Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., February 26, 2008 Adar1 20, 5768 | | Israel Time: 22:57 (EST+7) web haaretz.com   Back to Homepage Rosner's Domain Diplomacy Defense Jewish World Opinion National Print Edition Advertising Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File

A thundering silence By Haaretz Editorial Tags: Outpost, Israel, Police  The 14-year-old girls who spent three weeks in jail because they refused to identify themselves after being arrested at an illegal outpost are just one example of what is happening in the religious Zionist camp. It is easy to feel sympathy for minors whom the legal system arrested as a form of punishment, since arrest is not supposed to serve this purpose. In that sense, the court that released them was right to do so. But on the other hand, it is impossible to separate this act of rebellion from its context: a growing number of citizens who deny the state's right to enforce its laws on them. Through this symbolic act of rebellion, and the religious Zionist leadership's overwhelming silence in response to it, religious Zionism has positioned itself as a movement that denies the sovereignty of the state. It is no accident that the movement's leadership displayed sympathy for the girls. Such widespread rejection of the Israeli legal system's authority cannot be found among Israel's Arab citizens, among the non-Zionist anarchists of the left nor even in the most extreme ultra-Orthodox circles. This tacit support for the girls also reflects support for illegal settlement, and it highlights the serious problem of the new religious Zionists, whose loyalty to the state is conditional. As long as the state serves the goals of the settlements, they support it. But the moment a contrary decision is made - on territorial withdrawals or evacuation of outposts - this camp allows itself to break the law. If every group whose demands were not accepted were to behave this way, it would not be possible to maintain a state. No political camp has dared to challenge the state as blatantly as the national religious camp has done since the disengagement. The girls' silence under arrest was only an appetizer. Advertisement Another serious problem in the religious Zionist camp is the way its members turn a means into an end. The settlement enterprise was supposed to serve the state. But it has become an end in itself, which first and foremost serves the religious Zionists. By comparing a freeze on settlement construction to the British Mandate's White Paper, the settlers have shown that they view the institutions of the state as a foreign government. It is no wonder that some members of this camp are even willing to engage in terrorism and violent behavior. The tolerance with which they are treated merely encourages them. The message that these girls are trying to send is that there is no chance of evacuating outposts - not now, and not ever. The problem is not the silence of the girls, but the silence of the leadership. Religious Zionism is slowly removing itself from the camp that carries the torch of the Zionist enterprise, and one can legitimately ask whether its behavior is not becoming anti-Zionist. The use of illegal means in order to achieve their goals has become normative behavior. It is hard to level complaints against teenage girls when MK Aryeh Eldad is personally setting up an illegal outpost. Even if he is not part of religious Zionism's flesh and blood, he sets an example for these girls. In the past, religious Zionism symbolized the actualization of the state. Today, it symbolizes rebellion against the state. And its leaders bear the responsibility. This is not the passing caprice of a few teens, but the metamorphosis of an entire camp from a center of constructive activity to a center of subversion. Bookmark to del.icio.us   Personalized workout Boutique gyms is the next big thing - for those who can pay. No to non-violence 'Human chain' against the blockade on gaza yields disappointing turnout.   1.   Look in the mirror- 09:54  |  Adam 23/01/08   2.   whats more they are correct and the state is wrong 09:55  |  v hardman 23/01/08   3.   Zionism didn`t bring Kadima ! 10:48  |  Akram Zekaria 23/01/08   4.   #1 you should be ashamed 11:13  |  A.M. 23/01/08   5.   WE ARE FUGITIVES 11:23  |  dan 23/01/08   6.   The Law of Return is To The Land And Not the State wich forms 11:41  |  Joseph E . 23/01/08   7.   Editorial and Olmert represents the extreme Left, 11:50  |  Joseph E . 23/01/08   8.   Re Joseph E #6 11:52  |  Esther 23/01/08   9.   Hegelian politics IS foreign to judaism 12:19  |  Alex Levy 23/01/08   10.   A thundering gynephobia 12:22  |  Naftush 23/01/08   11.   Yes Haaretz, the emperor is naked 12:23  |  Another Jew 23/01/08   12.   You can take the Jew out of the ghetto 12:28  |  Rowan Berkeley 23/01/08   13.   6# Joseph E. Can the people of Israel sue the present 12:32  |  Akram Zekaria 23/01/08   14.   The Girls` Identity 12:41  |  Jerry 23/01/08   15.   Haaretz and the left are the TRUE subverisives 12:42  |  Israeli 23/01/08   16.   For all those playing at righteousness.... 12:45  |  Esther 23/01/08   17.   the new law will show who takes money from Israel`s enemies 12:55  |  McDougal V 23/01/08   18.   # 13 Akram Zekaria @ London / UK 12:57  |  Joseph E . 23/01/08   19.   Historical... 12:58  |  Esther 23/01/08   20.   # 16 Esther " Is Inciting to Dodge the Army` 13:10  |  Joseph E . 23/01/08   21.   Joseph E - a groupie of Friedman..... 13:13  |  Esther 23/01/08   22.   # 19 Esther " And these kippa-wearing protesters were right" 13:16  |  Joseph E . 23/01/08   23.   When the left violates the law Haaretz is silent 13:18  |  Mordechai 23/01/08   24.   18# Joseph E. Many thanks for your quick response. 13:34  |  Akram Zekaria 23/01/08   25.   # 21 Esther " What`` got to do thr right wing party with Friedman 13:40  |  Joseph E . 23/01/08   26.   silence 13:45  |  EA 23/01/08   27.   JosephE#22: made yourself perfectly clear..... 13:55  |  Esther 23/01/08   28.   A thundering silence 14:01  |  Ephraim Rubinger 23/01/08   29.   Re Joseph E #20 14:02  |  Esther 23/01/08   30.   Re Joseph E #25 14:11  |  Esther 23/01/08   31.   The New Religious Zionism 14:14  |  Avi Yerushalmi 23/01/08   32.   These girls are heroes 14:16  |  Hilda 23/01/08   33.   Chickens Coming Home To Roost 14:41  |  Yaakov Sullivan 23/01/08   34.   The Monster is out of the bag 15:14  |  The Other Alan 23/01/08   35.   responce to # 14 15:33  |  Sarah 23/01/08   36.   settlers 15:36  |  neturei karta 23/01/08   37.   Re Ya`akov Sullivan #33: required reading... 15:37  |  Esther 23/01/08   38.   A thundering silence 15:46  |  Sam 23/01/08   39.   Governments rule by the consent of the people. 18:23  |  bat yam 23/01/08   40.   #38 sam and government ? what government ? 18:37  |  v hardman 23/01/08   41.   Zionist will ULTIMATELY destroy the very state it built 19:10  |  TrippleJump 23/01/08   42.   They are NOT Zionists 19:43  |  Danite 23/01/08   43.   HIlda 19:45  |  Danite 23/01/08   44.   David Landau,proponent of rape of Israel,against14-yr old girls 19:48  |  Absolute Sweden 23/01/08   45.   state sttlements 21:44  |  Mike Packer 23/01/08   46.   just a small rant 22:53  |  yehuda 26/02/08

Today Online Rosner: Would Obama be supportive of a Likud-led Israel? Responses: 148 Yoel Marcus: Annihilating Israel truly is Iran's goal Responses: 157 Nazir Majali: Why is Israel destroying its ties to Egypt? Responses: 71 Report: Widow of Hezbollah No. 2 says Syria killed him Responses: 99 PM: I'm unsure peace deal with PA possible in 2008 Responses: 65 More Headlines 22:38 Officials: Israel let Egypt boost Gaza border troops 21:43 PM to Japanese Minister: Iran, N. Korea pose a threat to all Asia 18:53 MI Chief: Terrorists trained in Syria, Iran have infiltrated Gaza 22:29 Shalit`s French lawyers say planning to meet his kidnappers 19:45 UN expert: Palestinian terror 'inevitable' result of occupation 13:44 Survey: Jews are America's top-earning religious group 21:47 Military Advocate General: No one culpable for 2006 Beit Hanun shelling 20:13 Olmert: I'm unsure peace deal with PA possible in 2008 19:21 UN: Israel, PA, Egypt must find new strategy to end Gaza crisis 21:10 IDF tank unit kills Palestinian near Gaza border 20:14 Arab League head elected as chief of new launched Arafat Foundation Previous Editions Select Day 25 feb 24 feb 22 feb 21 feb 20 feb 19 feb 18 feb 17 feb 15 feb 14 feb 13 feb 12 feb

Special Offers Advertisement Free the Palestinians from: Corrupt Kleptocracy, Tyrannical Theocracy, Abysmal Anarchy Long-term Israel programs MASA is your gateway. More programs. More grants. 7589 rockets fired so far HELP US TO HELP THEM Marina Royale Herzelia Pituach Your Luxurious Suite While Staying in Israel Fattal Hotel Chain Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel. ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th Dead Sea Salt Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off! Eldan Rent a Car Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations Junkyard Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt

Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |

Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.

© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved