Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., January 26, 2009 Shvat 1, 5769 | | Israel Time: 13:53 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Joy of Giving Travel Week's End Anglo File
Let's be done with all the Talanskys
By Gideon Levy
Tags: Israe, Ehud Olmert 

Click here for more articles by Gideon Levy

Revealing the identity of the primary witness, Morris Talansky, in the lastest Ehud Olmert affair raises questions that go beyond the prime minister. Serious questions need to be asked about the relationship between American Jewry and Israel.

Granted, Talansky is a mere individual, but he is not the only one. Jerusalem is full of wheeler-dealers, functionaries, lobbyists, donors and philanthropists. There are rich men and middlemen, envoys and delegations, many of them with good intentions, but some without.
Advertisement
They wheedle and schnorr and contribute to various causes. It's the kind of schnorring that begins with Shaare Zedek Medical Center and could end in court. The question here is why did Talansky, or any other Jewish American, invest, allegedly, in Olmert? What do they receive in exchange for this pot stirring?

It's time to reorganize the system, to air out the relationship between the world's largest and second-largest Jewish community - a relationship that has long become distorted and even harmful. It is time to say to the American Jews directly, as is customary among relatives: Leave us alone. Take your hands off Israel. Stop using your money to buy influence in Israel. Stop "contributing" to advance your interests and views, some of which are at times delusionary and extremely dangerous to the future of the country you're supposedly trying to protect.

No thank you, we're doing all right. No thank you, some of you are causing us great damage. If you want to wield influence, do it in your own country. You have a lot of power and influence there. Perhaps too much; it's none of our business. You are American, not Israeli citizens, and no amount of money can or should change this fact. War and peace, social justice and government, education and religion in Israel are a matter for its citizens alone.

Our door should of course remain open to visits, immigration and displays of interest. But the extent of American Jewry's intervention in our affairs has long become intolerable. It's time to show them the door - the one that separates them from us.

Israeli politicians from all parties engage in an overly close rapport with American Jews, and of course, their money. The American Jewish establishment may support all Israeli governments blindly and automatically - this, too, is inexplicable and raises weighty questions. But under the official countenance of not intervening in our internal affairs, they have a thumb in every pie.

Sixty years old, economically sound, enjoying the great superpower's massive support, which is unequalled worldwide - Israel is strong and mature enough to manage without the interference of American Jewry.

The name of the game, of course, is money. Everything is about money, even if it is concealed under a pile of cliches and promises. From the prime minister to the mayor of a remote town, from hospital director to community center manager - all look to Jewish-American money. That's a guarantee for unhealthy relations. If it could be justified in the state's early days, when everything was still new, it no longer has place in a 60-year-old state that can and should build its own community centers and avoid the price it will be charged for schnorring. We are dealing with an impatient, aggressive Jewish community, whose aggression is reflected in its relations with Israel.

In many areas the damage is direct and considerable. The settlements in the territories, for example, would not have thrived and grown had it not been for the big money flowing from American Jews. A Ynet investigation released around two years ago found that American Jews sent $100 million to the settlements in the past decade.

Dozens of Jewish associations foster and finance the most nefarious project we've ever had here, from the One Israel Fund to the Hebron Fund, from American Friends of Ateret Cohanim to Shuvu Banim. They are all fattening the settlements, some openly and others under the table.

By so doing the Jews are helping to shape and mutilate another state. It's not only money: The loud, blatant Jewish right wing, which crushes any display of a different opinion in America, is trying to do the same in Israel. Camera, a McCarthyist group that persecutes journalists in the United States, is directing its absurd persecution and slander campaigns against the Israeli media as well. That is also part of the distorted relationship.

The contribution of American Jewry to Israel may on balance be positive. They financed and built for us quite heavily; we in turn offered them a safe haven and a source of pride. Neither side of this equation is relevant any longer. We no longer need their money, certainly not at the price of their interference, and it is doubtful we can still offer them that haven or pride. Let's part as friends, then. Let American Jews attend to their own business, and us to ours. And let's be done with any more Talanskys.
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Disturbing trend
Jewish Agency says Anti-Semitic acts in Jan. 2009 triple last year's records.
After the war
IDF gains in Gaza have softened Israel's stance on Shalit deal.
  1.   Leave Us Alone AIPAC 09:50  |  Tupac 11/05/08
  2.   Talansky 11:01  |  Ralph 11/05/08
  3.   Israel a source of pride, derision, fear - take your pick 11:05  |  dana 11/05/08
  4.   put the blame where it belongs 11:09  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 11/05/08
  5.   Not forgetting the equally malign US Christian Zionists 11:25  |  Chanalau, Tova 11/05/08
  6.   Israeli and diaspora Jews mix into each other`s business 11:29  |  Sam 11/05/08
  7.   So CAMERA has been getting at you, Gideon, eh? 11:48  |  Freethinker 11/05/08
  8.   Strong words from an employee of a GERMAN-OWNED NEWSPAPER! 11:49  |  Dr. L. Brnd 11/05/08
  9.   Without the (right-wing) U.S. Jewish establishment...... 12:09  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/05/08
  10.   This time Levy is really foaming at the mouth 12:24  |  Freethinker 11/05/08
  11.   Let`s rather be done with all the Gideon Levy & Amira Hass` 12:32  |  Ari ben Yisrael 11/05/08
  12.   Let`s be done with all the Talanskys 12:34  |  Ephraim Ben-Zeev 11/05/08
  13.   The entire zionist project was a colossal mistake and the 12:46  |  lakshmi 11/05/08
  14.   AIPAC supported by the loony right 13:10  |  Marilyn 11/05/08
  15.   unintended consequences and careless journalism 13:22  |  nina 11/05/08
  16.   $100 million for Gaza greenhouses given to the palis 13:31  |  Tom 11/05/08
  17.   14. Marilyn : the ?truth? 13:39  |  Lea 11/05/08
  18.   Serious questions need to be asked about Gideon Levy 13:49  |  Joe Sittizen 11/05/08
  19.   7.Freethinker: Gideon and CAMERA 13:51  |  Rose 11/05/08
  20.   Beilin said this years ago 14:00  |  Rowan 11/05/08
  21.   American Jews influence 14:33  |  nkd 11/05/08
  22.   Gideon Levy. 14:36  |  sandra chitayat 11/05/08
  23.   The US Jews help Israel!!! 14:48  |  Dr Eric 11/05/08
  24.   Shame on Gideon Levi 14:50  |  dr Eric 11/05/08
  25.   Levy`s Point of View 15:21  |  Jane 11/05/08
  26.   skating on thin ice, Gideon 15:24  |  Geoff - Sydney 11/05/08
  27.   7.Freethinker: Gideon and CAMERA 15:28  |  Rose 11/05/08
  28.   US Jewry holding back peace 15:58  |  El-Birawi 11/05/08
  29.   Marilyn 16:05  |  Australia 11/05/08
  30.   "Money under the Table"..! 16:09  |  Stephen. 11/05/08
  31.   Good Article by Gideon Levy & he`s right...enough political influ 16:14  |  Smadar 11/05/08
  32.   Europe and the Left 16:20  |  daat y 11/05/08
  33.   # Thank You Dr Brnd - 16:38  |  Lisa 11/05/08
  34.   Thank You to our brothers in the US!!! 16:42  |  Dr Eric 11/05/08
  35.   How wonderful Israel is!! 16:47  |  dr Eric 11/05/08
  36.   Integrity still must have a role 16:50  |  Geoff - Sydney 11/05/08
  37.   American Jews are proud of Israel and love Israel!!! 16:53  |  Dr Eric 11/05/08
  38.   Thank You JANE #25 17:01  |  Dr Eric 11/05/08
  39.   us money and supportkeeps Israel strong 17:08  |  aaron Tobin 11/05/08
  40.   Let`s be done with all the Talansky 17:09  |  Joe 11/05/08
  41.   Question 17:17  |  US Jew in Israel 11/05/08
  42.   Do Pals want state on West Bank if they must accept Jewish state? 17:35  |  Sam 11/05/08
  43.   WOW! I Agree 17:37  |  JT 11/05/08
  44.   "Let`s be done" Impossible, I say. 17:43  |  hollingsworth 11/05/08
  45.   Don`t forget Robert Maxwell 17:47  |  Chris Linthwaite 11/05/08
  46.   Right on, Gidon 17:50  |  Shelley 11/05/08
  47.   Gideon Levy 18:07  |  Fred Voss 11/05/08
  48.   Gideon Levy is right American jews are the biggest problem 18:42  |  Yaakov Sullivan 11/05/08
  49.   #13 lakshmi. Absolutely. israel must be peacefully dismantled. 18:43  |  Yaakov Sullivan 11/05/08
  50.   to Fred Voss #47 18:55  |  Dr Eric 11/05/08
  51.   No More American Jewish Involvement 19:34  |  MB 11/05/08
  52.   Potential or future Israelis 19:43  |  Joseph 11/05/08
  53.   Levy is absolutely correct 19:45  |  david 11/05/08
  54.   Give it instead to the ... 19:46  |  Joe 11/05/08
  55.   Why not just be gracious... 19:48  |  Avi 11/05/08
  56.   Leave us alone 20:00  |  Victor 11/05/08
  57.   ok wise-guy- who funds you? 20:05  |  Jewboy 11/05/08
  58.   Gideon, please limit yourself to writing about the poor Palestini 20:14  |  Michael 11/05/08
  59.   Let`s be done with all the Levys 20:18  |  Ron 11/05/08
  60.   #13 Yaakov Sullivan 20:21  |  Udi 11/05/08
  61.   The Corruption that rots from within 20:25  |  Greg Bacon 11/05/08
  62.   WHAT "SETTLEMENTS" ARE YOU REFERRING TO? 20:40  |  PalestniansAreA Myth 11/05/08
  63.   get real 20:47  |  - 11/05/08
  64.   42 Sam,the shoe is on the other foot! Since 1988 20:49  |  lakshmi 11/05/08
  65.   Pals don`t accept Jewish state.Why should Jews accept Pal one? 21:18  |  Sam 11/05/08
  66.   They`re not doing you much of a favor.... 21:27  |  Gray 11/05/08
  67.   Too much influence? & U ignore other Jewish-US organisations #1 21:36  |  USAccuracy 11/05/08
  68.   ...U deny other organisations #2 21:54  |  USAccuracy 11/05/08
  69.   Part as friends? Not with your insults and interference 22:20  |  Goes both ways, Levy 11/05/08
  70.   PalestiansAreAMyth 22:31  |  Bridleways 11/05/08
  71.   # 13 Lopsh, how about dirty and hungry hindu state?... 22:42  |  misha 11/05/08
  72.   Greg Bacon #61, more than just "tax dollars" 22:46  |  Gray 11/05/08
  73.   Anti-Jewish Propaganda 22:50  |  guy 11/05/08
  74.   Agree, but..... 22:55  |  Emetty 11/05/08
  75.   Crying "anti-semitism and taking U.S. tax $ 23:20  |  Gray 11/05/08
  76.   Another stupid article from Gideon Levy 23:43  |  Josh 11/05/08
  77.   hawa, hot air 23:56  |  yonah 11/05/08
  78.   From a Gideon Levy groupie... 23:56  |  Esther 11/05/08
  79.   My apologies.. "crying anti-semitism..." 00:04  |  Gray 12/05/08
  80.   Leave us alone EU and other foreign retreat supporters 00:05  |  Dr. Aaron Lerner 12/05/08
  81.   #5 accurate, #9 accurate but there`s more to it 00:12  |  sherry 12/05/08
  82.   No more American Friends of Peace Now!!!!!!!! 00:25  |  Dov Hatzafon 12/05/08
  83.   #60 This guy is a NY actor, married with 2 kids 00:49  |  Yaakov Sullivan 12/05/08
  84.   CAMERA has the gall to criticize journalists!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 00:51  |  BDL 12/05/08
  85.   #69, "goes both ways, Levy" 01:16  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 12/05/08
  86.   God`s oath with Israel 01:21  |  roger wallace 12/05/08
  87.   Response to #81, "silencing of any critism of Israel"???? 01:41  |  Proud American 12/05/08
  88.   #15 Nina. When is enough, enough for Israel? 01:59  |  Maureen Ann 12/05/08
  89.   AIPAC...Right wing US Jews...The Christian Zionests..... 02:01  |  ali 12/05/08
  90.   It takes all kinds 02:09  |  Afikoman 12/05/08
  91.   What about the foreign funding of `Peace Now` et al? 03:31  |  Jason 12/05/08
  92.   A Ynet investigation released around two years ago found that Ame 04:06  |  Silvienne 12/05/08
  93.   We are all Jews, except for Herr Levy. 04:16  |  Mr. Ami Goldman 12/05/08
  94.   #8 Dr Brnd - You hit the nail on the HEAD! 05:07  |  Maya 12/05/08
  95.   Gideon Levy is right! 05:42  |  Truth Serum 12/05/08
  96.   American jews 06:09  |  johnjf 12/05/08
  97.   Everyone! Please Google "Political Ponerology" 06:26  |  HPS 12/05/08
  98.   4 Cipora - Nefarious? 07:52  |  Mark of Lewiston 12/05/08
  99.   4 Cipora - Nefarious? 07:52  |  Mark of Lewiston 12/05/08
  100.   Let`s be done with all the Talanskys 07:55  |  Jeremy 12/05/08
  101.   47 Fred Voss - Real Charitable Contributions are Fine 08:01  |  Mark of Lewiston 12/05/08
  102.   what are you proposing? 08:06  |  benham 12/05/08
  103.   18 Re: Serious questions about Joe Sittizen` suggestion 08:27  |  Dutch 12/05/08
  104.   # 11 Ari Ben Yisrael, your short sightness 09:03  |  Dutch 12/05/08
  105.   92. Silvienne.Raising funds for terror 09:04  |  Berenice 12/05/08
  106.   # 94 Maya 09:23  |  Dutch 12/05/08
  107.   Gideon Levy, a recent poll 09:36  |  Dutch 12/05/08
  108.   you`ve said it well, gideon; it`s time israel WEANED itself! 09:40  |  eric 12/05/08
  109.   and for us non-Jews in US 10:03  |  samos 12/05/08
  110.   # 100 Berenice , what about state sponsored terrorism? 10:23  |  Dutch 12/05/08
  111.   gidon levy is an ant compared to... 10:28  |  jo jo 12/05/08
  112.   # 69 to cipora re: the poster you agree with 10:42  |  eric 12/05/08
  113.   G.Levy is a giant compared to some posters #109 11:10  |  A.M. 12/05/08
  114.   And what about Peace Now and the EU ?? 11:40  |  Leah 12/05/08
  115.   Agree with Aaron Lerner! 11:47  |  Leah 12/05/08
  116.   # 109 hey there jo jo 12:01  |  eric 12/05/08
  117.   Jo Jo #109 a poster child for what is wrong with this discourse! 14:02  |  HPS 12/05/08
  118.   Camera or CAMERA? 16:08  |  H-Haw 12/05/08
  119.   #112 eric 16:44  |  Question Mark 12/05/08
  120.   @119 re: Wars for Israel: TRUTH is not anti-Semitic! 18:12  |  HPS 12/05/08
  121.   #120 HPS 18:49  |  Question Mark 12/05/08
  122.   @Question Mark: You`ve got to be kidding me. 19:26  |  HPS 12/05/08
  123.   More "pathetic inability to reason" right here! 19:34  |  HPS 12/05/08
  124.   And who can forget good Ari? Haaretz April 2003 19:36  |  HPS 12/05/08
  125.   More evidence of US Zionist/Neocon meddling 19:39  |  HPS 12/05/08
  126.   #122 HPS 19:49  |  Question Mark 12/05/08
  127.   #125 and Others HPS Part 2 20:11  |  Question Mark 12/05/08
  128.   to dr L BMD San diego - dirty misinformation 20:45  |  anatoli 12/05/08
  129.   I was going to answer Mr. Question Mark in detail 21:47  |  HPS 12/05/08
  130.   #129 HPS 22:13  |  Question Mark 12/05/08
  131.   HPS Is it anywonder whyAmericans want totake back their goverment 23:02  |  Dutch 12/05/08
  132.   #131 Dutch 00:30  |  Question Mark 13/05/08
  133.   #105, No, Berenice, that is not what I said... 04:16  |  Silvienne 13/05/08
  134.   # 119 to question mark 04:18  |  eric 13/05/08
  135.   #134 eric 05:52  |  Question Mark 13/05/08
  136.   # 133 Question Mark, Re: The Christian Right 08:07  |  Dutch 13/05/08
  137.   # 135 whatever you say, question mark 08:24  |  eric 13/05/08
  138.   # 118 to h-haw 08:49  |  eric 13/05/08
  139.   #137 eric 11:14  |  Question Mark 13/05/08
  140.   #136 Dutch, Continued 11:26  |  Question Mark 13/05/08
  141.   test 12:12  |  test 13/05/08
  142.   #136 Dutch Continued 12:41  |  Question Mark 13/05/08
  143.   #137 eric 12:47  |  Question Mark 13/05/08
  144.   # 139 to question mark (2nd try) 05:25  |  eric 15/05/08
  145.   let`s be done with all the Talanskys 12:12  |  lks 21/05/08
 Read & React
Livni: Israel should strike Hamas again to halt arms smuggling
Responses: 44
Amir Oren: 'Decisive' Gaza offensive merely rehearsal for next crisis versus Iran
Responses: 8
Netanyahu: Likud-led government wouldn't build new settlements
Responses: 36
Akiva Eldar: Saudi plan offers Israel united front with Arab states against Iran
Responses: 10


More Headlines
13:40 Livni: Obama can use Gaza op success to alter Mideast reality
11:52 Egypt to Hamas: Take Gaza truce before Netanyahu is PM
12:30 Veteran ultra-Orthodox MK Avraham Ravitz dies aged 75
11:24 Iran MPs plan Gaza visit to praise Hamas resistance against 'Zionist offensive'
12:54 Sky News joins BBC in refusing to air Gaza fundraiser
13:16 Lecturers say IDF officer who justified Gaza strikes should not teach law
10:14 Nine held for allegedly attacking Israeli Arabs in Upper Nazareth
10:36 Netanyahu: Likud-led coalition wouldn't build new settlements
13:17 IDF rabbinate publication during Gaza war: We will show no mercy on the cruel
12:12 Survey: Most Israelis want Benjamin Netanyahu to be prime minister
10:35 Haaretz probe: Unknown overseas sources paid MK Lieberman NIS 2.5m
10:51 2 hurt, 1 seriously, after light plane crashes near Beit She`an
04:42 EU presses Egypt to take action against Gaza arms smuggling
11:27 Number of laid-off Israelis set new high in December
07:41 U.S. businessman Guma L. Aguiar gives $8m to Nefesh b'Nefesh
07:43 Program launched to bring all Jewish teachers worldwide to Israel
04:43 Court to state: Let foreign media into Gaza when borders open
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Summer in Israel
Israeli style - Tzofim Chetz V'Keshet 2009
Blue And White Forever Israel Army T-shirts
Wear with Proud Donate the Soldiers Kit
You can make a direct IMPACT!
on the life of an Israeli soldier
State of Israel Bonds
During this time of market volatility, Israel bonds can help.
SURF RAMBAM
Keep current about new-wave medical care, education and research.
Summer Camp in Israel
The best place for your children this summer
Fattal Hotel Chain
Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
Jewish Singles Personal Ads
Find the love of your life on JDate.com
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
Real Estate in Israel | Travel to Israel with Haaretz | Hotels Israel | Restaurants Israel | Tourist attractions Israel | Shops Israel
birthright Israel | Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved