Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., May 20, 2008 Iyyar 15, 5768 | | Israel Time: 10:50 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Advertising
Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Rosner's Blog
Shmuel Rosner Chief U.S. Correspondent www.haaretz.com/rosner Biography | Email me
Posted: May 16, 2008

Was Bush's Knesset speech a swipe at Obama?

Barack Obama's aides were quick to respond. His people called it "extraordinary politicization of foreign policy." While U.S. President George W. Bush was speaking in Israel and comparing those who would talk with Iran to those who would have talked to Adolf Hitler, a storm broke out in the American political arena. Did Bush mean Obama? Was he comparing him to Neville Chamberlain? The president's travels in the Holy Land - which didn't make a lot of headlines in a media steeped in election coverage - were suddenly hot news.

Bush taunted those who follow "the false comfort of appeasement, which has been repeatedly discredited by history." There is only one candidate for the White House in 2008 who advocates direct dialogue with the Iranian regime, and that is Obama. And although the White House stated that Bush's remarks were not directed at Obama, pundits - and the campaign headquarters - were quick to find clues indicating that these comments were directed at the senator from Illinois. Obama issued a statement: "It is sad that President Bush would use a speech to the Knesset on the 60th anniversary of Israel's independence to launch a false political attack."

Obama also has an inherent interest in faking insult, thus garnering attention and emphasizing for voters the differences between him and Bush - and Republican candidate John McCain, widely seen as Bush's ideological heir.

Tying McCain to Bush is the Democratic strategy ahead of the upcoming election. And regarding Israel, the strategy is clear too: Everyone supports Israel, and any Republican attempt to claim otherwise is nothing but lies. Even Obama's rival, Hillary Clinton, said yes when asked if Obama would support Israel. So too says House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-California) ahead of her visit to Israel next week: All of them will support Israel - Obama, Clinton and McCain.

Obama, as we wrote Thursday, is working to calm voters worried that he might not support Israel as strongly as his predecessors. McCain plans to use the Iranian issue to prove that not all forms of support are equal. He hopes to attract Jewish votes in states like Florida, which could tip the scales in his favor, and believes he will succeed - certainly in getting more Jewish votes than Bush did in 2004.

Obama is setting his sights on McCain as Clinton slides out of political consciousness. Even with her impressive win in West Virginia, she had trouble filling the seats on her press bus this week, while Obama garners headline after headline. He's gotten some help from his new friend, John Edwards, a crucial endorsement. And no one knows which way the prized Al Gore endorsement will go yet. But Obama needs something more than Gore's endorsement: He needs superdelegates. He already has more of these than Clinton, but he will clinch the nomination only after he has enough to boost him from the "leading" candidate to the "winning" candidate.

Related articles:

  • Obama tries to inch closer to Israel
  • Obama advisor: Jerusalem must be included in peace talks
  • Jews bend over backward to stay neutral in U.S. vote

  •   1.   Bush` Speech 03:20  |  P. J. Casey 16/05/08
      2.   A good Swipe not just at Obama 03:31  |  Brod 16/05/08
      3.   Obama - I Hope It Was a Swipe 03:44  |  Tod Zuckerman 16/05/08
      4.   Jimmy Carter 04:25  |  Politics Politics 16/05/08
      5.   Depends on what the meaning of "support" is...is... 04:36  |  Webster 16/05/08
      6.   The President is Right. Here`s what he said. 04:42  |  MIKE 16/05/08
      7.   Conflicting reports say it WAS a cheap political ploy 04:51  |  Lou 16/05/08
      8.   The old addage-" the Jews want to take over the world" 04:57  |  Avrum 16/05/08
      9.   ALL THE GOYIM WILL PRAISE YOU, ISRAEL, G-D`S CHOSEN NATION))))))) 05:11  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 16/05/08
      10.   This belongs in "Rosner`s Domain" 05:14  |  Rowan 16/05/08
      11.   Huge difference... 05:15  |  Shalom 16/05/08
      12.   Bush speech 05:23  |  KT 16/05/08
      13.   Bush speech 05:25  |  KT 16/05/08
      14.   Duh! 05:45  |  barney 16/05/08
      15.   of course it was 06:12  |  steve 16/05/08
      16.   Are you seriously asking this, Rosner? 06:14  |  Occasional Observer 16/05/08
      17.   Obama, your pants are on fire 06:14  |  JustMe 16/05/08
      18.   I took Bush to mean all who propose apeasement, especially the 06:21  |  Ben 16/05/08
      19.   # 10 barney; Not so fast, Republicans have been waiting who will 06:30  |  Max Horoskopski 16/05/08
      20.   Was Bush taking a swipe at Obama 06:35  |  Kathleen Schofield 16/05/08
      21.   Your Poll 06:57  |  Leonard 16/05/08
      22.   If Obama plans on being the prez... 07:06  |  Walter 16/05/08
      23.   McCain is hopeless. He will lose his own base during campaign 07:23  |  Natallie Durson 16/05/08
      24.   do not be confused.. After seen how the US sold Iraq war.be aware 08:04  |  Marco 16/05/08
      25.   the reference in the speech 08:24  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 16/05/08
      26.   A WONDER BUSH STILL HAS ABILITY TO ATTACK 09:04  |  indrajaya 16/05/08
      27.   At Natallie Durson #16 be sure where you talk about 09:42  |  Marco 16/05/08
      28.   Bush: Arrogant, Shameful & A Disgrace 09:48  |  D. 16/05/08
      29.   Rosner In The Dark 09:52  |  Jonathan Swiller 16/05/08
      30.   Support democracy 10:14  |  Joe 16/05/08
      31.   #23 McCain lose his own base 10:14  |  ghostoflutherblisset 16/05/08
      32.   the worse that can happen for the West (Israel included)? 10:33  |  Marco 16/05/08
      33.   #23 now i know mcain will be elected nutullie 10:44  |  v hardman 16/05/08
      34.   Bush family aided Nazis 12:40  |  Harold S Kramer 16/05/08
      35.   Bush gets his info from Haaretz Bloggers 13:35  |  Ronnie Wolman 16/05/08
      36.   Reuters and a few others 13:36  |  Lynn 16/05/08
      37.   Hey Bush,Its OSAMA you are after, not Obama 13:39  |  Ronnie Wolman 16/05/08
      38.   Natallie Durson: McCain and Able 14:00  |  Ronnie Wolman 16/05/08
      39.   Churchill= Jaw is better than war 14:08  |  Galgal Ha-Khozer 16/05/08
      40.   Correction 14:33  |  Mary 16/05/08
      41.   Obama, I am sure, will attempt to appease Iran, and just for this 14:38  |  Bernard 16/05/08
      42.   Bush and Obama 15:11  |  Jerry 16/05/08
      43.   Munich analogy insults history -- time to stop using it 15:24  |  Proudest Zionist 16/05/08
      44.   Peace 15:28  |  Keeshond 16/05/08
      45.   ghostoflutherblisset # 28 McCain`s Base 16:04  |  Jeff Northridge 16/05/08
      46.   Bush` speak on the knesset 16:21  |  Mordechai Cano 16/05/08
      47.   Ronnie Wolman # 32 They Rhyme Don`t They? 16:23  |  Jeff Northridge 16/05/08
      48.   Proof-reading Rosner 16:29  |  Jay Chamblin 16/05/08
      49.   Yes, Cipora... 16:30  |  CHGODMK 16/05/08
      50.   How childish for Obama to act `offended`, to `resent`... 16:34  |  Guido 16/05/08
      51.   Obama for President 16:38  |  Choni Davidowitz 16/05/08
      52.   Bush`s Knesset Talk 16:41  |  t greenberg 16/05/08
      53.   Bush`s knesset speech 16:42  |  Tom Pantalena 16/05/08
      54.   Talking with Radicals 16:43  |  jdledell 16/05/08
      55.   Can Israel Afford to Alienate an Obama Presidency? 16:46  |  CHGODMK 16/05/08
      56.   Munich??? reply to 38 16:50  |  Rob of melbourne 16/05/08
      57.   McCain was for talking with Hamas in 2006 16:50  |  DrSteveB 16/05/08
      58.   Disinformation at its worst 16:51  |  Michael N 16/05/08
      59.   Trifling non-event of Bush visit 16:52  |  Jay Chamblin 16/05/08
      60.   Bush the most Jewish!! 17:08  |  Koala 16/05/08
      61.   Better analogy than Munich 17:13  |  ScotGuy 16/05/08
      62.   Really Attacking Reagan 17:19  |  Mark of Lewiston 16/05/08
      63.   Who is the stronger supporter of Israel 17:23  |  Sam C 16/05/08
      64.   To Indrajaya, no. 26 17:26  |  Sam C 16/05/08
      65.   To ALL BLOGGERS HERE 17:27  |  PINE 16/05/08
      66.   To ALL BLOGGERS HERE 17:28  |  PINE 16/05/08
      67.   # 38; I totally agree. 17:41  |  moke 16/05/08
      68.   swipe at Obama? don` be so self-centered 17:49  |  rehovot 16/05/08
      69.   Who wrote his speech to the Knesset ? 17:50  |  David James Vickery 16/05/08
      70.   "Faking Insult ..." 18:56  |  Timothy3 16/05/08
      71.   Bush has nothing to lose, but we do 18:57  |  Stanley 16/05/08
      72.   So, it`s clear that Shmuel will not vote for Obama. 19:17  |  ManintheMiddle 16/05/08
      73.   idotic 19:29  |  mike 16/05/08
      74.   TROJAN HORSE TUNNELS ENEMY WITHIN 19:43  |  MOSIACH 16/05/08
      75.   THIS WAS NEITHER ABOUT OBAMA NOR APPEASEMENT 20:41  |  James Raider 16/05/08
      76.   Bush, Obama and appeasement 21:11  |  james phillips 16/05/08
      77.   Tasteless 21:13  |  RSC 16/05/08
      78.   oBama is a complete moron putting words in Bush`s mouth. 21:29  |  Avram 16/05/08
      79.   Cheap Political Stunt by Obama 21:50  |  MIKE 16/05/08
      80.   its about obama, appeasement and funny as hell 21:58  |  proudamerican 16/05/08
      81.   Answer to your question 21:59  |  Jeremiah 16/05/08
      82.   Bush Now is meeting his masters the Terrorists 22:18  |  Sami Abdul 16/05/08
      83.   Republican Politicization of Israel 22:28  |  Jack 16/05/08
      84.   If the boot fits wear it, Me thinks Obama doth protest too much. 23:49  |  Galit 16/05/08
      85.   Bush was mild in his remarks 00:29  |  Salty 17/05/08
      86.   Obama`s chat with A-Jad 01:18  |  T Kemp 17/05/08
      87.   Max Horoskopski; Totally wrong conclussion and fear mongering 01:54  |  Max Horoskopski 17/05/08
      88.   Is Bush important enough? 02:48  |  Mohammad 17/05/08
      89.   #63. Good points, Jack. 03:15  |  ManintheMiddle 17/05/08
      90.   Sorry, I meant #79. But since I`m here, who`s the appeaser here? 03:43  |  ManintheMiddle 17/05/08
      91.   McCain is even slower than BushMcCain is even slower than Bush 04:48  |  Mush 17/05/08
      92.   Bush is so stupid it hurts 05:07  |  Caam 17/05/08
      93.   Bush speech 10:59  |  M Gallagher 17/05/08
      94.   #49, CHGODMK 11:23  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 17/05/08
      95.   #55, CHGODMK, can he walk on water? 11:34  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 17/05/08
      96.   Failure of Barak`s advisers 16:30  |  California Liberal 17/05/08
      97.   Cipora Julianna Kohn #94 17:52  |  CHGODMK 17/05/08
      98.   Cipora Julianna Kohn #95 17:59  |  CHGODMK 17/05/08
      99.   Cipora Julianna Kohn #95, Pt. II 18:04  |  CHGODMK 17/05/08
      100.   CHGODMK 22:00  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 17/05/08
      101.   Need to stop recycling history 22:59  |  amazed american 17/05/08
      102.   Bush should have apologized 23:35  |  Gene Gershon 17/05/08
      103.   Bush`s Recent Knesset Speech 23:40  |  Gene Buday 17/05/08
      104.   Cipora Julianna Kohn 23:44  |  CHGODMK 17/05/08
      105.   Ending Maxwell Smart`s Foreign Policy 03:20  |  Mark of Lewiston 18/05/08
      106.   Bush appeased Hamas 07:23  |  Rabbi Sendor Cohen 18/05/08
      107.   to #104chgodmk 09:26  |  Shmuelshachor