Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., January 15, 2008 Shvat 8, 5768 | | Israel Time: 10:47 (EST+7) web haaretz.com   Back to Homepage Rosner's Domain Diplomacy Defense Jewish World Opinion National Print Edition Advertising Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File

Last update - 09:51 14/01/2008 Abbas should be safeguarded By Akiva Eldar Tags: Israel President George W. Bush, who came to jump-start the peace talks, is fading in the distance, and the large-scale military action in Gaza is getting closer. It is as if there are two peoples: The people of the West Bank and the people of Gaza. With the first we make peace and with the second we go to war. There are even those who "know" that the president of the West Bank, Mahmoud Abbas, "begged" Prime Minister Ehud Olmert to go all-out against Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh's state. They propose bringing back Fatah people to rule Gaza, riding in Israel Defense Forces tanks, and hope that Abbas' police will protect the children of Sderot. It is hard to tell which possibility is worse - that these advisors believe what they say, or that they have decided to eradicate the last Palestinian. A large-scale Israeli military operation against Hamas in the Gaza Strip will not only not strengthen Abbas' status in the territories; it will fatally damage him and might even bring about a Hamas takeover of the West Bank. The pictures of the dead and wounded Palestinians in the Strip will thwart the shred of a chance that Fatah will keep its pledges in security matters not only in Gaza, but in the West Bank, as per the first stage of the Road Map. Advertisement To the Palestinian public, Fatah will become a South Lebanese Army clone, and its supporters in Gaza will be forced to ally themselves with Hamas for protection. The strengthening of Hamas will deepen the influence of Iran and Hezbollah in the territories. The Annapolis process will collapse and with it Abbas and the two-state solution. Lacking a central government in Gaza, the IDF will become bogged down there and bear responsibility for the humanitarian disaster that is already taking place. Hamas is showing increasing interest in lifting the blockade of the Gaza Strip and is reiterating its proposal to declare a cease-fire. Such messages reveal pressure from the population in the Strip, which is not enjoying Hamas policies, to put it mildly. However, Israel should not be lured into temporary agreements with Hamas that will perpetuate its hold over a large part of the territories. If Olmert really sees Abbas as a partner for a peace agreement and wants to strengthen his position, he must also see Abbas as the address for the end of the violent conflict and for easing the economic distress in the Strip. Israel must not hand Hamas the achievement of a massive prisoner release in exchange for Gilad Shalit. Marwan Barghouti and hundreds of Fatah and Hamas prisoners, with or without blood on their hands, should be handed over to Abbas. These are all essential conditions, but they are not enough. A cease-fire in Gaza, without progress in talks on the core issues, will become a pause in the uprising against the occupation and will augment support for Hamas. A failure and even a freeze of the talks will illustrate to the inhabitants of the territories the powerlessness of the pragmatic camp, which hangs its hopes on the diplomatic path, as opposed to the success of organizations like Hamas and Hezbollah to rankle the Israelis by violent means. Significant diplomatic progress, accompanied by the easing of restrictions on the ground will make damage control possible in regional and international channels. A positive atmosphere around the negotiating table will be a convenient context for discussions of an initiative to replace the IDF in Gaza with an international force. Israel has come across the chance to prove to the residents of the territories that their choice of Hamas was a mistake, and to announce that it is prepared to sign an agreement with Abbas that includes a cease-fire and the opening of the Gaza Strip crossings. That will, of course, require restraint from the IDF and close supervision by the government over the army. If Hamas refuses the cease-fire, it will be the one that bears responsibility for the continued siege and IDF actions in Gaza. The organization will not disappear as a result, but it will be politically weakened in the mind of the Palestinian public. The prime minister determined that without dividing the country, "Israel is finished." Thus the strengthening of the Palestinian partner to the two-state solution is in Israel's existential interest. Before he decides to undertake an extensive military operation in Gaza, to free Hamas prisoners, surrender to Avigdor Lieberman or give in to the settlers, the prime minister must ask himself whether it is best for the Jews, or whether it will harm the essential partner essential for the existence of their state. We must safeguard Abbas. Bookmark to del.icio.us   Diskin's faulty math The Shin Bet's estimate of civilian casualties was revealed to be too low. Wooing minorities The color of Barack Obama's skin has returned as an issue to the campaign.   1.   We must not invade Gaza 10:05  |  Dror 14/01/08   2.   There are many reasons not to invade Gaza, aside from Abbas 10:06  |  Natallie Durson 14/01/08   3.   Elfar,move your granddaugter Tamar to Sderot and then write your 10:13  |  Absolute Sweden 14/01/08   4.   HAMAS will "hang Abbas as a traitor" when they take over 10:15  |  PETER SM 14/01/08   5.   Our mistake is... 10:34  |  Walter 14/01/08   6.   Eldar needs to wake up from his radical agenda 10:50  |  Ken Jurist 14/01/08   7.   Want to strengthin Abbas? 10:57  |  Mechooel 14/01/08   8.   #1 Dror is correct 11:03  |  ATLAS 14/01/08   9.   to PETER SM #4 11:44  |  zeev 14/01/08   10.   To Ken Jurist 11:49  |  Anne 14/01/08   11.   ABBAS BEGGED OLMERT TO DESTROY GAZA? 11:55  |  indrajaya 14/01/08   12.   Again, Eldar scores on a vital point 12:04  |  Ivar 14/01/08   13.   this guy is an imbecile ! when are you going to learn? 12:14  |  v hardman 14/01/08   14.   Before all else, Abbas and the rest of the Arab, Palestinian and 12:32  |  Natan Katzenelson 14/01/08   15.   ZEEV.Hamasa showed how strong Abbas was in Gaza,in a few hours. 12:44  |  PETER SM 14/01/08   16.   BUSH PUSHING ANTI-ISRAEL AGENDA OF STATE DEPT ARABISTS 12:51  |  G. Marcus 14/01/08   17.   Gaza 14:09  |  Hilda 14/01/08   18.   to PETER SM #15 14:49  |  zeev 14/01/08   19.   Wrong assumptions 15:10  |  Frank 14/01/08   20.   There`s a Separate Hell For the Saudis and Their Kind 15:35  |  Klaudia 14/01/08   21.   Perhaps This Was the Topic of bush/olmert meet last week 15:49  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/01/08   22.   hamas and fatah 16:19  |  maria 14/01/08   23.   It is to the people of Palestine to strengthen Abbas, NOT Israel! 16:31  |  AliciaYasmeen 14/01/08   24.   Divide not the country , Mow Down Fatah-Hamas Occupation 16:35  |  Joseph E . 14/01/08   25.   Mow down domestic and foreign enemy 16:38  |  Joseph E . 14/01/08   26.   Akiva Eldar makes no sense as usual 16:47  |  Gee 14/01/08   27.   to Frank #19 17:01  |  zeev 14/01/08   28.   Natan @ 14, I fully agree with you! In addition, once 17:05  |  Yaron 14/01/08   29.   Next Year, Eldar Will Say.... 18:15  |  ZADOK 14/01/08   30.   Abbas weakness comes from Gaza`s nest of snakes 18:45  |  Marwan مروان خوري 14/01/08   31.   YES SAFEGUARD THE IDIOT WHO IS SELLING PALESTINE CHEAP! 18:58  |  TrippleJump 14/01/08   32.   safe guard who..? 19:08  |  ravi 14/01/08   33.   Time to trade Abu Mazen for a draft pick to be named later 19:11  |  Jacob Blues 14/01/08   34.   # 23, ALICIA YASMEEN 19:12  |  indrajaya 14/01/08   35.   Who is Akiva Eldar? A Netanya-based selfhater par excellence 19:22  |  Nemesis 14/01/08   36.   Israel and Gaza 19:22  |  Jacqui Isensee 14/01/08   37.   Kill `em FIRST, then talk 19:29  |  Raffa 14/01/08   38.   abbas and eldar 19:35  |  Connie 14/01/08   39.   To Ravi 19:48  |  Jacqui 14/01/08   40.   Right Natan (14), but shouldn´t Israel try to reach out 19:51  |  Karl 14/01/08   41.   to Natan Katzenelson #14 23:39  |  zeev 14/01/08

Today Online Israel begins building 60 new homes in East Jerusalem Responses: 39 Israel offers Jewish Anglo doctors $60,000 to immigrate Responses: 37 Ex-U.S. envoy: Slim chance for Mideast peace by end of year Responses: 25 PM to aides: Progress in peace talks worth risk to coalition Responses: 5 Yoel Marcus: Bush may be a lame duck, but he's determined Responses: 1 More Headlines 10:45 IDF raid kills 7 Palestinians; Gaza sniper kills farmhand 10:17 PM to aides: Progress in peace talks worth risk to coalition 10:10 Israel begins constructing 60 new homes in East Jerusalem 09:07 Israel offers Anglo doctors $60,000 in immigration incentive 09:09 Historian threatens to reveal Polish atrocities against Jews if tried for slander 09:03 Ex-U.S. envoy: Slim chance for Mideast peace by end of year 09:36 Settler group refuses to vacate land slated for school for the disabled 09:05 Archaeological discoveries may prove barrier to Jaffa port rejuvenation 09:42 Homeless woman dies of exposure to cold on bench in Bat Yam 09:15 University heads: Deal with lecturers in 2 days or semester canceled Previous Editions Select Day 14 jan 13 jan 11 jan 10 jan 09 jan 08 jan 07 jan 06 jan 04 jan 03 jan 02 jan 01 jan

Special Offers Advertisement Dead Sea Salt Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off! Teach & Study Program make a difference in Israel FAREWELL ISRAEL New Film The Coming War for Islamic Revival - View Movie Trailer Inbal Jerusalem Hotel Unbeatable rates at the Finest hotel in Jerusalem Long-term Israel programs MASA is your gateway. More programs. More grants. Eldan Rent a Car Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations AMERICANS CHOOSE DEMOCRATIC NOMINEE U.S. citizen in Israel vote in Democrats-Abroad official global primary.

Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World |