Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., May 21, 2008 Iyyar 16, 5768 | | Israel Time: 23:09 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Advertising
Books Peres Conference Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Commander-designate of the Israel Air Force, Maj. Gen. Ido Nehushtan (Tomer Appelbaum / BauBau)
Last update - 13:40 17/03/2008
Next IAF chief: IDF's entry into Gaza will stop rocket manufacture
By Amos Harel and Yuval Azoulay, Haaretz Correspondents and Reuters
Tags: Israel, IDF, Ehud Barak 

The commander-designate of the Israel Air Force, Maj. Gen. Ido Nehushtan, believes the presence of Israel Defense Forces troops on the ground in the Gaza Strip could prevent the manufacture of the Qassam rockets that are plaguing the Negev as well as the smuggling of weapons into the Strip.

"Professionally speaking," he said, "if Israel wants to prevent any high-trajectory rocket or mortar fire, it must establish good control on the ground."

At the same time, Israel is examining anew the possibility of purchasing one of two foreign-made anti-rocket defense systems to combat the Qassams, according to defense officials, because the Israeli-made Iron Dome system, currently under development at the Armaments Development Authority Rafael, will not be operational before 2010.
Advertisement
In a lecture at the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs delivered two months ago, and made public Sunday, Nehushtan, currently the head of the IDF Planning Directorate, said: "Compare Lebanon and Gaza to the West Bank, where Israel has control over the external perimeter and can control the entrance of weapons inside the area. In Lebanon, well-organized shipments of weapons flow across an open border with Syria. Gaza is open along the Egyptian border. The West Bank is not open and the weapons don't flow in with the same freedom."

According to Nehushtan, who will take command of the IAF on May 14, while "local arms production is a matter of know-how ... if Israeli forces are present on the ground, as they are in the West Bank, then we can stop the development and manufacture of rockets and other weapons in time."

Asked whether the Gaza problem could be solved militarily, he referred to Israel's Operation Defensive Shield in the West Bank in April 2002. "It took a few years [after the operation ¬ A.H.], but we managed to establish a different kind of control. The motivation of suicide bombers in the West Bank did not recede, but their capabilities did." The decision as to the role of the army, Nehushtan added, is in the hands of the country's political echelon: "In Gaza, as well, the IDF will do what it is instructed to do."

Nehushtan noted that the Gaza Strip represents the first example in the world "of a regime affiliated with the Muslim Brotherhood," which began in Egypt.

"Hamas is building up its power and building its military capabilities ... Even if we build better shelters, this is no way to raise children," he noted, referring to the "constant shelling that really makes life impossible" for people living in Sderot and nearby communities.

He acknowledged "the difficulties of an open, modern, sensitive, Western society such as Israel's in operating against terrorists who operate from within civilian territory against civilians on the Israeli side," adding: "It was not like this in World War II ... We have to operate within this environment and under these constraints. At the same time, we still have to provide security for our people.

"Now that civilians are part of the equation," he continued, "anti-terror operations become much more difficult. When we have to operate against forces that operate within a civilian environment, we have to be pinpoint precise and very sensitive to collateral damage. We are much more limited in what we can do."

This was not the first time that Nehushtan, a former combat pilot, has spoken about the need for ground operations to prevent rocket fire. In meetings at the IDF General Command in late July 2006, during the Second Lebanon War, Nehushtan and another pilot Military Intelligence head Amos Yadlin were among the first senior officers to tell then chief of staff Dan Halutz that his plan to continue the aerial attacks on Hezbollah was not working.

"You must bring this before the government," Nehushtan told Halutz, according to the protocol of the meeting as published in Haaretz over a year ago. "You need to tell them straight that without a major ground operation, we cannot remove the Katyusha threat. If the government does not approve it, we should tell them that they must stop the campaign now."

Meanwhile, Defense Minister Ehud Barak is reviewing two potential substitutes for Iron Dome to counter the Qassam rockets. One is Nautilus, a joint Israeli-American invention that uses lasers to blow up rockets and mortar bombs mid-flight. The other is Phalanx, an automated machinegun produced by U.S. firm Raytheon whose heavy bullets shred incoming shells.

Defense Ministry director general Pinchas Buchris flew Sunday to the U.S. state of New Mexico to watch Nautilus now being upgraded under a new name, Skyguard in action. The mission is significant as Israeli experts long wrote off Nautilus's performance as inadequate. A Defence Ministry delegation visited Raytheon earlier this month to inspect the Phalanx.

Defense Ministry spokesman Shlomo Dror confirmed that Israel is examining the Phalanx and Nautilus systems, if only to assess their core technologies as potential complements for Iron Dome. "I think the future will be a combination of laser and missile systems," he said.

Dror denied that protectionism had motivated Iron Dome's initial selection, saying its slated performance was deemed to be more reliable than that of Nautilus or Phalanx.

Palestinians fired five Qassam rockets at Israel Sunday, but no one was injured and no damage was caused.

Related articles:
  • Halutz objected to ground offensive almost until end of war
  • Iron Dome system found to be helpless against Qassams
  • Barak rethinking 'Iron Dome' defense system in face of Gaza rockets
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Say what you want
    French court: Claim that Al-Dura tape doctored isn`t libelous.
    Peace in our time
    Olmert: Peace talks with Syria are a 'national duty'.
      1.   Delta Company - First Battalion - Fifth Marines - USMC 02:53  |  Guaranteed Peace 17/03/08
      2.   If the air force boss is saying ground forces are the solution 03:01  |  Mark B. 17/03/08
      3.   refreeshing 03:03  |  geroge 17/03/08
      4.   IS THE FOLLOWING THEN ACCEPTABLE TO PEACE for Jews and Arabs..... 03:04  |  ALI 17/03/08
      5.   Meanwhile - Take Phalanx Out of Stock 03:21  |  Mark of Lewiston 17/03/08
      6.   Barak Needs A Iron Fist In Gaza Not a Iron Dome 03:24  |  Shepherd 17/03/08
      7.   Nothing can stop rockets from gaza 03:33  |  Bobby 17/03/08
      8.   At least 03:34  |  Frank 17/03/08
      9.   What it will take 03:58  |  Mark Lincoln 17/03/08
      10.   Do it now 04:17  |  Commonsense 17/03/08
      11.   Caught in your own web 04:19  |  Harold 17/03/08
      12.   They haven`t tried everything! 05:30  |  Paul 17/03/08
      13.   An option: Push them back 05:35  |  US CITIZEN 17/03/08
      14.   Bobby, you are so wrong 05:40  |  Dan 17/03/08
      15.   IDF has to control the ground to protect whom? 06:25  |  Straight Talk 17/03/08
      16.   Time to go to the heart of the problem. 06:27  |  Akram Zekaria 17/03/08
      17.   Barak needs to make up his mind 06:29  |  Kipperraes 17/03/08
      18.   Nothing will work unless.... 07:20  |  Ossama 17/03/08
      19.   MarKkLincon & Bobby 07:39  |  Brad 17/03/08
      20.   Marc military expert without manage a single unit. 08:03  |  Aby 17/03/08
      21.   Absolute victory. 08:13  |  Jean Van Daem 17/03/08
      22.   Inadequate 08:15  |  Eitan 17/03/08
      23.   Armageddon Not Needed 08:25  |  Mark of Lewiston 17/03/08
      24.   The only solution - Air Attacks on Gaza 08:43  |  A 17/03/08
      25.   zionists why don`t you ever consider peace,and getting out of 09:09  |  lakshmi 17/03/08
      26.   For 60 years IDF has failed to provide peace 09:19  |  Tupac 17/03/08
      27.   Brad: Hamas Will NEVER be destroyed 09:31  |  Tupac 17/03/08
      28.   Shouldn`t this man shut his stupid mouth and simply obey orders? 10:14  |  Clickfool 17/03/08
      29.   Secret weapon lying dorment... 10:21  |  Chanalau, Tova 17/03/08
      30.   #3 Pretentious Kibbitzer 10:36  |  Panther Jet 17/03/08
      31.   israel needs the russian army units that pacified chechyna 10:52  |  v hardman 17/03/08
      32.   8 OUT OF 10 10:55  |  indrajaya 17/03/08
      33.   Bobby 1 11:00  |  ChanahS 17/03/08
      34.   The sign of a true military man 11:19  |  Natallie Durson 17/03/08
      35.   free gaza 11:21  |  jack 17/03/08
      36.   At what cost and what does that mean long term?? 11:23  |  De 17/03/08
      37.   Open front in Gaza will open another in the south. 11:26  |  J 17/03/08
      38.   Another pearl by Mark Lincoln #3 11:46  |  S 17/03/08
      39.   the unmilitary solution 11:58  |  whizbang 17/03/08
      40.   The dogs bark 12:40  |  Yonatan 17/03/08
      41.   WHAT A WASTE OF MONEY 12:51  |  MJ 17/03/08
      42.   About humanitarians concerns. 12:55  |  Robert 17/03/08
      43.   Next IAF chief: IDF`s entry into Gaza will stop rocket manufactur 13:30  |  Goober 17/03/08
      44.   To the Pompous Idiots 13:33  |  George W Patton 17/03/08
      45.   Never worked, won`t work 13:59  |  Salem 17/03/08
      46.   Next IAF chief is right. 14:00  |  Vital 17/03/08
      47.   TO NO 20 14:19  |  DANNY. 17/03/08
      48.   It`s the property 14:29  |  Sam 17/03/08
      49.   To Salem 14:33  |  Oleg 17/03/08
      50.   To Ossama 14:36  |  Oleg 17/03/08
      51.   11# Ossama. "nothing will work" indeed ! 14:43  |  Akram Zekaria 17/03/08
      52.   Nehushtan, Olmert is an incopetent manipulator 14:44  |  Yoel 17/03/08
      53.   Olmert Barak, everything but to make the hard decisions 15:09  |  Yoel 17/03/08
      54.   to Bobby 15:13  |  Dik 17/03/08
      55.   Do You Really Wanna Stop Rocket Attacks? 15:23  |  MIKE 17/03/08
      56.   No One Silver Bullet Will Work 15:37  |  Jeff Northridge 17/03/08
      57.   Next IAF Chief 16:00  |  Fred 17/03/08
      58.   But that means undoing the Itnatkut -another Leftist failure! 16:10  |  Feiglin for PM 17/03/08
      59.   cutting the power cuts the manafacture 16:10  |  peter 17/03/08
      60.   #25-lockshen keeps slurping 16:13  |  peter 17/03/08
      61.   Delta Company 16:16  |  Fred 17/03/08
      62.   Idiot M.Lincoln,V2 were falling on London until their bases were 16:30  |  Absolute Sweden 17/03/08
      63.   peter of Montreal 16:40  |  GABE1 17/03/08
      64.   to Mark of Lewiston 16:45  |  Dik 17/03/08
      65.   Israel is falling down 16:56  |  Atilla Karagözoğlu 17/03/08
      66.   humanitirian trucks going to Gaza 16:56  |  Atilla Karagözoğlu 17/03/08
      67.   Israel is right 16:57  |  Atilla Karagözoğlu 17/03/08
      68.   Fred # 61 Which Delta Company? 17:01  |  Jeff Northridge 17/03/08
      69.   Atilla Karagözoğlu has no respect FOR ANY JEW ! 17:02  |  ... 17/03/08
      70.   Atilla what are you drinking ? 17:03  |  ... 17/03/08
      71.   Israel to loose its air bases 17:04  |  Jonathan S 17/03/08
      72.   # 16 Akram Zekaria Time to go to the heart of the problem. 17:14  |  KATHY 17/03/08
      73.   Natallie, Sign of a true military man 17:18  |  Neal 17/03/08
      74.   best probagandas are simple continious ones 17:23  |  atilla karagözoğlu 17/03/08
      75.   # 70 Atilla...Yes What Are You Drinking.And.. 17:30  |  JOSH 17/03/08
      76.   IRON DOME IS NOT AVAILABLE YET, MISTER 17:32  |  indrajaya 17/03/08
      77.   Jeff Northridge @56 17:33  |  GABE1 17/03/08
      78.   Nehushtan Is Only Half Right 17:36  |  massaraksh 17/03/08
      79.   Does atilla karagözoğlu love or respect HAARETZ ? 17:37  |  ... 17/03/08
      80.   # 56 Jeff Northridge..No One Silver Bullet Will Work 17:48  |  KATHY 17/03/08
      81.   Kaddish for the unborn child. 17:58  |  Fortuna Benmayor 17/03/08
      82.   # 78 massaraksh..Bingo! Couldn`t have Said it Better Myself. 17:58  |  KATHY 17/03/08
      83.   Tupac 26 18:02  |  ChanahS 17/03/08
      84.   IAF Maj Gen.Ido Nehushtan is saying what we all know 18:15  |  Shepherd 17/03/08
      85.   love your enemy. karagözoğlu truly loves :) 18:19  |  Christian Atilla K. 17/03/08
      86.   love your news site, they work for you 18:21  |  atilla karagözoğlu 17/03/08
      87.   Combine Nautilus, Phalanx and a Ground Offensive in Gaza 18:24  |  Fortuna Benmayor 17/03/08
      88.   72# Kath. You could be right. 18:27  |  Akram Zekaria 17/03/08
      89.   To indrajaya 18:32  |  Oleg 17/03/08
      90.   # 59 peter..cutting the power cuts the manafacture 18:40  |  KATHY 17/03/08
      91.   More Israeli Firepower=Less Thinking=More Stupidity 18:44  |  Bye-Bye Israel 17/03/08
      92.   peter of Montreal 18:50  |  GABE1 17/03/08
      93.   Gabe- grow up 18:51  |  peter 17/03/08
      94.   # 87 Fortuna Benmayor.Combine Nautilus, Phalanx and a Ground 19:00  |  KATHY 17/03/08
      95.   34 Natallie - Not True 19:15  |  Mark of Lewiston 17/03/08
      96.   peter of Montreal @93 19:16  |  GABE1 17/03/08
      97.   64 Dik of Spijkenisse 19:25  |  Mark of Lewiston 17/03/08
      98.   brain-dead 19:27  |  Mark Katzman 17/03/08
      99.   Kathy re peter @90 19:27  |  GABE1 17/03/08
      100.   68 Jeff Northridge - It Doesn`t Matter 19:29  |  Mark of Lewiston 17/03/08
      101.   Here`s an incredible secret weapon against rocket attacks... 19:36  |  just another jew 17/03/08
      102.   ALCON 19:42  |  Matt 17/03/08
      103.   PHALANX? ROYAL NAVY DID IT 1982!! 19:47  |  Ian 17/03/08
      104.   #1 Guaranteed peace; You must be kidding, when was the last time 20:01  |  Haham Me Bta Yam 17/03/08
      105.   #101 NICE IDEA,BUT... 20:01  |  Ian 17/03/08
      106.   101 the answer is in 52 and 53,they want you dead 20:09  |  yoel 17/03/08
      107.   #88 Kathy advising Akram? 20:14  |  uriah heep 17/03/08
      108.   #88 Kathy advising Akram? 20:14  |  uriah heep 17/03/08
      109.   25 lakshmi, answer to your ? 20:14  |  leo 17/03/08
      110.   Great example of the difference between general and statesman 20:18  |  Tosefta 17/03/08
      111.   #100 Mark of Lewiston--re:Jeff N. It doesn`t Matter 20:19  |  KATHY 17/03/08
      112.   GABE 1 post 96 20:19  |  Gerald 17/03/08
      113.   56# Jeff Northridge. Hamas is a rage & not a government.. 20:21  |  Akram Zekaria 17/03/08
      114.   Peter of Montreal #93: Grow Up 20:24  |  CHGODMK 17/03/08
      115.   The problem isn`t the rockets the problem is Israel 20:26  |  Dutch 17/03/08
      116.   # 103 IanPHALANX? ROYAL NAVY DID IT 1982!! 20:27  |  KATHY 17/03/08
      117.   Peter of Montreal: Your Forum 20:29  |  CHGODMK 17/03/08
      118.   111 Kathy - Availability 21:02  |  Mark of Lewiston 17/03/08
      119.   yes cutting the power cuts the manufacture 21:23  |  peter 17/03/08
      120.   #116 KATHY 21:39  |  Ian 17/03/08
      121.   To Dutch # 115 - Outraged ...... 21:43  |  Dolly 17/03/08
      122.   To Dutch # 115 - A homeland for Arabs ... 21:58  |  Dagma 17/03/08
      123.   The terrorists 22:06  |  Paul 17/03/08
      124.   Making peace would be a far simpler approach 22:25  |  Labhras 17/03/08
      125.   Stop those Rockets 22:41  |  Bob R. 17/03/08
      126.   KATHY # 80 The Sampson Option 23:14  |  Jeff Northridge 17/03/08
      127.   #115 the problem is rockets in the head of doris cadigan 23:21  |  v hardman 17/03/08
      128.   #119 labarse of arabia and making peace by one party on its own 23:23  |  v hardman 17/03/08
      129.   claim your rights from the right parties 23:36  |  Egypt 17/03/08
      130.   It`s all about compromise 23:41  |  peter 17/03/08
      131.   claim your rights from the right parties 23:42  |  Egypt 17/03/08
      132.   P{eople should abandon this fascist-like state 23:51  |  Dutch 17/03/08
      133.   Oh yea, ground assault, stay out of the cities 00:10  |  Bob R. 18/03/08
      134.   Jeff N and KATH on `The Sampson Option` #121+#80 00:57  |  examiner 18/03/08
      135.   # 121 Jeff Northridge...Got Your Message,Thanks... 00:57  |  KATHY 18/03/08
      136.   # 97 Mark of Lewiston..Not On Subject,But I would Like To say.... 01:08  |  KATHY 18/03/08
      137.   stopping missiles 01:17  |  lee 18/03/08
      138.   Fortuna - and how do you pay for all that? 01:18  |  Mark Lincoln 18/03/08
      139.   GO IDF WE ARE PROUD OF YOU 01:29  |  History 18/03/08
      140.   For KATHY # 94 02:05  |  Fortuna Benmayor 18/03/08
      141.   # 125 examiner.Typical of you to find the mini typo error.. 02:11  |  KATHY 18/03/08
      142.   # 128 History..GO IDF WE ARE PROUD OF YOU. AMEN BROTHER! 02:19  |  KATHY 18/03/08
      143.   111/127 Kathy - Thanks 02:21  |  Mark of Lewiston 18/03/08
      144.   Israel For Heavens Sake Wake Up 02:21  |  Dave Levy 18/03/08
      145.   116 Kathy - Ready Now 02:25  |  Mark of Lewiston 18/03/08
      146.   Gerald @112 -This is a Reply. 02:42  |  GABE1 18/03/08
      147.   #128 Mark Lincoln..So You have Decided What Our Chief Of Stuff .. 03:02  |  KATHY 18/03/08
      148.   IS THIS GOING TO BE ANOTHER DEFENSIVE WAR? 03:28  |  PalestniansAreA Myth 18/03/08
      149.   NO STOLEN LAND & NO OCCUPIED LAND 03:50  |  US 18/03/08
      150.   # 110 Tosefta..Generals v.s Statesman.Where Are They? 04:11  |  KATHY 18/03/08
      151.   # 129 History.GO IDF WE ARE PROUD OF YOU Amen To That Brother. 04:17  |  KATHY 18/03/08
      152.   Kathy - No, I have not 04:37  |  Mark Lincoln 18/03/08
      153.   Kathy - details of the `exchecquer" 04:43  |  Mark Lincoln 18/03/08
      154.   ONLY WAY TO STOP ATTACKS IS TO SHOW THE WILL TO WIN 04:48  |  Jorge 18/03/08
      155.   Dan, Brad, ChanaS, Dik -Just talking 04:49  |  Bobby 18/03/08
      156.   ^ Shepherd and suicide 05:30  |  Truth 18/03/08
      157.   #133 You appear to demolish your own argument, US 06:11  |  Johnboy 18/03/08
      158.   Now listen up everyone! 06:33  |  Jim 18/03/08
      159.   Reply to #2 Mark B 06:40  |  Jim 18/03/08
      160.   Gabe1 06:49  |  x-ray 18/03/08
      161.   # 28 Clickfool 06:58  |  Jim 18/03/08
      162.   #71 Jonathan S, 07:22  |  Jim 18/03/08
      163.   If the laser guided missile doesn`t explode the Qasam,at least it 08:32  |  to life 18/03/08
      164.   No compassion, no democracy 13:15  |  Nick Ferriman 27/03/08
      165.   # 25 - lakschmi 22:59  |  Rozz 21/05/08
     Read & React
    Al Gore: Israel should lead the way in renewable energy
    Responses: 122
    Olmert to U.S.: Impose naval blockade on Iran
    Responses: 211
    Israel, Syria to begin indirect peace talks
    Responses: 185
    Opinion: The demise of the European left
    Responses: 113
    Rosner's Domain
    8 short comments on the Israel-Syria peace talks
    5 questions: Does Israel need rescue?
    Goldberg vs. Boot. I'm going to stay neutral!
    Rosner's Guests: Israel not likely to invade Gaza soon
    Can Obama win over Jewish voters? (WTR)


    More Headlines
    22:52 Ex-Olmert aide recorded money transfers between PM, Messer
    22:58 Olmert: Peace talks with Syria are a 'national obligation'
    20:37 Golan regional head: Olmert endangering Israel's existence
    21:36 8 short comments on the Israel-Syria peace talks
    23:02 Champions league final: Grant's Chelsea equalize against Man U
    19:31 Hamas: Israel-Syria talks won't affect our 'strategic' ties with Damascus
    21:02 French court: Claim that Al-Dura tape doctored isn`t libelous
    22:18 Lebanese relieved as standoff ends; Hezbollah supporters celebrate
    21:41 Ex-chief rabbi Eliyahu's condition deteriorates further after stroke
    17:07 ANALYSIS / Small piece of land could scupper Israel-Syria talks
    18:31 Microsoft CEO, in Herzliya: Our company almost as Israeli as American
    13:15 Iran detains seven Baha'i leaders, citing 'Zionist' ties
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Dead Sea Products
    Buy Dead Sea mineral skin care and beauty products. Coupon code Haaretz for 10% off.
    Istudy
    Learn Hebrew in 3 months
    The Terraces
    Your Ultimate Coastal Address On Nitza Boulevard, North Netanya
    Together Celebrating Israel's 60th
    The Jewish Agency and You - together making history
    Pardes Institute Summer Sessions
    http://www.pardes.org.il/
    Free the Palestinians from:
    Corrupt Kleptocracy, Tyrannical Theocracy, Abysmal Anarchy
    Fattal Hotel Chain
    Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
    ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel
    Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
    Real Estate in Israel
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved