A thorn in the Shin Bet's side - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Thu., January 10, 2008 Shvat 3, 5768

Israel Time: 16:10 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Rosner's Domain

Diplomacy

Defense

Jewish World

Opinion

National

Print Edition

Advertising

Books

Arts & Leisure

Business

Real Estate

Easy Start

Travel

Week's End

Anglo File

Last update - 09:46 08/01/2008

A thorn in the Shin Bet's side

By Amira Hass

Tags: Shin Bet, Israel

About a month ago, Dr. Mustafa Barghouti was invited to the Italian Consulate in Jerusalem to receive a citation of honor from the government of Italy. The consulate submitted requests to the Israeli authorities for 15 entry permits to Jerusalem, for Barghouti and another 14 guests - family members and friends. The consulate was informed that 14 permits were issued. Only Barghouti did not receive a permit, he relates with a laugh.

Ever since March 2007, upon the establishment of the Palestinian unity government, the Civil Administration has not granted Barghouti - a physician by profession - entry permits to the Gaza Strip. A member of the Legislative Council for the National Initiative list that he established, Barghouti was the information minister in that short-lived unity government.

For the past three months he has not been receiving entry permits for Jerusalem either. He estimates that he has requested entry into Jerusalem 12 or 13 times. For the most part, it was European diplomats who invited him to meetings, and it was they who submitted the request for the permit. On one occasion it was Labor MK Ophir Pines-Paz.

	Advertisement

The Shin Bet security service has told Haaretz in response that "Mustafa Barghouti is forbidden to enter Israel, and this is because of, among other things, his connections with terror activists and activity on behalf of a terror organization, and with no connection to his membership in the National Initiative list in the Legislative Council."

As in thousands of other cases of individuals denied freedom of movement, the Shin Bet seems to be revealing a small glimpse while concealing the whole picture. It feels confident in firing off its standard reply because the majority in the Jewish society of Israel backs it and is convinced that the organization is guided by pure, objective and professional security considerations. It is convinced that Shin Bet officers are devoid of personal and bullying motives, and that they are either not influenced by a wink from the political echelon or that it is not possible that they have been ordered or advised to suit the political excuse to a political intention.

In Israel, most of the public is convinced: If a person does not get a travel permit of any sort, the Shin Bet has conclusive proof that he is dangerous. So maybe it is a blunder by the Shin Bet and the Israel Defense Forces that Mustafa Barghouti moves freely back and forth to Jenin, Nablus, Ramallah and Hebron like tens of thousands of other people "prohibited for security reasons?" Because what can the layman conclude? That a person who "is active for a terror organization" must be apprehended, if only for questioning. But Barghouti has not been arrested, even when during Ramadan he tried to enter Jerusalem when Israeli authorities allowed all people over 50 to enter the city. He was delayed for three hours at the checkpoint and sent back, even though he is "active on behalf of a terrorist organization."

The travel permits are a way to tell Palestinian public figures exactly whom the Israeli patron wants to honor. Whose politics is tolerated, whose is legitimate and whose is intolerable. With no connection to the electoral weakness of Barghouti's National Initiative, the messages that are linked with his name are clear, resonant and popular: Hamas and Fatah have to get down off their high horses, rectify the serious mistakes they have made in recent months, and get back on the path of unity to fight the occupation. Popular struggle - along the separation fence, against the Jewish settlements in the occupied territories and against the apartheid roads - is the most effective means, which involves the entire society.

Only last Friday, Barghouti, with hundreds of Palestinian activists and a hundred Israelis, took part in a demonstration against Road 443, which is blocked to Palestinians. Barghouti is frequently interviewed by foreign journalists because of his eloquence, and he is exactly the person who will stick pins in balloons that are inflated with false optimism on the progress of the negotiations because the Palestinian and Israeli negotiating chiefs - Ahmed Qureia and Tzipi Livni - have managed to come up with procedures for convening the committee that will discuss "the core issues."

His messages interfere with the new taming course that Israel is trying to give the Palestinian Authority's high officials. Its main lesson is how to nurture the rupture with Hamas and how to swallow the frog of the settlements. And this is what makes Barghouti a thorn in the side of the Shin Bet.

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	'Bush go home'
	Israeli Arab parties join leftist protests against the Bush visit.


	Peace overture
	Syria says it isn't seeking a military solution with Israel.




1.	Amira the occupier	09:58	\|	Daily Harangue	08/01/08

2.	Roger Clemins is Right!!!	10:11	\|	Andy Pettite	08/01/08

3.	With my salary I could help!!	10:14	\|	A-Rod	08/01/08

4.	Count me in too !!	10:16	\|	Lebron James	08/01/08

5.	There are no rights of entry for foreign citizens	10:23	\|	josef cohen	08/01/08

6.	the terms "terror" and "terrorism" are mystifications	10:55	\|	Rowan Berkeley	08/01/08

7.	this guy barghouti is a joke	10:59	\|	matt	08/01/08

8.	Amira & her terrorists friends	12:20	\|	Stephanie J	08/01/08

9.	And Israel wants to have sole control over Jerusalem!	12:38	\|	El-Birawi	08/01/08

10.	More lies from the traitoress	13:41	\|	dudu	08/01/08

11.	#6 ash tree take a course in law -intent is part of law	13:53	\|	victor hardman	08/01/08

12.	Amira Hass and Norman Finkelstein together in the same web page	14:21	\|	Shaul	08/01/08

13.	A Symptom of Apartheid, Israeli Style	14:53	\|	Yaakov Sullivan	08/01/08

14.	# 10 more lies from you know whom	15:05	\|	Jacqueline K	08/01/08

15.	to racist number 9	18:05	\|	Jerusalem status quo	08/01/08

16.	Amira, Shin Bet picked on the wrong man	08:07	\|	Dutch	09/01/08

17.	#12 Shaul, surely, you mean...	08:43	\|	Dutch	09/01/08

18.	Amira, Shin Bet	11:02	\|	isreal	09/01/08

19.	Barghouthi holds a mirror to the face of Israel`s occupation...	11:13	\|	Sarah	09/01/08

20.	Amira Hass - Kapo, first class?	11:35	\|	Andrei Iosef	09/01/08

21.	Thank goodness Haaretz doesn`t listen to its readers` rantings	12:12	\|	Kirsty	09/01/08

22.	to #5: East Jerusalem is not in Israel, it is occupied!	12:13	\|	emmanuel levy	09/01/08

23.	Thank you to Amira Haas	16:05	\|	Shira Avni	10/01/08

Today Online


	Bush: I believe we will reach peace deal by the end of 2008
	Responses: 157


	Libya thwarts Security Council censure of Shlomi missile strike
	Responses: 57


	Shavit: If they want a state, Palestinians must undergo ideology change
	Responses: 78


	W. Bank Palestinians brace for visit by 'that criminal' Bush
	Responses: 44

More Headlines
12:32 Bush: I believe we will reach peace deal in 2008


13:56 ANALYSIS: Palestinians believe Bush won't pressure Israel


15:22 Israeli envoy to U.S.: All options are on the table regarding Iran


15:53 Manchester United invited to play during Israel's 60th anniversary celebrations


14:26 British magazine names Israeli model Bar Refaeli 'Body of 2008'


15:24 Montenegro air base that played role in Israel's birth under threat


14:13 Ministers to present PM list of Palestinians to free for Shalit


15:55 From Amsterdam to Tel Aviv: Israel's 2nd city promotes bicycling