Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., January 28, 2008 Shvat 21, 5768 | | Israel Time: 07:27 (EST+7) web haaretz.com   Back to Homepage Rosner's Domain Diplomacy Defense Jewish World Opinion National Print Edition Advertising Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File

Last update - 00:00 15/01/2008 The Qassam rocket as collective punishment By Bradley Burston, Haaretz Correspondent Tags: Burston, Jews, Israel  Imagine a situation in which thousands and thousands of people, many of them children and the elderly, are plunged into a situation in which they must fear for their lives day in and day out, their livelihoods crippled, their schools and even pre-schools under siege. Entire communities are trapped, paralyzed. Whole childhoods are spent in a state of post-traumatic stress. Occasions which should be high points in a lifetime are routinely curtailed or cancelled. The people of this place are forced to bear the burden of the whole of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. They are the unarmed proxy warriors of their side, victimized by the tactical cruelty of the other. They are the victims of collective punishment. And they live in Israel. The world is unsympathetic. The world does not think highly enough of Hamas to hold it accountable for the actions of the gunners who use the launchers produced by Hamas and the rockets produced by Hamas. The world believes that if Israel outguns Hamas with an arsenal that includes the most advanced fighter bombers and even nuclear weapons, the people of Sderot are somehow protected from the rockets that strike them day in and day out, year after agonizing year. The people of Sderot have nothing but miracles to depend on. And even miracles betray them. Because if they are spared from death by one miracle after another, the world cannot be bothered to care about them. Even their fellow Israelis concede that they would do more to defend the people of Sderot, if more of them were being killed - yet another form of collective punishment. When Israel cut fuel shipments to Gaza this month, the same defense establishment which had been given weeks and months to plan for the step, found itself taken aback that water and sewage pumps stopped working ? not because of Hamas subterfuge or Hamas hyperbole, but because Israel stopped supplying fuel to Palestinian power plants. Many Gazans, non-combatants, were left without water in a public health crisis akin to a natural disaster. There's a certain perverse justice to how this works. When it comes to terrorism, the Palestinians practice intentional killing of civilians. When we kill civilians in the context of military activity, we view it as incidental, the regrettable by-product of necessary self-defense. In the case of collective punishment, the opposite situation obtains. We practice collective punishment as an intentional tactic, believing it to be more humane than outright invasion and carpet bombing ? holding, as we do, to the preposterous hope that after 40 years of failing at it, we will persuade the people of Gaza to bring their own militants to heel. The Palestinians who fire Qassams, meanwhile, see them not as collective punishment but as legitimate self-defense, employed because they have no other alternative. They are wrong. Dead wrong. And so are we. Collective punishment is abhorrent. It is morally reprehensible. It is functionally self-defeating. It destroys the moral fiber of those who order it, practice it, countenance it, turn a blind eye to it. This may explain why the victims of collective punishment may find themselves resorting to its use. We are guilty of it. The Palestinians are guilty no less. Crimes against humanity are crimes against humanity. The victims of crimes against humanity never "had it coming to them" as we might persuade ourselves to believe. We're going to have to find some other way to stop Qassams. After an eternity in which both sides resist it, we may have to talk to Hamas, which can actually get the job done. In the meanwhile, it is time to think long and hard about what we gain and what we lose by practicing collective punishment in Gaza. The Israeli airwaves have been awash in recent days with learned, intelligent people arguing that no one who has a healthy mind supplies his enemies with the tools and the fuels of war. Their point is understandable. But it assumes that there is logic to this conflict. It assumes that the target of Palestinian anger over collective punishment will be Hamas and not Israel. It assumes that the world is ready to change its rotation. It also assumes that the world is ready to accept collective punishment. God help us all when that happens. ______________ Previous blogs: Sharon, savior of the settler, killer of Palestine Mr. Bush, you were born to make peace Here's to the '67 borders, the new middle of the road Hamas - If we can kill them, we can talk to them Self Test: Are you a fanatic on the Middle East? Bookmark to del.icio.us   Officer convicted A military court convicts an IDF officer who led troops in a West Bank rampage. A different Anne Frank A Dutch Jewish condemns the distribution of a postcard of Anne Frank wearing kaffiyeh.   1.   It is better to be humane thatn to be alive 19:58  |  Robert 22/01/08   2.   Bradley you got the labels wrong 21:24  |  Don Camillo 22/01/08   3.   It is the occupation stupid 23:15  |  Bandar Michaels 22/01/08   4.   "Poor Palestinians" 23:26  |  Tim R 22/01/08   5.   Qassams-Bradley version 23:55  |  David Gershon 22/01/08   6.   #5 David Gershon 02:32  |  Dawid 23/01/08   7.   More Gibberish - Big Surprise 03:44  |  Tod Zuckerman 23/01/08   8.   Samuel B.Clemens world famous writer from the USA , 04:42  |  Joseph E . 23/01/08   9.   Gaza "Blackout" and the Laws of War 06:16  |  Joseph E . post 1 23/01/08   10.   D.CAMILLO WRONG collective punishment Qassems,suicide-bombers or 06:19  |  PETER SM 23/01/08   11.   Comments 06:20  |  Joseph E . post 2 23/01/08   12.   Comments 06:21  |  Joseph E . Post 3 23/01/08   13.   Comments from Ceren Article 06:25  |  Joseph E . 23/01/08   14.   BANDAR MICHAELS"occupation" what was your excuse in 1830,1920, 06:28  |  PETER SM 23/01/08   15.   Collective Punishment by Hamas: Hamas closes Gaza bakeries 06:42  |  Joseph E . post 1 23/01/08   16.   Collective Punishment by Hamas: Hamas seizes fuel from hospitals 06:45  |  Joseph E . post 2 23/01/08   17.   "The World" ?? Not READY ? 08:50  |  Rick and TC 23/01/08   18.   ONLY ONE PURPOSE OF QASSAMS 10:49  |  indrajaya 23/01/08   19.   more illogical crap from the don 10:59  |  v hardman 23/01/08   20.   Jews as Invaders or Refugees - Peter SM 11:06  |  Bandar Michaels 23/01/08   21.   I`m not sure the term "collective punishment" is accurate here 11:44  |  Outsider 23/01/08   22.   To Bandar Michaels: "We Palestinians have received" 11:54  |  AA 23/01/08   23.   AA AND RECEIVING 12:44  |  Bandar Michaels 23/01/08   24.   Bradely is half right 12:50  |  pal- 23/01/08   25.   There`s a difference between a nation and a terrorist group 12:59  |  Natallie Durson 23/01/08   26.   Because they have no other alternative... 13:35  |  Mladen Andrijasevic 23/01/08   27.   #25 Nattalie Durson 13:56  |  Sarah 23/01/08   28.   ethnic cleansing--apartheid 14:00  |  Hilda 23/01/08   29.   # 27 - Sarah 14:17  |  Natallie Durson 23/01/08   30.   carpet bombing and nuclear options 14:31  |  akiva (zionist) 23/01/08   31.   #29 Natallie Durson 14:43  |  Sarah 23/01/08   32.   BANDAR MICHAELS There were NO "invaders" in 1830 in Safed 14:43  |  PETER SM 23/01/08   33.   Bradley Compass Off the Mark 14:53  |  B 23/01/08   34.   Goody-goody Jews wring their hands,leave dirty work to other Jews 15:16  |  Sam 23/01/08   35.   collective punishment 15:42  |  Tidi 23/01/08   36.   Natallie #25 working overtime 15:46  |  Tom C 23/01/08   37.   Natallie #25 working overtime 16:03  |  Simone 23/01/08   38.   How years did it take Mr. Burston? 16:37  |  Gee 23/01/08   39.   How years did it take Mr. Burston? 16:37  |  Gee 23/01/08   40.   Peter SM 1830 and 1920 don`t don`t have Historic relevance 16:38  |  Bandar Michaels 23/01/08   41.   We are no better than you, Jews. 16:38  |  CHICAG0 FamilyGuy 23/01/08   42.   Burston Switches Sides ...Again! 16:38  |  Tony Anthony 23/01/08   43.   # 37 - Simone (any relation to Tom?) 17:31  |  Natallie Durson 23/01/08   44.   Comparison of who kills more civilians 18:02  |  Rich 23/01/08   45.   Natallie 18:37  |  Simone 23/01/08   46.   Bradley misses the entire operating logic 18:38  |  Tosefta 23/01/08   47.   Rich re comparisons 18:41  |  Simone 23/01/08   48.   Tosefta 18:57  |  Da Nang 23/01/08   49.   Qassams are not a collective punishment 18:58  |  Boris 23/01/08   50.   Is Gaza occupied 19:01  |  Marco P 23/01/08   51.   worst article Burston has ever written 19:30  |  McQueen 23/01/08   52.   GAwd Bradley, you have lost the plot 19:51  |  Marilyn 23/01/08   53.   Bandar Michaels, I agree with your point with reservations 19:52  |  Yaakov Sullivan 23/01/08   54.   Is Gaza occupied? (Marco #50) 20:19  |  Tosefta 23/01/08   55.   Lifting of a siege is a fine military objective (Da Nang #48) 20:28  |  Tosefta 23/01/08   56.   On one point Bradly is right,assuming Palis 20:52  |  TOMY 23/01/08   57.   indrayaja,genital mitilations in Indonegea 21:00  |  TOMY 23/01/08   58.   #41 As a Catholic I understand your feelings toward Israel 21:52  |  Yaakov Sullivan 23/01/08   59.   Hey, move! 22:21  |  hollingsworth 23/01/08   60.   Mr. Burston`s opening paragraph 22:24  |  hollingsworth 23/01/08   61.   " collective punishment "? Gaza is now EGYPT 22:34  |  Rick and TC 23/01/08   62.   A history lesson for Bandar Michaels #3 22:47  |  dovvod 23/01/08   63.   Tosefta #46 23:06  |  TonyL 23/01/08   64.   Collective reward vs collective punishment 23:13  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 23/01/08   65.   a drama set into motion by the directors 23:42  |  rising suspicions 23/01/08   66.   "we`re going to have to find some other way" 23:43  |  David Howard 23/01/08   67.   Putting and End on Qassams 23:45  |  Igor Kogan 23/01/08   68.   war sucks 00:06  |  rickibobbi 24/01/08   69.   Tosefta 00:41  |  Da Nang 24/01/08   70.   Israel acting as rogue nation 00:44  |  Lance Thruster 24/01/08   71.   Tosefta 00:47  |  Marco P 24/01/08   72.   What the crime requires 01:21  |  Mark Lincoln 24/01/08   73.   they are settlers sitting on stolen Palestinian land 01:44  |  nobodysacred 24/01/08   74.   Lies and damn lies 02:04  |  Joe 24/01/08   75.   Bradley you seem to forget that the people.... 02:26  |  Deborah 24/01/08   76.   #3 and #4, you are both retarded 03:07  |  King David 24/01/08   77.   Careful of what you say, the IDF might improve their aim! 03:26  |  PADDY 24/01/08   78.   War is collective pinishment!! 04:03  |  a wandering Jew 24/01/08   79.   who started this colective punishment trend? 04:08  |  Grassi 24/01/08   80.   Mr. Burston and the new talkback law 04:36  |  Mark Lincoln 24/01/08   81.   Bandar Michaels #40 04:49  |  Mohammed the Dog 24/01/08   82.   collective punishment 05:11  |  Gregor 24/01/08   83.   Jews: Take Long & Hard Look At The Mirror 06:28  |  Joe McCain 24/01/08   84.   Jews: Take Long & Hard Look At The Mirror 06:28  |  Joe McCain 24/01/08   85.   B.MICHAELSArabs killing unarmed Jews No Historic relevance toYOU 06:46  |  PETER SM 24/01/08   86.   to the DOG#75 08:12  |  mosheh 24/01/08   87.   Tosefta #46 Spin, spin, spin And More Spin Till You`ll Rotate... 08:17  |  Tim R 24/01/08   88.   Israel, cries foul play. 08:30  |  Frank Chun 24/01/08   89.   Joe McCain 08:47  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 24/01/08   90.   In the British Navy . . . 09:31  |  Charles 24/01/08   91.   #3 You are right about "Sderot" 10:17  |  Robert Firth 24/01/08   92.   1.3 BILLION MUSLIMS ARE ANGRY! 15:43  |  Mike 24/01/08   93.   Move Hamas prisoners to Sderot 19:21  |  David K. 24/01/08   94.   Baloney, David K. 20:30  |  hollingsworth 24/01/08   95.   Song about Sderot 21:10  |  Dovid 24/01/08   96.   Let the Palestinas be the policemen!! 21:50  |  a wandering Jew 24/01/08   97.   Frank Chun #88 Why Don`t You Do Some Homework? 22:59  |  Tim R 24/01/08   98.   Not "it`s the occupation stupid", just stupid 01:25  |  Gili 25/01/08   99.   The qassam rocket is collective punishment for Israeli appeasment 02:59  |  Chaim 25/01/08   100.   Indiginous Indeed! 03:20  |  Steve 25/01/08   101.   Indiginous Indeed! #3 03:42  |  Steve 25/01/08   102.   "Firther" than the truth 04:45  |  Steve 25/01/08   103.   Proud to look in the mirror 06:05  |  Steve 25/01/08   104.   to Tim R "who is reacting?" 06:41  |  25 25/01/08   105.   Qassams are `self-defence`?? Are you confused - Israel left Gaza 09:29  |  Richard 25/01/08   106.   Israel and the Rational Agent Problem 11:00  |  Thomas Jackson 25/01/08   107.   #104 25 So You Are One of The People Who Don`t Believe In .. 12:28  |  Tim R 25/01/08   108.   Thomas Jackson 15:04  |  American in NY 25/01/08   109.   when the context is war 17:33  |  Harry Scott 25/01/08   110.   I see..... 17:40  |  hollingsworth 25/01/08   111.   hollingsworth #110 Yep ... 21:49  |  Tim R 25/01/08   112.   Hollingsworth (110) looks in the mirror 02:29  |  Steve 26/01/08   113.   Qassam rockets as collective punishment 11:15  |  Zoe 26/01/08   114.   Jew Haters are clearly NOT ROCKET SCIENTISTS! 14:31  |  Elizabeth 26/01/08   115.   Democratic election 00:57  |  Joseph 27/01/08   116.   DEFEAT OF ISRAEL IS-REAL 02:42  |  Joe McCain 28/01/08   117.   WORLD VIEW OF ISRAEL 02:48  |  Joe McCain 28/01/08   118.   Joe McCainn #116 and #117 Who Is Resisting Whom? 03:36  |  Tim R 28/01/08   119.   Natalie Durson #29 A Cease Fire For A Cease Fire.. 06:24  |  Tim R 28/01/08

Today Online PM promises Abbas not to disrupt flow of aid to Gaza Responses: 189 Anti-Semitic incidents rise in Germany, Australia, U.S. in 2007 Responses: 136 Editorial: Gaza border crisis endangers peace with Egypt Responses: 126 Gideon Levy: IDF troops fell because of Israel's war of folly Responses: 88 Dutch Jewish group slams image of Anne Frank wearing kaffiyeh Responses: 80 Rosner's Domain Two days before the Florida primary, Rudy seeks solace in football The best Jewish date (What To Read) McCain using support for Israel to court Jews - and Christians Poll: How important is Israel in the 2008 election? More Headlines 06:27 Source: J'lem will be last topic on peace agenda 04:20 Officials: Israel won't let Gaza border breach threaten security 02:21 Iran offers to help Egypt deal with chaos at Gaza Strip border 23:48 Report: Barak met secretly with Pakistan's Musharraf last week 01:13 Lodz Ghetto document reveals 'Israel's 1st declaration of independence' 23:51 IAF wounds four Hamas militants in strike on armored car in Gaza 05:40 Egypt shuts stores, cooperates with Hamas to urge Gazans to return home 04:37 AG: Policemen will not be indicted for deaths of 13 in October riots 05:06 EU foreign ministers to meet Monday to revamp Palestinian aid plan 00:38 Arab FMs nix Syrian bid to strengthen Hezbollah as 8 killed in Lebanon 04:12 Panel recommends expansion of Wisconsin welfare-to-work plan 05:54 Court sends employer to jail for underpaying employees in unprecedented ruling 04:54 Fun Munich carnival held on Holocaust remembrance day angers Jews Previous Editions Select Day 27 jan 25 jan 24 jan 23 jan 22 jan 21 jan 20 jan 18 jan 17 jan 16 jan 15 jan 14 jan

Special Offers Advertisement Dead Sea Salt Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off! FAREWELL ISRAEL New Film The Coming War for Islamic Revival - View Movie Trailer Inbal Jerusalem Hotel Unbeatable rates at the Finest hotel in Jerusalem Eldan Rent a Car Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations SUPER-TUESDAY U.S. PRESIDENTIAL PRIMARY U.S. citizen in Israel vote Democrats-Abroad Global Primary online, in-person. Junkyard Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt

Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |

© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved