Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., April 02, 2008 Adar2 27, 5768 | | Israel Time: 12:54 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Advertising
Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Another obstacle to Zionism
By Akiva Eldar
Tags: Occupied Territories, Zionism 

After recognizing "Jewish population concentrations" in the territories, President George W. Bush brought down from the attic the old American position under which the settlements are an obstacle to peace. Bush was not entirely accurate. The settlements are not an obstacle to peace. What would happen if the Palestinians were to announce tomorrow morning that they welcome the settlers and are relinquishing their demand for an independent state in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, with its capital in East Jerusalem? What would we do if Hamas were to lay down its arms and unilaterally declare a hudna (temporary truce) for 50 years? What would we say if the Palestinians were to demand that Israel annex the territories, including Kiryat Arba and Hebron, Nablus and Itamar? In that case, the settlements would not be an obstacle to peace. They would be the epilogue to the Zionist story.

For too many years many people in Israel, including fine people on the left, saw in the settlement movement a new, national-religious version of the secular Zionist movement. The time has come to examine this myth in light of the current reality between the sea and the Jordan River, at the end of 40 years of settlement. In the state's 60th year, it is no longer possible to hold onto the argument that in 1948, too, we stole Arab lands. That chapter of the Zionist struggle ended on May 15, 1948. The Declaration of Independence laid the moral foundations for the state of the Jews - the realization of the Zionist vision.

The constitutive Zionist document guarantees that this state will provide "complete equality of social and political rights to all its inhabitants." This declaration means that if the territories are annexed, Israel is obligated to grant the rights of citizenship to Palestinians as well, including the right to vote and to be voted into the Knesset. Within the Green Line, the pre-1967 borders, Jews constitute a solid majority (79 percent). According to demographic forecasts, the separation of Israel and the territories would guarantee that in 2020, too, the Jews will retain their relative advantage. But annexation of the West Bank and East Jerusalem - whether officially or de facto - makes the territory between the sea and the Jordan River a binational state even now (54 percent Jews, 46 percent non-Jews).
Advertisement
The Zionist leadership declared that the State of Israel "will be based on freedom, justice and peace." The settlement in the heart of the territories has for 40 years denied freedom to millions of people, including the freedom of movement. What connection is there between the expropriation of "state lands" or the takeover of private lands, on the one hand, and the creation of justice and peace, on the other? How does the enormous growth in the number of settlers since the signing of the Oslo Accords (from 100,000 in 1993 to 270,000 today) square with the 60-year-old declaration, "We extend our hand to all neighboring states and their peoples in an offer of peace and good neighborliness."?

Were it not for its fear of the settlers, Israel would not be ignoring the extended hand of the Arab League, which offers peace and good neighborliness within the June 4, 1967, borders. And what is the contribution of the settlements to Israel's international standing, in keeping with the declaration, "We appeal to the United Nations to assist the Jewish people in the building-up of its State and to receive the State of Israel into the comity of nations"? The settlements and the course of the separation fence, which was tailored to suit their needs, have drawn the largest number of UN condemnations and international protests against Israel.

The most important Zionist-political document also announced that the new state "will foster the development of the country for the benefit of all its inhabitants." The development of the land of the settlers for the benefit of a minority, who do not even amount to 5 percent of the state's inhabitants, was carried out at the expense of other areas of the country, including the underprivileged towns, and the Negev and Galilee in general. The salaries of the employees of the local and regional authorities in the Judea and Samaria District (the West Bank) always arrive on time. And we have not even mentioned the enormous sums spent by the Israel Defense Forces in protecting the settlements and their access routes.

America discovered a generation ago that the settlements are an obstacle to peace. That has not kept Israel from expanding these obstacles even today. For years Ehud Olmert poured fire and brimstone on those who warned that the way of the settlements, of which he was a follower, would lead to a binational state. He dismissed those who warned, more than 50 years before he himself said it to Haaretz, that if a two-state solution is not reached soon, "the State of Israel is finished." Apart from talking, what is Olmert doing to remove the obstacle from the path of Zionism?
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
WHO knows?
The WHO says Israel lets Gazans die in 'avoidable tragedies'.
Friendly faces
Google, Facebook and Yahoo heads will attend a J'lem technology summit.
  1.   PALESTINIANS MOTHERS ARE THE REAL OBSTACLE 08:10  |  indrajaya 07/01/08
  2.   The Obstacle is how you word it Akiva 08:32  |  Yardena 07/01/08
  3.   Inherent obstacle 08:34  |  English Resident 07/01/08
  4.   how does haaretz spell peas? piece ? 08:40  |  victor hardman 07/01/08
  5.   An inaccuracy Minimization of the problem 08:44  |  Shalom Freedman 07/01/08
  6.   Whaddaymean, "no longer possible"? 08:50  |  Rowan Berkeley 07/01/08
  7.   Is this the REAL obstacle! 08:51  |  Yitz 07/01/08
  8.   #1 obstacle is miss-obstacle 09:03  |  Yardena 07/01/08
  9.   My name is Israel and I haven`t had an annexation for 1 week 09:05  |  Natallie Durson 07/01/08
  10.   Indrajaya: Religious Jews Have FAR More ChildrenThan Muslims 09:13  |  Yishai Kohen 07/01/08
  11.   Settlements are the embodiment of Zionism 09:14  |  Dani 07/01/08
  12.   # 9, NATALLIE DURSON 09:21  |  indrajaya 07/01/08
  13.   THERE WILL NEVER BE A "PALESTINIAN" STATE! PERIOD! 09:39  |  WARRIOR 07/01/08
  14.   OBSTACLE TO PEACE= LEFT-WING TRAITORS IN ISRAEL 09:40  |  LIBERAL 07/01/08
  15.   Palestinisation of the Jews 09:45  |  MarianoW 07/01/08
  16.   The settlements are not the problem. 09:47  |  Steve the Pals. 07/01/08
  17.   touché!...touché!...and again, touché!!! 09:51  |  eric 07/01/08
  18.   #9 nutullie is addicted to posting garbage 09:55  |  victor hardman 07/01/08
  19.   The obstacle to Peace are the Arabs themselves, they are violent! 10:10  |  Mark Hamil 07/01/08
  20.   Turning proud Zionism into a shifty enterprise 10:13  |  Esther 07/01/08
  21.   The Left More than Arabs Is an Obstacle to Zionism 10:17  |  Joseph E . 07/01/08
  22.   ANTI SEMITISM is an obstacle to Zionism!! 10:25  |  Ben Uziel 07/01/08
  23.   To the reformed/left - Judaism is the biggest obstacle 10:26  |  Binyamin Dissen 07/01/08
  24.   Akiva Eldar is right 10:28  |  regdi05 07/01/08
  25.   Survival of Infidels is the Obstacle to Peace 10:34  |  Efox 07/01/08
  26.   #2, Yardena and her wordings 10:37  |  roberto 07/01/08
  27.   My name is Durson and I haven`t had my valium 10:41  |  roberto 07/01/08
  28.   9Natalie Durson,this addiction is called insatiable greed! 10:41  |  lakshmi 07/01/08
  29.   #6 10:49  |  roberto 07/01/08
  30.   If the Palestinians really wanted piece 10:50  |  Zev 07/01/08
  31.   Indrajaya`s laughable ignorance!! 10:50  |  Stan 07/01/08
  32.   Pseudo progressive self loathing elites in Israel r the obstacle! 10:53  |  Chaim 07/01/08
  33.   even THE ZIONIST STORY ENDS 11:13  |  Atilla Karagözoğlu 07/01/08
  34.   ELDAR SELLS JEWISH DESTINY FOR DEMOCRACY...SEE YA IN USA AKIVA... 11:19  |  REAL JEWS 07/01/08
  35.   Strange pervervisity when an HaAretz editorial shows concern for 11:22  |  josef cohen 07/01/08
  36.   real obstacles to peace on this talkback 11:31  |  obstacletowar 07/01/08
  37.   Roberto in Mexico 11:33  |  Stan 07/01/08
  38.   Eldar is an obstacle to Zionism 11:55  |  Gilad 07/01/08
  39.   #21 Joseph and his obstacles 12:09  |  roberto 07/01/08
  40.   American&Israeli settlements with God bring Peace 12:29  |  sam 07/01/08
  41.   eric "touche" 12:34  |  rafi 07/01/08
  42.   Hitler would have built settlements too 13:12  |  Teich 07/01/08
  43.   #1 13:16  |  DANNY 07/01/08
  44.   #24 Regdi05, "amen" to your energizing idea! 13:18  |  AliciaYasmeen 07/01/08
  45.   Akiva needs a visit to the Gush 13:44  |  peter 07/01/08
  46.   Eric the private dancer 13:51  |  Jasmine Murphy 07/01/08
  47.   Gone in seconds 13:59  |  Gilad 07/01/08
  48.   Josef Cohen 14:01  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 07/01/08
  49.   Zionism its own worst enemy 14:09  |  The Other Alan 07/01/08
  50.   Re Yishai #10 15:07  |  Esther 07/01/08
  51.   The Arabs still believe the Jews stole all the land 15:34  |  Sam 07/01/08
  52.   Gone in seconds? to #47 15:37  |  regdi05 07/01/08
  53.   Original Promised Land 15:38  |  Petra 07/01/08
  54.   Zionistan is based around land theft & war 16:09  |  POP 07/01/08
  55.   I thought Zionism was a form of racism. The UN says so 16:09  |  POP 07/01/08
  56.   How different parties deal with the demographic/borders problem 16:12  |  Tosefta 07/01/08
  57.   # 43, DANNY 16:34  |  indrajaya 07/01/08
  58.   # 31, STAN 16:38  |  indrajaya 07/01/08
  59.   ahem 16:46  |  ahem 07/01/08
  60.   Self-delusions 16:46  |  Bo 07/01/08
  61.   #54/5 and rabid delusions keep him posting 17:35  |  victor hardman 07/01/08
  62.   " months ago Eldar was for a bi-national state 17:43  |  Absolute Sweden 07/01/08
  63.   POP the UN is a racist body 17:55  |  Jasmine Murphy 07/01/08
  64.   #1 Please Indrajaya, go to a madrassa and learn English 17:56  |  JG 07/01/08
  65.   And when Obama becomes President. . . 18:17  |  Stuart Wilder 07/01/08
  66.   Look what has already happened 18:27  |  Walter 07/01/08
  67.   Eldar Be Honest, You Are Anti-Zionist 18:50  |  Tod Zuckerman 07/01/08
  68.   # 26 re make them -givethem-love them-coddle them..etc 18:51  |  Yardena 07/01/08
  69.   fear of change 18:54  |  david 07/01/08
  70.   #25 Say Efox 19:05  |  ballistic 07/01/08
  71.   #61 Say Paul Harris 19:13 &n