Getting to the root of the Ramon case - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Mon., February 11, 2008 Adar1 5, 5768

Israel Time: 11:03 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Rosner's Domain

Diplomacy

Defense

Jewish World

Opinion

National

Print Edition

Advertising

Books

Arts & Leisure

Business

Real Estate

Easy Start

Travel

Week's End

Anglo File

Last update - 22:46 10/02/2008

Getting to the root of the Ramon case

By Haaretz Editorial

Tags: Israel, Haim Ramon

The trial of Vice Premier Haim Ramon is not leaving the public agenda, and rightfully so. The deeper we delve into the circumstances in which the complaint against him was filed, investigated and deliberated in court, the more troubling the questions that arise.

Already at the time of the trial, the judges expressed surprise that wiretaps conducted during the investigation had been concealed from the defense attorneys. For this reason, a retired judge, Shalom Brenner, was asked to examine the material, and his conclusions raised additional questions. The justice minister also asked for an opinion from another retired judge, Vardi Zeiler, after Brenner had determined that "the investigation of the minister was conducted with considerable negligence."

Zeiler's opinion is a very severe document, which casts a shadow over the conduct of the legal authorities. In Zeiler's view, the defectiveness of the proceedings was detrimental to Ramon's defense; his attorneys were unaware during the questioning of the complainant in court that her phone had been tapped. While judge Brenner determined that senior officials in the State Prosecutor's Office and police officials had not acted as required - saying that they should have known that wiretaps had been conducted but failed to investigate this matter properly - Zeiler pins most of the blame on senior police officers.

	Advertisement

Zeiler's conclusions raise a serious suspicion that this was not a case of coincidental or negligent concealment of facts, but rather concealment that might have derived from "a personal interest" not to expose the immoderate police pressure exerted on the complainant to convince her to submit the complaint.

The words of Brenner and Zeiler - both judges with extensive experience - are extraordinary in their severity. In light of the fact that this matter has yet to be investigated by an entity endowed with enforcement authorities, and due to the incomplete investigation into the question of malice in concealing the material, a government committee of review should be appointed, as Zeiler recommended, that would be authorized to conduct an exhaustive investigation that gets to the root of the matter.

Zeiler believes that the establishment of a state commission of inquiry is designed for other matters and that it is possible in this case to suffice with a government committee of review. The advantage of a state commission of inquiry is that its members are appointed by the president of the Supreme Court and not by ministers whose purview includes the matter under investigation.

The ministers of justice and public security, who would be authorized to appoint a review committee under the Law on Government, could win public confidence by assigning the role of committee chairman to a senior (retired) judge who is also a prominent expert in criminal law, such as former judge Eliezer Goldberg, who also served as state comptroller. The committee chairman would be joined by legal experts from the fields of criminal and constitutional law, who are not current or recent civil servants.

The review committee should not be limited by its letter of appointment and it should complete its work within a few of months. There is a supreme public obligation to clarify and get to the bottom of what appears at this stage to be a serious failure, if not worse, in "the corridors of power" of the police and State Prosecutor's Office, which are entrusted with protecting human dignity and liberty.

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	All in the family
	Tel Aviv municipality moves to retain contract with Gaza City as 'twin city.'


	Pining for a leader
	A documentary examines Ariel Sharon's motive for the Gaza disengagement.




1.	Same day Ramon is for punishing Gaza,"Haaretz" digs out	23:32	\|	Absolute Sweden	10/02/08

2.	Meaning Ramon can get away with acting like Katsav	07:33	\|	Ilan	11/02/08

3.	The article smells of PMO spin !	10:06	\|	redmike	11/02/08

4.	Indeed the trial of Haim Ramon should not leave the public agenda	10:29	\|	S	11/02/08

Today Online


	Report: Haniyeh goes underground as IDF plans assassinations
	Responses: 57


	Harel and Issacharoff: New Hamas tactic: Bomb Israel into truce
	Responses: 39


	Hebron settlers, Arab clans said holding 'reconciliation talks'
	Responses: 46


	Editorial: Israel must protect its citizens and borders at all costs
	Responses: 12

More Headlines
10:32 Report: Haniyeh in hiding as IDF plans assassination campaign


09:52 ANALYSIS / New Hamas tactic: Bomb Israel into a truce


04:55 U.S. pushes Israel to accept proposed Egypt border deal


10:06 Obama rides momentum before 'Potomac Primaries' Tuesday


10:44 IDF imposes closure on Jenin to thwart would-be suicide bomber


09:42 Comptroller report: Schools in Haredi, Arab sectors dilapidated


10:59 29 years after revolution, Iran vows not to suspend nuclear program


10:03 Sderot residents, wary of rocket lull, plan to protest on Ayalon Hwy.


00:04 Hebron settlers, Arab clan chiefs said holding 'reconciliation talks'


09:01 Police: Crime dropped in 2007 as less terror put cops back on beat


09:51 Barak may cut short trip to Turkey due to ongoing Qassams


08:26 Haifa cable car reopens after damaged during Lebanon War


08:35 New syringe packaging leads to faulty inoculation at Givatayim school