Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., April 19, 2008 Nisan 14, 5768 | | Israel Time: 02:20 (EST+7) web haaretz.com   Back to Homepage Rosner's Domain Diplomacy Defense Jewish World Opinion National Print Edition Advertising Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File

An Israeli Navy submarine docking in Haifa port. (Reuters) Last update - 14:07 17/04/2008 Israeli thriller explores how subs could be used against Iran By Reuters Tags: Submarines, Israel, Iran Anticipating a showdown with Iran, Israel decides secretly to deploy a submarine off its coast. But how? The quickest route from Israel's Mediterranean coast is via the Suez Canal, which runs through Egypt and which the classified vessels shun. So the submarine is hidden in the belly of a commercial tanker, which delivers it to the Gulf. Such is the plot of an Israeli thriller, "Undersea Diplomacy." Does it hold water? Perhaps not. Then again, the author, Shlomo Erell, is no mere novelist. He's an ex-admiral with experience in Israel's most sensitive military planning. Advertisement "It's pure fiction, but it's informed fiction," he said simply, when asked if his book reflects how the Israeli fleet of Dolphin-class submarines could be used against Iran, whose leadership has called for Israel to be "wiped off the map," stoking international concern over Tehran's nuclear programme. Israel has three Dolphins, with two more on order from Howaldtswerke-Deutsche Werft, a German shipyard custom-building them at a steep discount as part of Berlin's bid to shore up a Jewish state founded in the wake of the Nazi Holocaust. The submarines are a subject of deepest secrecy given speculation that they carry nuclear-tipped cruise missiles. Many analysts believe the Dolphins are Israel's "second strike" weapons, referring to the Cold War theory that a country can deter foes from launching nuclear attacks by maintaining the ability to retaliate, even after its own territory has been laid waste. A nuclear "platform" out at sea is the best guarantee. Iran denies seeking nuclear weapons, and independent experts say it is years away from any such capability. Some, in turn, think Israel's expanding submarine fleet may be part of preparations to foil the perceived future threat through force. "There is nothing on the horizon to suggest Iran would have the capability to knock out Israel's nuclear delivery means," said Sam Gardiner, a retired U.S. air force colonel who stages Middle East wargames for U.S. government and private clients. The Dolphins, he said, may be part of "a conventional capability to deal with the number of targets Israel believes would need to be struck in a conventional preemptive attack". Distance no object Israel sent jets to bomb Iraq's nuclear reactor in 1981 and has hinted it could do the same against Iranian facilities if U.S.-led diplomatic pressure failed to rein in Tehran's plans. But the Iraqi raid was on a single site, relatively close to Israel's borders. Targets in Iran might be too numerous and distant for Israel's air force, especially as intermediate Arab states or Turkey would likely refuse overflight rights. Israel is assumed to have ballistic missiles, yet its small size may make surprise launches impossible: an unannounced missile test in January became news within minutes as the startled residents of nearby towns reported the roaring takeoff. Submarines could bridge the gap, especially if positioned in Iranian waters. That possibility has given rise to speculation that Israel wants five Dolphins in order to allow for at least one to be at sea at all times while others are being serviced. The question remains of how far they might travel. Israeli navy sources say the Dolphins do not use the Suez -- to avoid being inspected by Egyptian harbourmasters. That means that, to reach the Gulf, Israel would either have to resort to fantastical ruses like the one in "Undersea Diplomacy," or send the submarines around Africa -- a month-long trip at least. Jason Alderwick, a maritime analyst with the International Institute for Strategic Studies in London, is skeptical. "I don't buy the idea of a rotation. These submarines have not been purchased with a view to operating in the Gulf," he said. As Dolphins run on conventional rather than nuclear power so require regular refuelling and shore maintenance, he described them as better suited to close Mediterranean missions. Israel also has access to the Red Sea through Eilat port. But navy sources said there was no plan to dock submarines there because the narrow Red Sea, which is shared with several Arab states, is vulnerable to blockades at the Straits of Tiran. Deterrents never used Restricted to the Mediterranean, analysts point out, the Israeli Dolphins could pose a "second-strike" threat to Iran only if they carried nuclear cruise missiles capable of hitting targets as far as 1,500 km (970 miles) away. Lee Willett of the Royal United Services Institute for Defence and Security Studies noted that Dolphins lacked the vertical tubes used by much bigger Western and Soviet-era submarines to launch ballistic missiles. Cold War tests showed nuclear warheads are too heavy to be delivered long distances on cruise missiles, so Israel could hit Iran only with conventional warheads if they were fired from the Mediterranean, he said. A nuclear attack on Iran by a Dolphin, Willett argued, would have to be from the Gulf, which in turn would give away an unsupported submarine's position and probably doom it to being destroyed by surviving Iranian forces. "The whole point of a deterrent is that it's never used," Willett said. "In designing the Dolphins as a second-strike platform, I imagine the Israelis were thinking 'it's not ideal, but it's the best we've got.'" Israel does not discuss its nuclear capabilities, under an "ambiguity" policy billed as warding off regional enemies while avoiding the kind of provocations that can trigger arms races. Erell appeared to support such thinking. The message of his book -- which made a modest splash in Israel, and is currently available only in Hebrew -- was "how to use a submarine without resorting to war." "It's about affecting statecraft," he said. Related articles: PM: Iran will not be nuclear UN: Iranian uranium enrichment operating well below capacity China: Int'l talks on Iran end with 'some' agreement on incentives Bookmark to del.icio.us   A gentleman's word Olmert tells Haaretz he knows Iran won't have nuclear capacity. Farewell to arms B'Tselem says IDF must ban wide-range shell that killed civilians in Gaza.   1.   Faulty postulate 13:09  |  Axel 17/04/08   2.   Iran can destroy ur subm* like it destroyed ur Saar boat in 2006 13:18  |  Aounis 17/04/08   3.   Aounis. tell all about the Saar with sources please 14:50  |  PETER SM 17/04/08   4.   #2 Aounis 15:04  |  Michael 17/04/08   5.   Persian Gulf, Persian Gulf and Persian Gulf 15:13  |  Mizarahi 17/04/08   6.   To #3 Peter SM: Here`s the source requested 15:15  |  Aounist 17/04/08   7.   how long will it be before unmanned bombers are used ? 15:17  |  v hardman 17/04/08   8.   To #2 Michael: Iran has the tech & the funding to surprise you 15:21  |  Aounist 17/04/08   9.   Civil Society in Iran - Can I have a Dream? 16:05  |  D. Lolltson 17/04/08   10.   #2 Aounis 16:27  |  Ojo Rojo 17/04/08   11.   Aounist, Mr. Sell out 16:57  |  Tony 17/04/08   12.   #2 Aounis 17:00  |  C 17/04/08   13.   To #2 Ojo : All the arab leaders agreed to the 2002 proposal 17:26  |  Aounist 17/04/08   14.   To #7 Tony: The opposition will beat ur ass in the 2009 elections 17:53  |  Aounist 17/04/08   15.   right now israhel has two german supplies deisel subs 18:09  |  pay attention 17/04/08   16.   Submarine Transport 18:14  |  Sy Dill 17/04/08   17.   #3 and #4. Can you guys Google? 19:37  |  ManintheMiddle 17/04/08   18.   #11. Do you blame them for allying themselves with... 19:44  |  ManintheMiddle 17/04/08   19.   #1 faulty postulate 19:46  |  Brian V Hunt 17/04/08   20.   #7. To answer your question. 19:49  |  ManintheMiddle 17/04/08   21.   Aounist, I stand corrected 20:04  |  ManintheMiddle 17/04/08   22.   #2 Aounis, Rachmunis on your limited thinking 20:07  |  Max Zinger,P.Chimist 17/04/08   23.   And what about the Iranians subs? 20:16  |  ManintheMiddle 17/04/08   24.   Good thinking 21:16  |  Danite 17/04/08   25.   Subs are useless in the Persian Gulf, can be seen from the air 21:25  |  anti-racist 17/04/08   26.   Iran can wipe out Israel, with its conventional missiles 21:29  |  anti-racist 17/04/08   27.   Why bother with submarines? Cruise missiles launch from anywhere 21:32  |  Dr. L. Brnd 17/04/08   28.   #10 21:46  |  New yorker 17/04/08   29.   Subs against Iran 21:47  |  noel 17/04/08   30.   To Man in the Middle 22:53  |  Michael 17/04/08   31.   Yes, of course, use a commercial ship to hide a submarine 23:06  |  Andreas 17/04/08   32.   #19. There must be a name for your condition, Doctor. 23:10  |  ManintheMIddle 17/04/08   33.   #22. Michael 23:24  |  ManintheMiddle 17/04/08   34.   Picture of Israeli sub on its way to the Persian Gulf 23:39  |  ManintheMiddle 17/04/08   35.   Aounis 23:46  |  Jon 17/04/08

Read & React Editorial: Israel can't demolish all of Gaza Responses: 127 Yishai to Carter: Tell Meshal that I want to discuss prisoner swap Responses: 40 IDF troops do nothing as Hebron settlers threaten German MPs Responses: 154 Rice: Syria 'most certainly an issue in nuclear proliferation' Responses: 63 IDF kills top militant wanted in plot to poison Ramat Gan restaurant Responses: 35 Rosner's Domain The Passover test and The Passion of Passover Just say no to Carter Poll: What is Carter doing in the Middle East? Let the debate begin: what's a "pro-Israeli" position? Clinton: Massive retaliation if Israel attacked (WTR) More Headlines 23:35 Qassam hits power lines in Sderot causing blackout 20:20 Israel: PA can reopen 20 police stations in West Bank 01:03 Carter meets Hamas leader, Syrian President in Damascus 19:38 Boim: 'Natural growth' reason for 100 new settlement homes 21:06 Iranian official: Asian traders make up for German sanctions 22:56 IDF: Reuters reporter risked his life by going to Bi'lin 23:25 Muslim preacher sentenced in Britain for supporting terrorism 19:55 Hamas: Shalit won't 'see light' until Palestinian prisoners freed 20:05 The Israeli 'settler' serving in Italy's parliament 20:04 Mayor to raise funds for E. J'lem Arabs to block Hamas 20:22 IDF kills militant leader wanted in plot to poison Ramat Gan restaurant 18:48 IDF troops do nothing as Hebron settlers threaten German MPs 08:57 Israel closes off West Bank and Gaza for duration of Passover Previous Editions Select Day 18 apr 17 apr 16 apr 15 apr 14 apr 13 apr 11 apr 10 apr 09 apr 08 apr 07 apr 06 apr

Special Offers Advertisement Learn Hebrew online with Israel's best teachers Sign up for a trial lesson today Pardes Institute Summer Sessions Study Jewish texts and issues in Jerusalem, Co-ed, All Levels Free the Palestinians from: Corrupt Kleptocracy, Tyrannical Theocracy, Abysmal Anarchy Fattal Hotel Chain Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel. ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th Eldan Rent a Car Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations Junkyard Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt

Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |

Real Estate in Israel

Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.

© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved