Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., May 06, 2008 Iyyar 1, 5768 | | Israel Time: 19:35 (EST+7) web haaretz.com   Back to Homepage Rosner's Domain Diplomacy Defense Jewish World Opinion National Print Edition Advertising Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File

Last update - 15:07 22/04/2008 For our worst enemy, Hamas, just two words By Bradley Burston Tags: Olmert, Hamas, Carter  I'd like a word with our worst enemy, please. You already know who it is. Jimmy Carter knows, too. That's why he spent so much time letting us know whom he wanted to talk to. True, Iran talks big, goes on and on about erasure from the map. For the time being, though, what they have to show for the Big One is a lot of centrifuges the size of Coke cans and a wad of unpaid bills to the Russians for parts and service. Ahmadinejad is not our worst enemy. It's not Bashar Assad either. Yes, thanks to Iran, Russia, North Korea and native ingenuity, Syrian rockets - and, some experts believe, chemical weaponry - can reach Tel Aviv and everything else we've got. But it's not Syria. Nor is it Hezbollah, with its resolute commitment to Jew hate and its unshakable, oddly pathetic flirtation with the possibility of destroying Lebanon on its way to annihilating the Zionist entity. Even the Islamic Jihad, with its finely honed obsession with killing Jews for the offense of being Jewish, is not our worst enemy. No. I'd like a word with Hamas, please. Jimmy Carter doesn't speak for me. Nor Olmert, Barak, Netanyahu or Lieberman. I'm speaking for no one but myself, a guy who has watched you and wondered about you, often admired and often cursed you, since the day you became an organization. You are our worst enemy because, apart from us, you are the only party with the strength and the capability to forge a solution to the conflict and because - like us - you cannot bring yourselves to decide what you really want, what you're willing to do about it, nor roll over and go out of business as a result. You are our worst enemy because you face many of the same problems that we do. You want to find a solution for huge numbers of people who view pre-1967 Israel as their rightful home. We want to find a solution for huge numbers of people who view post-1967 territories as their rightful home. Neither of wants to tell these people what we know in our hearts to be true - that the fervent beliefs in a Jewish Greater Israel and an Islamic Palestine are unrealizable. It's certainly no accident that you rushed out a disclaimer after Jimmy Carter quoted, or misquoted, you having told him thjat you "would accept a Palestinian state on the 1967 borders, if approved by Palestinians," and that you "would accept the right of Israel to live as a neighbor next door in peace." It's no wonder that you then called in the news media to tell us that you're willing to live with us for 10 years, provided we withdraw to the 1967 borders and agree to the right of return for refugees. I understand that after 60 years of grief and longing - to say nothing of Arafat's lies about millions of Palestinian potential shahidim, presumably many of them refugees, marching on Jerusalem - offering refugees and their descendants something less than a return is an impossible sell. In the long run, though, it's one that you'll have to find a way to make. Just as we're likely to have to someday move tens and tens of thousands of settlers out of the homes. Why, you may ask, do we not go ahead and do it now, force these people to move, return to 1967 lines? I have two words for our worst enemy: defensible borders. That, at root, is what Israelis want. Not the east Jerusalem Palestinian villages annexed to the city, not the settlements, not the suffering of the Palestinian people. The fact is, our settlers have abandoned trying to sell Israelis the idea that the settlements are good for them. Now, all they really have to sell, is the concept that Qassams are bad for them. Since the disengagement from Gaza, this has become a given for Israelis, even most of those who long supported the cause of an independent Palestine in the territories. For Israelis, you, as our worst enemy, have reduced defensible borders to the bedrock issue. What's it going to take for both sides, both enemies, to get to the point where the 1967 lines become defensible borders? You're not going to like this. But you might turn out to be better at this than we are. In the Middle East, peace is made by individuals willing to be the true shahid, the person who is willing to become a sacrifice to the cause of creating a future for two peoples, leaders who are willing to become in a literal sense a martyr for peace. Anwar Sadat and Yitzhak Rabin were such, as were lesser know but no less heroic people like Issam Sartawi and Emil Grunzweig, people killed by extremists on their own side, for the crime of having worked for reconciliation. Yasser Arafat, who said he was our friend, repeatedly spoke of the peace of the brave, but lacked the courage to become that martyr for his people. In the end, I have much more faith in the courage of the worst of our enemies. _______________ Previous blogs: The New 12 Tribes of Israel A place at the table I want the Palestinians to win The jihad against the Jews Ten ways Israel keeps Hamas afloat Macho U.S. Jews, pantywaist Israel Bookmark to del.icio.us   Shimon goes green Peres says to fight terror Israel should reduce its dependence on oil. Voices of heroism IDF releases audio recordings from famed 1976 Entebbe raid.   1.   EVERYBODY WHO STAND FIRM IS THE ENEMY OF ISRAEL 12:39  |  indrajaya 22/04/08   2.   Bradley Burston, are you sure you understand the Middle East...?? 12:53  |  Swiss (Dino) 22/04/08   3.   Bradley, What are your feelings on a moat and tower setup? 13:15  |  Natallie Durson 22/04/08   4.   B`KAROV ETZ`L`CHA #1 13:49  |  Ari ben Yisrael 22/04/08   5.   INDRAJAYA HAMASS IS STANDING FIRM ON NO PEACE EVER 13:52  |  PETER SM 22/04/08   6.   to the Jakanta Islamic propagandist 14:07  |  Hilda 22/04/08   7.   Mr. Burston, our worst enemy cannot read English. 14:11  |  Mr. Ami Goldman 22/04/08   8.   bradley & irony! But you it wrong Brad! 14:12  |  lakshmi 22/04/08   9.   HILDA correction please to the PAID Islamic progandist 14:24  |  PETER SM 22/04/08   10.   Iran is our presently most dangerous enemy 14:35  |  Shalom Freedman 22/04/08   11.   #2 it is the swiss roll who doesnt know the mid east 15:04  |  v hardman 22/04/08   12.   I`m not sure Hamas is the worst enemy ... 15:05  |  Edith 22/04/08   13.   WORST ENEMY ? 15:10  |  MICHEL KESLACY 22/04/08   14.   # 1 Indy....You have zero to be proud of or to really say 15:12  |  Lynn 22/04/08   15.   # 2 Swiss...so, now you don`t believe security 15:16  |  Lynn 22/04/08   16.   lakshmi...just a note....... 15:19  |  Lynn 22/04/08   17.   Hamas is right to suspect Israeli insincerity. It is real. 15:20  |  Nick Ferriman 22/04/08   18.   Greater Israel or Islamic Palestine is end result 15:23  |  Sam 22/04/08   19.   As you wait Americans die 15:37  |  dan 22/04/08   20.   A great column! 15:45  |  Canderra 22/04/08   21.   Strange discussion - Hamas is being decimated... 15:45  |  17 22/04/08   22.   Natallie Durson # 3 "Defensible Borders" (part 1) 15:46  |  Jeff Northridge 22/04/08   23.   defensible borders 15:46  |  Mark Lincoln 22/04/08   24.   at Shalom Freedman 15:52  |  Marco 22/04/08   25.   Bursting in Dreamland 16:02  |  Tosefta 22/04/08   26.   Natallie Durson # 3 "Defensible Borders" (part 2) 16:13  |  Jeff Northridge 22/04/08   27.   Jeff Northridge 16:25  |  Natallie Durson 22/04/08   28.   Jeff Northridge 16:32  |  Natallie Durson 22/04/08   29.   Hey Jeff #22 your wrong 16:37  |  dan 22/04/08   30.   # 15 Lynn 16:37  |  Swiss (Dino) 22/04/08   31.   Other choices?? 16:38  |  a wandering Jew 22/04/08   32.   # 11 v hardman 16:42  |  Swiss (Dino) 22/04/08   33.   some theories 16:45  |  montgomery rosen 22/04/08   34.   # Natallie Durson - You are right it is quite possible - 16:49  |  17 22/04/08   35.   #17 nick the fairy man and more its israels fault! 16:49  |  v hardman 22/04/08   36.   I agree with Bradley-DISARM HAMAS 16:51  |  Anonymous 22/04/08   37.   The end of Israel according to Natallie Durson 16:51  |  Tulip 22/04/08   38.   Mark Lincoln # 23 What 1967 Borders? (part 1) 16:53  |  Jeff Northridge 22/04/08   39.   Thank G-d the Israel-Palestine problem became a laghing matter. 16:57  |  Akram Zekaria 22/04/08   40.   to Sam #18 - on total victory 17:01  |  zeev 22/04/08   41.   Just how indefensible are the 1967 borders? 17:02  |  Walter 22/04/08   42.   3# Natallie Durson . Hamas made Palestine melt from the map. 17:12  |  Akram Zekaria 22/04/08   43.   Mark Lincoln # 23 What 1967 Borders? (part 2) 17:25  |  Jeff Northridge 22/04/08   44.   Defensive borders and evolution 17:31  |  Tosefta 22/04/08   45.   Haaretz: Message Boards for Fools 17:37  |  Tex 22/04/08   46.   Good article Brad! 17:39  |  PantherJet 22/04/08   47.   #3 Nathalie You Wrong again...BUT 17:40  |  Alfred 22/04/08   48.   Burston & Haaretz are sold to shallow epater le bourgeois 17:48  |  Fortuna Benmayor 22/04/08   49.   Lynn, your note to Lakshmi was terribly racist. 17:48  |  Ibrahim 22/04/08   50.   zeev-You are a putz 17:49  |  Sam 22/04/08   51.   ask some military 17:57  |  cool 22/04/08   52.   #1 Indrajaya 18:08  |  Moshe 22/04/08   53.   What about Jerusalem? 18:12  |  Refugee 22/04/08   54.   dan # 29 That Is Not How Wars Are Decided 18:18  |  Jeff Northridge 22/04/08   55.   40# Zeev. If Meshal can give Israel 10 years Hudana, 18:26  |  Akram Zekaria 22/04/08   56.   Hamas, Carter and Abbas 18:35  |  Ilan 22/04/08   57.   Natalie salivaters at nuclear destruction of Pals 18:39  |  FOX 22/04/08   58.   Sorry Ibrahim, but Islamic imperialism is a historical fact, 18:42  |  Freethinker 22/04/08   59.   tosefta and evolution 18:44  |  harzion 22/04/08   60.   what would the arab world look like when it is unfettered 18:47  |  harzion 22/04/08   61.   What`s more, Ibrahim, your example of the Muslim pediatrician 18:47  |  Freethinker 22/04/08   62.   Evolution + mutation = Tosefta 18:48  |  FOX 22/04/08   63.   Tosefta 18:55  |  PlanoStu 22/04/08   64.   23# Mark Licoln you forget one thing. No Arab country on Israel 19:05  |  Akram Zekaria 22/04/08   65.   Natalie - here she goes again 19:11  |  PlanoStu 22/04/08   66.   to clear-minded Sam #50 19:11  |  zeev 22/04/08   67.   #17 Nick Ferriman 19:15  |  Moshe 22/04/08   68.   Ibrahim what do muslims as muslims offer? 19:16  |  unmuslim 22/04/08   69.   Ferryman you did get lost in your negatives 19:19  |  x-ray 22/04/08   70.   It`s Just A Hudna Won`t Work Anyway 19:29  |  Yosemite 22/04/08   71.   #49 Ibrahim 19:33  |  Moshe 22/04/08   72.   Bradley 19:47  |  Yosemite 22/04/08   73.   #17 Nick Ferriman 19:51  |  Sarah 22/04/08   74.   Thank you, well said! 19:55  |  El-Birawi 22/04/08   75.   zeev-you surround yourself with defeatists 19:58  |  Sam 22/04/08   76.   to Akram Zekaria #53 20:02  |  zeev 22/04/08   77.   Ferriman, beef ball noodle soup 20:06  |  FOX 22/04/08   78.   I would have said "PISS OFF!" 20:08  |  Avram 22/04/08   79.   Sam # 50 Nobody Is Going Anywhere 20:20  |  Jeff Northridge 22/04/08   80.   PlanoStu, #59 Tossi is a fraud sir 20:21  |  FOX 22/04/08   81.   #40 Tex..I was Once Told by A reserved Soldier During the Lebanon 20:23  |  KATHY 22/04/08   82.   Thanx indra o tell us something about your favoured consorts 20:26  |  Karl 22/04/08   83.   #73 FOX about Ferriman 20:39  |  Sarah 22/04/08   84.   to PlanoStu #64 20:42  |  zeev 22/04/08   85.   # 8 That "free philistin state" could be built in Hindia, Lopsh.. 20:45  |  misha 22/04/08   86.   #79-Jeff Northridge- an uncharacteristic mistake 20:57  |  peter 22/04/08   87.   Not drawing the right parallels 21:02  |  B 22/04/08   88.   Zeev 21:10  |  PlanoStu 22/04/08   89.   Mark Lincoln knows borders 21:11  |  peter 22/04/08   90.   hamas in pal gov, Kahana in israel`s? 21:14  |  Dany 22/04/08   91.   Plano Stu #63 21:16  |  Tosefta 22/04/08   92.   The danger of rabies (as in Rabid Fox) - Sm #62 21:17  |  Tosefta 22/04/08   93.   to hilda 21:21  |  Elias 22/04/08   94.   to Sam #75 21:27  |  zeev 22/04/08   95.   That was the last chance 21:49  |  Realist 22/04/08   96.   76# Zeev. I have no doubt in my mind that you are 21:58  |  Akram Zekaria 22/04/08   97.   Israels,s leaders need hearing aids 22:06  |  Labhras 22/04/08   98.   # 80 Fox To PlanoStu..re:Toss` You Forgot a few other monikers 22:09  |  KATHY 22/04/08   99.   to Jeff Northridge #79 22:17  |  zeev 22/04/08   100.   A follow up to Mark Lincoln 23#. If it wasn`t for 22:23  |  Akram Zekaria 22/04/08   101.   61 Freethinker to Ibrahim,the Arabs were famous for their medical 22:25  |  lakshmi 22/04/08   102.   re 27 Natty it wont happen. Get over it. 22:25  |  Alan the real one 22/04/08   103.   #27 Durson..Haven`t we reminded you should what you say happens 22:42  |  ... 22/04/08   104.   To # 86 Realist - What `new` coiuntry,,,,? 22:46  |  Dolly 22/04/08   105.   PlanoStu - In answer to your request 22:48  |  Natallie Durson 22/04/08   106.   Plano Stu #63 22:48  |  Tosefta 22/04/08   107.   # 49 Ibrahim....not bigoted, but true 22:54  |  Lynn 22/04/08   108.   # 91 The only skills arabic/muslim morons are famous with... 22:59  |  misha 22/04/08   109.   to Sam #75 23:01  |  zeev 22/04/08   110.   to Jeff Northridge #79 23:03  |  zeev 22/04/08   111.   # 28 Just as arabic tribe overal, Fatmeh, you are vicious... 23:10  |  misha 22/04/08   112.   Funny about that, when the Jews were accepted among the Moslems 23:24  |  x-ray 22/04/08   113.   #1 Who is this piece of 23:29  |  Einstein 22/04/08   114.   to PlanoStu #88 23:49  |  zeev 22/04/08   115.   #92 My Humble Apologies to Fox.I went a bit too far.Sorry 23:51  |  Tosefta 22/04/08   116.   zeev-you choose to lay all the blame on Israeli Jews 23:59  |  Sam 22/04/08   117.   # 53 Refugee...in LA? 00:04  |  Lynn 23/04/08   118.   Lynn, most racists like you are in denial 00:11  |  Ibrahim 23/04/08   119.   Peter, are you sure? 00:16  |  Ibrahim 23/04/08   120.   Three words from a Great Jewish Rabbi -- Love your enemy 00:21  |  stevarab 23/04/08   121.   #109 Ibrahim re Lynn and her bigotry 01:09  |  Labhras 23/04/08   122.   yes I`m sure Ibrahim 01:14  |  peter 23/04/08   123.   Natallie Durson is a genius ... 01:30  |  Impressed 23/04/08   124.   #92 The danger of rabies (as in Rabid Fox) - Sm #62 01:34  |  Tosefta 23/04/08   125.   peter # 86 & zeev # 99 OK 01:41  |  Jeff Northridge 23/04/08   126.   Natalie - what rock do you live under...? 02:55  |  Elihu 23/04/08   127.   # 59 harzion tosefta and evolution 02:59  |  ... 23/04/08   128.   #118 Ibrahim...not a bigot 03:28  |  Lynn 23/04/08   129.   #121 Labrhas...always carping 03:34  |  Lynn 23/04/08   130.   to Sam #116 - (2) 03:36  |  zeev 23/04/08   131.   to Sam #116 - (3) 03:37  |  zeev 23/04/08   132.   Sam # 50 re: zeev. You are the#### 03:56  |  American in NY 23/04/08   133.   to Akram Zekaria #96 04:17  |  zeev 23/04/08   134.   to Akram Zekaria #96 04:22  |  zeev 23/04/08   135.   to Sam #116 - (1) 04:32  |  zeev 23/04/08   136.   zeev-The "moderate" Erekat,Abbas,Fayyad all said NO JEWISH STATE 04:35  |  Sam 23/04/08   137.   to Jeff Northridge #125 04:52  |  zeev 23/04/08   138.   #1 Satan of Jakarta 05:59  |  The Seer 23/04/08   139.   125- Jeff not exactly 06:15  |  peter 23/04/08   140.   #122, Peter the Canadian imbecile 07:26  |  Palestinian PRince 23/04/08   141.   Re #91 - Tosefta 07:36  |  PlanoStu 23/04/08   142.   Tosefta 08:03  |  PlanoStu 23/04/08   143.   # 138, THE SEER 08:21  |  indrajaya 23/04/08   144.   Lynn As Ibrahim hinted 10:52  |  examiner 23/04/08   145.   to Sam #136 11:39  |  zeev 23/04/08   146.   Zeev didn`t notice the intifada #145 13:54  |  FOX 23/04/08   147.   # 144 examiner....I know what my country 14:18  |  Lynn 23/04/08   148.   Lynn, if that is the case, then kindly get off of your pedestal 17:52  |  Ibrahim 23/04/08   149.   Pal Prince, thanks for your assurances 19:42  |  FOX 23/04/08   150.   Aussies in Denial 19:49  |  FOX 23/04/08   151.   Bradley conveniently forgets about Sharia law 22:40  |  Diane 23/04/08   152.   MASTERPIECE from "Fortuna Benmayor" 23:46  |  Dror 23/04/08   153.   Epater le Bourgeois 23:50  |  Dror 23/04/08   154.   #50, Sam: No Point in Arguing With The Likes of Zeev 05:33  |  Tim R 24/04/08   155.   Hey Bradley Check This Out 06:21  |  Yosemite 24/04/08   156.   Tim R 11:12  |  John Syracuse 24/04/08   157.   so many enemies 16:35  |  Paco Pérez 24/04/08   158.   John Syracuse #156 17:11  |  Tim R 24/04/08   159.   Projection 17:23  |  Andrew Kent 24/04/08   160.   John Syracuse #156 00:37  |  Tim R 25/04/08   161.   Defensible borders 03:44  |  Ron 25/04/08   162.   SYMMETRY for the BLIND, DEAF and DUMB 08:32  |  Steve 25/04/08   163.   #7 you would be surprised 18:16  |  uturn 25/04/08   164.   No one will listen 03:05  |  Don 26/04/08   165.   FOX #146 - reading comprehension problem 04:47  |  zeev 26/04/08   166.   Thank you John #156 04:57  |  zeev 26/04/08   167.   What If ... (John Syracuse, Zeev, are you paying attention?) 15:51  |  Tim R 26/04/08   168.   Israel needs strong partners, yes! 17:06  |  Fritz T. 26/04/08   169.   Fritz`s International Community 19:24  |  Steve 26/04/08   170.   to Tim R #167 01:19  |  zeev 27/04/08   171.   Zeev #170 11:28  |  Tim R 27/04/08   172.   to Tim R #171 21:12  |  zeev 27/04/08   173.   to Tim R #171 - cont. 22:00  |  zeev 27/04/08   174.   Zeev #172/#173 The Great Intellectual.. 03:46  |  Tim R 28/04/08   175.   The two words for peace with Hamas should be: 1967 borders 14:41  |  Aounist 29/04/08   176.   My response? 00:08  |  Samar Qutob 04/05/08

Read & React Erekat: No progress in Monday's talks, key issues still contested Responses: 80 Moshe Arens: Is Olmert pushing for peace at any price? Responses: 53 Daphna Golan: When will we listen to the Palestinians' suffering? Responses: 109 Soldier killed in Lebanon War 'finally promoted to rank of Jew' Responses: 67 Rosner's Domain Why progressives don't like Israel (WTR) Poll: If Olmert is gone, who should be PM? The Democrats are fighting over Iran Carter is helping Hamas achieve their strategic goal How people die in Gaza? (WTR) More Headlines 18:20 State upholds gag on Olmert probe; details emerge in U.S. media 16:09 Barak: Probe will not affect Olmert's political decisions 19:27 PM ex-aide's attorney: State trying to get to Olmert via Zaken 14:24 Polish police: Kuwaiti envoy's son held 3 Jewish teens captive 17:53 8 Jerusalem youths arrested for allegedly stabbing 2 Israeli Arabs 17:37 Police quiz Druze women over possible Memorial Day protests 19:24 Court orders state to explain why citizenship law won't be reversed 12:30 Erekat: No progress in Monday's talks, key issues still contested 15:41 Palestinian forces kill bystander in clash with Jenin gunmen 16:47 Israel at 60: Population nears 7.3 million, 76% Jewish 19:32 Soldier killed in Lebanon War 'finally promoted to rank of Jew' 19:28 TA court sentences 'DNA Rapist' to 25 years in prison Previous Editions Select Day 05 may 04 may 02 may 01 may 30 apr 29 apr 28 apr 27 apr 25 apr 24 apr 23 apr 22 apr

Special Offers Advertisement Dead Sea Products Buy Dead Sea mineral skin care and beauty products. Coupon code Haaretz for 10% off. Together Celebrating Israel's 60th The Jewish Agency and world Jewry shaping the destiny of Israel and the Jewish people. Pardes Institute Summer Sessions http://www.pardes.org.il/ FAREWELL ISRAEL New Film The Coming War for Islamic Revival - View Movie Trailer The interest rates haven't changed But your profits will! Learn Hebrew online with Israel's best teachers Sign up for a trial lesson today Free the Palestinians from: Corrupt Kleptocracy, Tyrannical Theocracy, Abysmal Anarchy Fattal Hotel Chain Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel. ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th Eldan Rent a Car Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations Junkyard Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt

Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |

Real Estate in Israel

Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.

© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved