A harsh migration policy - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Wed., February 20, 2008 Adar1 14, 5768

Israel Time: 13:00 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Rosner's Domain

Diplomacy

Defense

Jewish World

Opinion

National

Print Edition

Advertising

Books

Arts & Leisure

Business

Real Estate

Easy Start

Travel

Week's End

Anglo File

Last update - 12:51 19/02/2008

A harsh migration policy

By Haaretz Editorial

Tags: Israel, refugees

Even as the Finance Ministry is drafting a plan to reduce the number of foreign workers in Israel, thousands of migrant laborers are pouring into the country from Africa across the wide-open Egyptian border. This irrationality makes us feel like we lack a government that functions, thinks, manages and cares. This is true in many areas, such as the uncontrolled takeover of state lands by individuals, including criminals. But it is particularly noticeable, in all its severity, in the current influx of thousands of refugees to public parks and shelters in Tel Aviv.

It seems that a policy on the absorption of migrant laborers is being formulated here only after the fact, and that it involves caving in to pressure from lobbyists and color stories in the papers. What is lacking is any consideration of the public welfare. Every ministry adopts a different position, and in the end, they make do with no policy at all. In a situation where it should demonstrate humanity, sensitivity and an open heart, the government is instead demonstrating harshness. The decision to absorb refugees and then abandon them to their fate is inhumane.

Also inhumane is the decision now being finalized by the Bank of Israel and the Finance Ministry for a sharp reduction in the number of work visas alloted to caregivers for the elderly. The idea that Israelis will take the places of Filipinos is ridiculous. Many elderly people who today enjoy round-the-clock care will be left abandoned, isolated and dependent on the kindness of their relatives, who cannot provide them with round-the-clock care.

	Advertisement

The 50,000 Filipinos employed in this capacity are not stealing jobs from Israelis, because there are no Israelis willing to devote themselves to such work. Instead of setting a standard under which every person 80 or older who wants round-the-clock care can have it, with no humiliating tests, the government intends to make things harder for such people by slashing the quota of Filipino workers to a fifth of their current number. This is the moment for the Pensioners Party to prove it has a reason to exist.

The migrant laborers and refugees who are coming by the thousands from Africa will apparently be employed under miserable conditions in agriculture, construction and service industries, thereby making a laughingstock of the welcome efforts to supervise the employment of foreign workers at fair wages. These migrants will live in inhuman conditions but will not complain for fear of being deported. Trafficking in cheap labor may already be taking place over the wide-open border with Egypt, far from the state's planning and enforcement agencies. The government must make it harder for most of these people to enter, while also improving the absorption of anyone it decides to allow in as a refugee. Any "middle road" is both stupid and cruel.

It is not clear why an Immigration Authority is being established when immigration policy is irrational and disconnected from Israeli society's true needs. Bureaucratic red tape is becoming typical of this authority even before it is established. From now on, every application to import foreign workers will require an economic opinion from the Industry, Trade and Employment Ministry and approval from the "Agenda Forum" - a joint body consisting of representatives from the treasury, the Prime Minister's Office, the Bank of Israel, the Welfare Ministry and the National Insurance Institute. And as the forms are being passed from office to office, the elderly will suffer from a cruel reduction in the number of Filipino workers, for whom there is no substitute, while thousands of Africans whose entry has not been approved by any forum continue to pour in over the southern border every year.

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	Intrigue at Heathrow
	According to the BBC, an IDF general dodged arrest as U.K. police feared shootout.


	Decency in remission
	A Ramat Yishai widow is suspected of faking cancer to receive donations.




1.	congratualtions! another bullshit	16:47	\|	no name	19/02/08

2.	I once got lost in Detroit	18:24	\|	Haredi	19/02/08

3.	migration policy	23:21	\|	j	19/02/08

4.	Who else will do this work?	11:48	\|	Ariella Cohen	20/02/08

Today Online


	Israel still building in settlements despite Olmert's promise
	Responses: 127


	Abbas aide: PA should mull declaring statehood like Kosovo
	Responses: 57


	Amira Hass: Israel is stealing Palestinian land, private or not
	Responses: 32


	Peace-minded residents of Gaza and Sderot share joint blog
	Responses: 21


	Uzi Benziman: Olmert thinks peace is a deed done through trickery
	Responses: 8

More Headlines
10:55 PA official: We should mull declaring statehood like Kosovo


12:54 Netanyahu: Olmert government taking measures to cede Jerusalem


09:18 Israel still building in West Bank settlements despite PM's pledge


11:20 Obama sweeps Wisconsin and Hawaii, securing 10 straight wins


11:37 MKs to fan out globally to warn of Iran threat


10:36 Beit Hakerem - The last secular holdout in Jerusalem


10:34 ANALYSIS: When it comes to Jerusalem, both sides are right


12:28 Winograd panel member questioned over political considerations


11:52 Comptroller: The president's bureau is not exempt from inspection


12:48 MKs to vote on law easing women's ability to get restraining orders


06:20 Sweden accused of persecuting civil servant for pro-Israel views


05:41 Business owners in north told to return Lebanon war compensation