Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., March 13, 2008 Adar2 7, 5768 | | Israel Time: 01:50 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Advertising
Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File

Last update - 11:36 13/03/2008
Rightist rabbis call on Jews to avenge yeshiva killings
By Yair Ettinger, Haaretz Correspondent
Tags: Rabbi Dan Segal 

A group of rabbis identified with the extreme right called on Jews Wednesday to avenge their enemies "measure for measure." An anti-Zionist rabbi, meanwhile, called the massacre "divine punishment."

Notices in the Kiryat Moshe neighborhood, the location of the Mercaz Harav yeshiva where a Palestinian gunman shot to death eight students last week, said: "Each and everyone is required to imagine what the enemy is plotting to do to us, and to match it measure for measure."

The rabbis also said it was necessary "to work to create a proper Jewish leadership," and looked forward to the day when "Jews will congregate in their cities ... and strike those who wish upon them ill in those days at this time." The latter alludes to the Book of Esther, which will be read next week on Purim.
Advertisement
Among the signatories to the street notice were Rabbi Yaakov Yosef, son of Shas spiritual leader Rabbi Ovadia Yosef, Rabbi Ido Elba, who was sentenced to a two-year prison term for incitement to racism, Rabbi Gadi Ben-Zimra, the rabbi of the Orthodox high school where girls who were arrested refused to recognize the court's authority.

"In going to war," the rabbis write, "the Cohen [priest] fills the people with motivation by giving him the knowledge that he is going to fight his enemies and he must not show compassion or mercy."

Ben-Zimra told Haaretz that the message did not call for individual acts of vengeance because that is the job of the proper Jewish leadership that must be established.

Ben-Zimra said the words "local blessed actions" in the notice referred to acts such as returning to Gush Katif. He said the notice he had been asked to sign was formulated somewhat differently than the one that appeared.

"Private vengeance is damaging and I for one am not calling for it," Ben-Zimra said. "I don't think that this message implies that one must go out and take revenge."

Channel 1 reported Tuesday that a rabbi had given permission to yeshiva students to carry out revenge attacks. The head of the Bnei Akiva yeshivas, Rabbi Haim Druckman, sharply criticized the message and said no such thing took place at the Mercaz Harav yeshiva. He said individuals were forbidden to take security matters into their own hands.

The extreme right represented by the notice's signatories is usually opposed to the "government stream" of Orthodoxy with which the Mercaz Harav yeshiva is identified.

MK Zevulun Orlev (National Religious Party-National Union) demanded Wednesday that the Public Security Ministry investigate the validity of the television report. Public Security Minister Avi Dichter told the Knesset in response that the Shin Bet security service and police have no information on revenge plots.

Another notice posted in Jerusalem and signed by the right-wing groups Komemiyut, the Jewish Heart, and Women in Green, said that "we will come in masses to destroy the murderer's house and expel his family." The notice also made reference to the Book of Esther and the victory of Jews over their enemies.

A few days ago, the police arrested right-wing activists at the Promenade in southern Jerusalem, not far from the village of Jabal Mukkaber, where the terrorist's family lives. The activists said they were on their way to destroy the family's house.

Meanwhile, a different Orthodox response to the massacre at Mercaz Harav came from the leader of the anti-Zionist Lithuanian stream of Judaism, Rabbi Dan Segal.

According to the new ultra-Orthodox daily, Yom Hadash, Segal told his students the massacre was a divine punishment for violating two of three oaths the Talmud links with coming to live in the Land of Israel. The issue of the three oaths is at the nexus of debate between Zionist and anti-Zionist Orthodoxy.

Segal reportedly said that the Orthodox were called to greater strictness in keeping the two oaths, which are not to come as a group to live in Israel using force, and not to rebel against the nations of the world.

Other non-Zionist ultra-Orthodox leaders, among them the leader of the Satmar sect, wrote eulogies for the victims of the attack. The ultra-Orthodox United Torah Judaism Knesset faction visited the Mercaz Harav yeshiva on Wednesday.

The human rights organization B'Tselem said Wednesday in response to Dichter's instruction to the police to destroy the terrorist's home: "The destruction of a home to take vengeance on a family that has committed no crime is a step suitable to a terror organization and not a state of law."

B'Tselem also said the destruction of terrorists' houses had been stopped in 2005, when a military panel determined that it did not prevent terrorism and might even increase it.

The police Wednesday began exploring whether the terrorist's house could legally be destroyed or sealed, following Dichter's instruction. Dichter told the Knesset that he "very much hoped" a legal way could be found to destroy the house. The police said Thursday that if such a decision were made, it would be the army, and not the police, who would carry it out.

Related articles:
  • 'His face would glow with joy,' say friends of yeshiva attack victim
  • ANALYSIS: Gazans see attack on yeshiva as unusual achievement
  • Lieberman: Jerusalem attack is product of Arab MK incitement
  • Eight killed when terrorist opens fire in library at Jerusalem yeshiva


    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Hezbollah scare
    Lebanese group's influence has dramatically increased in the West Bank.
    Literary boycott
    Peres calls Muslim countries' shunning of Paris Book Fair 'most ridiculous.'
      1.   Rabbi:terror attack punishment for rebellion 23:16  |  Michael Dick 12/03/08
      2.   Errors and Confusion 23:17  |  Dovy 12/03/08
      3.   This Is Insanity Folks! 23:27  |  b`galil 12/03/08
      4.   Knowing God 23:36  |  NevaAgain 12/03/08
      5.   Disgusting creature 23:40  |  Charlie 12/03/08
      6.   Non Zionist Bus Blew Up Several Yr Ago 23:43  |  Marc 12/03/08
      7.   if there were no israeli army what would he then say? i say garba 23:51  |  ralph 12/03/08
      8.   If only they truly knew... 23:52  |  Avrohom 12/03/08
      9.   Two words 23:53  |  Peter McDaniel 12/03/08
      10.   Errors and Confusion 23:53  |  Dovy 12/03/08
      11.   9/11 00:07  |  W 13/03/08
      12.   What has Shalosh Shevua got todo with Hezballa/Hamas.They nutters 00:14  |  Alan 13/03/08
      13.   Punishment --crazy Religon 00:15  |  Michael 13/03/08
      14.   Punishment --crazy Religon 00:15  |  Michael 13/03/08
      15.   terror attack 00:23  |  michael 13/03/08
      16.   Bravo 00:23  |  Aaron 13/03/08
      17.   No different than the Evangelicals after September 11th 00:23  |  Ben 13/03/08
      18.   Shvuot annulled by Balfour Declaration 00:31  |  Itzchak 13/03/08
      19.   NONSENSE 00:38  |  Common Sense 13/03/08
      20.   Save us from the holymen 00:43  |  moicher 13/03/08
      21.   Reason for Mercaz attack 00:44  |  Menachem Petrushka 13/03/08
      22.   Obscurantism 00:47  |  Michel 13/03/08
      23.   Oaths no longer apply 00:54  |  Ilan 13/03/08
      24.   Leftie Esther from TA says exactly the same :It`s Zionists fault 01:10  |  Absolute Sweden 13/03/08
      25.   yeshiva attack 01:22  |  tom 13/03/08
      26.   He looks 01:23  |  Mark Lincoln 13/03/08
      27.   Crazier then Pat Robertson? 01:29  |  Mark of Lewiston 13/03/08
      28.   Sole brothers 01:29  |  win ner 13/03/08
      29.   Both are wrong, the Zionist rabbi and anti-Zionist rabbi 01:40  |  Not so religious 13/03/08
      30.   This is proof 01:49  |  T 13/03/08
      31.   Confused 01:52  |  Robert 13/03/08
      32.   torah punishment 02:21  |  geroge 13/03/08
      33.   Hey HAARETZ TAKE A LOOK AT THIS 02:27  |  poor Haaretz 13/03/08
      34.   14 Michael,the English mystic&poet William Blake called jehovah 02:31  |  lakshmi 13/03/08
      35.   not the only "potz" rabbi in Israel 03:46  |  hipolito 13/03/08
      36.   Attack is Gods punishment for not adhering to the Torah 03:54  |  Maurice Zaslawsky 13/03/08
      37.   Baranovitch Talmidim`s Death 04:10  |  Baruch 13/03/08
      38.   israeli scumbags, after u kill expect payback 04:45  |  stop whing u trash 13/03/08
      39.   Torah demands us protect and preserve 05:06  |  Jeff 13/03/08
      40.   Jewish Alqaida 05:12  |  Yoav 13/03/08
      41.   Spinning the Truth 06:04  |  Alex Nevilles 13/03/08
      42.   israeli arab 06:09  |  masters 13/03/08
      43.   Eye for Eye? 06:11  |  MRW 13/03/08
      44.   the GOD men 06:51  |  zichron 13/03/08
      45.   punishment for rebellion against Torah 07:03  |  Shmuel Gurewicz 13/03/08
      46.   why the fuss 07:14  |  Adrian de Klerk 13/03/08
      47.   The Rabbi`s should call and demand new elections 07:20  |  Dish It Out 13/03/08
      48.   Justice, yes. Revenge, no. It is the difference between the side. 07:33  |  a wandering Jew 13/03/08
      49.   "Rabbis Revenge" 07:46  |  ROBOCOP 13/03/08
      50.   THE SCHOOL SHOULD HAVE BEEN/SHOULD BE BLOWN UP 08:08  |  johnj 13/03/08
      51.   Instead of Individuals they have the IDF 08:23  |  Tupac 13/03/08
      52.   Terrorists in Pakistan killed more Civilians 08:37  |  Tupac 13/03/08
      53.   Dangerous words from Radical Rabbis 08:40  |  SJ 13/03/08
      54.   Reply to # 36 Jeff in Atlanta 08:46  |  SJ 13/03/08
      55.   Dichter 09:03  |  No Leftie 13/03/08
      56.   An Orthodox War? 09:14  |  Zev 13/03/08
      57.   Unholy viciousness 09:44  |  Clickfool 13/03/08
      58.   What kept God, Jeff? # 36 10:20  |  Clickfool 13/03/08
      59.   Two Birds of the Same Feather 10:23  |  Johan Odin 13/03/08
      60.   Two wrongs make a rightist 10:30  |  Ivar 13/03/08
      61.   For Johan Odin # 50 10:51  |  Clickfool 13/03/08
      62.   Which is more important people of ISrael or land of Israel 11:10  |  H 13/03/08
      63.   Rightist rabbis call on Jews to avenge yeshiva killings 11:31  |  Yaakov 13/03/08
      64.   Go for it granpa! 12:17  |  Natallie Durson 13/03/08
      65.   59Johan Odin,not 242 but 181 is the only legally authorised 13:11  |  lakshmi 13/03/08
      66.   Ticking Bombs from Left, Right and Centre. 13:21  |  Peacelover 13/03/08
      67.   Rabbis: Israel has given her power away 14:06  |  AliciaYasmeen 13/03/08
      68.   Our problem is every carrier of messianic messages 19:08  |  D. Solingor 13/03/08
      69.   Even if commanded to, he wouldn`t know how to start 22:00  |  observer 13/03/08
      70.   Rightist gestopo rabbis