Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., March 25, 2009 Adar 29, 5769 | | Israel Time: 22:48 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Joy of Giving Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 00:00 10/03/2008
No discounts and no installments
By Akiva Eldar
Tags: disengagement, annapolis 

When soldiers fell in defense of the settlers in Gush Katif, the Jewish brain invented the patent of unilateral withdrawal from the Gaza Strip. When a terrorist from the East Jerusalem neighborhood of Jebel Mukaber murders yeshiva students in the west of the city, the Israeli genius proposes unilateral withdrawal from the capital's "outer neighborhoods."

How easy and simple: Wherever they shoot, we pull out. The rest of the territories will wait patiently for convergence, Annapolis, a shelf agreement, or the next catastrophe. Whatever comes first.

We don't understand why, after we left Gaza, they continue to fire rockets at Sderot from there. Is that how they want to build trust with the Israeli public? Is it any wonder that even the most ardent Meretz supporters are afraid that if we leave the West Bank, their homes in Kfar Sava will enter the range of the Qassams?
Advertisement
We wanted so badly to disengage from the Strip that we convinced ourselves that Gaza and the West Bank are two separate entities. Jerusalem, with its approximately 250,000 Arab residents and the sites holy to Islam and Christianity, is a third entity as far as we are concerned, an inseparable part of the State of Israel.

Nobody asks himself what would happen if a foreign conqueror were to withdraw, say, from the North of the country, leaving the other parts of Palestine-Eretz Yisrael, including Jerusalem and the Western Wall, under occupation. Would the Jewish community in Tel Aviv give the occupier a moment's peace, or would it turn Haifa into a base for continuing the struggle for the liberation of the rest of the country?

It's true that there is no territorial contiguity between Gaza and the West Bank, but the entire world, including the Israeli government, has recognized them as a single, national-political unit. This situation did not change even after Hamas removed Fatah from the Strip in disgrace.

The reactions of Deputy Prime Minister Haim Ramon and Internal Security Minister Avi Dichter to the terror attack at the Mercaz Harav yeshiva testify to the fact that the country's leadership has not learned a thing from what happened with Gaza. Ramon is enlisting last week's terrible incident for the campaign he is conducting in favor of disengagement from the Arab neighborhoods hastily annexed to Israel in the heat of victory in the Six-Day War: The terrorist came from the Jebel Mukaber neighborhood, we are disengaging from Jebel Mukaber. So simple. Why didn't we think of it earlier? And afterward, we will be surprised when they fire from there on Jerusalem.

The internal security minister's patent is "to connect the body and the heart" of people like the Jebel Mukaber terrorist. Dichter proposes expelling to the West Bank the ingrates among the residents of East Jerusalem, those whose identity was not transformed from Palestinian to Israeli by the blue Israeli ID card that Israel was kind enough to grant them.

It is hard to believe that the man who spent decades in the security service does not understand his main clients. The hearts of most of East Jerusalemites, like the hearts of the Gazans and the residents of the West Bank, are in the same place: the 1967 borders, including, and primarily, Haram al-Sharif, which we call the Temple Mount. Partial substitutes such as the Gaza Strip and Jebel Mukaber bring their hearts closer to the 1948 borders.

If anyone needs a closer tie between body and heart, it is the decision makers in Israel post September 1993. The Oslo Accords brought the hearts of masses of Palestinians close to the solution of two states on both sides of the Green Line. Since then, the bodies of about 250,000 Israelis have wandered from the west side of this line to the east. Right now, at a time when Prime Minister Ehud Olmert has decided to freeze negotiations over Jerusalem, which the Palestinians consider the heart of the conflict, his friends in the associations of the extreme right are not sitting idle.

Extremist nationalist Jewish groups are taking over more and more houses in the heart of the Old City and in the neighborhoods of what is called the Holy Basin: Ras al-Amud, Silwan and Sheikh Jarrah. According to a Palestinian negotiating team document, this means adding 5,000 settlers to the 3,100 Jews living in 17 neighborhoods in the Old City, and in the ring surrounding it.

Within a year this sensitive and important area, the center of the political, cultural, religious and economic life of the Palestinians, will be finally severed from the rest of the territories. From its body, but not its heart.

Peace is not a program "by popular request" - today Gaza, tomorrow Jebel Mukaber, and the day after, anything is possible. Security cannot bought on sale. In our conflict the price is set. There are no discounts and no installments.
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Military in denial
IDF chief Ashkenazi refuses to believe IDF troops harmed Gaza civilians in cold blood.
Coalitional contention
Labor demands chairmanship of key Knesset committee promised to Lieberman.
  1.   This article makes no sense!! 10:26  |  Dr Eric 10/03/08
  2.   Haaretz = Voice of Hamas!! 10:29  |  Dr eric 10/03/08
  3.   Fatah has no way to regain control of the gaza! 10:32  |  dr eric 10/03/08
  4.   The Gaza is Egypts problem!! 10:38  |  Dr Eric 10/03/08
  5.   TAKE THE GAZA OUT OF THE PALESTINIAN EQUATION!!! 10:43  |  Dr Eric 10/03/08
  6.   Even after we pay the price, they want more 11:31  |  Burned Liberal 10/03/08
  7.   I don`t understand what gave Jews the 11:52  |  kiwi girl 10/03/08
  8.   Kiwi girl is right! 12:30  |  US CITIZEN 10/03/08
  9.   Kiwi Girl,return 300.000 Samoans to their NZ citizenship! 12:43  |  Absolute Sweden 10/03/08
  10.   # 7 kiwi girl 12:49  |  guy 10/03/08
  11.   #10 guy 13:07  |  chris 10/03/08
  12.   #7 kiwi girl needs a dictionary and a history book 13:24  |  v hardman 10/03/08
  13.   Esoteric... 13:25  |  Esther 10/03/08
  14.   #8 US Citizen is a dolt 13:28  |  Johnboy 10/03/08
  15.   To Kiwi Girl 13:31  |  Proud Israeli 10/03/08
  16.   To Johnboy 13:40  |  Proud Israeli 10/03/08
  17.   not so esoteric; one thinks 14:01  |  khairi janbek 10/03/08
  18.   #16 And if pigs can fly...... 14:03  |  Johnboy 10/03/08
  19.   "No discounts and no installments" - catching but stripped 14:10  |  Bader S Abu-Ghosh 10/03/08
  20.   Kiwi Girl 14:32  |  Kiwi Boy 10/03/08
  21.   To Johnboy: Answer #2 14:40  |  Proud Israeli 10/03/08
  22.   This article says everything... 14:44  |  Meyer 10/03/08
  23.   (Repeated attempt at) first reply to Johnboy 14:48  |  Proud Israeli 10/03/08
  24.   Proud Israel offers no productive thoughts 14:55  |  Ibrahim 10/03/08
  25.   This article says everything...Part 2 14:57  |  Meyer 10/03/08
  26.   This article says everything...Part 3 14:59  |  Meyer 10/03/08
  27.   citizenship-for kiwi girl 15:09  |  nina 10/03/08
  28.   This article says everything...Part 4 15:09  |  Meyer 10/03/08
  29.   This article says everything...Part 5 15:10  |  Meyer 10/03/08
  30.   Johnboy found the solution! 15:16  |  nina 10/03/08
  31.   Reply to Ibrahim 15:18  |  Proud Israeli 10/03/08
  32.   Akiva Eldar should go live in Sderot & enjoy the peace he created 15:41  |  Yael 10/03/08
  33.   For Burned Liberal # 6 15:57  |  Clickfool 10/03/08
  34.   Proud Israel should read the New Testament 16:10  |  Ibrahim 10/03/08
  35.   By this logic, they will continue to kill until Israel disappears 16:17  |  McQueen 10/03/08
  36.   Question to Ibrahim 16:28  |  Proud Israeli 10/03/08
  37.   Any other state than Israel would expel the Palestinians 17:03  |  Bo 10/03/08
  38.   Fatah Charter. 17:22  |  Ibrahim 10/03/08
  39.   Re: Fatah Charter 17:58  |  Proud Israeli 10/03/08
  40.   Ibrahim 18:00  |  Meyer 10/03/08
  41.   To Mr Eldar. They want all of Israel 18:05  |  Altalena 10/03/08
  42.   to kiwi girl and Guy, the argument is based on whole heck of a 18:07  |  JJ 10/03/08
  43.   Ibrahim, militant actions and charter run 18:16  |  JJ 10/03/08
  44.   what is the author`s point? 18:22  |  nahum 10/03/08
  45.   think about what ur saying yael 18:29  |  to mrs yael 10/03/08
  46.   think first 18:34  |  to kiwi girl 10/03/08
  47.   MR. ELDAR, IN THEIR HEARTS, NO JEWS SHOULD BE IN ISRAEL 18:42  |  Jorge 10/03/08
  48.   Akiva, Israel needs your security, just as it needs idiots... 18:52  |  Misha 10/03/08
  49.   Request to Mr. Eldar 19:34  |  Proud Israeli 10/03/08
  50.   Akiva Eldar is correct 19:43  |  marco 10/03/08
  51.   To Dr.Eric,# 4 21:10  |  Michael 10/03/08
  52.   The US & EU shouldn`t be supporting those shameless land thieves 21:33  |  Dutch 10/03/08
  53.   "son of Man" 22:00  |  Rozz 10/03/08
  54.   JJ, spare me the sillyness 22:15  |  Ibrahim 10/03/08
  55.   "Clickfool" - a well chosen description 22:39  |  South African Rabbi 10/03/08
  56.   Lamed! 22:57  |  Paul 10/03/08
  57.   Gaza, Eastern Jerusalem and the Westbank.... 23:02  |  Fritz T. 10/03/08
  58.   OR HOW ABOUT THIS ONE? 23:24  |  Rozz 10/03/08
  59.   Just an addition 23:37  |  Rozz 10/03/08
  60.   until pals stop terror Israel free to build and live in her land 23:38  |  don 10/03/08
  61.   #30 No doubt you do, nina 23:50  |  Johnboy 10/03/08
  62.   Burned Libral: Twisted Truth 23:56  |  pal 10/03/08
  63.   58. your Ezekiel quote is incomplete 00:12  |  anangryjew 11/03/08
  64.   52. EU - no need to boycott Israel 00:16  |  Euro-Jew 11/03/08
  65.   Dream on Pal, dream on! 00:18  |  Rozz 11/03/08
  66.   55. South African Rabbi 00:25  |  anangryjew 11/03/08
  67.   #57 Fritz T 00:30  |  Rozz 11/03/08
  68.   # 63 Anangryjew 01:23  |  Rozz 11/03/08
  69.   And what price will the Palestinians pay, Eldar? No refugees! 01:36  |  McQueen 11/03/08
  70.   History belongs to the victor 01:42  |  Jeff 11/03/08
  71.   Peace will cost more than Israel wants to pay 02:09  |  Zaf 11/03/08
  72.   This is totally insane. It reads like very poor satire. 02:14  |  Chaim 11/03/08
  73.   Help The Jewish People by Helping Pals 02:40  |  One111 11/03/08
  74.   Is this article so smart that I can`t understand it? 03:00  |  Fortuna Benmayor 11/03/08
  75.   Israel still plays the "victim" 03:19  |  betz55 11/03/08
  76.   no discounts 03:30  |  Shmuelshachor 11/03/08
  77.   To Betz55 04:28  |  South African Rabbi 11/03/08
  78.   kiwi girl 05:41  |  dan 11/03/08
  79.   Fortuna on smarts - 1st try 06:01 HT 06:01  |  BBSNews 11/03/08
  80.   This is not your land 06:15  |  Joe F 11/03/08
  81.   Hey,an earthquake is potentially about to hit Israel,Gaza and 06:41  |  An observer 11/03/08
  82.   Betz55 Thank you 07:21  |  pal 11/03/08
  83.   This talkback thread is as funny as....... 07:26  |  Johnboy 11/03/08
  84.   H21 Proud Israeli - the basis of your State... 08:35  |  Benjamin B, 11/03/08
  85.   world pressure 08:41  |  zecharia 11/03/08
  86.   Olmert and clique still in Government? 09:59  |  Rozz 11/03/08
  87.   Eldar-the darling of Israel`s haters 10:18  |  CS 11/03/08
  88.   G-d and Abraham (Genesis) 10:29  |  Rozz 11/03/08
  89.   Eldar correct: 1967 borders for peace! 10:45  |  Ivar 11/03/08
  90.   68. Rozz 11:04  |  anangryjew 11/03/08
  91.   ISAAC - and not Ishmael! 11:14  |  Rozz 11/03/08
  92.   to Johnboy#61 11:46  |  nina 11/03/08
  93.   #81 Jus ad bellum and Jus in bello, nina 12:44  |  Johnboy 11/03/08
  94.   anangryarab... anangryjew? 15:51  |  Rozz 11/03/08
  95.   Arab, Jew or German - what`s it matter? 09:36  |  ahuman 12/03/08
  96.   Peace should not be the goal 22:46  |  Jenny 25/03/09
 Read & React
IDF: 600 Hamas men, 309 civilians died in Gaza offensive
Responses: 239
Obama: Peace won't be easier under Netanyahu, but just as necessary
Responses: 117
Religious IDF troops walk out of event featuring woman singer
Responses: 121


More Headlines
22:47 Hamas: We've resumed Shalit talks with Israel
21:35 Medical panel: Anthrax experiments on IDF soldiers were unjustified
19:52 Israel's UN ambassador: Netanyahu committed to peace
22:19 Palestinian children sing for Holocaust survivors
19:34 Rights group: Hamas tortured Gaza inmate to death
20:04 Rights group: Israel made illegal use of phosphorus shells in Gaza
21:58 Israeli archeologists find 1,500-year-old Byzantine bathhouse
23:11 WATCH: Daily news round-up from Israel
17:15 MI chief: Iran has crossed nuclear bomb threshold
17:16 Assad says Syria-Israel talks depend on clear U.S. position
18:02 IDF soldier hurt in Jordan Valley shooting-range accident
19:44 Syria offers to help Obama pull troops from Iraq
16:47 6 Danes convicted of selling T-shirts to fund Palestinian terror
19:02 Vatican official to rededicate menorah honoring Holocaust victims
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Spring Specials-Dan Hotels
Jerusalem from 179$. Tel-Aviv from 223$. Herzliya from 336$
Dead Sea Skin Care
Quality cosmetics from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 12% off!
Camp Kimama Israel 2009
The best place for your children this summer
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
Jewish Singles Personal Ads
Find the love of your life on JDate.com
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | | Israel 2009 election results
Site rules | Makom: Engaging on Israel | Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved