Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., February 26, 2008 Adar1 20, 5768 | | Israel Time: 10:17 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Advertising
Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 10:03 21/02/2008
Kosovo is already here
By Israel Harel
Tags: Kosovo

Kosovo's declaration of independence has sparked concern in certain circles in Israel. The day may not be far off when the Arabs of Galilee start clamoring for political independence, too. In recent years, many of them have been cutting themselves off, psychologically and physically, from the Jewish-democratic State of Israel.

The Muslims of Kosovo constitute an absolute majority of the population, and the same is true for the Galilee Arabs. Quite a few Jews have been leaving the Galilee, especially since October 2000, and not many are joining the sparse Jewish population there, despite an array of financial incentives. The events in Kosovo have triggered memories of the thousands who took part in the violence in Wadi Ara in 2000, blocking major traffic arteries and cutting off access to Jewish communal settlements in an outbreak of rioting that coincided with Yasser Arafat's war of terror.

Memories come rushing back on the use of live ammunition in some cases, and the operation of an underground and terror cells alongside the suicide bombers dispatched from Gaza, Judea and Samaria.
Advertisement
Demonstrations where the Palestinian flag is raised in protest - on the anniversary of Arafat's death, for example - have become commonplace on campuses in Israel, especially at the University of Haifa. In the Galilee and Haifa, Arab intellectuals and public figures have compiled documents known as "The Vision," in which they reject Israel as a Jewish state and the homeland of the Jewish people.

Before the Annapolis summit, delegates of all the Israeli Arab organizations convened in Nazareth and reached a unanimous decision to call upon Mahmoud Abbas not to cooperate with Ehud Olmert and recognize Israel as a Jewish state. A delegation of Arab Knesset members was sent to meet with the Palestinian negotiators to ensure that the message had sunk in. If the Arab citizens of Israel vehemently oppose recognizing Israel as the Jewish homeland, said MK Ahmed Tibi to Abu Ala (Ahmed Qurei), how can you, the representatives of the Palestinian people, even consider such a thing?

Israeli governments have resigned themselves to the blatant, unconcealed separatist actions of the Galilee Arabs, and this only perpetuates the phenomenon. Shimon Peres, who was appointed by several governments to oversee measures ultimately aimed at increasing the Jewish presence in the Galilee, talked a lot but did little. Political correctness, such as halting the campaign to "Judaize Galilee," was his guideline.

All the authorities, including those in charge of law enforcement, have resigned themselves to criminal acts ("juvenile delinquency," the police chief of the Northern District calls the phenomenon of stones thrown at Jewish vehicles, especially near Hamovil Junction), such as encroaching on state land and illegal construction that has reached the scope of tens of thousands of buildings.

Kosovo is already here, even without a formal declaration of independence. Looking at the government's mode of conduct in the periphery, and even its response to the Qassam rockets in the south, one realizes the futility of expecting it to wake up and fight against those who are challenging Israeli sovereignty in the Galilee.

The leaders of this separatist policy in the Israeli Arab community know very well that apathy and lack of self-confidence also characterize the approach of the agencies of the state - the police, the courts, the Israel Lands Administration, the tax authorities and the Ministry of the Interior - in their dealings with the Arab public. This only increases the motivation to gnaw further at Israeli authority and sovereignty.

Unlike the Kosovars in the Balkans, who are satisfied with their separatist province and do not claim ownership over all Serbian territory, the Arabs of the Galilee, and certainly the northern wing of the Islamic Movement, claim ownership - political and territorial - over all of Israel. The "salami method" pays off.

In the Negev, the Bedouins are taking over large stretches of land almost without hindrance, while Israel's do-nothing government responds by establishing committees to "sort out" the land issues. The most recent of them is the committee chaired by Judge Eliezer Goldberg, which is now convening.

This inertia will probably continue, with the Zionist state financing, via education, health, national insurance and other state monies transferred to citizens, a population that is de facto establishing a Palestinian state within the sovereign State of Israel - separate, of course, from the Palestinian state that the Arabs are pushing for in Judea and Samaria.
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Personalized workout
Boutique gyms is the next big thing - for those who can pay.
No to non-violence
'Human chain' against the blockade on gaza yields disappointing turnout.
  1.   Burning Jewish homes in Peknin unpunished,AG Mazuz&Co hinder any 10:32  |  Absolute Sweden 21/02/08
  2.   Yisrael Harel the consummate panic-monger... 10:56  |  Esther 21/02/08
  3.   Does the world feel guilty Part 2 11:20  |  Hastaroth 21/02/08
  4.   Utter nonsense 11:32  |  Fadi (Israeli Arab) 21/02/08
  5.   Mr. Harel 12:21  |  l 21/02/08
  6.   Do not trust them. 12:30  |  Jean Van Daem 21/02/08
  7.   Amen Esther! 12:32  |  Eleni 21/02/08
  8.   We need Moshe Feiglin as PM - he will fix the Gallil Arabs 12:55  |  Pro Manhigut Yehudit 21/02/08
  9.   Gevalt! (1) 12:58  |  zeev 21/02/08
  10.   The matter is simple 13:00  |  Said 21/02/08
  11.   Statistics + Time = Israel Undermined 13:09  |  Stonemason 21/02/08
  12.   Is This Road Map 3 States Solution Or 2 ? Or What ? 13:26  |  Joseph . E 21/02/08
  13.   jordan the arab palestine awaits them all 13:30  |  v hardman 21/02/08
  14.   This is a racist rant 13:33  |  Billy boy 21/02/08
  15.   Gevalt! - (2) 13:36  |  zeev 21/02/08
  16.   Israel is South Africa 13:38  |  Kosohoes 21/02/08
  17.   WAY TO GO PALESTINIAN PEOPLE 13:58  |  indrajaya 21/02/08
  18.   Kosovo is here 14:06  |  Hilda 21/02/08
  19.   16: Yes Kosohoes, we`ve finally gained freedom 14:16  |  David Teich 21/02/08
  20.   Harel as Irredentist/Ethic Nationalist pt 1 14:43  |  Dorothy 21/02/08
  21.   Harel as Irredentist/Ethic Nationalist pt 2 14:45  |  Dorothy 21/02/08
  22.   5th column 14:52  |  dav zee 21/02/08
  23.   To dav see 15:20  |  Mark B. 21/02/08
  24.   Harel Sees the Urgency of Transfer 15:26  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/02/08
  25.   This will be Israel`s demise 15:47  |  Ron 21/02/08
  26.   Kosovo in Israel 16:12  |  Naim S. Mahlab 21/02/08
  27.   Pledge of Allegiance to Revocation to Deportation 16:17  |  B 21/02/08
  28.   Birds of a feather flock together 16:30  |  Natallie Durson 21/02/08
  29.   How to solve the two Kosovo problems Israel is facing 16:44  |  Tosefta 21/02/08
  30.   ISRAELI POLITICAL SHORT SIGHTEDNESS PT 1 16:57  |  zionist forever 21/02/08
  31.   Kosovo is a "unique" situation under the law 17:09  |  Ethel 21/02/08
  32.   US/NATO WAR On Serb CHRISTIANS. We Bombed the Wrong Side (1) 17:11  |  Linda Rivera 21/02/08
  33.   ISRAELI POLITICAL SHORT SIGHTEDNESS PT 2 17:13  |  zionist forever 21/02/08
  34.   US/NATO WAR On CHRISTIANS. We Bombed the Wrong Side (2) 17:16  |  Linda Rivera 21/02/08
  35.   US/NATO WAR On CHRISTIANS. We Bombed the Wrong Side (3) 17:19  |  Linda Rivera 21/02/08
  36.   20 17:27  |  zionist forever 21/02/08
  37.   Britain: Immigrants Declare: "IT`S MUSLIM LAND" (1) 17:29  |  Linda Rivera 21/02/08
  38.   Too bad that hindsight is better than foresight... 17:33  |  bat yam 21/02/08
  39.   Britain: Immigrants Declare: "IT`S MUSLIM LAND" (2) 17:34  |  Linda Rivera 21/02/08
  40.   Yesterday the demographic bomb, today a state within a state! 17:37  |  DrumDrum 21/02/08
  41.   How true, how true. Too bad very few are listening. 17:39  |  common sense 21/02/08
  42.   Number 4 Kol Hakavod 17:46  |  Ussishkin 21/02/08
  43.   Trash Talk 17:48  |  TimothyL 21/02/08
  44.   21 17:48  |  zionist forever 21/02/08
  45.   21 17:48  |  zionist forever 21/02/08
  46.   inevitable... 17:57  |  ravi 21/02/08
  47.   to David Teich #19 18:06  |  zeev 21/02/08
  48.   Israeli Arabs selective memory how convinient 18:27  |  Ferragamo 21/02/08
  49.   Legalise Settlers by sending them to Galillee 18:31  |  Palestinian Brit 21/02/08
  50.   Orwellian - the robbed are now the robbers ? 18:31  |  David 21/02/08
  51.   Kosovo is already here 18:35  |  Dragan RAKIC 21/02/08
  52.   Why dont they refuse to accept Child Allowance benefits?? 18:39  |  Avi 21/02/08
  53.   # 52 They should be given one way ticket out of Israel instead 19:38  |  Misha 21/02/08
  54.   10 Said,good short analysis;let me add to it! 19:56  |  lakshmi 21/02/08
  55.   Tax money 20:09  |  pal 21/02/08
  56.   53 20:50  |  zionist forever 21/02/08
  57.   Israel? Kosovo? 20:53  |  P. J. Casey 21/02/08
  58.   The case for Kosovo independence 21:04  |  Ethel 21/02/08
  59.   #55 Zionist forever 21:08  |  tbora 21/02/08
  60.   There`s some truth to this 21:13  |  B 21/02/08
  61.   Ethel you are wrong 22:05  |  Here is why 21/02/08
  62.   = 22:18  |  fred 21/02/08
  63.   Paranoia 22:22  |  Danite 21/02/08
  64.   #28 Sounds a Racist 22:29  |  Natallie Durson 21/02/08
  65.   Orthodox Jews are most likely to try to establish 22:31  |  Jozef 21/02/08
  66.   but why can`t Israeli Arabs have cultural independence? 22:36  |  Israeli guy 21/02/08
  67.   I meant ETHNIC nationalist- sorry. 22:55  |  Dorothy 21/02/08
  68.   US Israel, Kosovo Palestinians 23:25  |  John I aka Yussef 21/02/08
  69.   Kosovar Designs on All Serbia: They May Have Them 23:29  |  Efox 21/02/08
  70.   First they came for Jordan, then they came for Judea and Samaria 23:35  |  Efox 21/02/08
  71.   5th colimn-like Napoleon said 23:41  |  redondo 21/02/08
  72.   Xenophobia 23:58  |  Ethel 21/02/08
  73.   Real Jews should declare Jewish Independant state in 00:15  |  John the Priest 22/02/08
  74.   Israeli Guy 00:39  |  Eitan 22/02/08
  75.   #3 00:56  |  Farida 22/02/08
  76.   if arabs from Galilee declare indepence thats fine 03:02  |  paulo2005 22/02/08
  77.   didn`t meir kahane warn us,that this would happen 04:40  |  chaim 22/02/08
  78.   Kudos. Israel has no future as an occupational apartheid state. 05:23  |  POP 22/02/08
  79.   Misses the Point 07:08  |  ARTH 22/02/08
  80.   Misses the Point 07:13  |  ARTH 22/02/08
  81.   Misses the Point #2 07:17  |  ARTH 22/02/08
  82.   #43 07:45  |  ARTH 22/02/08
  83.   Only When the Druze Wake Up 08:10  |  LebaneseDruzeWarrior 22/02/08
  84.   HELP ME I AM IN LOVE WITH NATALIE DURSON 08:48  |  Atilla Karagözoğlu 22/02/08
  85.   To 72 08:53  |  Kosovo is Serbia 22/02/08
  86.   NATALIE dURSON i LOVE YOU POETRY #28 PLESE MARRY ME 08:55  |  Atilla Karagözoğlu 22/02/08
  87.   I WANT TO BE FREE AND FLY LIKE A BIRD, LIKE A BIRD 08:56  |  Atilla Karagözoğlu 22/02/08
  88.   Incitment through nonesense 09:38  |  Lobo08 22/02/08
  89.   TOO FEW DIASPORA JEWS EMIGRATE TO ISRAEL 21:24  |  Anthony Fallon 22/02/08
  90.   Who Will Build the Galillee? 22:32  |  Jeremy 22/02/08
  91.   Almost comic 04:16  |  Colin Wright 23/02/08
  92.   democracy 16:06  |  honestly 23/02/08
  93.   Kosovo is already here 00:59  |  Paul 24/02/08
  94.   47: Poor Zeev, same broken chord 09:47  |  David Teich 26/02/08
  95.   91: Colin Wright still in denial 09:51  |  David Teich 26/02/08
 Today Online
Yoel Marcus: Annihilating Israel truly is Iran's goal
Send response
Nazir Majali: Why is Israel destroying its Egypt ties?
Responses: 9
Canadian Jew loses bid to have 'Jerusalem, Israel' in passport
Responses: 135
Obama`s top adviser: Israel and Arabs must negotiate own peace
Responses: 163
Akiva Eldar: AIPAC does not even bother to rally for two-state solution
Responses: 87


More Headlines
09:42 High Court upholds Katsav sex crimes plea bargain
07:55 Iran ordered to pay $33 million to murdered Israeli diplomat's family
07:39 ANALYSIS: In the end blood was shed in Sderot, not Gaza
10:08 Will Obama be supportive of an Israel controlled by a Likud government?
02:13 Report: Widow of slain Hezbollah terrorist blames Syria for killing
06:46 Store manager fined for employing Jewish workers on Shabbat
07:26 Israeli diplomat postpones meeting after Costa Rica recognizes Palestinian state
06:22 Iran UN envoy: Exiled group feeding U.S. lies on weapons plan
03:08 Olmert aides: Demonstration in Gaza 'much ado about nothing'
06:06 Australian soccer player to be disciplined for dressing as Hitler
08:35 Vets mend sea turtle's limb in first operation of its kind in Israel
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Long-term Israel programs
MASA is your gateway. More programs. More grants.
7589 rockets fired so far
HELP US TO HELP THEM
Marina Royale Herzelia Pituach
Your Luxurious Suite While Staying in Israel
Fattal Hotel Chain
Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel
Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th
Dead Sea Salt
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved