Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., February 03, 2008 Shvat 27, 5768 | | Israel Time: 11:25 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Advertising
Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 09:31 11/01/2008
Sharon, savior of the settler, killer of Palestine
By Bradley Burston
Tags: Burston, Ariel Sharon, Hamas 

Genius in statecraft is often slow to reveal itself. Genius in strategy often masquerades as folly.

Consider the case of Ariel Sharon. An opinion poll conducted ahead of the second anniversary of his devastating January 4, 2006 cerebral hemorrhage, showed that 26.8 percent of Israelis believe that Sharon's stroke was punishment for his expulsion of thousands of settlers and soldiers from the Gaza Strip less than half a year before.

The survey also showed that percentage of Israelis who believe this to be true was more than twice as high among the ultra-Orthodox. Asked whether it was correct to "connect Sharon's health conditions to his part in the disengagement and view it as a punishment," 56.6 percent of the Haredim surveyed agreed with the statement.
Advertisement
In time, we may come to view these numbers as especially curious, not to say cruel, in view of the following:

In erasing all traces of Israel in the Gaza Strip in the space of six days in the summer of 2006, Sharon may have guaranteed the occupation of the West Bank and Jerusalem lands captured by Israel in the space of six days in the summer of 1967.

Though he incurred the fiery wrath of the right and the religious, Sharon in disengaging from Gaza may have ensured the existence of West Bank settlements in perpetuity.

In the bargain - and this may have been his ultimate intention - he set in motion the events which have demolished the movement for an independent Palestine. Perhaps more correctly, he paved the way for the Palestinian national movement to demolish itself, perhaps permanently.

We may never know what Sharon's real intentions were in ordering and overseeing the dissolution of the settlement project he once shepherded in the Strip. On the face of it, he was tearing apart the very enterprise that had been his life's work, the settlement movement in the territories.

Certainly, without Sharon's prodding, planning, and literal bulldozing as founding ideologue of the Likud, as agriculture minister, as defense minister, and as infrastructures minister, the settlement movement would be but an anemic shadow of its present status as a central arbiter of Israeli policy and effective landlord of much of the West Bank.

Only a mind as endlessly imaginative and bottomlessly outrageous as Sharon's could have come up with the notion of blanketing the territories with settlements, and then causing them to materialize.

Only a mind as keenly attuned to public opinion as Sharon's could have perceived that the Israeli people couldn't wait to leave Gaza, even avowed right-wingers, who, after one tour of reserve duty in that least Jewish of places, became overnight converts to the idea of building a fence around the place and giving it away.

Only a mind as relentless as Sharon's could know that the anguish engendered by the disengagement, coupled with the government's signal inability to resettle 8,000 of the total of more than a quarter million settlers, would forever give Israelis pause over a further expulsion. Moreover, in offering Gush Katif and Netzarim as a sacrifice, Sharon won landmark White House support for future annexation of settlement blocs in the West Bank.

Finally, only a mind as guileful as Sharon's could have foreseen that from the moment that Israel left Gaza, the Palestinians would do everything they could to stand in the way of their own statehood:

  • That the Palestinians would immediately act to lose international sympathy by using the ruins of settlements not as platforms for promoting critically needed employment for Gazans, but as launching sites to attack Israeli civilian population

  • That the Israeli withdrawal from Gaza would be claimed and exploited as a grand victory by the Islamists of Hamas, who would then crush the corrupt and feeble Fatah in an election victory which caught Hamas entirely unprepared for rule.

  • That their election victory would prompt Hamas officials, who rode to power on an anti-corruption ticket, to explore the temptations of corruption on their own.

  • That the frictions of governance would lead Hamas and Fatah to a step which Palestinians had believed unthinkable: a civil war in which the brutality of Hamas prompted immediate and persuasive comparisons to the harshest measures of Israeli occupation.

  • That the split would also be reflected in an international boycott of the remaining Palestinian government in Gaza, encompassing such traditional friends and benefactors of the Palestinians as the United Nations, the European Union, and Russia.

  • That the sectarian feud and the lack of coherent leadership would so demoralize Palestinians that they would begin to question the very wisdom of establishing an independent Palestine in the foreseeable future.

    The hard right and the fanatically religious can curse Sharon and gloat over his incapacitation all they want. Even as they spat on him, burned him in effigy, blackened his memory, denigrated his deeds, he did their work for them, all by himself.

    ______________


    Previous blogs:

    Mr. Bush, you were born to make peace
    Here's to the '67 borders, the new middle of the road
    Hamas - If we can kill them, we can talk to them
    Self Test: Are you a fanatic on the Middle East?
    People who hate the very idea of peace
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    'British Oskar Schindler'
    Nicholas Winton, who saved 669 Jewish children during the Holocaust, is up for the Nobel.
    Pride of Israel
    Tennis: Shahar Peer beats Russia's Dinara Safina to give Israel 1-0 lead in the Fed Cup.
      1.   Burstons nonsense surpasses himself 10:21  |  Natallie Durson 11/01/08
      2.   In killing the Palestinian State, did Sharon also kill Israel? 10:30  |  Clickfool 11/01/08
      3.   ONLY SOLUTION: GAZA UNDER EGYPT; PARTS OF W.BANK LINKED TO JORDAN 10:32  |  G. Marcus 11/01/08
      4.   The road to the one-state solution 11:02  |  Velvl Shmerlson 11/01/08
      5.   Natallie 11:07  |  James 11/01/08
      6.   Sharon Saw Much Less 11:18  |  dyinglikeflies 11/01/08
      7.   Well Written Bradley 11:28  |  FOX 11/01/08
      8.   Only One State Soultion 11:31  |  Tupac 11/01/08
      9.   to # 3 G. Marcus Oedipus the great. 11:35  |  Steve the Pals. 11/01/08
      10.   Reasonable and comprehensive speculation 11:43  |  Shalom Freedman 11/01/08
      11.   Check your blood pressure, Natallie 11:52  |  nina 11/01/08
      12.   #2 Clickfool 11:56  |  Avi 11/01/08
      13.   This article makes absolutely no sense 11:57  |  Zev 11/01/08
      14.   #4, Velvl 12:06  |  Avi 11/01/08
      15.   Machiavellian intentions? 12:09  |  David Howard 11/01/08
      16.   Don`t remove any Settlers, make them Pals 12:26  |  Joe 11/01/08
      17.   Bradley, don`t confuse Sharon with G-d 12:45  |  Burned Liberal 11/01/08
      18.   Clickfool`s final nail in his reputation`s coffin 13:10  |  Nik Miller 11/01/08
      19.   #1 nutullie and total confusion about peac 13:10  |  victor hardman 11/01/08
      20.   What`s your point Burston? Both the `illegal` outposts so called, 13:12  |  lakshmi 11/01/08
      21.   #1 Natallie durson 13:14  |  Avi 11/01/08
      22.   BURSTON WAS MISGUIDED AND DISORIENTED 13:16  |  indrajaya 11/01/08
      23.   For Avi # 12 13:19  |  Clickfool 11/01/08
      24.   Sharon. Terrorist, war criminal etc. 13:44  |  Jens 11/01/08
      25.   Shalom Freedman (Post No. 10) 14:06  |  Johnny Weintraub 11/01/08
      26.   "blackened his memory, denigrated his deeds" 14:08  |  Sarah L 11/01/08
      27.   Hardly unforeseeable.... 14:13  |  Tenar 11/01/08
      28.   removed all traces??? 14:18  |  Viktor H 11/01/08
      29.   Durson- on Israeli expansion 14:25  |  Sam 11/01/08
      30.   Joe VA `our public funds` who are you? 14:35  |  enquiring minds 11/01/08
      31.   a poem for haaretz ! 14:36  |  ... 11/01/08
      32.   STUPİD HEERTZ :) 14:38  |  ... 11/01/08
      33.   would you kindly accept my apologise 14:39  |  ... 11/01/08
      34.   haartez heeertez huurtez haaaarets hiiirtiz haxwertes 14:49  |  karggogoogluoggluu 11/01/08
      35.   haretzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz 15:01  |  :) 11/01/08
      36.   well I forgive you guys always 15:02  |  ... 11/01/08
      37.   :) 15:05  |  :) 11/01/08
      38.   Lebensraum and Irony 15:06  |  Yaakov Sullivan 11/01/08
      39.   Just another long term Sharon plan failure 15:11  |  Tosefta 11/01/08
      40.   #9: "Palestinian" identity is Arab invention against Israel 15:20  |  G. Marcus 11/01/08
      41.   Sharon vs. Bush; a comparison 15:22  |  Tosefta 11/01/08
      42.   The Fraud 15:24  |  Joseph E . post 1 11/01/08
      43.   The Fraud 15:26  |  Joseph E . post 2 11/01/08
      44.   Avi from Motzkin on the Arabs 15:27  |  Yakkov Sullivan 11/01/08
      45.   The Assessment 15:27  |  Joseph E . Post 3 11/01/08
      46.   haaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaretz 15:28  |  :) 11/01/08
      47.   End Murderous Arab Occupation NOW . 15:29  |  Joseph E . Post 4 11/01/08
      48.   Killer of Gush Katif Creator of Hamastan 15:42  |  B 11/01/08
      49.   Any peace will require an end to Murdeous Arab Occupation 15:50  |  Joseph E . 11/01/08
      50.   haaretz ! I got a good news :) 15:53  |  ... 11/01/08
      51.   To # 14 Avi 15:57  |  Velvl Shmerlson 11/01/08
      52.   HAARETZ ! IS SHABBAT BEGIN ? 15:57  |  Atilla Karagözoğlu 11/01/08
      53.   Arik Sharon is a hero! 15:58  |  Michael Steiner 11/01/08
      54.   # 20 lakshmi 15:59  |  Joseph E . 11/01/08
      55.   HAARETZ ! SHUT UP PLEASE, SHABBAT JUST STARTED 16:00  |  ARUTZ 7 11/01/08
      56.   Sharon still on machines? 16:04  |  Aaron 11/01/08
      57.   # 20 lakshmi 16:05  |  Joseph E . 11/01/08
      58.   ONE SINGLE THING ABOUT SHARON 16:15  |  indrajaya 11/01/08
      59.   Why is Slowman so slow on Fridays? 16:25  |  Bursting Brad 11/01/08
      60.   MY GREATEST LOVE ! YOU HAARETZ ! 16:29  |  ... 11/01/08
      61.   RULES ! RULES ARE TO DESTROY FOR ME 16:40  |  ... 11/01/08
      62.   #23, Yakkov Sullivan 16:40  |  Avi 11/01/08
      63.   Palis never claimed a state after 1967 war 17:15  |  TOMY 11/01/08
      64.   You give Sharon way too much credit 17:28  |  B (not #26) 11/01/08
      65.   Sharon, a master of cunning and calculation 17:32  |  Yaakov Sullivan 11/01/08
      66.   Friday much less jew haters 17:34  |  Rasputin 11/01/08
      67.   yaakob sllivan 17:37  |  danny 11/01/08
      68.   sharon and Gaza 17:39  |  Yaakov Sullivan 11/01/08
      69.   aha,so Amos Schocken,David Landau &rest of "Haaretz"=killers of P 17:53  |  Absolute Sweden 11/01/08
      70.