Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., April 26, 2008 Nisan 21, 5768 | | Israel Time: 00:30 (EST+7) web haaretz.com   Back to Homepage Rosner's Domain Diplomacy Defense Jewish World Opinion National Print Edition Advertising Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File

Last update - 16:01 16/04/2008 Breaking ranks with U.S. Jewish 'establishment' on the occupation By Paul Katz Tags: Breaking the silence, Harvard  A few weeks ago, I learned that I am anti-Israel, which certainly came as a surprise to me. The cause of the accusation was an exhibit exploring the effect of military service in the West Bank and Gaza Strip on ordinary Israelis. I have always considered myself strongly Zionist and have devoted much of my time at Harvard to advocating for policies to bring the only Jewish, democratic state in the world closer to its most inspiring ideals. Yet, in the wake of the decision by the Harvard College Progressive Jewish Alliance (PJA) to host to an exhibit by Israel's own "Shovrim Shtika" ("Breaking the Silence"), I found PJA - and by implication, myself - the target of denunciation. To quote a recent open letter by the president of the Zionist Organization of America, Morton Klein, by facilitating the exhibition, we are guilty of "inciting hatred of Israel" and "playing into the hands of Israel's enemies." Advertisement The strangest aspect of much of the criticism PJA has received has been its source - individuals outside of the campus community who have not seen the exhibit themselves. Of course, Shovrim Shtika's exhibit, which includes some 60 photos and several videos, was explained and contextualized by two former Israel Defense Forces soldiers with combat experience in the West Bank, was not uncontroversial on campus. Although it was not sponsored by Harvard Hillel, the exhibit was housed in Hillel's building, a decision which made some members of the campus Jewish community uncomfortable. Many students disagreed with what they saw as the exhibit's negative characterization of the occupation. Others expressed their concern at the exhibit's lack of context, which they felt would leave students uninformed about the conflict with an unduly negative view of Israel's commitment to human rights. Nonetheless, at Harvard these reasonable criticisms were expressed respectfully and intelligently, and PJA's desire to promote a more just Jewish state was never questioned. Only in the broader national and international press did we morph into self-hating Jews seeking to undermine Israel. The most virulent criticism of the exhibit came from Klein himself, who was quoted in Jewish Week as saying that, "Harvard Hillel should be ashamed of itself and should immediately rescind giving legitimacy to a program that only promotes hatred against Israel and Jews." His criticism was echoed in a recent column by Isi Leibler in The Jerusalem Post, in which Leibler argued that Hillel's "post-modern" commitment to pluralism and free expression led it to allow "a ferociously anti-Israeli exhibition on Hillel premises." Leibler went on to express his outrage that Klein was the only major voice within the American Jewish community to publicly condemn the exhibit. This silence, he claims, is evidence of "the extent to which post-modernism has penetrated the Jewish agenda and blurred distinctions between good and bad." This criticism stems from the belief - one which PJA strongly contests - that the only appropriate role for American Jews to play in their support of Israel is neatly bounded by one word: Hasbara, or, the promotion of Israel's image abroad. We believe that a real commitment to Israel should be characterized not only by educating others about the strength of Israel's ideals, but advocating for change when those ideals are being obscured by destructive policy decisions as well. Now is a time when an end to the occupation of Judea and Samaria is widely seen as a distant prospect. The failure of unilateral withdrawal from Gaza has bred a frustration in the American Jewish community that translates into a pessimistic refusal to look beyond the status quo: continued occupation and the strategic expansion of settlement blocks in the West Bank. Yet American Jews must understand that the status quo is not a costless alternative to the difficult and risky prospect of negotiated withdrawal. Shovrim Shtika's exhibit is about measuring its cost in real, human terms. A constructive approach to the current conflict demands an honest Jewish dialogue about the nature of occupation and its costs, instead of the image-centered marketing campaigns that have become the bread and butter of the Israel programming of many of America's major Jewish organizations, including the ZOA. This sort of dynamic conversation is just what Shovrim Shtikva has been promoting at Harvard and in the Boston community at large. More than most places, Harvard is a forum for open debate and intellectual engagement. Far from alienating Jewish students from supporting Israel - as Klein fears Shovrim Shtika has already done - the exhibit has proven to the Harvard community that it is possible to both support a just and secure Jewish state and criticize policies plainly destructive to that end. Such a position not only expresses our faith in Israel's capacity to fulfill its democratic vision, but also reflects the fact that we at Harvard understand our community. Our willingness to criticize Israeli policy in the name of the state's Jewish and democratic ideals represents a much more effective response to those at Harvard who attack Israel's legitimacy than Klein's blunt and anti-intellectual attempts to stifle dissent in the name of hasbara. In fact, the potential of Shovrim Shtika to positively influence "our enemy's" thinking was poignantly illustrated to me by a Muslim friend's reaction to the exhibit. "When I lived in the West Bank, I despised the Israeli soldiers," she explained on the Harvard International Review's online blog. But her tour of the photographs and videos, and her conversation with her guide, a former soldier, changed her perspective. "They helped me understand so much why the IDF does what they do in the territories," she wrote. The exhibit, her blog entry explains, helped her to see Israeli soldiers not as impersonal objects of hatred but as human beings pushed into a pattern of behavior by the tactical demands of a dehumanizing policy. This sort of "re-humanization," possible only when we acknowledge rather than ignore the true nature of occupation, is the first step toward understanding and coexistence. Paul Katz, an undergraduate student at Harvard, is Co-Chair of the Harvard College Progressive Jewish Alliance. Bookmark to del.icio.us   Peer pressure Facing widespread pressure, Nadine Gordimer may pull out of Israel writers meet. My struggle German Jewish leader backs the publication of an annotated version of Hitler's Mein Kampf.   1.   Is Katz a dupe for Pal media spin? 16:22  |  Joe Sittizen 16/04/08   2.   Hey Paul, don`t give yourself a pad 16:25  |  Buzaglow 16/04/08   3.   The topic is not fashionable these days. 16:41  |  Natallie Durson 16/04/08   4.   thank you Paul 17:06  |  rebecca 16/04/08   5.   Jewish vs. universal values 17:22  |  Miriam 16/04/08   6.   Breaking Ranks 17:42  |  Muriel 16/04/08   7.   Right On, Paul. Don`t stop now 17:50  |  Shelley 16/04/08   8.   To Miriam 17:59  |  Shelley 16/04/08   9.   Lost Zionist 17:59  |  Gene 16/04/08   10.   Miriam, Jewish values are universal values. 18:35  |  Steve 16/04/08   11.   yes, post-zionism caught you 18:37  |  jason 16/04/08   12.   nicely done 19:54  |  ruben 16/04/08   13.   To Mr Katz: Hasbara to save lives 20:15  |  Altalena 16/04/08   14.   Not equating occupation with strength 20:22  |  Jonathan Sivan 16/04/08   15.   Back in fashion 20:22  |  Eillatan Nosrud 16/04/08   16.   Hey, Paul, Who Are You Trying to Fool ? 20:30  |  Tod Zuckerman 16/04/08   17.   Fashionable topics 20:33  |  Eillatan Nosdur 16/04/08   18.   PAUL KATZ 20:50  |  YITZAK BEN SHLOMO 16/04/08   19.   Straw man: people who think occupation a "costless alternative" 21:39  |  McQueen 16/04/08   20.   Harvard Hillel Should Stop Sponsoring "Progressive Jews" 21:49  |  Jon 16/04/08   21.   traitor 22:41  |  gary hess 16/04/08   22.   lets ask this. 22:46  |  billy jack 16/04/08   23.   Paul, Bubbaleh.....my sheltered undergrad 22:50  |  Jewish State 16/04/08   24.   # 5 Miriam --- Jewish = universal values 23:09  |  17 16/04/08   25.   More Katz is what Israel Needs Now 23:24  |  Markus 16/04/08   26.   Hate to be cynical.. 23:35  |  hollingsworth 16/04/08   27.   "Progressive" idiots 23:36  |  Zena 16/04/08   28.   We all take risks 23:41  |  Joe 16/04/08   29.   Natallie, Billy Jack & P. Katz: Who is the agressor ? 23:55  |  Altalena 16/04/08   30.   Is this just naivity ? 00:11  |  A. 17/04/08   31.   Hey Paul - Humanize the arab return of all Jewish Holy Sites 00:37  |  paul who? 17/04/08   32.   Since When is it "Just" to Let Yourself Be Blown Up? 00:53  |  Harold 17/04/08   33.   Need for the change of the collective narrative! 01:29  |  bocknrockn 17/04/08   34.   Naive BS of the Left 03:49  |  Howard 17/04/08   35.   Yishar Koach, Mr. Katz 04:57  |  Nov 17/04/08   36.   Paul Katz`s double standard 05:18  |  Josh 17/04/08   37.   American Jew Haters 05:31  |  IM Knotfooled 17/04/08   38.   Imagine Peace 07:27  |  Yael 17/04/08   39.   Nothing new here, Jews were always their own worst enemies 09:35  |  YSL 17/04/08   40.   Breaking the Silence 13:48  |  Mike Friedman 17/04/08   41.   The bottom line 13:55  |  Stayin Alive 17/04/08   42.   respose to muriel 17:34  |  paul newman 17/04/08   43.   ZOA is a HUGE organization with massive grassroots support 17:49  |  Zena 17/04/08   44.   US Jewish `establishment` 18:11  |  Miki Hertz 17/04/08   45.   PAUL KATZ IS A FRIEND OF MINE 18:45  |  indrajaya 17/04/08   46.   Yawn.... 19:05  |  Kobi former Swede 17/04/08   47.   Katz 20:40  |  Daniel Ben-Hillel 17/04/08   48.   Katz the "Progressive" BLACKMAILER 21:24  |  Harvard Mom 17/04/08   49.   Occupation 22:30  |  Marc 17/04/08   50.   Occupation 22:30  |  Marc 17/04/08   51.   Paul and PJA are the new (and better) Jews 20:24  |  Kung Fu Jew 18 18/04/08   52.   There is no "occupation": it is Us or Them 12:03  |  ex-leftist 19/04/08   53.   The Defamers of Israel like Katz have never been silent 05:40  |  Anne 22/04/08   54.   The Defamers of Israel like Katz have never been silent 05:49  |  Anne 22/04/08   55.   misguided 23:54  |  RE 25/04/08

Read & React Israeli envoy to UN calls Carter 'a bigot' for meeting Meshal Responses: 176 Israel: Syria may rethink retaliation in light of nuclear revelations Responses: 118 Israel snubs Hamas truce bid as ruse to recover from fighting Responses: 123 Two Israeli guards killed in West Bank shooting; third flees Responses: 72 Yossi Sarid: If it runs like apartheid and acts like apartheid... Responses: 113 Rosner's Domain Syria insists on a return to the pre-1967 lines (WTR) Poll: Will the new spy case harm U.S.-Israel ties? Notes on the new Israeli-espionage affair The real numbers of the Jewish vote in Pennsylvania More Headlines 23:47 Abbas: I failed in U.S., no progress in peace talks 23:11 IAEA slams U.S. for withholding data on alleged Syrian nuclear reactor 00:13 Three people killed, one person hurt in Ramle shooting spree 14:35 Two Israeli guards killed in West Bank shooting; third flees 22:11 7,000 Hamas supporters rally at Gaza north, south borders 19:44 German Jewish leader backs publication of Hitler's 'Mein Kampf' 18:04 Facing widespread pressure, Nadine Gordimer may pull out of Israel writers meet 18:02 Hackers commandeer Israel Bank site, post anti-Israel jibes 13:55 Syria accuses U.S. of aiding Israel in strike on nuke facility 13:23 Israel: Syria may rethink retaliation in light of nuclear revelations 15:48 IMF praises PA for 'bold reforms,' strides toward fiscal sustainability 22:23 Berlin's Holocaust memorial to host classical open-air concert Previous Editions Select Day 25 apr 24 apr 23 apr 22 apr 21 apr 20 apr 18 apr 17 apr 16 apr 15 apr 14 apr 13 apr