Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., August 09, 2008 Av 8, 5768 | | Israel Time: 05:04 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
French President Nicolas Sarkozy. (Reuters)
Last update - 21:41 19/02/2008
ANALYSIS: Sarkozy's Holocaust education plan baffles Jews
By Daniel Ben-Simon, Haaretz Correspondent
Tags: CRIF, France, Holocaust 

A week after Nicolas Sarkozy launched his revolutionary proposal to reform Holocaust education, France is still in turmoil. The president has gotten more and more deeply embroiled in a raucous political debate, which has spread to right-wing as well as left-wing parties and social movements.

But the controversy is most markedly felt in the Jewish community, which is in disarray over the contentious preoccupation with the Holocaust heritage.

It actually started on a good note. For the first time in the history of the Fifth Republic the president himself attended last week's annual dinner of the Representative Council of Jewish Institutions in France (CRIF). Sarkozy's predecessors, although generally supportive of the Jewish community, thought attending the event in person might be perceived as encouraging sectarianism.
Advertisement
To much applause, Sarkozy spoke highly of his country's renewed honeymoon with Israel. Toward the end of his keynote speech, he said he intends to raise the profile of the memory of the Holocaust, by having 11-year-old schoolchildren 'adopt' a Jewish child of the same age who perished in the Holocaust.

During the Nazi occupation, several hundred French Jewish children were transported to concentration camps and murdered.

"Nothing is more exciting for a child," the president said, "than the story of a child of the same age, who played the same games and had the same dreams, but was unfortunate enough to be born Jewish in the 1940s."

The guests were overwhelmed with excitement and gave him a standing ovation. One woman, sitting at the president's table, remained seated. Simone Veil, a Holocaust survivor and a former right-wing minister, could not believe her ears.

Later that night, she expressed her amazement at the president's proposal. "It is inconceivable and unfair," Veil, the chairwoman of the Foundation for the Memory of the Shoah in France, told reporters. "We can't do this to a 10-year-old. It's impossible to ask a child of that age to relate to a dead person. It would be unbearable for them."

The next day, Sarkozy's idea was extensively debated in the media and in political circles. He was continuously accused of traumatizing innocent children. The chairman of the Socialist Party suggested scrapping the proposal and holding a thorough debate in the National Assembly and among teachers and headmasters to study its prospective impact on young children.

Jean-Marie Le Pen, the leader of the extreme right, was fuming. Having referred in the past to the gas chambers as a footnote in the Second World War, he said that the proposal is morally abhorrent and psychologically criminal.

"The poor children will feel guilty and break down," he added.

The controversy around the memory of the Holocaust seems to have embarrassed the country's Jewish organizations. They said that they find the presence of such a sensitive subject in the media spotlight very difficult. Some of them have said, off the record, that the president should have consulted more people before making a decision.

Sarkozy has been toying with this idea for a few years. As interior minister under Jacques Chirac he was astonished by the number of anti-Semitic incidents. He told his associates at the time that he believes the best way to combat racism is education. Shortly after his election as president, he asked his interior minister to promote a Holocaust education program based on personal stories of young victims.

The Elysee Palace was taken aback by the media noise the president's remarks instigated. His chief of staff said that they will shortly be reviewing ways to implement the proposal. "The president is determined to put his proposal into practice, but is also open to suggestions."

Commentators have said that if Sarkozy's approval ratings had not been so low, his proposal would have met a much wider support.

"In the miserable state he's in," wrote a Le Figaro columnist, "why wonder he's attracting fire wherever he goes?"

Related articles:
  • French President sparks row over religion, Holocaust studies
  • Sarkozy defends Holocaust education proposal amid uproar
  • French gov't softens Sarkozy plan to honor Holocaust victims
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Iranian row
    Rice on possible IDF Iran strike: U.S. has no veto over Israeli military operations.
    Hamas movie set
    Hamas transforms former Gaza settlement into movie production house.
      1.   Here`s a better idea 16:51  |  idf_sergeant 19/02/08
      2.   honeymoon with zion! what a happy thought!! 17:10  |  Assad-u-LLAH 19/02/08
      3.   Sarkozy 18:07  |  Avichai 19/02/08
      4.   Sarkozy`s idea is not baffling to Jews 18:25  |  Netanel 19/02/08
      5.   An appaling judgment.. 18:41  |  Kris 19/02/08
      6.   11,000 out of 100,000? 18:47  |  DJStahl 19/02/08
      7.   correct the figure 18:55  |  Daniel 19/02/08
      8.   To #2 Assad u-LLAH 19:23  |  Jeremy 19/02/08
      9.   Will lessons be applied training on Zionists?Enroll me! 19:33  |  Tayfun_Turkey 19/02/08
      10.   to DJStahl 21:07  |  Daniel 19/02/08
      11.   Jeremy You are correct! 21:24  |  Euro 19/02/08
      12.   11. euro and jeremy two self serving joos or one? 21:44  |  Assad-u-LLAH 19/02/08
      13.   Assad-u-LLAH - Yet another Arab in Denial! 21:59  |  Paul Wood 19/02/08
      14.   idf sarge 22:01  |  lola 19/02/08
      15.   Asad-ulahh never heard about tolerance 22:17  |  Abu Yusuf 19/02/08
      16.   Re #10 the numbers 22:39  |  DJStahl 19/02/08
      17.   DJ stahl dont provide jewish sources 23:17  |  doggystyle 19/02/08
      18.   to dj stahl ( ur a joke) 23:19  |  raw truth 19/02/08
      19.   President Sarkozy Holocaust education plan 23:20  |  aaron Levy 19/02/08
      20.   13. what a really stupid thing to say Paul Wooden head 23:23  |  Assad-u-LLAH 19/02/08
      21.   Sarkozy. 23:25  |  Maureen Ann 19/02/08
      22.   HAARETZ - WHY 23:43  |  Jeremy 19/02/08
      23.   20. Maureen Ann 23:49  |  whoopsie 19/02/08
      24.   To Euro, #11 23:56  |  Jeremy 19/02/08
      25.   re #16 the numbers 00:01  |  Daniel 20/02/08
      26.   jeremy you are a liar and a cry baby 00:10  |  Assad-u-LLAH 20/02/08
      27.   #9 Tayfun Turkey 00:45  |  Boris 20/02/08
      28.   Who cares? All that matters is that he supports Israel, right? 01:19  |  peacelover 20/02/08
      29.   haha 01:37  |  koen 20/02/08
      30.   Mrs. Veil forgets that this is what ... 01:37  |  Edith 20/02/08
      31.   Im sure if they were Christian Frenchman 02:08  |  B. 20/02/08
      32.   Here`s a better idea 02:20  |  Abe 20/02/08
      33.   Own goal for Holocaust Industry 02:29  |  Chalanau, Tova 20/02/08
      34.   Sarkozy 02:45  |  Shem 20/02/08
      35.   No More "White Guilt" that era is over! 03:31  |  Dan Theman 20/02/08
      36.   Re #18 raw truth 06:06  |  DJStahl 20/02/08
      37.   "THE MEDIA SPOTLIGHT" -very revealing 06:19  |  PADDY 20/02/08
      38.   sarkozy2 06:27  |  Shem 20/02/08
      39.   The same project exists in Austria and works 11:21  |  Susi 20/02/08
      40.   I know why 12:49  |  O Camone 20/02/08
      41.   Sarkozy`s Holocaust education plan 16:51  |  Jill RG 20/02/08
      42.   Not Ever 17:21  |  Tim 20/02/08
      43.   A better idea 18:43  |  Rich 20/02/08
      44.   Uh oh - research... 19:54  |  CDM 20/02/08
      45.   Sarkozy`s Holocaust Proposal 00:26  |  Eric Weis 23/02/08
      46.   Holocaust 12:18  |  Naim S. Mahlab 09/05/08
      47.   Holocaust 07:44  |  bernard lindner 05/08/08
      48.   #! I agree. It`s about Victim Mentality 04:45  |  outsider 09/08/08
     Read & React
    Israel slams Turkey over Ahmadinejad plan to visit
    Responses: 100
    Israel: We'll hold Lebanon responsible for Hezbollah's actions
    Responses: 176
    PRC: Open crossings within 3 weeks or we'll end Gaza truce
    Responses: 55
    Ze'ev Sternhall: Burying the Jewish state between Hebron and Yitzhar
    Responses: 61
    Ultra-Orthodox 'Modesty Guard' suspected in beating of J'lem woman
    Responses: 81
    Rosner's Domain
    The reassuring candidacy of Eric Cantor (WTR)
    Congress likely to see record number of Jewish legislators
    Israel looking for leader and agenda, but finds neither
    On Peter Rodman, Lebanon and Syria


    More Headlines
    01:07 EU tightens sanctions against Iran over nuke program
    00:12 Peres joins 80 world leaders at Olympics opening ceremony
    01:28 Russia sends tanks into South Ossetia in bid to wrest control from Georgia
    03:10 Three-star middleman
    03:28 Anti-Semitic graffiti prompts Sarkozy's son to take legal action
    04:20 Controversial far-right leader Haider to head Austrian rightist faction
    21:58 'Israeli Miracle' is developing strong ties with Communist China
    03:43 U.S. Jewish lawyer accused of links to KKK wins racially-charged primary
    15:17 Israel at the Beijing Olympic Games
    17:00 Beijing can help stop Iran threat, Peres tells Jintao
    01:13 Police question Olmert for 5th time in graft probe
    15:04 Ultra-Orthodox 'Modesty Guard' suspected in beating of J'lem woman
    22:59 Bernie Brillstein, producer of 'The Muppets' and 'Ghostbusters,' dies at 77
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Fattal Hotel Chain
    Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
    Isaac Maimon at Dreamshoppe
    Special summer sale. Make an offer now. You will be surprised.
    MBA in Israel in English
    APPLY NOW! Limited spaces available
    Israel's Premier Real Estate Website
    www. israel-property.com
    Yossi Avrahami Presents:
    New Luxurious Projects in North Tel Aviv & Eilat
    Your vacation starts here
    Israel Travel Center Guaranteed Lowest Rates
    Hebrew Summer courses
    From $39.95
    ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel
    Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
    Real Estate in Israel | Travel to Israel with Haaretz | Hotels Israel | Restaurants Israel | Tourist attractions Israel | Shops Israel
    birthright Israel | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved