Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., February 19, 2008 Adar1 13, 5768 | | Israel Time: 18:29 (EST+7) web haaretz.com   Back to Homepage Rosner's Domain Diplomacy Defense Jewish World Opinion National Print Edition Advertising Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File

Last update - 05:43 17/02/2008 A third of settlements on land taken for 'security purposes' By Meron Rapoport, Haaretz correspondent Tags: West Bank, Israel  More than one-third of West Bank settlements were built on private Palestinian land that was temporarily seized by military order for "security purposes," according to a report by the Civil Administration that is being published here for the first time. The settlements in question, which include Ariel, Kiryat Arba and Efrat, have tens of thousands of residents, and many have existed for decades. A security source termed this a "difficult statistic" that is liable to cause trouble for Israel both in Washington and its own courts. The defense establishment has consistently refused to publish this information, and a month ago, the Defense Ministry told a court that its publication would "damage the state's security and foreign relations." Peace Now, which discovered the data, said it proves that most of the settlements are illegal even under Israeli law, and termed the attempt to hide the information a "blow to democracy." Advertisement International law allows the seizure of occupied territory, but only for military needs. Instead, Israel built many of the settlements via such seizures, in defiance of a 1979 cabinet decision that forbade using private Palestinian land for settlements. A legal source said the very fact that so many settlements were built in this way will make it hard for the state to convince the High Court of Justice that "military necessity" justifies keeping them in existence rather than returning the land to its Palestinian owners. According to the Civil Administration data compiled in October 2006, 44 of the 120 West Bank settlements "are based to some extent" on lands seized by military order. A knowledgeable security source said that most of this land was privately owned by Palestinians. In addition to Ariel, Efrat and Kiryat Arba - three of the largest West Bank settlements - the list includes major "ideological" settlements such as Ofra, Beit El, Psagot, Kedumim, Karnei Shomron, Elon Moreh and Shiloh; Jordan Valley settlements such as Gitit and Mechora; and even "quality of life" settlements such as Kfar Ruth, near Modi'in. Until the late 1970s, most settlements were built on land seized by military order. In 1979, however, the High Court overturned a seizure order for the land on which Elon Moreh was slated to be built, saying it saw no "security necessity" for the settlement. Following that ruling, Menachem Begin's government decided that all new settlements or expansions of existing ones would be built only on state land, and since then, military seizure orders officially have not been used for this purpose. However, a Haaretz investigation found that at least 19 of the 44 settlements on the Civil Administration's list were established after 1979, which means they violated this decision. Efrat, for instance, was established in 1983. A few years ago, the Defense Ministry set up a task force headed by Baruch Spiegel to collect information on how the settlements were established and their current legal status. After Haaretz reported the existence of this database, several organizations, including Peace Now, asked to view the data, but were refused. They consequently went to court, and a month ago, the Defense Ministry told the court that releasing this information might "damage the state's security and foreign relations." Attorney Michael Sfard, who represents several Palestinians whose property has been taken over by settlers, said the data "proves that systematic land theft for the purpose of establishing settlements was carried out via a fictitious and completely illegal use of the term 'military necessity.' The concealment of this information for all these years shows that the authorities also knew they were committing illegal acts." In response, the Israel Defense Forces said: "These orders are in force until they are canceled. In some of these settlements, part or all of [the land] was declared 'state land' at the same time, but the seizure orders have not been canceled, either partially or totally." It added that "in general," seizure orders have not been used to build settlements since 1979, but "in the early 1980s, Nahal [an army unit] outposts were still built on the basis of seizure orders, and some later became settlements. There were also isolated cases during those years in which land was seized for roads or buildings for existing settlements." Related articles: PM completely freezes new construction in W. Bank settlements French FM Kouchner: Israel must stop settlement activity Citing security, state refuses to release data on settlements Bookmark to del.icio.us   Artistic justice Israel Museum to exhibit art looted by Nazis and unclaimed. Let in snow For second time this winter, Jerusalem braces for snow.   1.   Rents Way Past Due 07:29  |  Mark of Lewiston 17/02/08   2.   EURO FUNDED APPEASE NOW!!!!! 07:37  |  Ben Uziel 17/02/08   3.   the revelations of truth never seem to end 08:00  |  eric 17/02/08   4.   ISNT "PEACE" NOW AN ILLEGAL ORG.??????? 08:28  |  amy 17/02/08   5.   I think I`ll simplify my life. 08:35  |  Colin Wright 17/02/08   6.   Reaching a bit further back into History,... 08:55  |  akiva (zionist) 17/02/08   7.   Peace Now must be put on trial for espionage. It`s reports... 09:03  |  Chaim 17/02/08   8.   Why should we stop the settlement of our own Land ? 09:06  |  Jean Van Daem 17/02/08   9.   you might also mention that center moderates support disengagemen 09:21  |  Michelle 17/02/08   10.   War Is Hell: To Quote American General William Tecumseh Sherman 09:30  |  Yishai Kohen 17/02/08   11.   Peace Now is an Illegal Org. Founded by Yuli Tamir 09:44  |  Joseph . E 17/02/08   12.   New Site Opens to Counter `Peace Now` 09:48  |  Joseph . E 17/02/08   13.   Request to Ban Peace Now 09:49  |  Joseph . E 17/02/08   14.   Peace Now "Spying on Israel" in the Service of Foreign Countries 09:52  |  Joseph . E 17/02/08   15.   The Knesset has passed a law designed chiefly to fight Peace Now 09:56  |  Joseph . E 17/02/08   16.   STOP THE PRESSES!! 09:58  |  H50 17/02/08   17.   The So Called Private Areab Pal Land is A Deception 10:02  |  Joseph . E 17/02/08   18.   Squatters and the military, stealing land for Greater Israel 10:15  |  Clickfool 17/02/08   19.   How the North and South West Bank Ghettos will be formed 10:23  |  Clickfool 17/02/08   20.   All Settlements are Illegal! 10:47  |  Moshe 17/02/08   21.   The Jews RETURNED to the land of theri Ancestors!!!!!!! 11:07  |  Ben Uziel 17/02/08   22.   News for Ben Uzial # 21 11:18  |  Clickfool 17/02/08   23.   Jews are immigrants. Their ancesteors left the land.... 11:31  |  Palestinian Brit 17/02/08   24.   The Return of Jews to their Ancestral Homeland is Legal,Lawful, 11:46  |  Joseph E . post 1 17/02/08   25.   # 7 to chaim 11:48  |  eric 17/02/08   26.   Israel is a Roadblock to Terrorism 11:49  |  Joseph E . post 2 17/02/08   27.   The bottom line is.... 12:53  |  Esther 17/02/08   28.   THIEVERY at it`s best, WE SAID SORRY IN AUSTRA;IA 13:09  |  VIPER 17/02/08   29.   #6, AKIVA, frothing at the mouth, here`s proof 13:12  |  VIPER 17/02/08   30.   #10, YISHAI, here`s more proof of the opposite 13:14  |  VIPER 17/02/08   31.   Shall America give the Indians all the land back? 13:22  |  Petra 17/02/08   32.   Yes, and you at Haaretz cannot pretend not to be part of this 13:22  |  Andreas 17/02/08   33.   Actually, what`s the news here? 13:34  |  Kris 17/02/08   34.   In 1947 the UNResolution,the Partition Resolution,partitioned 14:00  |  lakshmi 17/02/08   35.   Viper 30: Your Lies Were Exposed Long Ago: Example Below 14:33  |  Yishai Kohen 17/02/08   36.   APPEASE NOW CROWD!!! GLOBALISTS W/ NO SENSE!!! 15:05  |  Ben Uziel 17/02/08   37.   Lakshmi: You Crack Me Up! 15:10  |  Yishai Kohen 17/02/08   38.   really? theft? Israel? The Jews? 15:40  |  al 17/02/08   39.   an eye for an eye, ... asset for asset, 23:12  |  Tzvi 17/02/08   40.   To Michelle number 9 00:09  |  l 18/02/08   41.   # 27 amen to that, esther 00:46  |  eric 18/02/08   42.   100% of palestinian land is on Israeli land 01:00  |  eddie 18/02/08   43.   land 05:17  |  Ben 18/02/08   44.   The entire West Bank was `siezed for Security Reasons` 06:45  |  Daniel 18/02/08   45.   # 27 amen to that, esther 07:41  |  eric 18/02/08   46.   #39 Well, it`s an eye-opener, that`s for sure Tzvi 08:36  |  Johnboy 18/02/08   47.   #20 Yes, exactly so Moshe 08:55  |  Johnboy 18/02/08   48.   wow! 09:50  |  resident 18/02/08   49.   to cham: 10:05  |  correction 18/02/08   50.   johnboy 10:25  |  correction 18/02/08   51.   #7 Chaim. Here`s some reality-shock-treatment for you: 12:08  |  zmogus 18/02/08   52.   UNBELIEVABLE 12:21  |  Danny 18/02/08   53.   Scandal... 13:15  |  Chris 18/02/08   54.   I think that i missed someting 13:27  |  danny 18/02/08   55.   Hhahahahaha 15:01  |  Said 18/02/08   56.   Danny #54, yes you`ve missed 15:10  |  Chris 18/02/08   57.   Illegal land setlement? 21:43  |  Avi Yerushalmi 18/02/08   58.   wow 23:39  |  Andrew 18/02/08   59.   land for security 00:07  |  Tom jefferson 19/02/08

Today Online Livni: Halting peace talks with Palestinians will not end terror Responses: 87 Lebanon tense amid specter of fresh Israel-Hezbollah fighting Responses: 102 German intellectuals: Israel's creation made Palestinians victims of the Nazi Holocaust Responses: 108 Meron Benvenisti: The demographic bomb is 1-2 years away Responses: 44 Yoel Marcus: Better to keep tabs on terrorists than to kill them Responses: 18 Rosner's Domain Poll: Is it important to have an Israeli-Palestinian agreement by the end of 2008? Most blatant example of Israeli interference in American election Clinton's peace team: the attacks on Rob Malley "vicious" (WTR) The U.S. and Mughniyah / Not just 'who' but also 'where' The row over Obama's stance on Israel is a dispute between Jews More Headlines 13:58 Livni: Halting peace talks with PA will not end terror 17:42 Palestinians: 10-year-old Gaza boy killed in Hamas-IDF crossfire 16:58 IDF: Reinforcing private homes in Sderot is our last priority 16:22 ANALYSIS: Sarkozy's Holocaust education plan baffles Jews 14:47 Islamic Jihad, Palestinian rights groups at odds over deadly Gaza blast 16:53 Egyptian officials meet with Hamas on Gaza-Egypt border security 18:07 Driver responsible for 3 deaths receives only 3-year prison term 14:01 Lawyer jailed for fraud in dealing with Jews' pensions in Germany 12:10 Report: Syria to present progress in Mughniyah killing probe within days 16:35 Pakistan's pro-Musharraf party concedes defeat in elections 15:21 Egypt police kill Sudanese migrant on Israel border