Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., May 19, 2008 Iyyar 14, 5768 | | Israel Time: 20:58 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Advertising
Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 18:15 17/05/2008
ANALYSIS: Who wants to stop Iran?
By Shmuel Rosner, Haaretz Correspondent
Tags: George W. Bush, Barack Obama 
Bush may not be as naive as Obama, but U.S. policy under his watch has failed on the Iranian issue.

Idaho senator William Borah didn't live to see the end of World War II. He died in 1940, before the U.S. had even joined the Allies and gotten involved in the war. Borah was an isolationist who wanted nothing more than American withdrawal from world affairs. And it is his words that Bush quoted Thursday in Jerusalem: "Lord, if I could only have talked to Hitler, all this might have been avoided."

Bush did not waver Thursday from the policies that have guided his administration since September 11, 2001. His position on Iran is longstanding. But on Thursday, when he again spoke of the naivete of those who believe dialogue can block Iran's nuclear program, it blipped on America's political radar. Barack Obama's campaign was quick to respond, calling it "extraordinary politicization of foreign policy." If those who want to talk to Iran are like those who wanted to talk to Hitler - then Obama is Neville Chamberlain or Senator Borah.

But Bush should be measured by the same yardstick. Meetings will not stop Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, but neither will speeches in Knesset.
Advertisement
Bush may not be as naive as Obama, but U.S. foreign policy under his leadership has failed time after time on the Iranian issue. International sanctions are too skimpy to mount any real pressure against Iran's uranium enrichment program, and Tehran is gaining.

One knowledgeable observer was using this baseball metaphor yesterday. The Iranians have players waiting on all three bases. Hamas on first, Syria on second and Hezbollah on third. All they need now is the grand slam homerun - a nuclear bomb in the hands of Iran that will send them running around the bases for home.

Bush often says he learned a thing or two from his years as the owner of the Texas Rangers baseball team: "I developed a thick skin against criticism. I learned to ignore minor setbacks and focus on the long haul." But in the case of Iran, the long haul is creeping ever closer, and it appears Bush plans to leave the problem for his successor.

Earlier this week, he gave the Israeli press a rather complicated answer regarding what he hopes to accomplish during his term. "I think what definitely will be done is a structure on how to deal with this, to try to resolve this diplomatically. In other words, sanctions, pressures, financial sanctions; a history of pressure that will serve as a framework to make sure other countries are involved."

And here is what he said Thursday: For the sake of peace, the world must not allow Iran to have a nuclear weapon. And he added: "America stands with you in firmly opposing Iran's nuclear weapons ambitions." Bush's declarations could be seen as a calming expression of support: The U.S. president clearly does not favor a nuclear Iran. But one can also wonder about the wording he chose in this speech. Does relying on what the "world" does - or standing with Israel, which might take action itself - mean that America does not plan to be the one to stop Iran?

Related articles:
  • Kissinger at Peres conference: Timetable needed to combat global nuclear threat
  • Ahmadinejad: Israel 'dying,' Mideast to destroy it when given chance
  • New IAF chief mentions Iran, abductees at inauguration ceremony
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Nothing to fear
    Nancy Pelosi in Israel: I trust all presidential candidates in regard to Israel.
    Bonfire drama
    Mount Meron grave of famed rabbi at center of ownership row.
      1.   Rosner -- Get real 03:31  |  sam 16/05/08
      2.   Sane people 03:39  |  Jonny 16/05/08
      3.   Bush and Olmert Full of Rhetoric No Action 03:52  |  Gary 16/05/08
      4.   Just think of the advantages of Olmert 03:56  |  Mark Lincoln 16/05/08
      5.   Bush Is A Worldwide disaster 04:02  |  Moshe 16/05/08
      6.   Meanwhile in the US Navy 04:04  |  Mark Lincoln 16/05/08
      7.   stop iran 04:42  |  Shmuelshachor 16/05/08
      8.   Acceptance and Blame Placement 04:45  |  Druid 16/05/08
      9.   Bush Laid Down the Int`l Ground Work against Iran Nukes 04:49  |  Joseph . E 16/05/08
      10.   to Sam 04:52  |  sami 16/05/08
      11.   BUSH`S POOR JUDGMENT CAN`T BE TRUSTED 05:22  |  Arik Silverman 16/05/08
      12.   Israel - I Hope It Is Preparing to Take Out the Iranian Reactors 05:27  |  Tod Zuckerman 16/05/08
      13.   To Jonny, no. 2 05:29  |  Sam C 16/05/08
      14.   # 5 Bush has proven to be a national and a worldwide leader 05:30  |  Joseph . E 16/05/08
      15.   bush is the naive one 05:49  |  barney 16/05/08
      16.   Put this stuff in "Rosner`s Domain" 05:55  |  Rowan 16/05/08
      17.   Iran Threat 06:23  |  Jonathan 16/05/08
      18.   you heard it here first 07:03  |  Gregor 16/05/08
      19.   Bush can`t even stop Israel. How can he stop Iran? 07:15  |  Natallie Durson 16/05/08
      20.   Good news, bad news 07:24  |  Shimon Cleopas 16/05/08
      21.   Stop the Lie 07:41  |  ERSB 16/05/08
      22.   Do we trust Mahmoud Ahmadinejad ? 07:56  |  Jean Van Daem 16/05/08
      23.   Rosner, you are right in your analysis 08:44  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 16/05/08
      24.   Durson ravings on Israeli biological WMDs 09:35  |  Stephen in New York 16/05/08
      25.   #19 ERSB, Truth is so hard to come by, THX 09:36  |  Dror 16/05/08
      26.   Israel must bite as much as it can eat...or 09:45  |  Iranian-American 16/05/08
      27.   The only one to stop Iran is McCain. But he won`t be President 09:45  |  S 16/05/08
      28.   When Iran goes nuclear 09:48  |  Dror 16/05/08
      29.   Iran should not be stopped and cannot be stopped. 09:52  |  Dutch Dirk 16/05/08
      30.   USA-Iran Power Sharing 10:02  |  MiddleStanian 16/05/08
      31.   #19, Durson 10:05  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 16/05/08
      32.   Begging and cringing got Israel in the present mess,time to strai 10:06  |  Absolute Sweden 16/05/08
      33.   I have a little problem with my sources 10:18  |  Rowan 16/05/08
      34.   to Joseph E. 10:21  |  tony benson 16/05/08
      35.   Tod,the IDF pilots might even refuse to bomb Iran 11:04  |  Absolute Sweden 16/05/08
      36.   Cipora #22 Exactly. 11:11  |  S 16/05/08
      37.   What Bush learned as owner of the Texas Rangers 11:39  |  Peter 16/05/08
      38.   One starts to support Iran with passion when reading posts here 11:57  |  Mark B. 16/05/08
      39.   Even Rahm Emanuel slammed Bush 12:51  |  Rowan 16/05/08
      40.   Naivete abounds - when would Bush order the attack ? 13:34  |  redmike 16/05/08
      41.   #5 - I doubt your name is Moshe but you gave us a laugh! 13:40  |  redmike 16/05/08
      42.   Iran is convenient for America 14:35  |  Ronnie Wolman 16/05/08
      43.   One thing for sure 15:14  |  Chris Linthwaite 16/05/08
      44.   Forget it 15:36  |  William 16/05/08
      45.   It`s up to Israel to destroy Iran`s nukes. What are we waiting fo 15:46  |  Chaim 16/05/08
      46.   For Tod Zuckerman, safe in San Francisco # 12 15:58  |  Clickfool 16/05/08
      47.   Question for Chaim #34 16:05  |  Clickfool 16/05/08
      48.   Obama Will Not Win in 2008 16:12  |  Gary 16/05/08
      49.   #30 - RedMike 17:01  |  jdledell 16/05/08
      50.   Maybe Bush IS Ahmadinejad 17:09  |  Aphemia 16/05/08
      51.   #32 Chris Lintwaite. One thing for sure - 18:03  |  Axel 16/05/08
      52.   What do you militant Zionists think ... 18:04  |  Axel 16/05/08
      53.   TheJews will get their war with Iran 18:36  |  John 16/05/08
      54.   Israel`s best friend: George Bush 18:37  |  John 16/05/08
      55.   Cipora Julianna Kohn 18:55  |  John Syracuse 16/05/08
      56.   For #35 19:08  |  Claude 16/05/08
      57.   WHO WANTS TO STOP ISRAEL 19:10  |  indrajaya 16/05/08
      58.   For John Syracuse # 39 19:14  |  Clickfool 16/05/08
      59.   Rosner...Stop Criticizing Obama 19:18  |  MB 16/05/08
      60.   # 40 claude 19:24  |  Axel 16/05/08
      61.   chaim 19:28  |  Axel 16/05/08
      62.   # 24 - Kohn - Action speaks louder than words 19:28  |  Natallie Durson 16/05/08
      63.   2nd try-Durson on Israeli biological WMDs 19:35  |  Stephen in New York 16/05/08
      64.   2nd try-Durson on Israeli biological WMDs 19:37  |  Stephen in New York 16/05/08
      65.   lose-lose situation for Israel 19:54  |  spyguy 16/05/08
      66.   #3 Gary - Bush anti-war ?? -- you gotta be kidding 20:02  |  Rick 16/05/08
      67.   Is the Israeli public prepared ... 20:29  |  Axel 16/05/08
      68.   Call themselves world leaders? Gutless, spineless wreched men. 20:52  |  Harvey (Chaim) 16/05/08
      69.   eliminate all iranian military capacity now. 20:55  |  frenz 16/05/08
      70.   #28, Mark B 21:14  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 16/05/08
      71.   Rosner, you forget about Kaddhafi 21:15  |  Mack 16/05/08
      72.   US foregn policy dictated by the UN 21:19  |  Avram 16/05/08
      73.   Durson, Kohn is too smart for you. 21:31  |  Nathan 16/05/08
      74.   Bush is a disaster for Israel 21:45  |  scott 16/05/08
      75.   What do Blair and Rosner have in common? 21:53  |  Jeremiah 16/05/08
      76.   For Mark B # 28 21:55  |  Clickfool 16/05/08
      77.   Bush`s speech in Knesset 22:20  |  Hilda 16/05/08
      78.   Iran-Not a super power like Germany cira 1940 22:24  |  Tom Clark 16/05/08
      79.   I`m so embarassed of my US president 22:42  |  Soccer01 16/05/08
      80.   The May 15th Prophecy 22:55  |  LastDayWatch 16/05/08
      81.   Churchill`s wisdom for Slowman 00:22  |  Shmuel Rosner 17/05/08
      82.   # 53 avram 00:32  |  Axel 17/05/08
      83.   Obama not naive 01:33  |  Don 17/05/08
      84.   Obama not naive 01:34  |  Don 17/05/08
      85.   the beauty of this 01:57  |  natan 17/05/08
      86.   Durson 02:01  |  Maura 17/05/08
      87.   First, Israel was in action, now is full of inaction 03:18  |  Ingvar Karlsen 17/05/08
      88.   Durson,listen to Cipora 03:37  |  Max 17/05/08
      89.   don`t be so gullible durson 03:39  |  max 17/05/08
      90.   George Bush`s speech in Israel. 04:24  |  Maureen Ann 17/05/08
      91.   Hubris 05:11  |  John M. Nardo 17/05/08
      92.   Review Question 05:22  |  Shimon Cleopas 17/05/08
      93.   Is there no one? 05:49  |  Mark Lincoln 17/05/08
      94.   #93, Mark Lincoln 06:50  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 17/05/08
      95.   tsk tsk tsk rosner; you ought to be ashamed! 08:25  |  eric 17/05/08
      96.   fundamentalism is goin down 10:08  |  Nemo 17/05/08
      97.   #95, eric 10:44  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 17/05/08
      98.   Obama flef guilty hence assuming Bush meant him when refering to 12:13  |  Joe 17/05/08
      99.   The "problem" with Iran 13:37  |  RW 17/05/08
      100.   # 38 Mark B...colonial powers and racists 15:22  |  Lynn 17/05/08
      101.   # 76 Clicky....sounds like something 15:29  |  Lynn 17/05/08
      102.   # 39 Rowan...are the Dems feeling guilty? 15:34  |  Lynn 17/05/08
      103.   Analyze this...then that...!? 16:45  |  Joobin 17/05/08
      104.   ROSNER, U.S. HAS BEEN NEGOTIATING WITH IRAN 16:48  |  JH 17/05/08
      105.   Eisenhouwer overruled his generals 17:25  |  Count Iblis 17/05/08
      106.   Who does Bush think he`s talking to? 19:53  |  Rachel 17/05/08
      107.   incompetence 20:00  |  sam 17/05/08
      108.   Nathan -73 you jesting? 20:07  |  uriah heep 17/05/08
      109.   Beware of God`s People 21:17  |  Brad 17/05/08
      110.   The only problem is Brad..... 21:32  |  David Vickery 17/05/08
      111.   "Real" Israelites Response 23:21  |  Brad 17/05/08
      112.   "Real" Israelites Response 23:34  |  Brad 17/05/08
      113.   Equality, anathema to...... 23:55  |  Gray 17/05/08
      114.   let`s get real here 23:57  |  margaret 17/05/08
      115.   Who says Obama is Naive? 00:57  |  ARTH 18/05/08
      116.   to joobin # 103 01:10  |  rachel 18/05/08
      117.   BOMB Iran & Syria 01:49  |  Paul 18/05/08
      118.   US citizens point of view 01:51  |  American 18/05/08
      119.   102 Lynn - Obama Responds 02:34  |  Mark of Lewiston 18/05/08
      120.   39 Rowan - Bush was attacking Reagan 02:39  |  Mark of Lewiston 18/05/08
      121.   who wants to stop Iran? 05:30  |  lainey 18/05/08
      122.   BUSH as BUSH 06:24  |  Jason 18/05/08
      123.   #119, Mark of Lewiston 08:39  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 18/05/08
      124.   Obama fell for a ploy 10:08  |  Reid 18/05/08
      125.   Mark of Lewiston 10:17  |  Reid 18/05/08
      126.   #123, Reid 10:32  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 18/05/08
      127.   "Peace in Our Time" part 2 11:23  |  FOX 18/05/08
      128.   123 Cipora 12:13  |  Mark of Lewiston 18/05/08
      129.   125 Reid - Swiftboating Losing Effectiveness 12:21  |  Mark of Lewiston 18/05/08
      130.   Israel naive about Bush: Strong words do not a strong man make, 1 12:52  |  David Turner 18/05/08
      131.   Israel naive about Bush: Strong words do not a strong man make, 2 12:53  |  Dvid Turner 18/05/08
      132.   Part III March 1938 13:09  |  FOX 18/05/08
      133.   OBAMA AND OLMERT ARE THREAT TO ISRAEL 16:22  |  ROB SCHWARTZ 18/05/08
      134.   diplomacy the Bush/McCain way... 19:32  |  lainey 18/05/08
      135.   #110 David Vickery 20:21  |  ballistic 18/05/08
      136.   #133 Rob Schwartz 20:24  |  ballistic 18/05/08
      137.   #118 American 21:05  |  ballistic 18/05/08
      138.   #98 Joe in FL 21:15  |  ballistic 18/05/08
      139.   #114 Great post Margaret, go Obama! 21:17  |  ballistic 18/05/08
      140.   # 97 maybe it has cipora, 23:22  |  eric 18/05/08
      141.   John Syracuse - Reread your history 01:03  |  Reid 19/05/08
      142.   Rosner on Brooks on Obama on Chomsky 10:12  |  T.R. Neibhor 19/05/08
      143.   Analysis: Stop Iran time? 20:51  |  Heatherross 19/05/08
     Read & React
    Israel to Hezbollah: Forget Palestinian prisoners in swap for IDF soldiers
    Responses: 109
    Bin Laden: All Muslims must help end Gaza siege
    Responses: 107
    Obama urges settler policy change, recognition of Israel
    Responses: 79
    Google founder: Anti-Semitism drove my family from Russia
    Responses: 66
    MKs seek to strike Arabic as an official language of Israel
    Responses: 104
    Rosner's Domain
    Harel & Issacharoff: Can Israel deter Hezbollah and Hamas?
    What makes Nancy Pelosi pro-Israeli?
    The hysteria over talking to Hamas (WTR)
    Poll: Was Bush attacking Obama?
    Israel, the largest Jewish ghetto? (WTR)


    More Headlines
    20:42 Ramon: Israel's government holding talks with Hamas
    20:15 Prosecutor: Talansky personally handed Olmert envelopes of cash
    20:39 Barak to Mubarak: No truce with Hamas unless attacks stop
    19:33 France FM: We are in touch with Hamas; group confirms informal contact
    19:46 Rights groups accuse police of brutality during Nakba protest
    20:37 Egypt: U.S., Israeli occupations causing more Mideast instability
    19:21 Make love not war: Israeli adult Web site promotes reconciliation in new way
    19:44 Accused Nazi guard loses appeal on extradition to Ukraine
    20:50 Chelsea's Avram Grant fails to secure vote of confidence for next season
    19:34 Bridge over troubled city / J'lem braces for unveiling of oft-maligned monument
    13:03 Israel to Hezbollah: Forget Palestinian prisoners in swap for IDF soldiers
    17:20 PMO: Olmert to have 'routine' test for cancer treatment
    16:48 Palestinian troops arrest two Islamic Jihad leaders in Jenin
    20:34 Israeli jails use dog barks to spot prison break
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Dead Sea Products
    Buy Dead Sea mineral skin care and beauty products. Coupon code Haaretz for 10% off.
    Istudy
    Learn Hebrew in 3 months
    The Terraces
    Your Ultimate Coastal Address On Nitza Boulevard, North Netanya
    Together Celebrating Israel's 60th
    The Jewish Agency and You - together making history
    Pardes Institute Summer Sessions
    http://www.pardes.org.il/
    Free the Palestinians from:
    Corrupt Kleptocracy, Tyrannical Theocracy, Abysmal Anarchy
    Fattal Hotel Chain
    Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
    ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel
    Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
    Real Estate in Israel
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved