Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., January 27, 2008 Shvat 20, 5768 | | Israel Time: 11:15 (EST+7) web haaretz.com   Back to Homepage Rosner's Domain Diplomacy Defense Jewish World Opinion National Print Edition Advertising Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File

Last update - 06:39 26/01/2008 Not in it for the money By Daniel Orenstein Tags: Aliyah, Immigration, Israel  It's customary in Israel to receive a new arrival with a "baruch habah" ("welcome," but literally, "blessed be the one who has come"), to which the customary response is "baruch hanimtzah" ("blessed be the one who is [already] here"). As I read of the recent obsessive efforts by the Ministry of Absorption and private organizations to convince Israelis abroad and other Jews to come home, I keep repeating that latter phrase in my head. The Israeli government should be thinking about it as well. Last year, I returned to Israel with my family after six years in the United States. It was a purely ideological move: We wanted to be in Israel and be part of that sometimes seemingly anachronistic effort to create a progressive Jewish state. We happily accepted the minimal financial aid we were offered by the Ministry of Absorption (reduced-price tickets on El Al). Upon our return we were met with a barrage of bills: The National Insurance Institute wanted their NIS 4,000 in unpaid bills from the period we were abroad; the Israel Broadcasting Authority wanted another NIS 3,000 in TV fees from the years we were gone (we paid the first bill, but are appealing the second one). Furthermore, I will have to pay for private health insurance for the next 10 months. You may think I am noting these financial burdens simply to fulfill my national duty to complain, but my real point is that none of these deterred us. We want to live here. Advertisement I'm not alone. For various reasons, more than 10,000 American citizens immigrated to Israel between 2000 and 2006. Another 18,000 came from Europe (excluding the former Soviet Union) and 1,400 from Canada, New Zealand and Australia. In addition, 38,000 Israelis abroad decided to return to Israel between 2002 and 2005. In the absence of the specter of rampant anti-Semitism or economic collapse, we can assume they came because they were ideologically driven or they simply saw Israel as their home, and not because someone was paying them to move. Migration experts speak in terms of "push and pull" factors that influence people. On the one hand, the place where they are may be increasingly unwelcoming - perhaps due to poverty, war, lack of opportunities and the like. On the other hand, it may be that immigrants are pulled by the lure of economic promise or of a better life for them and their children. When the combined push-and-pull factors overpower the justification for staying in situ, people pick up and move. Israelis move abroad (and nearly 100,000 did so between 2002 and 2005) for many reasons, although it's a safe assumption that most are seeking a better life - materially, spiritually, socially. Life in Israel, rewarding as it may be, is tense politically and is also expensive. On the international front, we continue to live in a constant state of conflict with the Palestinians and enemies further away. On the home front, we have a deteriorating education system and a health care system that is becoming increasingly expensive for citizens. Israelis see promise overseas. In response, our Ministry of Absorption recently announced a plan to entice ex-pat Israelis to come home through a package of economic incentives - in particular, by eliminating some of the unexpected bills that greeted us when we arrived. Additionally, the private immigration advocacy group Nefesh B'Nefesh, funded by philanthropists and by the Israeli government, is offering Jewish doctors (MDs, not PhDs) $60,000 to move to Israel. I am not asking to have those privileges extended to me and my cohort - those who moved here prior to the increased incentives package. On the contrary, I suggest we reconsider the incentives. And perhaps we can consider a slightly larger reapportionment of government largesse. By closing the Ministry of Absorption, we could disperse its NIS 1.4-billion budget to benefit Israelis who live here - immigrants and long-time residents alike. The Education Ministry could use the additional funds to raise the salaries of teachers and university professors. The Environment Ministry, which currently gets less than 15 percent of the budget that the Absorption Ministry has, could use the money to clean up our rivers, air and land. The Science Ministry, which gets only half what the Absorption Ministry does, could stimulate basic research and strengthen Israel's research and development prowess. And those $60,000 grants could go to local doctors and hospitals in appreciation of their service. Since the immigration waves of the 1990s, which increased Israel's population by more than 20 percent in less than a decade, there is scarcely a responsibility belonging to the Absorption Ministry that couldn't reasonably be reassigned to a different ministry. We have a Foreign Ministry that can represent us abroad. We have ministries of health, welfare, housing and education that can also tend to the special needs of new immigrants. For added benefit, these ministries cater to the needs of all Israelis (Jewish, Muslim and Christian), and thus they need not be part of a discriminatory governmental system in which, under the code "immigrant," Israel's Jewish citizens get preferential treatment over its Arab ones. Stop pandering to the Israelis who have decided to seek their fortunes abroad, or to Jews who are happy where they currently live. We can show them some respect for their decision - and some self-respect as well. By investing in those who live here, we will not only weaken the "push" factors that may cause future generations of Israelis to leave, but we will strengthen the "pull" factors that will bring Israeli ex-pats and other potential immigrants to Israel. They will come, not for a bribe, but for quality of life, education, social services and a clean environment. Always bless and welcome those who come. But invest in those who are here. Daniel Orenstein is a postdoctoral fellow at the Technion Faculty of Architecture and Town Planning and a lecturer at the Arava Institute for Environmental Studies. More Jewish World news and features Bookmark to del.icio.us   Strip Solidarity More than 1,000 march against the blockade on the Israeli side of the Gaza border. PFLP founder dead George Habash, founder of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, dies at 81.   1.   Emphasize , Strenghten and Promote the Law of Reurn to the Land 10:47  |  Joseph E . 25/01/08   2.   hmmm 11:44  |  Sam 25/01/08   3.   Doing away with one of Israel`s biggest beauracracies 12:40  |  Dror 25/01/08   4.   #1 Joseph E 14:01  |  chris 25/01/08   5.   Not enough money 14:58  |  Janice 25/01/08   6.   #4 janice is obviously in need of a history lesson 15:21  |  v hardman 25/01/08   7.   IF ISRAEL REALLY WANTED TO DO SOMETHING... 15:37  |  B`Galil 25/01/08   8.   but they are moving to GERMANY 15:44  |  David 25/01/08   9.   Why many Jews don`t want to live in Israel 15:52  |  Gene 25/01/08   10.   Gap in leadership 16:06  |  Peter 25/01/08   11.   # 3 chris , `no need charisma , it`s about to obey the Law ` 16:14  |  Joseph . E 25/01/08   12.   you don`t need to bribe them.....they will go back.... 16:38  |  maria 25/01/08   13.   From A Young Olah Chadasha 16:43  |  Alana 25/01/08   14.   Make an exception for the Israeli`s in the settlements 16:52  |  John 25/01/08   15.   NUMBER-WISE: MORE PEOPLE ARE LEAVING THE SINKING SHIP 17:01  |  TrippleJump 25/01/08   16.   Ornstein 17:38  |  Fed Up 25/01/08   17.   "Express" converts are also welcome 17:57  |  Natallie Durson 25/01/08   18.   #8 the law of the land and Joseph E. 18:00  |  chris 25/01/08   19.   #14 who is this moron tripple jump ? 18:08  |  v hardman 25/01/08   20.   Israel needs to offer JOBS, good JOBS for jewish abroad 18:31  |  Marcos 25/01/08   21.   To Janice and Fed up from Chicago 18:48  |  Shoshana Thomasson 25/01/08   22.   to #1 You got that right! 18:51  |  Jack 25/01/08   23.   Israel gets rid of the goys and will be peace and $$$ 19:15  |  V ----I 25/01/08   24.   "Postdoctor" and Alana 20:07  |  Yossi 25/01/08   25.   Not Enough Money - Janice 20:15  |  Still We Rise 25/01/08   26.   Not in it for the money 20:21  |  David 25/01/08   27.   How can a jew think this way 20:23  |  Zaki 25/01/08   28.   #8 David 20:56  |  Dav 25/01/08   29.   #12 maria 21:16  |  Jimmy 25/01/08   30.   demographic factors are no longer relevant 21:43  |  Wael Hendawi 25/01/08   31.   I don`t want to go to Israel 22:53  |  Harel B 25/01/08   32.   what about the Palestinians ? 23:46  |  poncie ponce 25/01/08   33.   I see jimmy...they bought packs of cigarettes 23:58  |  maria 25/01/08   34.   "V ---" so are you saying if the world got rid of the jews 00:03  |  ME 26/01/08   35.   Brava Janice ! Bravo, Zaki ! 00:06  |  Maki 26/01/08   36.   just to undestand, to #12 Maria 00:53  |  Kaled 26/01/08   37.   shame 00:58  |  tim 26/01/08   38.   a question? 01:19  |  Kaled 26/01/08   39.   to Janice and all the "pals" supporters 01:23  |  Yossi 26/01/08   40.   paradise 10:58  |  amy 27/01/08

Today Online Abbas to ask Olmert to give PA control of Gaza-Egypt border Responses: 24 Anti-Semitic incidents rise in Germany, Australia, U.S. in 2007 Responses: 36 Editorial: Gaza border crisis endangers peace with Egypt Responses: 8 Gideon Levy: IDF troops fell because of Israel's war of folly Responses: 4 Richard Silverstein: Seeking liberal Jewish bloggers Responses: 118 More Headlines 08:58 Abbas to ask Olmert for PA control of Gaza-Egypt border 11:05 Livni: Meeting with bereaved families is least I can do 08:31 Barack Obama wins South Carolina Democratic primary 07:26 Anti-Semitic incidents rise in Germany, Australia, U.S. in 2007 10:13 NASA delegates to visit Israel to remember astronaut Ilan Ramon 07:30 Drought forces cabinet to vote on emergency water measures 06:12 New labor bill puts workers' rights in companies' hands 07:34 Palestinians: PFLP founder George Habash dies at 81 17:01 In remembrance of Holocaust, UN chief Ban says 'never again' 01:28 Iran vows to retaliate against US bases in Gulf if U.S. attacks first Previous Editions Select Day 25 jan 24 jan 23 jan 22 jan 21 jan 20 jan 18 jan 17 jan 16 jan 15 jan 14 jan 13 jan

Special Offers Advertisement Dead Sea Salt Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off! FAREWELL ISRAEL New Film The Coming War for Islamic Revival - View Movie Trailer Inbal Jerusalem Hotel Unbeatable rates at the Finest hotel in Jerusalem Eldan Rent a Car Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations SUPER-TUESDAY U.S. PRESIDENTIAL PRIMARY U.S. citizen in Israel vote Democrats-Abroad Global Primary online, in-person. Junkyard Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt

Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |