Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., April 09, 2008 Nisan 4, 5768 | | Israel Time: 02:01 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Advertising
Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
A satellite photo of the facility that was destroyed in Syria. (Reuters)
Last update - 16:58 06/04/2008
Israel, U.S. plan to release details on Syria attack
By Barak Ravid and Amos Harel
Tags: U.S., North Korea, Israel 

Israel and the United States are coordinating the release of details on the air force strike in Syria last September, which foreign reports claim targeted a nuclear installation Syria was constructing with North Korean assistance. American officials may reveal details of the strike later this month during congressional hearings.

Even though the defense establishment in Israel is opposed to any publication of details of the attack, the Prime Minister's Bureau and U.S. President George W. Bush's administration are of the opinion that it is now possible to reveal details because there is little chance of a conflagration as a result of a Syrian decision to avenge the attack.

Details of the attack are likely to be revealed by senior Bush administration officials during hearings before Congress. Advisers to Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, Yoram Turbowicz and Shalom Turjeman, discussed the issue last week in Washington with senior U.S. intelligence officials, and National Security Adviser Stephen Hadley.
Advertisement
During the meetings, the two sides agreed on which details of the attack to make public and which details could have negative implications. According to foreign reports, Israel transfered to the U.S. detailed intelligence on the installation attacked, and the two sides agreed not to reveal any details without prior coordination.

The view in Washington and in Jerusalem is that publishing details of the attack will bolster Israel's deterrence and may even lead Syria to cool its close ties with Iran and North Korea.

According to the American assessments, the revelations about the attack will also bolster its hand in negotiations with North Korea on dismantling its nuclear arms.

However, the Israel defense establishment is strongly opposed to revealing any details of the attack in Syria and expressed concern that any airing of the details of the attack will result in lifting the strict censorship that was imposed in Israel on this incident.

Senior figures in the defense establishment and the Israel Defense Forces said in recent day that Israel must convince the Americans to deliver the report to Congress "in closed session."

Intelligence analysts in Israel maintain that any further release of the details on the strike will contribute to the already tense situation between Syria and Israel, which has been exacerbated in part because of Hezbollah's plans to avenge the assassination of the group's terrorist mastermind, Imad Mughniyah.

Any official release of the details of the attack and the nature of the installation may push Syria's Bashar Assad into a corner and put pressure him to respond, say intelligence officials.

The possibility of details being made public has also contributed to the mutual suspicions between the PMO and the Defense Minister's Bureau. In political circles it is now commonly accepted that the release of details of the attack may help bolster the public image of Prime Minister Ehud Olmert. Some politicians have offered assessments that Olmert may decide to lift the curtain on details of the attack close to the 60th anniversary of Israel's independence, in early May.

Other political sources say that the American revelations on this matter will not result in a change in Israel's censorship policy, and insist that Olmert will not discuss the subject of the attack during holiday interviews.

The hearings at the House Intelligence Committee may be held in the coming weeks. Congressmen have included in the bill on the intelligence budget that American intelligence agencies will not be given large portions of their budget unless they reveal in full the details of the strike in Syria and the nuclear cooperation between Pyongyang and Damascus.

This has led U.S. and Israeli officials to conclude that American officials will release details of the strike during the hearings.

Talks between the U.S. and North Korea are schedule to resume tomorrow in Singapore. One of the American conditions for lifting the sanctions on Pyongyang is for it to expose its nuclear collaboration with other countries, which North Korea maintains does not exist. According to South Korean media sources, Pyongyang has agreed to provide the U.S. with information on its nuclear cooperation with Syria, on condition that Washington will not make this public. The same sources stated that the U.S. has given North Korea a list of engineers that are suspected of involvement in the construction of the installation that was targeted in Syria.

Meanwhile, readiness levels are high at Northern Command and in security for Israeli missions abroad, as well as at airlines, as concerns remain that Hezbollah will try to avenge the assassination of its terrorist mastermind, Imad Mughniyah in February.

The statement by Defense Minister Ehud Barak last week, that Israel would retaliate with a heavy hand against any attack, was made following deliberations with intelligence officials. There are concerns that an order to carry out a terrorist attack has already been issued - and Barak's tough words were meant to signal Hezbollah and its patrons, Syria and Iran, that Israel will respond to any attack.

Related articles:
  • ANALYSIS: The air strike in Syria is a secret that cannot be kept
  • IDF lifts censorship of Sept. 6 IAF strike on target inside Syria
  • J'lem outraged by Netanyahu's admission of IAF strike on Syria
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Falk's folly
    Israel will refuse entry to the UN's Richard Falk for equating Israel to Nazi Germany.
    Peace when?
    After 30 years, the public has adopted Peace Now's views, but peace is still elusive.
      1.   Why haven`t the Syrians released anything? 03:16  |  natan 06/04/08
      2.   A double-shovel needed 03:20  |  Mark Lincoln 06/04/08
      3.   Let no one mistake any mistake 03:41  |  Panther Jet 06/04/08
      4.   syria, iran, hezbollah must be told in no uncertain terms any 04:12  |  ralph 06/04/08
      5.   Congress is an information sieve 04:49  |  spyguy 06/04/08
      6.   This is What Happened 05:00  |  MIKE 06/04/08
      7.   Congressional Right to Know 05:01  |  Mark of Lewiston 06/04/08
      8.   panther jet 4 05:20  |  potobac 06/04/08
      9.   Pather Jet - on War 05:51  |  Mark of Lewiston 06/04/08
      10.   F9F-4 06:18  |  Mark Lincoln 06/04/08
      11.   Building being rebuilt... for months? 06:29  |  Jacob Blues 06/04/08
      12.   "Foreign reports"? like whose? 06:44  |  Rowan 06/04/08
      13.   z 06:49  |  z 06/04/08
      14.   More sick war mongering by the Bush camp 06:56  |  Dutch 06/04/08
      15.   "Let no one mistake" 07:07  |  Warren J. 06/04/08
      16.   Entangling U.S. with Israel 07:40  |  Atoo 06/04/08
      17.   and iran and the rest should 07:53  |  sam i am 06/04/08
      18.   ISRAEL WILL RUIN THE U.S. 08:09  |  john adams 06/04/08
      19.   Israel did what was needed to be done 08:15  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 06/04/08
      20.   Olmert: the best gift you can give us is silence 08:17  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 06/04/08
      21.   #2, Mark Lincoln 08:30  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 06/04/08
      22.   Cipora ML is screaming to hide the sound of the truth 08:41  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 06/04/08
      23.   # 3 i DO believe you`re "mistaken", pantherjet 08:47  |  eric 06/04/08
      24.   #5 Mighty impressive looking rose-coloured glasses, CJK 09:50  |  Johnboy 06/04/08
      25.   Important despatches from Israel`s Ministry of Truth 10:27  |  Clickfool 06/04/08
      26.   A big, square, empty warehouse was flattened # 2 10:31  |  Clickfool 06/04/08
      27.   #18, fool, quoting Mark 10:50  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 06/04/08
      28.   In the meantime - CSM RELEASED GREAT ART 10:57  |  GREAT LINK 06/04/08
      29.   to Cipora 10:58  |  ALL 4 PEACE 06/04/08
      30.   John Adams #15 - Israel only helps the U.$. to Controlled Suicide 11:04  |  Mahatma Ghandi 06/04/08
      31.   RETALIATION IS IMMINENT 11:04  |  indrajaya 06/04/08
      32.   #7, MarkL claims that neither Iran nor Syria 11:05  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 06/04/08
      33.   Syria was presumably the home of the WMD 11:57  |  Iz Ray Leigh 06/04/08
      34.   Plant Enriched Depleted Bovine Waste for Bovinic Bomb Project 12:12  |  Mike Adams 06/04/08
      35.   Plant Enriched Depleted Bovine Waste for Bovinic Bomb Project 12:12  |  Mike Adams 06/04/08
      36.   Timing the Revenge 12:14  |  Gadees 06/04/08
      37.   Revealing our secrets to serve US interests 12:28  |  Tzfonit 06/04/08
      38.   Syrian..Attempt at a small nuclear detonation...? 12:31  |  Stephen. 06/04/08
      39.   FIRST, U.S. "INTELLIGENCE" REPORT 12:32  |  Robert 06/04/08
      40.   #9 "But they cannot build anything from the ruins" 13:09  |  Johnny 06/04/08
      41.   Hey, Mark Lincoln, Cipora`s a closet fan of yours.# 27 13:21  |  Clickfool 06/04/08
      42.   Playing With Bee Hives 13:25  |  gadees 06/04/08
      43.   So, What Was It? 13:43  |  Jeff Northridge 06/04/08
      44.   Answering Jeff Northridge # 43 14:14  |  Clickfool 06/04/08
      45.   ATOO " Israel wanted to start a war" bombing an empty warehouse?? 14:20  |  PETER SM 06/04/08
      46.   JOHNBOY Rose colored V`s Dark glasses and a walking stick 14:30  |  PETER SM 06/04/08
      47.   What`s the big deal? 14:40  |  Murray of Montreal 06/04/08
      48.   US Congress 14:43  |  Gary Schroeder 06/04/08
      49.   Post #3 Panther Jet 14:48  |  Gary 06/04/08
      50.   Clickfool it was nothing, otherwise the Syrians 15:01  |  Iz Ray Leigh 06/04/08
      51.   #26: If Americans Had Nothing to Do With It... 15:01  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 06/04/08
      52.   October Surprise 15:09  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 06/04/08
      53.   What did it achieve? 15:41  |  Chris Linthwaite 06/04/08
      54.   For Iz ray Leigh, who has difficulty with logic # 50 15:45  |  Clickfool 06/04/08
      55.   How Olmert will apologize for not informing the IAEA 16:21  |  Tosefta 06/04/08
      56.   #8 and 9 and of course there is always #0 16:46  |  Panther Jet 06/04/08
      57.   #23 Eric Idle From (New) Mexico 16:54  |  Panther Jet 06/04/08
      58.   The end game is to attack before Bush steps down! 16:54  |  lakshmi 06/04/08
      59.   #32 Cipora, Re your sick falsehoods 17:02  |  Dutch 06/04/08
      60.   #40 Gary 17:04  |  Panther Jet 06/04/08
      61.   The US is not a honnest peace procke, they are part of the confli 17:05  |  Moise 06/04/08
      62.   Say Nothing 17:06  |  MIKE 06/04/08
      63.   But, you will never dare to attack Iran because you`re afraid 17:10  |  Aounist 06/04/08
      64.   The Artical is Speculation 17:25  |  Ron 06/04/08
      65.   #32 Interplanetary traveller missed some events 17:30  |  Labhras 06/04/08
      66.   Mark (2) so you may show us the photo or give the link 17:37  |  Karl 06/04/08
      67.   #55 Tosefta 17:42  |  Panther Jet 06/04/08
      68.   If Hizballah attack; the Israel position should be to attack Syri 18:05  |  r 06/04/08
      69.   37 Tzfonit - Israelis Don`t Have to Reveal Anything 18:12  |  Mark of Lewiston 06/04/08
      70.   the big lie of nuclear syria 18:15  |  Li 06/04/08
      71.   for clickfool shooting an unarmed man in the Tube is thuggery 18:23  |  Iz Ray Leigh 06/04/08
      72.   # 32 Cipora J.K re:Mark L..He Thinks he is an experts.But Has No. 18:48  |  KATHY 06/04/08
      73.   #54 Click.The So-Called Thugary Unconvered what Syria/Korea was 19:01  |  KATHY 06/04/08
      74.   The whole world is watching 19:06  |  Mark Lincoln 06/04/08
      75.   Nothing will probably be disclosed, although it should be 19:30  |  Tosefta 06/04/08
      76.   Herta Daeubler-Gmelin 19:38  |  Keops 06/04/08
      77.   # 69. KATHY. You are quite right..in the nick of time. 19:53  |  Stephen. 06/04/08
      78.   Israel U.S. Plan to release details 20:00  |  Steve Gure 06/04/08
      79.   #71; Mark Lincoln, I know it was a milk plant 20:05  |  Doc Holliday 06/04/08
      80.   # 71 .;Mark Lincoln. Who is talking about a reactor.? 20:05  |  Stephen. 06/04/08
      81.   what really happened is that saddam hussein`s biological weapons 20:12  |  pal supporter 06/04/08
      82.   # 63. Youre wrong. Dead wrong... 20:14  |  Stephen. 06/04/08
      83.   re 53 a credible source 20:22  |  Alan th real one 06/04/08
      84.   To Mark Lincoln & Clickfool 20:30  |  leo 06/04/08
      85.   To pantnher piss #56 20:35  |  Bat Man 06/04/08
      86.   # 77 Stephen Agreed.So many of them at the time.. 20:54  |  KATHY 06/04/08
      87.   Post #60 Panther Jet 20:55  |  Gary Schroeder 06/04/08
      88.   #16, Atoo...well said! 20:58  |  Silvienne 06/04/08
      89.   # 85 Batman. When crude oil reaches 400 dollars. 20:58  |  Robin 06/04/08
      90.   #70 Li The Big Lie You say.Yes? Okay.. 21:09  |  KATHY 06/04/08
      91.   Price of Oil 21:11  |  Gary Schroeder 06/04/08
      92.   #85 Robin`s lesser half 21:15  |  panther Jet 06/04/08
      93.   #87 Yo Bubba! 21:25  |  Panther Jet 06/04/08
      94.   What a real Korean Magvox Reactor looks like 21:38  |  Mark Lincoln 06/04/08
      95.   To #91 and defending America 21:51  |  Bat Man 06/04/08
      96.   $400/bbl - long before Shiite Entity in Pesia would not own any 21:53  |  17 06/04/08
      97.   Another example of a Plutonium Production Plant 21:54  |  Mark Lincoln 06/04/08
      98.   RRRRRRobin #89 21:58  |  Bat Man 06/04/08
      99.   #85 Hey Bat Man I Suggest You Read #91 &# 85 Then Come Back 22:11  |  KATHY 06/04/08
      100.   What it will take to send the Jews and Zionists hom 22:18  |  Mikhail 06/04/08
      101.   #98 Bat Man I Too am Lmfo,but at You, Not With You! 22:32  |  KATHY 06/04/08
      102.   100 mikhail the intellect of the century 22:49  |  v hardman 06/04/08
      103.   #94 More bull from the Longhorn`s ass. 22:51  |  Panther Jet 06/04/08
      104.   #94, 97 Mark Lincoln." Whats up doc" ? 23:12  |  Stephen. 06/04/08
      105.   Post #95 Bad Man 23:23  |  Gary Schroeder 06/04/08
      106.   Post #95 Bad Man continued 23:26  |  Gary Schroeder 06/04/08
      107.   Syrian nuke plant was another Israeli Yehuda Gil Lie 23:30  |  Yossi Cronenberg 06/04/08
      108.   WARREN J.Do you believe Islamic dictators in Iran represent- 23:35  |  PETER SM 06/04/08
      109.   Some intel guys say it was a gay nightclub for government cronies 23:39  |  Yaakov Sullivan 06/04/08
      110.   # 102 v hardman - Mikhail is Russian immigrant anti-semite 23:40  |  17 06/04/08
      111.   pussycat jet you sound like bald samson 23:42  |  reza SHAH 06/04/08
      112.   101 kathy 23:52  |  Bat Man 06/04/08
      113.   TO # 24 NOW THAT... 00:22  |  THE TEACHER/INSTRUCT 07/04/08
      114.   Bat man greeting from tehran 00:46  |  reza SHAH 07/04/08
      115.   Bat Man. Ref yr post to KATHY. 01:19  |  Stephen. 07/04/08
      116.   109 BatMan First Iran Nuclear bomb might explode in NYC Harbor 01:26  |  I 07/04/08
      117.   108 reza: In all my travels in Iran I never met a moron like you 01:31  |  I 07/04/08
      118.   Bat Man - "fighting with our dollars and blood," ??? 01:47  |  17 07/04/08
      119.   It was Saddam Hussein that invested for Syrian Nuclear power 01:56  |  e.m Jordan is Palse 07/04/08
      120.   stephen #109 01:58  |  Bat Man 07/04/08
      121.   reza SHAH from Shiite Entity in Persia 01:59  |  17 07/04/08
      122.   #117 17 02:25  |  Bat Man 07/04/08
      123.   118 02:31  |  Bat Man 07/04/08
      124.   # 63 Aounist...Everyone Should be Afraid.. 02:32  |  Ross 07/04/08
      125.   Cipora Julianna Kohn #21 re M Lincoln 02:33  |  TonyL 07/04/08
      126.   Co-ordinating? 02:36  |  Paul 07/04/08
      127.   #106 Fur Crissakes Yossi that was 15 years ago 02:48  |  Panther Jet 07/04/08
      128.   Stephen - wrong 03:27  |  Mark Lincoln 07/04/08
      129.   Aounist, Bat man and other Islamonazis 03:27  |  X` 07/04/08
      130.   The power of fantasy 03:34  |  Mark Lincoln 07/04/08
      131.   #108 Turncoat Sullivan and his Gay Fixation 03:37  |  * BEN JABO 07/04/08
      132.   #43 How do you figure that, Jeff? 03:53  |  Johnboy 07/04/08
      133.   Mark Lincoln Loves Goerge Bush 04:09  |  Alex 07/04/08
      134.   Despite sci-fi fantasies and paranoid delusions 04:45  |  Mark Lincoln 07/04/08
      135.   Syrian base bombed 04:48  |  Sabra 07/04/08
      136.   The Syrian mystery box 04:50  |  Mark Lincoln 07/04/08
      137.   I - pranoid ravings? 04:52  |  Mark Lincoln 07/04/08
      138.   # 57 you`re dreaming panther jet 04:57  |  eric 07/04/08
      139.   Hello world! 05:01  |  Mark Lincoln 07/04/08
      140.   And making a bomb from Plutonium 05:06  |  Mark Lincoln 07/04/08
      141.   Syria - the record 05:12  |  Mark Lincoln 07/04/08
      142.   #134 Bull Dickey 05:26  |  Panther Jet 07/04/08
      143.   Sabra - `spilt milk` 05:30  |  Mark Lincoln 07/04/08
      144.   #129 johnboy says HE is dumb REDUX 05:34  |  CK Tan 07/04/08
      145.   126 x 05:34  |  Bat Man 07/04/08
      146.   131 Mark Lincoln, if its so tough, how did N Korea do it? 05:47  |  I 07/04/08
      147.   #129 Mr. Military Analysis 05:52  |  Panther Jet 07/04/08
      148.   F9F-3 - look it up 06:00  |  Mark Lincoln 07/04/08
      149.   #135 Eric Idly speaks again 06:01  |  Panther Jet 07/04/08
      150.   Bat Man from Gotham of delusion 06:05  |  17 07/04/08
      151.   CK Tan - what can be determined 06:06  |  Mark Lincoln 07/04/08
      152.   Astounding isn`t it? 06:13  |  Mark Lincoln 07/04/08
      153.   #138 Syria The Broken Record 06:15  |  Panther Jet 07/04/08
      154.   #138 mark L says syria is a peaceful nation (nudgex2, winkx2) 06:15  |  CK Tan 07/04/08
      155.   Compare the pictures 06:19  |  Mark Lincoln 07/04/08
      156.   Like taking candy from a baby 06:26  |  Mark Lincoln 07/04/08
      157.   What the neocon - Israelicon idiots did 06:33  |  Mark Lincoln 07/04/08
      158.   My position on nuclear weapons 06:39  |  Mark Lincoln 07/04/08
      159.   #38 BEN JABO homophobia is sickening... Shame 06:41  |  Yaakov Sullivan 07/04/08
      160.   The Nuclear Realit in the Middle East 06:46  |  Mark Lincoln 07/04/08
      161.   the hoax attack 06:51  |  Avi 07/04/08
      162.   were not scared from nuclear war 07:04  |  reza SHAH 07/04/08
      163.   158 Mark Lincoln, more wrong gneralizations. 07:06  |  I 07/04/08
      164.   I I don`t think you ever left your cocon 07:12  |  reza SHAH 07/04/08
      165.   152 Mark Lincoln, nobody claimed Syria had a PRODUCING reactor 07:15  |  I 07/04/08
      166.   #141, MarkL, claiming Syria is not a threat to Israel 07:28  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 07/04/08
      167.   #148 Eye from on high 07:31  |  Panther Jet 07/04/08
      168.   #151 mark L - say that to johnboy 07:43  |  CK Tan 07/04/08
      169.   EVOLUTION 07:51  |  Mark of Lewiston 07/04/08
      170.   I am amazed 08:27  |  I am amazed 07/04/08
      171.   Indrajaya`s Indonesia Condemned For Its Own Attack 08:32  |  Craig 07/04/08
      172.   Here we disagree, Mark Lincoln # 160 09:43  |  Clickfool 07/04/08
      173.   Rumour 10:16  |  guy fall 07/04/08
      174.   # 135 lol...i`m done with you pj 10:34  |  eric 07/04/08
      175.   #135 Sabra. Correct right down to last detail. Mark Lincoln, wake 11:25  |  Stephen. 07/04/08
      176.   #144 CK Tan proves something, anyway 15:04  |  Johnboy 07/04/08
      177.   # 134 Mark L. 16:44  |  Ross 07/04/08
      178.   Attack on Syria 03:09  |  Ziggy 08/04/08
      179.   Border incursion 03:21  |  Kevin 08/04/08
     Today Online
    Bradley Burston: I want the Palestinians to win
    Responses: 181
    Evangelist to Yoffie: 'I'm not trying to undermine peace'
    Responses: 125
    Moshe Arens: Making Palestine Judenrein
    Responses: 115
    Vice PM: Ofra settlement homes built on private Palestinian land
    Responses: 111
    Barghouti peace overture to be read at Peace Now rally
    Responses: 109


    More Headlines
    22:54 Complainant against Katsav seeks to reenter rape charge in new indictment
    19:01 Katsav accuser: Decision to drop plea deal stems from denial
    20:56 Anaylsis: All outcomes possible in Katsav sex crimes case
    01:20 IDF home front chief: Israelis ready to meet any threats
    01:48 Israel to deny UN official entry for comparing Israel to Nazis
    21:14 Peace Now: Our views are now mainstream but peace still elusive
    20:49 Tunnel meant for terrorist infiltration found in N. Gaza
    22:19 Interior Ministry, Finance Ministry employees to strike Wednesday
    20:40 Strikes cost Israeli economy over 2.5 million workdays in 2007
    22:08 Ahmadinejad: We've added 6,000 centrifuges to nuke program
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Learn Hebrew online
    with Israel's best teachers Sign up for a trial lesson today
    Behind the Z Word
    Scholarly essays, commentary, podcasts, blogs and much more.
    NEW! Dan Boutique Jerusalem Hotel
    Hip Dan Hotel in Jerusalem. Attractive Introductory Rates
    Pardes Institute Summer Sessions
    Study Jewish texts and issues in Jerusalem, Co-ed, All Levels
    FAREWELL ISRAEL New Film
    The Coming War for Islamic Revival - View Movie Trailer
    Free the Palestinians from:
    Corrupt Kleptocracy, Tyrannical Theocracy, Abysmal Anarchy
    Fattal Hotel Chain
    Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
    ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel
    Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved