Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., September 05, 2008 Elul 5, 5768 | | Israel Time: 10:26 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 20:19 02/06/2008
U.S. imam fighting deportation talks of torture in Israeli detention
By The Associated Press
Tags: United States, Imam 

A popular Muslim leader facing deportation asked that his children be removed from the New Jersey courtroom Monday before he broke into tears while describing graphic torture he said he was subjected to in Israeli detention.

The issue of torture is at the heart of the deportation proceedings against Mohammad Qatanani, a Palestinian who has been the mosque leader of the Islamic Center of Passaic County in Paterson since 1996. It is one of the largest mosques in the northeastern state.

The United States government has rejected his bid for permanent U.S. residency, saying Qatanani failed to disclose a 1993 arrest and conviction in Israel for being a member of Hamas on his green card application.
Advertisement
Qatanani denies the charges, saying he was detained, not arrested, by the Israelis along with many Palestinians at the time.

As he recounted his time in Israeli detention - describing being tied to a small chair with his hands bound, kept in a freezing cell, and subjected to violence and threats - several of his supporters in the packed courtroom began quietly weeping.

"Judge, you can not imagine," Qatanani said, his voice breaking. "They say 'We will kill your family.' They say: 'You know what your family is doing now? We will go to them, we will burn them.'"

Qatanani paused to compose himself before telling Immigration Judge Alberto J. Riefkohl, "At that time, you feel that death is better than life."

Earlier in the day, Qatanani described growing up poor in a Palestinian refugee camp. He said that since age 6, he has wanted to be a mosque leader - following in the footsteps of his father.

Qatanani's lawyers spent part of the morning trying to distance him from his controversial predecessor at the mosque, Mohammed el-Mezain, who was arrested and is facing re-trail on charges of funneling money to Palestinian terrorist groups.

Qatanani testified that he didn't get along with el-Mezain and never shared his vision. On the stand, Qatanani pointed to his commitment to interfaith dialogue, cooperation with law enforcement, and the integration of Muslims into mainstream American society.

Riefkohl, who is hearing the case in Newark federal court, said Monday would probably be the last day of the trial.

The judge said it could take him a month or more to decide whether Qatanani, his wife, and three of the couple's six children who are foreign-born can remain in the United States.

Related articles:
  • Not the Guantanamo model
  • Rabbi testifies in support of Hamas-linked imam facing U.S. ban
  • Twilight Zone / A window on interrogation
  • Shin Bet cuts use of special detention of suspects by half
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Playing with fire
    Sarkozy warns Iran it risks Israeli strike on nuke program.
    Our own desert island
    Israel tries to lure 'Big Brother' type U.S. reality TV series.
      1.   Torture imagination-honni soit qui mal Y pense 20:41  |  Jacob 02/06/08
      2.   When we do it it`s "enhanced interrogation" 21:13  |  Aphemia 02/06/08
      3.   boo hoo 21:48  |  vik 02/06/08
      4.   This a stupid imam 22:17  |  JDL 02/06/08
      5.   TO NO 1. 22:45  |  DANNY. 02/06/08
      6.   Movie actors 23:03  |  Peter 02/06/08
      7.   A member of hamas, he can be in oBama`s cabinet! 23:11  |  Avram 02/06/08
      8.   did he cry for Jewish victims of hamas terror attacks? 23:15  |  don 02/06/08
      9.   ya! and the germans tortured too! whatever! 23:38  |  Reasonable Man 02/06/08
      10.   Palli....wood .. da da da da da da daaa 00:17  |  GZLives 03/06/08
      11.   Israel is reknowned for its torture even on 00:19  |  kiwi girl 03/06/08
      12.   DO NOT SEND ARABS TO HOLYLAND, KEEP THEM IN AMERICA))) 01:04  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 03/06/08
      13.   "discomfort" does not equal "torture" 01:04  |  Susan 03/06/08
      14.   Murderers Israelis 01:05  |  Abbood 03/06/08
      15.   Another Pallywood production 01:07  |  Gee 03/06/08
      16.   Fact: Israel tortures 01:09  |  POP 03/06/08
      17.   WHO LET HIM IN THE U,S. ???????? 01:34  |  ARIEH 03/06/08
      18.   The Iman cries 01:54  |  Connie 03/06/08
      19.   Lies 02:27  |  nemesis 03/06/08
      20.   To Avrum, a repulsive fool 02:30  |  david 03/06/08
      21.   US Not Disputing Allegations 02:46  |  Mark of Lewiston 03/06/08
      22.   admission of guilt under "interrogation"?; LET HIM STAY!" 03:00  |  eric 03/06/08
      23.   KIWI GIRL .The source for your allegations exactly as you claim? 04:53  |  PETER SM 03/06/08
      24.   Kiwi Girl 06:07  |  Marc 03/06/08
      25.   don in toronto 06:09  |  potobac 03/06/08
      26.   peter sm 06:15  |  potobac 03/06/08
      27.   Fact: POP lies 06:54  |  Pervert 03/06/08
      28.   Yes eric, let him stay; send him to your house 06:55  |  Romano 03/06/08
      29.   What`s the problem. Return him to the PA. 07:18  |  Raymond in DC 03/06/08
      30.   POTOBAC so how does that apply to this man`s case if its banned 07:32  |  PETER SM 03/06/08
      31.   The return of Muslem prisonners 07:35  |  Pierre 03/06/08
      32.   Imam terrorist asked children to be kept out so they do not 07:58  |  Genuine Tosefta 03/06/08
      33.   Potobac here is your twisted proof that Syria does not torture 08:08  |  Genuine Tosefta 03/06/08
      34.   POTOBAC trying to pass off the past as current.,as you admitt 08:32  |  PETER SM 03/06/08
      35.   Islamic imams teach hate, violence, intolerance to children 09:16  |  Johnny 03/06/08
      36.   He didn`t deny being a member of Hamas - banned organization 09:40  |  x-ray 03/06/08
      37.   # 28 to romano 09:43  |  eric 03/06/08
      38.   # 28 to romano 09:53  |  eric 03/06/08
      39.   A torture country 09:57  |  Janice 03/06/08
      40.   # 35 learn how to read, x-ray 10:05  |  eric 03/06/08
      41.   genuine tosefta 33 10:41  |  potobac 03/06/08
      42.   peter sm 34 10:43  |  potobac 03/06/08
      43.   Time limitation? 11:13  |  Motic 03/06/08
      44.   #36 x-ray. America has many terrorists-in government. 11:24  |  Maureen Ann 03/06/08
      45.   Facts 11:27  |  Keops 03/06/08
      46.   POTOBAC If you have evidence why not produce it? 11:41  |  PETER SM 03/06/08
      47.   #35 Johnny 12:20  |  Nick Ferriman 03/06/08
      48.   eric the pompous. Read the article yourself 12:32  |  x-ray 03/06/08
      49.   kiwi girl 12:45  |  Nechama 03/06/08
      50.   9-11 celebrations in Paterson NJ 13:32  |  Steve 03/06/08
      51.   # 44 Maureen Ann...Australians were there too 13:39  |  Lynn 03/06/08
      52.   Evil Israelis 13:39  |  NJ MAN 03/06/08
      53.   # 12 Mosiach......no thank you 13:40  |  Lynn 03/06/08
      54.   Nick #47 On hateful islamic imams 13:44  |  Johnny 03/06/08
      55.   Pierre in Canada 13:46  |  ClearCut 03/06/08
      56.   Potobac 14:03  |  Steve 03/06/08
      57.   Keep him in the US 14:27  |  aj 03/06/08
      58.   #52 To the NJ man 14:35  |  Hastaroth 03/06/08
      59.   nick ferriman since we are all sinful 14:59  |  ivri 03/06/08
      60.   potobac why do you jail over one million blackss 15:02  |  justice 03/06/08
      61.   potobac 15:05  |  justice 03/06/08
      62.   # 22 eric...not the first Imam deported 15:45  |  Lynn 03/06/08
      63.   # 11 kiwi...maybe New Zealand will take him 15:47  |  Lynn 03/06/08
      64.   Why the U.S.? 15:47  |  utagawa 03/06/08
      65.   I Shall Quote a Follower of the Imam 16:54  |  FOX 03/06/08
      66.   62 Lynn - Detained is Not Arrested 16:59  |  Mark of Lewiston 03/06/08
      67.   You`re kidding 17:09  |  BDM 03/06/08
      68.   Ferriman`s Gush Eminem? 18:13  |  FOX 03/06/08
      69.   Hamas people, as this Imam is, would be willing to sell their 18:50  |  Fawaz 03/06/08
      70.   #58 Hastaroth 19:01  |  NJ man 03/06/08
      71.   steve 56 19:25  |  potobac 03/06/08
      72.   justice 60 19:33  |  potobac 03/06/08
      73.   ISRAEL`S FAVORITE: WATER BOARDING 20:05  |  indrajaya 03/06/08
      74.   Fawaz @ 69. It is refreshing to read your post. Thanks. 20:10  |  William 03/06/08
      75.   # 60 justice...Oh I know, because....... 20:19  |  Lynn 03/06/08
      76.   Another Arab Lier 20:58  |  Adam 03/06/08
      77.   justice #60,justice has been served to over 1 million criminals, 21:02  |  terrornator 03/06/08
      78.   potobac blacks make up 13% of the population 21:27  |  justice 03/06/08
      79.   potomac 21:30  |  justice 03/06/08
      80.   potomac iraq is rather near 21:32  |  justice 03/06/08
      81.   It`s just `enhanced interrogation` 21:34  |  H50 03/06/08
      82.   potobac "what is the difference between terrorists 21:42  |  justice 03/06/08
      83.   They are used to lie... 21:45  |  JP 03/06/08
      84.   This is Wrong! 21:53  |  DAT 03/06/08
      85.   justice A.K.A. ballestic,pulling out the race card again,i see 21:59  |  terrornator 03/06/08
      86.   Kiwi Girl#11 - 110% Palestinians are under the age of 18 22:53  |  William 03/06/08
      87.   Pop#27 - Yes, Israel tortures 22:54  |  William 03/06/08
      88.   He Should be Given Asylum in USA 22:58  |  Mr. Know-It-All 03/06/08
      89.   H50#81 - what makes you think they aren`t already? 22:58  |  William 03/06/08
      90.   Justice, our racist Ballistic 23:02  |  Malcom Z 03/06/08
      91.   Lynn #75 most of the black crimes 23:04  |  Roo 03/06/08
      92.   Justice#78 - Discrimination or failed assimilation 23:06  |  William 03/06/08
      93.   Hahaha #73 - Indrajaya and his fairy tales 23:09  |  William 03/06/08
      94.   DAT IN NYC#84 23:22  |  William 03/06/08
      95.   Justice-potomac and William 23:37  |  Roo 03/06/08
      96.   terrornator makes a change from the `anti-semite` card? 23:41  |  Roo 03/06/08
      97.   Roo,just because you found one item to back up 23:53  |  terrornator 03/06/08
      98.   vivid imagination 00:10  |  Hilda 04/06/08
      99.   Quite legit 00:14  |  W 04/06/08
      100.   93 William - FYI 00:26  |  Mark of Lewiston 04/06/08
      101.   98 Hilda - Prosecutors in Collusion? 00:37  |  Mark of Lewiston 04/06/08
      102.   #51 Lynn. I told you we would have a new P.M. 00:48  |  Maureen Ann 04/06/08
      103.   and,Roo proves what a racist,biggoted person she is in post # 96 00:56  |  terrornator 04/06/08
      104.   terrornator sets up `Straw Man` 01:01  |  Roo 04/06/08
      105.   mo-ROO-n,so now all Hilary supporters are blue collar,white, 01:03  |  terrornator 04/06/08
      106.   addition to # 97 Roo if blacks are willing to treat their own as 01:13  |  terrornator 04/06/08
      107.   justice 82 01:25  |  potobac 04/06/08
      108.   justice 80 01:28  |  potobac 04/06/08
      109.   justice 78 01:34  |  potobac 04/06/08
      110.   roo the racists are those who jail one million blacks 01:43  |  ivri 04/06/08
      111.   potobac but your human rights record in iraq and afghansitan 01:51  |  justice 04/06/08
      112.   potobac "the question is not what crime others commit" 01:54  |  justice 04/06/08
      113.   potobac "the blacks commit the most crimes 02:36  |  justice 04/06/08
      114.   potobac focus on this 02:40  |  justice 04/06/08
      115.   If you can`t the Heat, Then shut up! Teach love NOT hate 02:59  |  Doc Holliday 04/06/08
      116.   # 62 to lynn 03:12  |  eric 04/06/08
      117.   # 48 my apology to x-ray; i was mixing articles 03:22  |  eric 04/06/08
      118.   justice #113 what,is name calling all you got? 03:25  |  terrornator 04/06/08
      119.   From fiery-hateful oratory to tears in court 03:30  |  enrique 04/06/08
      120.   justice,focus on this,iraqis have killed hundreds of thousands of 03:44  |  terrornator 04/06/08
      121.   #115 Doc Holiday. In many documented cases... 04:00  |  Maureen Ann 04/06/08
      122.   justice 111 04:00  |  potobac 04/06/08
      123.   justice 112 04:03  |  potobac 04/06/08
      124.   justice 113 04:07  |  potobac 04/06/08
      125.   justice 114 04:11  |  potobac 04/06/08
      126.   # 48 my apology to x-ray; i mixed up articles (2nd try) 05:56  |  eric 04/06/08
      127.   Roo#95 - How do statistics make me a racist? 06:30  |  William 04/06/08
      128.   Mof L#100 - thanks for the history lesson 06:31  |  William 04/06/08
      129.   Roo#96 - "imagine jails full of white folks" 06:33  |  William 04/06/08
      130.   Maureen Ann did you say OUR soldiers? 08:19  |  Lennox 04/06/08
      131.   Send him to an Arab state 08:25  |  Ron 04/06/08
      132.   #121 get your facts straight 08:36  |  annoyed 04/06/08
      133.   Israeli torture 10:14  |  raymond deane 04/06/08
      134.   #133 10:54  |  Rab Burns 04/06/08
      135.   William 11:12  |  Roo 04/06/08
      136.   zoinists are not jews 13:21  |  khaled 04/06/08
      137.   Lennox 15:16  |  Benjamin 04/06/08
      138.   Roo,85% of the blacks in america are voting for obama,and you 16:59  |  terrornator 04/06/08
      139.   It is like saying that 90% Arabs are not Muslims 18:41  |  Genuine Tosefta 04/06/08
      140.   terromator 138 19:25  |  potobac 04/06/08
      141.   potobac,the same thing is happening in america today 21:39  |  terrornator 04/06/08
      142.   potobac,why is it only a problem when jews do it 21:45  |  terrornator 04/06/08
      143.   terromator 142 22:43  |  potobac 04/06/08
      144.   # 104 Roo not only are you following the manner/type of jb,BUT 21:32  |  KATHY 05/06/08
     Read & React
    Rosenblum: Israeli leaders want to be Obama
    Send response
    Pfeffer: Jewish Agency has signed its own death certificate
    Responses: 58
    Greenberg: The hero on flight 11
    Send response
    Nasrallah: We still seek fallen guerillas' bodies
    Responses: 16
    Top IDF officer: Israel not prepared for next war
    Responses: 16
    Chabad envoy to Alaska: Palin staunch friend of Jews
    Responses: 13


    More Headlines
    10:24 Nasrallah: Freeing Shaba won`t stop struggle against Israel
    08:39 Top IDF officer: Israel not prepared for next war
    08:10 McCain takes swipe at Bush, pledges to recover Americans' trust
    09:32 Sarkozy warns Iran it risks Israeli strike on nuke program
    09:38 This Ramadan, Arab TV seeks big ratings from captive audience
    01:25 Chabad envoy to Alaska: Palin staunch friend of Jews
    07:26 Assad: We won't cut ties with Hezbollah, despite Israel talks
    10:08 Nir Barkat campaign first to pursue Anglo constituents in Jerusalem
    04:44 Dichter: Officials who perpetrate leaks are akin to terrorists
    08:26 ANALYSIS / Ramon's settler evacuation-compensation bill is just talk
    09:41 VIDEO / Husband of innocent woman killed in botched gangland hit faces alleged killers
    08:19 Kadima sources: Olmert undermining successor to stay in power for longer
    07:23 Blair: Situation in West Bank has not improved fast enough
    02:10 Education Ministry to ban 'Bible Lite' study booklet
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Fattal Hotel Chain
    Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
    JMG your online solution
    Jewish Singles Personal Ads
    Find the love of your life on JDate.com
    MBA in Israel in English
    APPLY NOW! Limited spaces available
    Israel's Premier Real Estate Website
    www. israel-property.com
    Hebrew Summer courses
    From $39.95
    ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel
    Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
    Real Estate in Israel | Travel to Israel with Haaretz | Hotels Israel | Restaurants Israel | Tourist attractions Israel | Shops Israel
    birthright Israel | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved