Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., July 27, 2008 Tamuz 24, 5768 | | Israel Time: 04:53 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Rosner's Blog
Shmuel Rosner Chief U.S. Correspondent www.haaretz.com/rosner Biography | Email me
Posted: June 05, 2008

It's Obama's good intentions that pro-Israel activists fear

It's easy to be swept away by the flood of rumors and leaks emanating from the campaign headquarters of U.S. presidential hopefuls, cable news and Web sites. Sense and nonsense mix together into flights of fancy and worse. Has Hillary Clinton eyed the vice presidential ticket? After all, she did tell New York lawmakers she would accept the role. Will Barack Obama want her in that position? How does former U.S. president Jimmy Carter's decision to support Obama affect him, and will that support increase the suspicions of Jewish voters in Florida about the Democratic candidate?

Indeed, it is easy to be swept away, but it's worth stopping for an instant and rolling the name of the Democratic Party's apparent presidential candidate on the tongue. Obama is not just a candidate - he's the candidate, a candidate who is the son of a black man and a white woman. He will make his acceptance speech at the Democratic convention on the 45th anniversary of Martin Luther King's "I have a dream" speech. No campaign manager could have planned it better, none could have picked a more dramatic day.

Obama's victory is not surprising. The epic duel with Clinton gave everyone, including past and present Israeli officials dealing with the U.S., time to prepare. Until a few months ago, my notebook was full of quotes of Foreign Ministry and Defense Ministry officials who five, four and even two months ago promised that Clinton will end up the victor. In recent weeks they've kept quiet and allowed the reality to sink in.

Some American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) members currently convening at its annual conference have already discussed the possibility of a "President Obama" come November. Elections are still far away, but such an outcome is not a wild bet. AIPAC's wily and experienced lobbyists predict the first year of an Obama presidency will be challenging for Israel not because he has bad intentions, but because they might be too good. Until then, Israel will unwillingly be at the heart of the storm of the presidential race. Thus, the AIPAC meeting this week centered on stopping Iran's nuclear program.

Republican presidential candidate John McCain, who addressed the conference, was the first to strike when he lashed out against Obama's intent to meet Iranian leaders without any stipulations. On Tuesday he was joined by Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, who detailed Iran's stubbornness and defended the Bush administration's stance which she said was also McCain's. The question isn't why we aren't talking to Iran, Rice said, but why isn't Iran talking to us?

Polls show that Obama's support for holding unconditional talks with Iran, though it may be wrong, is much more popular among U.S. voters. But Obama is much smarter than the electorate, and it is doubtful he will carry out all of his fanciful promises.

There are enough reasons to prefer McCain to Obama, or Clinton to Obama, regarding their intended policy toward Iran. But even those who oppose him should put aside their political preferences, fear of the future and their pros and cons list for just a moment. Now is the time to take in Obama's astounding political victory, if one can still feel awe for anything in this day and age. Against all the odds, the campaign broke down the boundaries of bias and race, and brought out voters to cast their ballots. They may be naive, but they are not indifferent. They may be a little childish, but they aren't cynical.

Once Obama's battle was over, one could only sit at the AIPAC conference on Tuesday night, listen to another speech by Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, and look on with envy at Americans celebrating Obama's victory in amassing delegates on the streets of St. Paul, Minnesota. As far as we know, Obama has never accepted envelopes filled with wads of money like Olmert allegedly has. Instead, the millions of voters who stand behind Obama have turned his campaign into something without parallel in U.S. history.

  1.   Obama intentions 03:14  |  Zoltan Ackerman 05/06/08
  2.   Loss of Influence 03:14  |  Mark of Lewiston 05/06/08
  3.   No thanks to "holier than thou" politics 03:22  |  Gili 05/06/08
  4.   An Obamination 03:51  |  Chaim Gorenstein 05/06/08
  5.   Caveat! 04:27  |  Johnny Weintraub 05/06/08
  6.   good intentions 04:38  |  Shmuelshachor 05/06/08
  7.   The real election is ahead 04:51  |  Truth 05/06/08
  8.   AMERICANS VOTE FOR AMERICA 04:51  |  Joe 05/06/08
  9.   Israel & Obama 04:56  |  Sheila Dukelsky 05/06/08
  10.   Obama 05:38  |  Andrew 05/06/08
  11.   Obama 05:42  |  Sherri 05/06/08
  12.   Go Obama 06:17  |  Dave 05/06/08
  13.   repairing ties between blacks and Jews 06:20  |  Publius 05/06/08
  14.   Obama as a metaphor... 06:21  |  Michael 05/06/08
  15.   Good morning Mr. Rosner 06:51  |  Michael N 05/06/08
  16.   Aipac speech something weird 07:02  |  Bruce 05/06/08
  17.   Why would Obama have fanciful promises in the first place 07:13  |  Dish It Out 05/06/08
  18.   hhe can not be trusted 07:17  |  chad 05/06/08
  19.   OUR president 07:56  |  Tom Gold 05/06/08
  20.   AIPAC SPEECHES 08:06  |  BILL SLAVICK 05/06/08
  21.   "Truth" #4 repeats proven lie 08:12  |  David 05/06/08
  22.   Obama - Angry Black Man 08:14  |  Jak Black 05/06/08
  23.   Then for goodness sake, elect someone else Israel 08:14  |  David 05/06/08
  24.   O`s support of unified Jeruselem; A Recipe for Disaster 08:18  |  Julie B 05/06/08
  25.   #7 Voting record is pro-Israel 08:21  |  David 05/06/08
  26.   The US electorate... 08:41  |  CS 05/06/08
  27.   How`s that working out for you? 08:42  |  DaveK 05/06/08
  28.   Obama will be a great leader 09:06  |  Ariel 05/06/08
  29.   obama and aipac 09:06  |  wibism 05/06/08
  30.   Obama is NOT a friend of Israel or the US-1 09:15  |  CSB 05/06/08
  31.   Obama Should Reject Carter`s Support 09:17  |  Yosemite 05/06/08
  32.   Obama is not a friend of Israel or the US-2 09:31  |  CSB 05/06/08
  33.   Barack Obama is no Jimmy Carter! 09:36  |  Alan 05/06/08
  34.   Response to Dave 09:51  |  Ed 05/06/08
  35.   obama`s media machine 10:06  |  C. Jones 05/06/08
  36.   The missing element 11:15  |  JW 05/06/08
  37.   America`s choice 11:38  |  sherry 05/06/08
  38.   time US populace read these strings 12:04  |  by gum 05/06/08
  39.   ObamaNation 12:07  |  David L 05/06/08
  40.   Response to ed 12:28  |  Troy 05/06/08
  41.   The exuberance of oratory 15:25  |  Afikoman 05/06/08
  42.   How to use Obama`s oratory in the Middle East 15:45  |  Afikoman 05/06/08
  43.   Final word from Afikoman 15:53  |  Afikoman 05/06/08
  44.   Obama can say what he wants; 17:13  |  Fred Michaelsberg 05/06/08
  45.   Worry About Your Own Elections 17:48  |  Jeff 05/06/08
  46.   The Road to Hell (for Israel) Will Be So Be Paved 17:56  |  Tod Zuckerman 05/06/08
  47.   Obama Is Just Another Generational Change 18:11  |  David Gerhry 05/06/08
  48.   I respectfully disagree 18:14  |  Brett 05/06/08
  49.   Obama`s good intention 18:22  |  Luke Wilson 05/06/08
  50.   In your euforic fantasy you forget Rezko 19:15  |  Marcus 05/06/08
  51.   Friendship is not enough 19:16  |  MichaelF 05/06/08
  52.   CSB 19:25  |  MichaelF 05/06/08
  53.   31 - Yosemite 19:33  |  MichaelF 05/06/08
  54.   #38 - by gum 19:37  |  MichaelF 05/06/08
  55.   #2 - Mark of Lewiston 19:49  |  MichaelF 05/06/08
  56.   If an one deliveres an untimatum, one is "talking!" 20:52  |  Shlomo 05/06/08
  57.   The Best Reason To Support Barack Obama 20:56  |  Progressive Zionist 05/06/08
  58.   AIPAC is not a PAC 21:08  |  Progressive Zionist 05/06/08
  59.   Fear 21:15  |  Andrew yankama 05/06/08
  60.   good intentions 22:17  |  Cindy Bryant 05/06/08
  61.   Obama & Israel? 22:28  |  P. J. Casey 05/06/08
  62.   Politeness 23:07  |  Natalie 05/06/08
  63.   If Obama wins, no more settlements 23:26  |  mehmet 05/06/08
  64.   GO OBAMA! 00:16  |  J-Rock 06/06/08
  65.   Rosner`s Blog; June 5th 00:36  |  Robert Grossmark 06/06/08
  66.   It`s Obama`s good intentions that pro-Israel activists fear 01:31  |  Tarish 06/06/08
  67.   Not too soon he does the two step "I did not mean it that way"! 03:39  |  Pervert 06/06/08
  68.   Obama and AIPAC 04:42  |  Robin Chayes 06/06/08
  69.   Obama and AIPAC 04:57  |  Lea 06/06/08
  70.   Get it through your skull, Obama will be the next president 05:07  |  Daniel 06/06/08
  71.   Lea, don`t hold your breath. Read today`s reports about him 05:22  |  Mark Anthony 06/06/08
  72.   To #8 18:01  |  Victor 06/06/08
  73.   Obama 18:20  |  David 06/06/08
  74.   Obama is going to get fried by McCain 18:21  |  Dror 06/06/08
  75.   Obama`s past , his advisors, and entourage 18:24  |  Dror 06/06/08
  76.   Obama-Iran 18:38  |  Darryl E. Fox 06/06/08
  77.   He`s Already Backpedaling on AIPAC 18:45  |  Steve 06/06/08
  78.   Obama`s intentions#1 19:50  |  Otto Rand 06/06/08
  79.   Because he`s black 20:45  |  Chris Countey 06/06/08
  80.   Obama`s good intentions? 21:15  |  Connie 06/06/08
  81.   Its About Time ! 00:16  |  Danny Stockman 07/06/08
  82.   Obama not McCain 00:32  |  lifelong zionist 07/06/08
  83.   Obama intentions: one state 01:14  |  Tulip 07/06/08
  84.   The time they are changing 01:44  |  RM 07/06/08
  85.   Rosner always fails to grasp US politics 02:29  |  Isaac 07/06/08
  86.   Reading these messages 04:35  |  Janice 07/06/08
  87.   americans are hurting who can ease the pain ? 06:13  |  victor hardman 07/06/08
  88.   #83, Tulip 06:58  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 07/06/08
  89.   Obama and AIPAC 07:11  |  Lea 07/06/08
  90.   Cipora, shabbat shalom 11:35  |  Tulip 07/06/08
  91.   Obama as honest peacemaker 20:05  |  crzymon 07/06/08
  92.   Palestinians May Have A Chance 20:13  |  DAT 07/06/08
  93.   you are on your own, bubby 20:24  |  rudy 07/06/08
  94.   P.J Casey #61 Absolutely correct 21:13  |  Dror 07/06/08
  95.   Unfortunately, Michael, it just won`t work 22:12  |  Sam C 07/06/08
  96.   Israel visa vi Iraq 22:27  |  Sam C 07/06/08
  97.   What?!? 23:38  |  Salik 07/06/08
  98.   Why Haaretz??!!!! 03:31  |  khader Abu Alia 08/06/08
  99.   Obama intentions 04:21  |  saul schwartz 08/06/08
  100.   Obama for President! 05:11  |  David 08/06/08
  101.   Doesn`t need envelopes, he has bagman Rezco 07:15  |  ankhfnkhonsu 08/06/08
  102.   OBAMA CHANGE 10:50  |  MURRAY 08/06/08
  103.   New, better World Awaiting 11:33  |  IranianDood 08/06/08
  104.   Obama`s Middle Name: Liar 16:21  |  G. Jolte 08/06/08
  105.   Obama and Israel? 16:25  |  Richard Allen 08/06/08
  106.   What forces these stupid morons in Iran to pledge allegiance to . 16:27  |  J. Kpeller 08/06/08
  107.