Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., February 07, 2008 Adar1 1, 5768 | | Israel Time: 23:04 (EST+7) web haaretz.com   Back to Homepage Rosner's Domain Diplomacy Defense Jewish World Opinion National Print Edition Advertising Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File

Last update - 09:44 04/02/2008 The lights have been turned off By Gideon Levy Tags: Israel One after another, the final lights are being turned off, and a moral gloom is falling upon us as we stand at the edge of an abyss. Just last week, three more lights were turned off. The Winograd Report did not come out clearly against the fact that Israel embarked on a pointless war; the Supreme Court authorized collective punishment and the attorney general concluded that the killing of 12 Israeli citizens and someone from the territories by the police does not warrant a trial. The final keepers of order, the lighthouses of justice and law, are reconciling themselves with the most serious injustices of the institutions of authority and no one so much as utters a word about it. The upsetting and depressing crop of a single week has drawn the moral portrait of the country. As expected, the Winograd Committee became irrelevant. It avoided dealing with the first question that should have been on its agenda: Was there any justification for embarking on the war? A committee that says nothing about a country that declares war on its neighbor, kills a thousand of its citizens, causes mass destruction, makes use of horrific munitions and continues to kill dozens of innocents to this day - is a derelict committee. If the committee didn't delve into these key issues, then who will? A single, circuitous remark exposed the game: "We do not conclude, and have not concluded, that the decision to embark on war following the abduction [of the two reservists] was not justified." Well, what did it conclude? Despite what it said, this is what you really hear: It is legitimate in the eyes of the committee to go to war over two abducted soldiers. It is legitimate to utilize the tool of war, to kill indiscriminately, to disproportionately bomb and destroy - all as the preferred first response. No negotiations, no limited military operation - just war - and on such dubious grounds, and of course with such pathetic results. Not a word on the killing and the destruction that we caused in vain. The dignified-looking committee conducted itself like a public information office and supported what many around the world have described as war crimes. A golden opportunity to say something ethical about the language of force that we are always eager to use, was missed. The Winograd Committee is therefore a panel lacking a moral backbone, which avoided coming to terms with substantive questions. Advertisement On the same day that the committee released its final report, the Supreme Court, that same institution to which all eyes are turned, and over whose influence there is a bitter, ongoing battle, authorized another bug in the works. A panel of justices headed by Court President Dorit Beinisch ruled that Israel is authorized to limit the supply of electricity, gasoline and diesel to the Gaza Strip, "since even these diminished quantities sufficiently meet humanitarian needs." It is difficult to tell what "humanitarian needs" are according to Beinisch, but in the Gaza Strip a million and a half people are crying out for fuel, water and electricity. It is fair to ask the court president: Has she ever been exposed to the scenes of wretchedness in the Gaza Strip? Did she ever see the miserable people there carrying fuel jerry cans from Egypt? Has she considered the cold, which cannot be countered without electricity or fuel? Has she given any serious thought to what happens to children, the infirm and the elderly without these necessities? They are all innocents. But the severity of the Supreme Court's decision is not only on the human level: The Supreme Court is authorizing collective punishment, which is specifically forbidden under international law (Article 33 of the Geneva Convention). Henceforth, Israel will no longer be able to complain about attacks against innocents in Israel: If all the residents of the Gaza Strip deserve to be punished because of the Qassam rockets, then maybe all Israelis deserve to be punished because of the occupation? "This is the difference between Israel, a democracy fighting for its life within the framework of the law, and the terrorist organizations fighting against it," the Supreme Court stated sanctimoniously, like a lowly spokesman from the Foreign Ministry. "According to the law?" Which law? Not international law. "Israel is fighting for its life?" And maybe the Palestinians are fighting a war that is no less justified, against occupation and imprisonment? All this was not on the Supreme Court's agenda. And last, but not least: Attorney General Menachem Mazuz. Twelve citizens and a resident of the territories were killed by the police, and Mazuz ruled there was no point of initiating a criminal investigation at such a late stage. (The state prosecution decided at the time to delay the investigation until the Or Commission of Inquiry completed it work.) Why shouldn't the court decide? All the excuses, including passing the blame onto the victim's families, who did not permit autopsies, do not in the least diminish the well-founded suspicion: Had the dead been Jewish citizens, this would not have happened; the police would not have killed and the attorney general would not have closed the case. After all this, people here complain about those who wish to live in a more just country, who are forced to turn to institutions of international law. Who else can they turn to? The Supreme Court? Winograd? The attorney general? Their lights have all been turned off. Bookmark to del.icio.us   Baghdad, Interrupted Angelina Jolie takes on Iraq as UN goodwill ambassador. Backhanded compliment Hezbollah leader Nasrallah praises the Winograd Committee report.   1.   Gideion is right. Those zionist Jews don`t have any shame 10:07  |  Yaakov Sullivan 04/02/08   2.   Unwritten laws are the strongest since they cannot be repealed 10:10  |  Natallie Durson 04/02/08   3.   What happens when the law falls on its sword? 10:20  |  dana 04/02/08   4.   Lights 10:38  |  Cyclops 04/02/08   5.   wow! Brilliant as Always !! Thank you 11:07  |  Gisele From Beirut 04/02/08   6.   gideon levi a man is admirable and honest man 11:16  |  Godbless 04/02/08   7.   i admire your true heart, gideon... 11:17  |  eric 04/02/08   8.   Gideon,..The lighthouse keeper has been sacked.. 11:40  |  Stephen. 04/02/08   9.   Son of a Volksdeutch from Böhmen,Gideon Levy spins again 11:46  |  Absolute Sweden 04/02/08   10.   Durson and written laws 11:59  |  Joe Sittizen 04/02/08   11.   MR HAPPY will you stay happy with the consequences? 11:59  |  PETER SM 04/02/08   12.   You do alot of mouthing off Peter SM 13:02  |  kiwi girl 04/02/08   13.   Gideon Levy, please write about the suicide bomber 13:12  |  Fed up 04/02/08   14.   it doesnt matter! 17:25  |  Space 04/02/08   15.   In fact, some lights have been turned ON. Many more to go 20:37  |  Jebei Noyon 04/02/08   16.   Levy - Take Your BS to Berkeley or the EU 23:10  |  Tod Zuckerman 04/02/08   17.   What exactly was the report suppose to tell us RIGHT ??? 05:26  |  M. S. 05/02/08   18.   Thank you as always Gideion Levy 13:30  |  Ari 05/02/08   19.   Brilliant Analysis 16:13  |  Paul Fingerhut 05/02/08

Today Online Seven Gazans killed in IDF raid; 7 Qassams hit Negev Responses: 109 Barak vows harsher IDF response to Qassam fire Responses: 143 Senator: U.S. to shun UN racism meet over anti-Israel agenda Responses: 113 Egyptian FM: Whoever breaks border will have his legs broken Responses: 65 Vatican rejects criticism of new prayer for conversion of Jews Responses: 184 More Headlines 21:44 Israel begins reducing electricity supply to Gaza 21:50 Hamas rejects Abbas proposal to broker cease-fire with Israel 20:59 Mideast envoy Blair says PA starting to abide by 'road map' 18:09 Seven Palestinians killed in IDF raid in Gaza; 7 Qassams hit Negev 21:27 Egyptian FM: Whoever breaks border will have his legs broken 19:27 Man credited with saving Jews in WWII to repay survivor he allegedly swindled 21:51 Romney quits U.S. presidential race, takes shot at Europe 20:12 Qatar PM sues Kuwaiti paper which criticized his ties to Israel 19:21 Angelina Jolie visits Baghdad to highlight plight of Iraqi refugees 18:39 Vatican rejects criticism of new prayer for Jewish conversion 18:34 Colombian defense minister says ties with Israel are strong 18:35 Israel intercepts W. Bank-bound truck loaded with explosive material 16:59 Haifa, T.A. domestic airports suspend plans halt weekend civil aviation Previous Editions Select Day 06 feb 05 feb 04 feb 03 feb 01 feb 31 jan 30 jan 29 jan 28 jan 27 jan 25 jan 24 jan

Special Offers Advertisement Fattal Hotel Chain Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel. ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th Dead Sea Salt Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off! Eldan Rent a Car Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations U.S. CITIZEN PRESIDENTIAL PRIMARY Last chance to vote in Israel, in-person, Democrats-Abroad Global Primary. Junkyard Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt

Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |

© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved