 Ibrahim (2nd try) 21:20  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/06/08
      76.   Lets question some flawed presumptions 21:22  |  Scharker Yid 12/06/08
      77.   To Elihu the other ignorant fool part 1 21:28  |  noor 12/06/08
      78.   # 54 FOX, are you sure you are an artist....???? 21:31  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/06/08
      79.   To Elihu the other ignorant fool part 2 21:33  |  noor 12/06/08
      80.   And somehow Bradley had not mentioned OSLO ??? 21:37  |  Boris 12/06/08
      81.   41 Chaim, Since when is returning stolen goods concessions ? 21:40  |  Dutch 12/06/08
      82.   On Being Dumb 21:41  |  Mona 12/06/08
      83.   BRADLEY PLEASE TELL YOUR COHORTS TO STOP PRINTING THE PICTURE OF 21:42  |  Miriam Ashkelon 12/06/08
      84.   Noor 21:48  |  Linichka 12/06/08
      85.   # 59 Sorry Roxana, but Hip-hop is not really my thing..... 21:53  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/06/08
      86.   To Noor #73 21:58  |  Josh 12/06/08
      87.   Tosefta 22:02  |  Slowman 12/06/08
      88.   # 61 JP, unfortunately "very, very recently" and "today"..... 22:15  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/06/08
      89.   #75 Swiss(Dino) - The problem with Ibrahim`s "explaination" 22:15  |  JP 12/06/08
      90.   He`s got it right this time. 22:45  |  Fortuna Benmayor 12/06/08
      91.   Noor 23:07  |  x-ray 12/06/08
      92.   FOX, I do believe you are compensating 23:11  |  Ibrahim 12/06/08
      93.   Israel is a self-referenced state 23:13  |  kaled 12/06/08
      94.   # 74 To All Lauderdale noor:It Seems You Found The Fool? 23:16  |  K 12/06/08
      95.   Josh you`re right about Israel`s case being just 23:17  |  x-ray 12/06/08
      96.   #88 Swiss(Dino) - You can`t have it both ways 23:20  |  JP 12/06/08
      97.   Josh, you are misguided. 23:21  |  Ibrahim 12/06/08
      98.   Noor this is so interesting, from the Hamas Charter 23:22  |  x-ray 12/06/08
      99.   This ibrahim is a most disagreeable person 23:46  |  Mrs Levy 12/06/08
      100.   Moves and countermoves, the tit for tat 23:49  |  Stanley 12/06/08
      101.   Better 2 Be with Israel, Than Against Her... 00:01  |  Bill Cheshire, Jr. 13/06/08
      102.   Israel has some dumb policies 00:38  |  Ron 13/06/08
      103.   When smart countries go dumb 00:48  |  julie 13/06/08
      104.   #74 Noor. You`re the fool and "Palestine" never existed as a... 01:30  |  Chaim 13/06/08
      105.   #81 Dutch. Fantasize all you want about Jews leaving our Homeland 01:34  |  Chaim 13/06/08
      106.   Israel will find itself in retardville after 01:39  |  ELIAS KHOURY 13/06/08
      107.   #47 Clickfool. My interest is in ending Israeli retreat forever. 01:44  |  Chaim 13/06/08
      108.   "When smart countries like-Israel go-dumb" 02:22  |  Maureen Ann 13/06/08
      109.   For Chaim 03:55  |  Fortuna Benmayor 13/06/08
      110.   To Mr. Burston 04:24  |  Beitcafe 13/06/08
      111.   Ibrahim - Sincere Settlement 04:55  |  Reid 13/06/08
      112.   Dumb only on one item 07:13  |  Shimon Cleopas 13/06/08
      113.   for Clickfool (he knows he is Clicksmart) 07:25  |  karma 13/06/08
      114.   Dumb and dumber... 07:27  |  dbar1954 13/06/08
      115.   Swiss Dino! Deal! lets shake hands! 08:03  |  Roxana from IRAN 13/06/08
      116.   Fox - Swiss Dino, read an Israeli post 08:14  |  Roxana from IRAN 13/06/08
      117.   DINO, FOOTBALL AS ART? 08:25  |  FOX 13/06/08
      118.   DINO, Football as sport? 08:32  |  FOX 13/06/08
      119.   re Josh #12 `to Zeev #8` 09:07  |  Colin Wright 13/06/08
      120.   Ibrahim, Forgiving the 48 generation 09:28  |  FOX 13/06/08
      121.   Ibrahim, What I am "looking for" 09:33  |  FOX 13/06/08
      122.   WOW Slowman #87 to Tosefta: Thank you! 09:44  |  S 13/06/08
      123.   Ibrahim, Re: what I feel Fox and Josh want... 13:55  |  Dutch 13/06/08
      124.   # 115 Roxana, as I said before, you can have your Persian..... 14:53  |  Swiss (Dino) 13/06/08
      125.   FOX the hopeless rejectionist. 15:00  |  Ibrahim 13/06/08
      126.   # 117 / # 118 FOX, I will give you a 50 % approval rating..... 15:07  |  Swiss (Dino) 13/06/08
      127.   Rozana from Wherever #116 15:29  |  FOX 13/06/08
      128.   Doris (Dutch) such poetry. #123 15:37  |  FOX 13/06/08
      129.   Doris, No flag, no language, no name 15:42  |  FOX 13/06/08
      130.   Bush`s wisdom on Slowman`s education #87 (2nd try) 15:55  |  Bursting Brad 13/06/08
      131.   Swiss Dino, No smile just sword! 16:56  |  Roxana from IRAN 13/06/08
      132.   Fox! you`re as cunning as a fox! 17:25  |  Roxana from IRAN 13/06/08
     Read & React
    Syria and Israel aiming for direct peace talks by next month
    Responses: 14
    Akiva Eldar: Our fixation on Iran leads world to see Israel as the cause of tension
    Responses: 13
    IDF kills three gunmen near Gaza border fence
    Responses: 14
    Meron Benvenisti: Archaeologists' Israel-PA peace plan is naive and simplistic
    Responses: 1
    Rosner's Domain
    Judaism's swing vote: what to do with Jewish singles?
    What to make of the Journals of Rachel Corrie? (WTR)
    Poll: When should Israel have elections?
    Bobby Kennedy and the history of pro-Israel candidates
    NJDC: McCain's advisor soft on Iran (WTR)


    More Headlines
    11:37 Report: Hezbollah to return abducted IDF soldiers next week
    10:18 ANALYSIS / Hezbollah's price to return soldiers is not impossibly high
    10:13 IDF kills three gunmen near Gaza border fence
    08:40 Syria and Israel aiming for direct peace talks by next month
    09:00 Israel awaiting Egypt's answer to remaining issues on Gaza truce
    10:44 Officials: Abbas envoys to brief Gaza Fatah men on Hamas talks
    10:16 Battle of the attitude / Israeli girls vs. American Jews
    11:15 Girl, 12, leaps onto back door of thieves' van, retrieves stolen bag
    07:14 Mayor: Jerusalem is not a settlement, building will go on
    09:01 Environmental groups warn of damage from Dead Sea canal
    09:41 Lieberman ups the price for joining a future Netanyahu gov't
    07:14 Corruption charges abounded even in Ben Gurion's day
    00:08 Study: Israelis rank fourth in list of world workaholics
    00:08 Rice to Israel: 'Extremely important' to grant exit visas to Gaza Fulbright students
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    In the heart of Tel-Aviv
    The Meier on Rothschild tower
    Jerusalem of Gold
    Luxury apartments in Jerusalem's finest location
    Your vacation starts here
    Israel Travel Center Guaranteed Lowest Rates
    Istudy
    Learn Hebrew in 3 months
    Pardes Institute Summer Sessions
    http://www.pardes.org.il/
    Free the Palestinians from:
    Corrupt Kleptocracy, Tyrannical Theocracy, Abysmal Anarchy
    Fattal Hotel Chain
    Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
    ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel
    Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
    Real Estate in Israel | Travel to Israel with Haaretz | Hotels Israel | Restaurants Israel | Tourist attractions Israel | Shops Israel
    birthright Israel
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved