Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., May 07, 2008 Iyyar 2, 5768 | | Israel Time: 06:27 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Advertising
Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
President Shimon Peres carrying a torch during a memorial service at the Nazi Death Camp of Treblinka, eastern Poland, on Monday. (Reuters)
Last update - 00:38 16/04/2008
Peres, at Warsaw uprising memorial: Israel will avenge Holocaust through peace
By Lily Galili, Haaretz Correspondent, and News Agencies
Tags: Israel, Shimon Peres, Poland 

President Shimon Peres delivered an address at a ceremony marking 65 years since the Warsaw ghetto uprising, stating that peace is the way in which Israel must avenge the horrors of the Holocaust.

"During times of intifadas and [Iranian] uranium enrichment, it is through peace that the forces of light can avenge the actions of the forces of darkness."

On Monday, Peres did not grant the Poles penance or absolution on Monday. Nevertheless, when he said at the foot of the memorial at the Treblinka death camp: "It is difficult to stand here, not because of you, but because of what was here," Peres was saying out loud, alongside Polish President Lech Kaczynski, what the Polish people had been hoping to hear.
Advertisement
For years the Poles have been waiting for recognition that even if the horrors of the Holocaust may have taken place on their soil, they did not carry them out.

As Peres looked at the Israeli soldiers and youth groups accompanying him, he added: "If we had had these soldiers and young people then, this would not have happened to us, and it will not happen to us in the future. We will not let the beast go crazy again," the president said.

Israeli and Polish flags fluttered in the afternoon breeze as Poland's chief orthodox rabbi, Michael Schudrich, chanted the Kaddish, the Jewish prayer for the dead. Then, to the beat of a military drum, Peres, Kaczynski and survivors of the ghetto uprising placed wreaths at the foot of the monument, which was flanked by two large iron menorahs.

Peres praised the young fighters, who he said displayed a heroism that "our children will proudly carry with them in their hearts. The majority of the uprising fighters died, murdered in cold blood. They lost the fight, but from the point of view of history, there has never been such a victory," Peres said. "A victory of men over human bestiality, of pure souls over fallen ones.

"Yes, the Germans won, thanks to thousands of soldiers shooting without thought and gassing bunkers," Peres said. What did those terrible Nazis leave to the generations that followed? Only shame, a curse and damnation."

Two layers to Peres visit

Monday's event at Treblinka was the first of Peres' four-day official visit to Poland. Given the complex relations with Poland, the visit also has two layers: the Jewish part, which includes marking the 65th anniversary of the Warsaw Ghetto revolt; and the diplomatic side, in which Peres will meet with the Polish prime minister and give a speech in Hebrew in parliament.

However, in Poland, the two halves of the visit are not truly separate, and are interlinked, as at Treblinka on Monday.

When Kaczynski spoke of the good relations between the countries, which he only wants to improve, he mentioned in the same breath the Polish righteous gentiles who risked their lives to save Jews during the Second World War; and thanked Peres for his support of the nomination of one of them, Irena Sendler, for the Nobel Peace Prize.

All the ceremonies commemorating the Holocaust are similar to one another - and each is awe-inspiring in its own way. 880,000 Jews were murdered at Treblinka, most from Poland. The way to Treblinka passes through dozens of quiet towns and roads, with statues of Jesus and Mary standing at intersections. However, all this piety is forgotten in the face of the 17,000 crooked granite stones spread out over the grounds of the death camp, giving it the look of a surrealistic graveyard partially hidden in the forest.

Three quarters of the Polish Jews murdered here were from Warsaw, coming from the ghetto whose mythological bravery will be commemorated in a ceremony today.

Kaczynski, previously the mayor of Warsaw, did not forget to mention where the residents of his city who were killed here came from.

But an Israeli cloud of disagreement was hovering over the events. Joining the visit was former defense and foreign minister Moshe Arens, who has been dedicating a large part of his retirement to proving the part played by the Beitar revisionist movement in the Warsaw Ghetto uprising. Arens claims the official histories have written them out of the story. When asked about this, Peres chose to answer diplomatically, saying he honors all the fighters and victims.

Sixty-five years later, it seems Israel is reaching a certain level of balanced understanding with the Poles, but is still waging an internal battle on the history being written about the various groups. "Is there a single Jewish heart that does not tremble from the intensity of the pain and the greatness of the achievement?" wondered Peres at a meeting with 300 members of the Warsaw Jewish community at the end of a long day.

The heart trembles, but it still is searching for its place in the ethos of heroism.

More Jewish World news and features

Related articles:
  • Brothers in arms
  • Letters to a dead Jewish child
  • Neo-Nazi turns ultra-Orthodox after discovering Jewish roots
  • Landmark Jewish-Polish museum to open in central Warsaw
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Raining on the parade
    World Likud chief calls for cancellation of Nakba Day procession.
    Perfect match
    TA court sentences 'DNA Rapist' to 25 years in prison.
      1.   The Poles Were Neither Friends Nor Enemies 03:23  |  dyinglikeflies 15/04/08
      2.   Thank you Mr. Peres 04:23  |  Justine 15/04/08
      3.   Bravo, Peres! 06:22  |  Greg 15/04/08
      4.   Simon Persky back home, stay home 06:52  |  kasper 15/04/08
      5.   Congratulate the Poles for what? 06:59  |  Edelbert 15/04/08
      6.   Re #1: Haaretz Censors - Asleep at the switch! 07:11  |  Michel 15/04/08
      7.   Re #1: Haaretz Censors - Asleep at the switch! 07:11  |  Michel 15/04/08
      8.   Re #1: Haaretz Censors - Asleep at the switch! 07:11  |  Michel 15/04/08
      9.   In there souls 08:24  |  Dennis Slapo 15/04/08
      10.   WHAT A BORING ARTICLE ! I UNDERSTAND NOTHING 09:52  |  ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU 15/04/08
      11.   The typical Haaratez`s propaganda . 09:57  |  as 15/04/08
      12.   to #5 Edelbert 10:13  |  Pawel 15/04/08
      13.   to as 10:26  |  Harry 15/04/08
      14.   kasper 10:29  |  harry 15/04/08
      15.   #11 ROCK IN ROLL :) 10:47  |  Borat 15/04/08
      16.   POLISH ANTISEMITISM. 11:19  |  Robert 15/04/08
      17.   JEWISH ANTIPOLONISM 11:43  |  Ewa 15/04/08
      18.   To Harry 12:16  |  as 15/04/08
      19.   to Ewa 12:24  |  Harry 15/04/08
      20.   Poles & Jews 12:38  |  Chaim Abramowicz 15/04/08
      21.   To Harry 12:39  |  as 15/04/08
      22.   Polish citizens not Jews 12:46  |  Joel 15/04/08
      23.   Harry and all (1) 13:02  |  Ewa 15/04/08
      24.   Harry @all (2) 13:13  |  Ewa 15/04/08
      25.   Harry @all (3) 13:15  |  Ewa 15/04/08
      26.   turn on Polish TV now! 13:17  |  Ewa 15/04/08
      27.   Harry and all (1) 13:30  |  Ewa 15/04/08
      28.   Do not revenge from the Palestinians 13:46  |  Taha Mokhtar 15/04/08
      29.   To, 21 Chaim 14:00  |  Jozef 15/04/08
      30.   to as 14:02  |  Harry 15/04/08
      31.   to Ewa 14:04  |  Harry 15/04/08
      32.   Harry 14:23  |  Ewa 15/04/08
      33.   #5 Kasper or Kasperczak, Peres is from Russia! 14:31  |  Max Zinger,P.Chimist 15/04/08
      34.   Sinners and Saints 14:40  |  Sherlock Holmes 15/04/08
      35.   Righteous among the Nations 14:44  |  Philip 15/04/08
      36.   Polish antisemitism? 14:49  |  Marcin 15/04/08
      37.   #18 Ewa, Ypours is the typical Polish excuse and allegation that 14:49  |  Max Zinger,P.Chimist 15/04/08
      38.   and Harry 15:06  |  Ewa 15/04/08
      39.   It is well known... 15:07  |  Adelbert 15/04/08
      40.   # 33 Ewa, You are in denial.Wa aren`t antiPolish.Its your hate... 15:15  |  Max Zinger,P.Chimist 15/04/08
      41.   to Max Zinger 15:23  |  Ewa 15/04/08
      42.   #39 Max Zinger 15:33  |  Ewa 15/04/08
      43.   President Shimon Peres said in Poland... 15:45  |  Mira 15/04/08
      44.   more tripe and pretence that facts dont exist 15:48  |  victor hardman 15/04/08
      45.   Ewa. 2 years ago M.Edelstein,leader of Ghetto Uprising sent a le 15:56  |  Absolute Sweden 15/04/08
      46.   Maz Zinger, the admirer of Jakub Berman @34 16:02  |  Chris 15/04/08
      47.   hollingsworth on Treblinka. Instead of `see no evil` 16:07  |  examiner 15/04/08
      48.   It`s so easy to throw a stone... 16:29  |  Jacek 15/04/08
      49.   to hollingsworth 16:33  |  TAZ 15/04/08
      50.   to absolute sweden - Jewish Nazis 16:34  |  Ewa 15/04/08
      51.   Chris,admirer of Felix Derzynsky,keep Peres with you 16:36  |  Absolute Sweden 15/04/08
      52.   to Michel 16:41  |  hollingsworth 15/04/08
      53.   Harry will be forced to conclude.... 16:44  |  hollingsworth 15/04/08
      54.   TAZ supplies my laugh for the day 16:47  |  hollingsworth 15/04/08
      55.   to Ewa 16:49  |  Harry 15/04/08
      56.   to Ewa 17:01  |  Harry 15/04/08
      57.   I agree with Peres, pace is the answer 17:03  |  Yosi the Israeli 15/04/08
      58.   to Joe - go to England, you can be beaten 17:09  |  Joe 15/04/08
      59.   Ewa,Chris&Co:Polish doctors and ambulance crews were murdering 17:10  |  Absolute Sweden 15/04/08
      60.   "Resist the Devil and he will flee from you." Through the Power 17:32  |  of God`s Love... 15/04/08
      61.   Polsce bardzo brakuje braci Żydów 17:50  |  Andrzej 15/04/08
      62.   festiwal kultury zydowskiej 17:55  |  tymoteos 15/04/08
      63.   Yes, Jews are really mistaken about Poles - and even Germans... 17:58  |  bat yam 15/04/08
      64.   My fathers family 18:07  |  Nicole 15/04/08
      65.   to Harry 18:21  |  Ewa 15/04/08
      66.   to 63 18:25  |  Harry 15/04/08
      67.   silence 18:28  |  js 15/04/08
      68.   yes!!! look at all the peace peres brought you!!! 18:32  |  over the top 15/04/08
      69.   Here is a better idea 18:37  |  Ephraim 15/04/08