Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., February 05, 2008 Shvat 29, 5768 | | Israel Time: 02:29 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Advertising
Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
IDF Chief of Staff Gabi Ashkenazi. (Tess Scheflan)
Last update - 11:04 01/02/2008
Top IDF brass: Winograd report on Lebanon war an 'earthquake'
By Amos Harel, Haaretz Correspondent
Tags: Israel, Ashkenazi, IDF 

Senior officers in the Israel Defense Forces have characterized the Winograd Committee's findings on the army's performance in the Second Lebanon War as "nothing less than an earthquake."

The IDF chief of staff is taking action to implement the final report's recommendations, while the military advocate general has announced that the report does not require delaying the advancement of officers involved in the war.

O
Advertisement
ther officers say the committee "went overboard" on some issues and that many of the problems cited in the final report have already been fixed.

"The committee members know full well what went wrong in the army," one senior officer told Haaretz. "It will take two or three years to repair the damage caused by the war to the IDF and the impression the report made on the public. We'll have to work hard."

According to him, "While it's true that some of the faults have been fixed since the war, the report says bigger changes are needed. Maybe the situation in the army was worse than we thought, certainly when it came to maintaining values."

The officers say IDF Chief of Staff Gabi Ashkenazi has identified the erosion of the principles of warfare as an urgent problem. They say he has been deeply involved with the issue since he took up his post last February.

General Staff officers pointed out that even though the committee found flaws in the performance of most levels of the military, it is clear that they were worse in the General Staff than in lower ranks such as the Northern Command and the combat divisions.

The military advocate general, Brig.-Gen. Avihai Mandelblit, said that none of the report's findings require dismissing or changing the promotion track of any of the officers involved in combat. Senior defense sources, however, admitted that the findings "are not just an administrative comment. This is a government committee, and the things it says will certainly be taken into account in future decisions about the promotion of officers who were responsible for the deficiencies."

Critics of the committee in the IDF argued that its members did not sufficiently distinguish between the failings during the war and the state of the army today. "It's not the same army," they said. "We are very aware of the failures, but a large number of them were first identified by the IDF and were fixed over the past year and a half."

These officers argued that in the past two months of fighting in the Gaza Strip soldiers have demonstrated a higher level of decisiveness and persistence than there was in some of the battles in Lebanon that the committee criticized.

General Staff officers also disagreed with the committee's finding of a "deep rift" in the IDF. They say studies conducted by the IDF's Department of Behavioral Sciences do not bear this out, and that polls show that Israelis' opinions about the army are more positive than the report indicates.

A team headed by Maj.-Gen. Ido Nechushtan, head of the General Staff's Plans and Policy Directorate, is studying the final report for issues that require immediate attention. The General Staff Forum is to discuss the report soon, possibly as early as next week.

Related articles:
  • PM: Winograd report 'lifts moral stigma' from me
  • Peretz: Lebanon War was missed opportunity, but had to be done
  • Calls growing within Labor for Barak to quit Olmert coalition
  • Over to you, Ehud!
  • ANALYSIS: Mixed verdict in war report leaves protesters in a quandary
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Negev attack
    Dimona suicide bombing kills one woman in first such attack in more than a year.
    A friend in Dalia
    Knesset Speaker Dalia Itzik is secretly raising Knesset officials' salaries.
      1.   Are we ready for a change ? 08:44  |  Harold Lane 01/02/08
      2.   These issues are cosmetic. The real problems will remain. 08:54  |  Natallie Durson 01/02/08
      3.   What Winograd failed to mention 09:05  |  Fran 01/02/08
      4.   Good news for Israel: promotion coming for IDF bozos 09:44  |  Clickfool 01/02/08
      5.   Excellent decision to promote the incompetents. 09:46  |  Chanalau, Tova 01/02/08
      6.   #3 - Fran 10:01  |  Mike 01/02/08
      7.   Fran,as long as arabs are so self-deceiving as you,Israel`s safe 10:01  |  Absolute Sweden 01/02/08
      8.   IDF Brass 10:05  |  colin 01/02/08
      9.   #3 fran 10:08  |  danny 01/02/08
      10.   Natallie Durson #2 RIGHT!! 10:13  |  S 01/02/08
      11.   #9 To Danny 11:05  |  Fran 01/02/08
      12.   In my years, we were trained to get to the job after dinner and.. 11:07  |  Moshe 01/02/08
      13.   To Danny #9 12:00  |  Taso 01/02/08
      14.   #10, S, what are you talking about? 12:25  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 01/02/08
      15.   So no charges against IDF war criminals 12:45  |  Stephen Murray 01/02/08
      16.   #9 fran 12:50  |  danny 01/02/08
      17.   # 4. Clickfool. "Forgotten the British Retreat at Dunkirk.! 13:09  |  Stephen. 01/02/08
      18.   Danny and Fran et al 13:36  |  Ayman 01/02/08
      19.   For Stephen # 17 13:45  |  Clickfool 01/02/08
      20.   #17 Stephen 14:17  |  Moshe 01/02/08
      21.   #12 Moshe and breakfast 14:18  |  Bon Levi 01/02/08
      22.   #15 14:32  |  Moshe 01/02/08
      23.   #21 14:40  |  Moshe 01/02/08
      24.   For Moshe # 20 15:10  |  Clickfool 01/02/08
      25.   # 20. Moshe. This is a wake up call.for ZAHAL 15:20  |  Stephen. 01/02/08
      26.   Danny 15:22  |  Nadine 01/02/08
      27.   Cipora, apparently you do not understand (?) 15:52  |  S 01/02/08
      28.   #3 Fran - You missed the point entirely 16:44  |  * BEN JABO 01/02/08
      29.   Stephen Murray - Amsterdam 16:49  |  * BEN JABO 01/02/08
      30.   All Israeli General Must Return Their Salary 16:50  |  St dorge 01/02/08
      31.   #26 Nadine - Blame Hezbollah, they used clusters first 19:03  |  * BEN JABO 01/02/08
      32.   WINOGRAD FORGOT 21:44  |  KING K 01/02/08
      33.   Re Cipora #14 22:17  |  Esther 01/02/08
      34.   When 22:23  |  Omar 01/02/08
      35.   Re S #10 and #27 22:25  |  Esther 01/02/08
      36.   Rumsfeld and Dilbert 22:50  |  W 01/02/08
      37.   #24 23:56  |  Moshe 01/02/08
      38.   Moshe and breakfast at Khiam... 03:12  |  Bear 02/02/08
      39.   #32 KING K -You forgot to keep your children out of harms way 04:34  |  * BEN JABO 02/02/08
      40.   #24 Clickfool 04:36  |  Moshe 02/02/08
      41.   Taso # 13 04:37  |  Free Gilad Shalit 02/02/08
      42.   Clickfool 04:50  |  Free Gilad Shalit 02/02/08
      43.   King K - Libnan 05:26  |  Free Gilad Shalit 02/02/08
      44.   #41 Free Gilad Shalit 09:19  |  TASO 02/02/08
      45.   to FRAN and ben Jabo RE: Cluster Bombs 21:22  |  Morris 02/02/08
      46.   #45 Morris - Refer to my post #31 03:42  |  * BEN JABO 03/02/08
      47.   Values 03:45  |  jjvanka 03/02/08
      48.   Kohn (#14) 03:56  |  jjvanka 03/02/08
      49.   Murray (#15) 04:00  |  jjvanka 03/02/08
      50.   Free (#41) 04:25  |  jjvanka 03/02/08
      51.   #48 jjvanka - didn`t you know 06:27  |  * BEN JABO 03/02/08
      52.   The typical oficer is overpaid and unprofessional 08:34  |  Ethan 03/02/08
      53.   Ethan - Haifa 17:15  |  Malach HaMavet 03/02/08
      54.   Jabo (#51) 19:23  |  jjvanka 03/02/08
      55.   Cosmetic 02:57  |  Paul 04/02/08
      56.   Winograd 03:01  |  Paul 04/02/08
      57.   Barak `s move 03:42  |  Brod 04/02/08
      58.   #54 2ND TRY jjavanka 02:12  |  * BEN JABO 05/02/08
     Today Online
    One dead in suicide bombing in southern city of Dimona
    Responses: 480
    Bradley Burston: This is how Islam ends
    Responses: 167
    Terror attack was matter of time after Gaza border breach
    Responses: 93
    Sources: Hamas gives Israel letter from Gilad Shalit
    Responses: 56
    Palestinian reporter, W. Bank rabbi give PM, Hamas draft truce
    Responses: 60
    Rosner's Domain
    When Jewish identity is "locked into the holocaust" (WTR)
    Obama, Clinton and Iran: The vote that made the difference
    Poll: Do you trust Obama on Israel?
    The campaign for Darfur has achieved all its goals - but one
    Not despite Iraq - because of Iraq


    More Headlines
    22:52 Hamas claims Dimona attack, says bombers came from Hebron
    00:02 PM vows 'relentless' war on terror in wake of Dimona attack
    21:33 Report: Egypt reopens border after clashes with Gazans
    23:37 In symbolic vote, Knesset okays PM's post-Winograd speech
    22:39 PM appoints panel to probe 2002 killing of Hamas chief Shehada
    00:33 British government denounces hoax Holocaust e-mail
    21:07 Lebanon to lodge UN complaint against Israel for border shooting
    18:09 Policeman: Terrorist reached for the bomb and I shot him
    02:03 Dollar dives half-percent to NIS 3.578 sparking fears of labor strike
    23:29 Haredis and religious zionists to hold mass prayer against J'lem partition
    12:48 ANALYSIS: Terror attack was matter of time after Gaza border breach
    21:17 Palestinians: PRC leader killed, 2 hurt in IAF strike on north Gaza
    Previous Editions