Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., April 27, 2008 Nisan 22, 5768 | | Israel Time: 21:38 (EST+7) web haaretz.com   Back to Homepage Rosner's Domain Diplomacy Defense Jewish World Opinion National Print Edition Advertising Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File

Last update - 00:06 17/04/2008 New Jewish-American lobby wants to be alternative to AIPAC By Shmuel Rosner Tags: AIPAC, U.S. Jewry  Test of the 'J Street Project' will be how it affects U.S. policy and how much public support it can engender. WASHINGTON - On Monday night, Samuel Lewis spoke from a small stage in one of the banquet halls of Washington's Mayflower Hotel to an audience of Anti-Defamation League activists seated around the dinner tables at their annual conference. Lewis, a former U.S. ambassador to Israel, was sharing fond memories from the days of the peace treaty with Egypt. Thirty years have passed, but Lewis still gets emotional when recalling that period, and so do his listeners. The next day Lewis skipped skillfully from the memories of the past to policies of the future when discussing why his part in the new Jewish-American dovish lobby, whose purpose is to promote meaningful American leadership, and push Israel (and its neighbors) toward peace. In an afternoon conference call, Lewis is also on the line, explaining that not every attempt at persuasion is "pressure" on Israel. "Pressure," he says, "is a scare word." With him on the line are some of the founders, contributors and directors of the "J Street Project," named after the driving force behind the initiative, Jeremy Ben-Ami, former advisor to president Bill Clinton. Advertisement (Clarification: The 'J' for 'Jeremy' thing was meant to be a joke. Apparently, a bad joke. I still find it funny, but people did not understand it. So to make it clear: 'J' is because there is no J Street in Washington, and by creating one this lobby is filling a gap - like the gap it intends to fill in the political world) After a long gestation period, two results emerged. One - the lobby, which can by law promote a cause, but cannot donate money; and the other - a political action committee (PAC), which will be the donor arm to those politicians who show sufficient allegiance to the organization's somewhat ambiguous goals. On many issues, the similarity between the goals of the group and U.S. official policy may be confusing. In favor of a diplomatic solution to the conflict with Iran; against Israeli settlements in the territories; Jerusalem as Israel's recognized capital after a solution has been reached between the parties; two states, Israel and Palestine, living in peace and security. This is a clean, laundered formulation, behind which is a clearly dovish agenda. The two organizations and a host of public figures joining the project illustrate its intent more than its declared goals: Friends of Peace Now and Brit Tzedek Veshalom - Jewish Alliance for Justice and Peace. The long list of supporters includes former Senator Lincoln Chafee, not usually on the traditional list of Israel's supporters; Clinton peace-team member Robert Malley; Alan Solomont, a prominent Jewish supporter of Senator Barack Obama; and Victor Kovner, a donor to the Hillary Clinton campaign. Israeli supporters on a seperate list include former minister Shlomo Ben-Ami, former Foreign Ministry directors general David Kimche, Uri Savir and Alon Liel, former Knesset speaker Avraham Burg, retired Israel Defense Forces generals Amnon Lipkin-Shahak and Amram Mitzna (a former Labor Party chairman and candidate for prime minister in the 2003 election), and Haaretz journalist Daniel Ben-Simon. The J Street Project supports a U.S. withdrawal from Iraq, dialogue with Syria and opposes any use of force against Iran. Its future test: the extent to which it will be able to impact U.S. policy, and how much broad public support it will engender. Its leaders assume that the liberal bent of most American Jews will be to identify with the organization; the heads of more established Jewish groups say that in most cases, people who care are not close to the left-leaning goals of the J Street Project. During its formative stage, the heads of the J Street Project were reluctant to show publicly their opposition to the strongest and most established Jewish lobby, the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC). But in yesterday's conversation, this was made officially clear. "I'm not with AIPAC; I do not support AIPAC," Kovner said. The new organization will try to erode AIPAC's strength and restrain what they see as its identification with the American and the Israeli right. It will not be easy with a budget of $1.5 million now being discussed, not when AIPAC has $100 million in its coffers. J Street Project's people assume that the silent majority of American Jews are on their side. But AIPAC has more than 100,000 registered supporters in almost 20 branches across the U.S. The heads of the J Street Project hope to ride the new wave of political fund-raising - of which the Obama campaign serves as a model - getting a large number of small donors to strengthen the organization far beyond what appears likely at the outset. The debate over the need for and the significance of the J Street Project is over what makes up a "pro-Israeli" position. It is not a new debate, but in recent months the election campaign has brought it once more to the fore. Solomont says that in recent years, a pro-Israeli position has been defined by "neocons, right-of-center Jewish leaders and Christian evangelicals," and the J Street Project's other leaders agree with him. Which candidates qualify for their support? The Project is vague on this point, but the people heading it will not support those who "impose impossible conditions on assisting Palestinians." So let the new debate begin: what defines an "impossible" condition. A lot more on the 'J Street Project' on Rosner's Domain's What To Read Bookmark to del.icio.us   Fake reactor Syrian envoy: Photos of alleged nuke site fabricated by CIA. Modern Moses Commander of legendary Jewish immigrant ship Exodus dies at 90.   1.   The most important step in the history of the Jewish people ??? 13:46  |  Swiss (Dino) 16/04/08   2.   jerusalem as capital of israel,forget it! 13:50  |  lakshmi 16/04/08   3.   Swiss Dino you should study more history 14:08  |  Joe Frazier 16/04/08   4.   Lakshmi keep dreaming 14:10  |  Joe Frazier 16/04/08   5.   Congratulations on this blessed initiative 14:15  |  Eyal Raviv 16/04/08   6.   Anything short of whatever Hamas says will be hated 15:01  |  steve from raleigh 16/04/08   7.   Great. Another lobby of self serving bigots 15:01  |  POP 16/04/08   8.   I`ve signed up... but 15:20  |  drsteveb 16/04/08   9.   Excellent analysis, Swiss Dino 15:21  |  Yaakov Sullivan 16/04/08   10.   its a joke 15:23  |  joe Smith 16/04/08   11.   Avraham Burg abandoned Israel 15:40  |  Johnny Weintraub 16/04/08   12.   joe Smith of boston on AIPAC success 15:45  |  Yaakov Sullivan 16/04/08   13.   Why don`t they just lobby for Iran, Syria and Hamas? 15:52  |  GB 16/04/08   14.   # 3 Joe Frazier 16:02  |  Swiss (Dino) 16/04/08   15.   # 9 Yaakov Sullivan 16:04  |  Swiss (Dino) 16/04/08   16.   Media coverage is key 16:35  |  W 16/04/08   17.   j-sreet lobby 16:55  |  elliot 16/04/08   18.   Jew vs Jew in American lobbys? I don`t think so 17:20  |  Natallie Durson 16/04/08   19.   The talk of Bibi Natanjahu ... 17:21  |  Edith 16/04/08   20.   Good! We need an alternative! 17:33  |  J Man 16/04/08   21.   AIPAC tot. control of American foreign policy is "pro Israel." 19:01  |  David 16/04/08   22.   Another "Peace Now" type lobby 19:06  |  Ray 16/04/08   23.   The real problem with AIPAC 19:24  |  MichaelF 16/04/08   24.   Just what I`ve been waiting for 19:29  |  Stanley 16/04/08   25.   Another lobby? 19:35  |  Atoo 16/04/08   26.   Sorry to rain on your parade Dino 19:39  |  Jacob Blues 16/04/08   27.   Peace Yaacov, no, you want something else entirely 19:41  |  Jacob Blues 16/04/08   28.   More jobs........ 19:58  |  NS 16/04/08   29.   lakshmi 20:07  |  Elias 16/04/08   30.   Same Old Silly/Cowardly Jews 20:10  |  Tod Zuckerman 16/04/08   31.   frazier 20:11  |  Elias 16/04/08   32.   Any Opposition To The Malign AIPAC Is Welcome 20:26  |  chet 16/04/08   33.   4.Joe frazier a wise man said:he forgets his history is doomed to 20:30  |  lakshmi 16/04/08   34.   influencing Israel 20:45  |  steve dill 16/04/08   35.   THE "KAPO" LOBBY AIMS TO SERVE AIMS OF ISRAEL`S GENOCIDAL ENEMIES 21:54  |  Jack Goldberg 16/04/08   36.   This new lobby pushing pro-Arab agenda of State Dept Arabists 22:37  |  G. Marcus 16/04/08   37.   # 26 Jacob Blues 23:43  |  Swiss (Dino) 16/04/08   38.   What`s A Pro-Israeli Position? 00:20  |  Yosemite 17/04/08   39.   #37 was Hitler PRO Poland, France, and England? 00:58  |  stick to clocks plz 17/04/08   40.   #35 You need psychiatric help 01:13  |  no-to-AIPAC 17/04/08   41.   Durson on Jew vs Jew, how about Pal vs Pal? 01:39  |  Joe Sittizen 17/04/08   42.   maniacal rant on arabists 02:14  |  mohamed 17/04/08   43.   Pro-Israel=anti-settler. It`s that simple. 02:55  |  Jens 17/04/08   44.   Hegelian ploy? 03:20  |  hollingsworth 17/04/08   45.   MULTIPLE opinions and open discourse makes us strong & adaptable 05:21  |  PETER SM 17/04/08   46.   "J" Street? 06:02  |  Mark Lincoln 17/04/08   47.   Fraudulent Group Speaks Only For Small Minority of Jews 13:48  |  Ben Israel 17/04/08   48.   What????? 14:06  |  Nechama 17/04/08   49.   Peace For Israelis 16:47  |  Rossim 18/04/08   50.   Jews flames, look, flames................. 18:07  |  Dave from Chicago 18/04/08   51.   I suggest you all re-read Night..... 18:49  |  Dave from Chicago 18/04/08   52.   Say Whatever You Want But Just Don`t... 19:45  |  Yosemite 18/04/08   53.   No Shortage of Busybodies 19:46  |  Always Amazed 18/04/08   54.   PAC = Palestinian Action Committee 03:33  |  Sima 19/04/08   55.   Jews be warned: This group is an Arab lobby composed of leftist 02:55  |  Chaim 20/04/08   56.   #50 Ask yourself Why? 16:49  |  Keith T. 20/04/08   57.   Ben Israel.77, with Obama your right wing time is up 02:47  |  Jakecat3 21/04/08   58.   #56 Keith. You are blaming the victims. 04:27  |  Chaim 21/04/08   59.   #51 Dave, Problem: You are in favour of steps that would destroy 04:32  |  Chaim 21/04/08   60.   Any opposition to the malign AIPAC is welcome 07:06  |  mech 21/04/08   61.   Chaim, No one is going to support Apartheid 09:30  |  Dutch 23/04/08   62.   Now Jewish groups can contain both sides of the argument 21:30  |  macgregorUSA 27/04/08

Read & React U.S. irate after Israeli envoy to UN brands Carter 'a bigot' Responses: 238 Israel: Gaza truce hinges on Hamas control over Jihad Responses: 58 Avraham Burg: Jonathan Pollard is America's Vanunu Responses: 55 Report: Hezbollah man says new attack on Israel is question of 'when, not if' Responses: 142 Syria said demanding Israeli guarantee on Golan pullout Responses: 46 Barak defers U.S. trip in wake of CIA briefing over Syrian strike Responses: 25 Rosner's Domain Syria insists on a return to the pre-1967 lines (WTR) Poll: Will the new spy case harm U.S.-Israel ties? Notes on the new Israeli-espionage affair The real numbers of the Jewish vote in Pennsylvania More Headlines 20:12 Shas MK Benizri gets 18 months' jail for corruption 19:20 Netanyahu: PM promised Golan to Syria before talks ever began 15:04 Rightist editor: Olmert and Livni should be executed for treason 17:05 Assad: Facility Israel bombed in September was not nuclear 21:32 Exhibit shows how Holocaust survivors helped shape Israel's identity 21:01 On Israel's only Jewish-run pig farm, it's the swine that bring home the bacon 19:38 Experts recommend nullifying law granting mothers automatic custody 21:38 Men who hacked into Israel Bank site were motivated by Islamism 15:35 Are lice art? Israelis scratch their heads 17:41 Syria said demanding Israeli guarantee on Golan pullout 10:37 Report: Hezbollah man says new attack on Israel is question of 'when, not if' 14:41 French Socialist official says detained by Hezbollah for over 4 hours Previous Editions Select Day 25 apr 24 apr 23 apr 22 apr 21 apr 20 apr 18 apr 17 apr 16 apr 15 apr 14 apr 13 apr

Special Offers Advertisement Learn Hebrew online with Israel's best teachers Sign up for a trial lesson today Pardes Institute Summer Sessions Study Jewish texts and issues in Jerusalem, Co-ed, All Levels Free the Palestinians from: Corrupt Kleptocracy, Tyrannical Theocracy, Abysmal Anarchy Fattal Hotel Chain Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel. ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th Eldan Rent a Car Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations Junkyard Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt

Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |

Real Estate in Israel

Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.

© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved