Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., May 22, 2008 Iyyar 17, 5768 | | Israel Time: 06:29 (EST+7) web haaretz.com   Back to Homepage Rosner's Domain Diplomacy Defense Jewish World Opinion National Print Edition Advertising Books Peres Conference Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File

Last update - 12:08 18/05/2008 Lag b'Omer unity shattered by battle for grave of Kabbalah rabbi bar Yohai By Nathan Jeffay, The Forward Tags: Lag b'Omer, Israel  In Israel's answer to the Woodstock Festival, nearly half a million people will gather on a Galilee mountaintop on May 22, where they will pitch tents and engage in 24 hours of feasting, singing and ecstatic dancing. They will be taking part in the annual celebrations held on the yahrzeit of second-century sage Rabbi Shimon bar Yohai at his burial place on Mount Meron, near the northern Israeli city of Safed. The yahrzeit coincides with the minor festival of Lag b'Omer. The celebrations are widely viewed as a resounding display of Jewish unity. Advertisement "All shades of the rainbow come. There are Ashkenazim and Sephardim, Hasidim and knitted kippah-wearers, religious and secular," said Shlomo Shalvash, head of the Sephardic trust for the upkeep of the site. What makes bar Yohai such a crowd pleaser is the fact that he did not merely rule on matters of Jewish law. He is believed to have left the answers to life, the universe and everything, making him a figure of fascination for all these people, as well as stars like Madonna. Bar Yohai is the purported author of the Zohar, the central text of Kabbalah. But there is one mystery for which he left no answer: Just who owns his grave and the surrounding area? As revelers link arms and dance together, organizers will be locked in a bitter, ongoing behind-the scenes feud. Shalvash's Sephardic trust and a rival Ashkenazic one both claim full ownership of the site. The row is "paralyzing" the development of the site, the most visited religious place in Israel after the Western Wall, according to Jerusalem lawyer Shmuel Berkovitch, an expert on Israel's holy sites. In comparison to the chic plaza by the Western Wall, facilities on Meron are sparse, as each side knows that any building work it carries out is likely to be halted by challenges from the rival trust. "The place looks horrible," said Yosef Schvinger, head of the National Centre for Holy Sites, the government office that is meant to oversee the tomb and its surroundings. "It is not as the second most visited holy site in the country should look. It is also a safety concern. [The building around the tomb] is a very old building, and it must be sorted soon, otherwise the structure could be in danger. It is falling down." What frustrates Schvinger is that there is no lack of money for development. Before his death in 1999, Monaco-based Jewish banker Edmond Safra instructed his philanthropic foundation to fund redevelopment of the tomb and the surrounding area. The bequest is believed to be several million dollars, though the foundation's Israel representative, Yair Tarenageim, would not reveal its value. Tarenageim appeared to concede that the arguments are stopping the release of the funds, saying that in order to use the money all parties involved would have to work together. This week, as the row between the trusts continued, another battle began over the mountain. Moshav Meron, which surrounds the tomb, managed to halt work by the police and the National Centre for Holy Sites in preparation of the influx of Lag b'Omer visitors. It did so by obtaining an injunction at Nazareth Municipal Court, after bringing a claim that the moshav (and its members), and not the police and the National Centre for Holy Sites, has the rights to control access to the mountain during celebrations. This would have meant that, unlike the general public, moshav members would be allowed to bring cars up the mountain, and they could make money by running transport services to and from parking lots at the bottom. The police and the National Centre for Holy Sites claimed this would compromise security. The injunction stopped all Lag b'Omer preparations from Sunday, May 11, until the afternoon of Wednesday, May 14, when the case was heard in full and the moshav's demands rejected. Between the rival trusts, the battle lines are clearly drawn. According to Shalvash, "All areas are our areas" and the Ashkenazic trust "has no control of" Rabbi Shimon bar Yohai. But Ben-Zion Guberstadt, board member of the Ashkenazic trust, states simply, "We say the whole thing is ours." Both groups claim hundreds of years' precedent, and appeals through the past five years to courts - both religious and civil - have failed to settle the feud. "It is a matter of prestige," Berkovitch said. "Because of the high sanctity the place carries, and the very large number of visitors, controlling bar Yohai's grave carries with it a great deal of prestige, which the groups want for its own sake." Both groups say that they are ready to build prayer houses and ritual baths to serve the million-plus pilgrims a year. The Sephardim say they would use a multimillion-dollar Safra legacy. The Ashkenazim say that even without this money, they have donors in England who will give $25 million. The Sephardic trust, however, says that the Ashkenazim are driven less by a genuine interest in the site and more by the financial implications of control. Even 1,900 years after his death, many potential donors believe bar Yohai to be a fully active miracle worker. They also think that donations to charities linked to him will bring them special benefits. This means that showing tangible claim to the gravesite through buildings could be extremely lucrative. The Ashkenazic trust is battling for control "because they want money. That's the name of the game," Shalvash said in an interview with the Forward. Guberstadt flatly denied the claim. The battles frustrate politicians and many of the people on the ground at Meron. The prevailing opinion in the Israeli government is that it should take control of the site, an inside source said. On Meron, Rabbi Shraga Shnitzer suggests a different solution. Shnitzer, head of the independent charity Ohel Ha'Rashbi-Meron, which provides free food to visitors, believes that decisions about the site's future should be placed in the hands of the most respected contemporary halachic authorities, the gedolei hador. He said, "Ashkenazim and Sephardim need to sit together with gedolei hador who will come to the place and hear from everyone at Meron and decide what is allowed to do and what it is not allowed to do." But Schvinger says that any resolution will open up another can of worms, as there are rival splinter groups within each trust. "If it is decided that either the Sephardi or Ashkenazi hekdesh are the owners, this will open up a whole new question as to who is the true Sephardi or Ashkenazi hekdesh. Bookmark to del.icio.us   Say what you want French court: Claim that Al-Dura tape doctored isn`t libelous. Peace in our time Olmert: Peace talks with Syria are a 'national duty'.   1.   Another Kiddush HaShem!!!! 13:21  |  Jay A Friedman 18/05/08   2.   Jay A Friedman, master of sarcasm 14:58  |  Dror 18/05/08   3.   Bar Yohai`s tomb 15:23  |  Eli 18/05/08   4.   mmm- Very familiar indeed 15:52  |  Douglas Fireman 18/05/08   5.   Voodoo is Voodoo 16:37  |  Gad Giladi 18/05/08   6.   Nationalize National Assets 16:40  |  Straight Talk 18/05/08   7.   lag beomer 16:52  |  sceptic 18/05/08   8.   The High Rabbinical Court should rule... 17:42  |  Motic 18/05/08   9.   Ego rulles 17:42  |  Paul 18/05/08   10.   "Chic" plaza ? 19:01  |  David 18/05/08   11.   Let the secular Israel tourist authority take over! 19:07  |  colin 18/05/08   12.   The ashkenazim have quietly rebuilt the entire area, 19:16  |  just a Jew 18/05/08   13.   obviously written from New york 19:34  |  Joe Jew 18/05/08   14.   GIVE BACK TO PALESTINIANS 20:05  |  MIKE 18/05/08   15.   you cannot give back what was never theirs. 21:57  |  A young Jew 18/05/08   16.   #10 and have them continue to neglect it? 22:00  |  Jewboy 18/05/08   17.   Straight talk- the knesset is on Greek land 22:02  |  Jewboy 18/05/08   18.   Voddo and secular mantras 22:07  |  Jewboy 18/05/08   19.   Mike the Arabs were too busy: 22:10  |  Joe Jew 18/05/08   20.   The JewishPeople own this place. 00:02  |  harmonbond 19/05/08   21.   The GREEk ownership of Jewish Lands. 04:39  |  EGW 19/05/08   22.   Why don`t we all get along 06:15  |  gabriel 19/05/08   23.   #4 Douglas Fireman and the conflict 07:23  |  hala 19/05/08   24.   EGW the greek church siezed the land in turkish times 07:48  |  Joe Jew 19/05/08   25.   Kabbalah NOT connected to Bar Yokhai 09:35  |  Paqid Yirmeyahu 19/05/08   26.   Give it back to WHO? 10:21  |  Josh 19/05/08   27.   25- The forgery theory of Kabbalah is itself a forgery 11:01  |  Joe Jew 19/05/08   28.   Shimon Bar Yohai. 13:39  |  sandra chitayat 19/05/08   29.   Gabi in Houston 16:12  |  Dror 19/05/08   30.   #24 Seize, seize, seize! 22:13  |  hala 19/05/08   31.   # 14 Who owned the country? 09:45  |  Joseph 20/05/08   32.   Ownership of graves 09:51  |  Yossi 20/05/08   33.   ownership of land 17:42  |  michael furman 20/05/08   34.   Hamas now officially Hummus 04:43  |  Jou 22/05/08

Read & React Al Gore: Israel should lead the way in renewable energy Responses: 127 Olmert to U.S.: Impose naval blockade on Iran Responses: 281 Israel, Syria to begin indirect peace talks Responses: 248 Shein and Berkowitz: The demise of the European left Responses: 152 Rosner's Domain 8 short comments on the Israel-Syria peace talks 5 questions: Does Israel need rescue? Goldberg vs. Boot. I'm going to stay neutral! Rosner's Guests: Israel not likely to invade Gaza soon Can Obama win over Jewish voters? (WTR) More Headlines 04:52 PM: Talks with Syria are 'historic breakthrough' 02:21 ANALYSIS: What will come first, peace treaty or indictment? 04:11 Rice: Israeli-Palestinian track more likely to produce results 04:30 Gag order lifted on contents of Shula Zaken's date book 04:39 Poll: More Israelis object to Golan accord than to J'lem deal 04:51 PM got Erdogan's help, softened up Bush, and sent in Turbowicz 05:25 Sources: Not enough evidence to indict Olmert for bribery 21:36 8 short comments on the Israel-Syria peace talks 01:37 Ankara hopes for a direct Israel-Syria meeting next month 05:33 Head of Jewish Agency immigration dept. quits 22:18 Lebanese relieved as standoff ends; Hezbollah supporters celebrate 21:41 Ex-chief rabbi Eliyahu's condition deteriorates further after stroke 21:02 French court: Claim that Al-Dura tape doctored isn`t libelous 00:49 Man U defeats Chelsea FC in Champions League final Previous Editions Select Day 21 may 20 may 19 may 18 may 16 may 15 may 14 may 13 may 12 may 11 may 09 may 08 may

Special Offers Advertisement Dead Sea Products Buy Dead Sea mineral skin care and beauty products. Coupon code Haaretz for 10% off. Istudy Learn Hebrew in 3 months The Terraces Your Ultimate Coastal Address On Nitza Boulevard, North Netanya Together Celebrating Israel's 60th The Jewish Agency and You - together making history Pardes Institute Summer Sessions http://www.pardes.org.il/ Free the Palestinians from: Corrupt Kleptocracy, Tyrannical Theocracy, Abysmal Anarchy Fattal Hotel Chain Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel. ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th Eldan Rent a Car Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations Junkyard Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt

Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |

Real Estate in Israel

Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.

© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved