Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., February 19, 2008 Adar1 13, 5768 | | Israel Time: 02:19 (EST+7) web haaretz.com   Back to Homepage Rosner's Domain Diplomacy Defense Jewish World Opinion National Print Edition Advertising Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File

Who's he kidding? By Akiva Eldar Tags: Sderot, Israel, PA  Essentially, the Sderot residents are a new version of "the victims of peace." Government spokesmen explain that an invasion of the Gaza Strip may strike a fatal blow to Mahmoud Abbas, the partner, because peace negotiations with the West Bank Palestinian leadership cannot take place under the shadow of scenes of hundreds of Palestinian casualties caused by an Israeli invasion of the Strip. On the other hand, a cease-fire with Hamas will be considered a victory for the group fighting Israel, and would boost its support among Palestinians at the expense of its Fatah rival. If Prime Minister Ehud Olmert is interested in nurturing the Palestinian partner and making it easier for him to reach an agreement, the Israeli citizens bordering the Gaza Strip must be secured, aided and supported. However, according to Olmert himself, and in light of the realities in the territories, the residents of Sderot are victims of a make-believe peace. If Olmert is telling the truth to Rabbi Ovadia Yosef and is not holding secret negotiations on the future of Jerusalem, he is lying to the entire world. The explanation he offered the Israeli journalists who accompanied him to Germany, regarding the delay of dealing with the status of Jerusalem, is an insult to the public's intelligence. Advertisement First, as Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni noted in a letter to Jerusalem city councillor Nir Barkat, Israel promised at Annapolis that the negotiations will include all core issues "with no exceptions." She also noted that it was agreed that "until everything is agreed upon - nothing is agreed." In other words, even if we agree on all the other issues, including borders and refugees - without an understanding on the issue of Jerusalem, these accords will not even be worth the paper they were drafted on. Second, without dealing with the question of Jerusalem it is impossible to hold a serious discussion on a two-state solution. Without drafting the borders of Jerusalem there is no way to draw the permanent borders between Israel and Palestine. The prime minister told the reporters that compared to the difficult issue that is Jerusalem, "the question of borders is the simplest of the core issues and there is a broad basis for its resolution." Really? Olmert would do well to ask Mahmoud Abbas next time they meet if he too considers Har Homa a neighborhood of Jerusalem. He will hear that Jabal Abu Ghneim, the original name of Har Homa, is a settlement that was established on land confiscated from the residents of the town of Beit Sahur, on the outskirts of Bethlehem. As far as the Palestinians are concerned there is no difference between the settlement of Psagot, on the outskirts of Ramallah, and the Jerusalem neighborhood of Pisgat Ze'ev, which sits on the road connecting Ramallah to East Jerusalem. In the best-case scenario, the Jewish neighborhoods in East Jerusalem that are outside the walls are, from the point of view of Palestinians, one of the "settlement blocs" that will be annexed to Israel in an exchange of territory. In the absence of agreement on the borders of the Jerusalem bloc, there is no way to reach agreement on which alternative land the Palestinians will receive or their size. Third, delaying the negotiations on the future of the Old City of Jerusalem in general and the Temple Mount in particular, narrows the room the sides have to maneuver on other core issues. Olmert's argument that, "If we do not want to reach an impasse immediately it is best to begin negotiations on other things," was introduced more than seven years ago. The decision of then premier Ehud Barak to hold separate talks on each of the core issues is one of the reasons for the failure of Camp David II. On the basis of the information he had at the time, in exchange for Israeli flexibility on the sensitive issue of the Old City of Jerusalem, the Palestinians were willing to show flexibility on the sensitive issue of the right of return. In the end, the negotiations collapsed because Jerusalem was pushed to the bottom of the list. Let us assume that the threat posed by Shas over dissolving the government dictates to Olmert the conditions of the negotiations for a final-status settlement, and Abbas will have to postpone his wishes on Jerusalem. What is the prime minister offering his partners in exchange for such a painful concession? How does he intend to bolster Fatah's standing, as the organization is struggling with Hamas for the hearts and minds of the Palestinians? Olmert says that "it is best to begin with other things." What "things"? How many times is it possible to promise to lift roadblocks, evacuate outposts and release thousands of prisoners? No, the residents of Sderot are not "the victims of peace." They are victims of the same pathetic standstill of a government lacking direction, just looking to survive. Bookmark to del.icio.us   Artistic justice Israel Museum to exhibit art looted by Nazis and unclaimed. Let in snow For second time this winter, Jerusalem braces for snow.   1.   It`s The Settlers and Relgeos Fanatics 06:44  |  Robert B 18/02/08   2.   akiva eldar is the journalist with the least credibility 10:08  |  avi sela 18/02/08   3.   TIME TO LEAVE, NOT TO NEGOTIATE 10:10  |  indrajaya 18/02/08   4.   akiva on the road to perdition all alone 10:24  |  v hardman 18/02/08   5.   victim of piece 10:28  |  jojo 18/02/08   6.   akiva eldar is right 100% 10:31  |  ralph is back 18/02/08   7.   Akiva Eldar you have written a wonderful 10:36  |  kiwi girl 18/02/08   8.   Everyone knows peace agreement is Israel`s lowest priority 10:43  |  Chanalau, Tova 18/02/08   9.   Ughh...more surrender strategy from an "elitist" Jew 10:54  |  SLAVO 18/02/08   10.   NEGOTIATIONS COST JEWISH LIVES!STOP TALK OF SURRENDER IMMEDIATELY 10:54  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 18/02/08   11.   Who are you kidding Akiva ?? 11:23  |  Avrohom G 18/02/08   12.   NO NEGOCIATIONS. JERUSALEM IS PALESTINIAN 12:04  |  TripleJump 18/02/08   13.   Who`s he kidding - Jerusalem 12:17  |  Jacques 18/02/08   14.   Agree 100%. J`lem must come first, but not for those reasons. 12:18  |  Dr. L. Brnd 18/02/08   15.   Dr L.Brnd good luck 12:34  |  Palestinian Prince 18/02/08   16.   #12 triple jump has lost a p! still remains an idiot 13:42  |  v hardman 18/02/08   17.   # 4 vAmen!!! Let the Pals move back home, Jordon, Egypt, etc. 13:46  |  Petra 18/02/08   18.   just say it.... 13:53  |  ravi 18/02/08   19.   Birth of Christ 14:01  |  for all ppl 18/02/08   20.   A Government Based On Lies, Deception and Fraud 14:55  |  Yaakov Sullivan 18/02/08   21.   Israel As An Agent of Destabilisation 15:01  |  Yaakov Sullivan 18/02/08   22.   Al Quds is ours. Las Vegas is yours. 15:20  |  Raed Kami 18/02/08   23.   20/21 yaakov in despair the lights in new york have gone out 15:26  |  v hardman 18/02/08   24.   avis sela`s credibility 15:33  |  A.M. 18/02/08   25.   #Answer to a non elitist 15:40  |  A.M. 18/02/08   26.   Thanks Aqaba Elder, but No Thanks 16:12  |  B 18/02/08   27.   ravi "israel wants it all" 16:15  |  guru nanak 18/02/08   28.   # 4 V. Hardman @ Belfast / Northern Ireland 16:19  |  Joseph . E 18/02/08   29.   Agree with Akiva Eldar, but what about Shas? 16:24  |  Smadar 18/02/08   30.   be nice to the Croc. and nothing will happen 16:33  |  Wake up Nitwit 18/02/08   31.   joseph e for such an erudite person 16:35  |  v hardman 18/02/08   32.   The Palestinians already have a state 16:54  |  Bo 18/02/08   33.   Jerusalem Issue Is Intractable 18:48  |  Norman F Birnberg 18/02/08   34.   I predict American Tax Payers will dump this country overboard 18:50  |  Dutch 18/02/08   35.   More self delusional tales from an idiot who supported Itnatkut 20:10  |  Ronny 18/02/08   36.   Please ignore my patient. I have recently increased his dose 20:12  |  Eldar`s Psychiatrist 18/02/08   37.   Hope 20:26  |  pal 18/02/08

Today Online Bradley Burston: Anti-Zionism as a form of racism Responses: 266 Foreign Min. expected to slam Iran anti-Israel jibe in missive to UN Responses: 235 Top diplomat: Calling Sderot-Gaza violence 'cycle' may breed terror Responses: 114 Anshel Pfeffer: Are Israeli policies risking the lives of Diaspora Jews? Responses: 60 Abbas rejects PM call to defer talks on Jerusalem Responses: 87 Report: Progress made in Shalit prisoner swap deal Responses: 35 More Headlines 23:45 FM: Ending peace talks now would bolster Hamas 02:18 Lebanon braces itself for possible Hezbollah attack on Israel 23:45 Foreign Ministry said to slam Iranian anti-Israel jibe in missive to UN 22:05 Nine Qassams hit Negev, one strikes yard of home in Sderot 20:24 Top diplomat: Calling violence in south a 'cycle' may breed terror 01:57 France sends 29 to trial over kidnap and murder of Jewish man 01:47 Israelis 30 times more likely to be wiretapped than Americans 01:19 Vatican: Pius XII sainthood process not stalled 00:58 Coldest January in 15 years falls short of being Israel's harshest winter 22:04 Ashkenazi Chief Rabbi to retain position despite AG opposition 21:55 Mauritania releases 8 detained after Israeli embassy attack 22:40 Prisons Service refuses early release of man charged with giving Hezbollah information 00:10 Defense Min. in Singapore set to publicly attend weapons expo Previous Editions Select Day 18 feb 17 feb 15 feb 14 feb 13 feb 12 feb 11 feb 10 feb 08 feb 07 feb 06 feb 05 feb

Special Offers Advertisement Fattal Hotel Chain Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel. ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th Dead Sea Salt Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off! Eldan Rent a Car Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations Junkyard Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt

Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |

© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved