After Iowa: Is there room for both McCain and Giuliani? - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Thu., January 10, 2008 Shvat 3, 5768

Israel Time: 02:04 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Rosner's Domain

Diplomacy

Defense

Jewish World

Opinion

National

Print Edition

Advertising

Books

Arts & Leisure

Business

Real Estate

Easy Start

Travel

Week's End

Anglo File



		U.S. Republican presidential candidate Senator John McCain speaking in Iowa last week. (AP)

Last update - 20:16 05/01/2008

After Iowa: Is there room for both McCain and Giuliani?

By Shmuel Rosner, Haaretz Correspondent

Tags: Iowa, John McCain, Primaries

DES MOINES, Iowa - It's Wednesday night, and Hillary Clinton's face is on the TV screen. In another moment she'll say something funny; apparently she's capable of it. This was a festive evening for her, 24 hours before the Iowa caucus - but festive also for the host of the CBS Late Show. After being kept off the air by the Writers Guild strike, David Letterman is back. So he chose to open the show with a slight by Clinton: "Dave has been off the air for eight long weeks because of the writers strike," she said in a taped opening from Iowa. "Tonight, he's back. Oh, well, all good things come to an end."

An end has also come to the crazy Iowa race. "'Caucus' is a Greek word," Letterman's rival Jay Leno explained on the NBC Tonight Show, "which means 'the only day anyone pays attention to Iowa.'" In any case it's time to look forward, to New Hampshire next week, and beyond.

Republican candidate John McCain spent Wednesday in New Hampshire, and came here only in the afternoon, for a final campaign blitz. At 8 P.M., running very late (ice on the airport runway), he stepped out of the car into the bitter cold, and immediately entered the crowded, stuffy room where several hundred supporters were waiting with boundless patience. They already heard the flattering new poll numbers: McCain leads in New Hampshire, McCain takes national Republican lead in a new Pew Research Center poll ahead of Rudy Giuliani, the front-runner all year. It's just by 1 percent, but it's the momentum that counts. McCain's up, Giuliani's down.

	Advertisement

A week ago we reported here on McCain's progress, a by-product of America's relative success in Iraq in recent months. But McCain doesn't stick only to Iraq. He is the candidate insisting that the 2008 elections focus, ultimately, on foreign policy. "I know Pakistan. I know Israel," he declared. "I know these countries"- meaning the problematic ones that demand special attention.

Three senators accompany McCain to the event: former presidential candidate Sam Brownback of Kansas, John Thune of South Dakota, and Lindsey Graham of South Carolina, who tells the crowd how much world leaders respect McCain. He counts among his friends several Israelis, including Defense Minister Ehud Barak.

McCain left "my favorite Democrat" back in New Hampshire to carry on the good work. The mention of Joe Lieberman of Connecticut brings cheers from the crowd here in Iowa. Two weeks ago Lieberman announced his endorsement of the Republican McCain - a pretty astonishing move for someone who ran for vice president seven years ago on the Democratic ticket alongside Al Gore (as well as the first Jew to contend for that high office). And now the rumors that nobody confirms are spreading, and have reached all the way to senior officials in Jerusalem: Lieberman may also be McCain's running mate.

As McCain's candidacy picks up speed, questions abound regarding Giuliani's bid. John Podhoretz, the new editor of the neoconservative Commentary, observed this week that "the candidacies of Giuliani and McCain are one and the same - a pitch to be the president best suited to fighting the war on terror based on strong leadership skills and personal heroism." Now that McCain's position is growing stronger, it's not certain there will be room for both of them. One will have to disappear for the other to win the party's nomination.

The two candidates do have different takes on the Israeli issue. McCain's is the more traditional approach to resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, though he recently explained that a gradual solution is preferable to trying to resolve the conflict in one go, and also said that an American victory in Iraq is a necessary precondition for a successful Israeli-Palestinian agreement.

Still, McCain supports establishing a Palestinian state at the end of the process. Giuliani is more radical: he is not at all certain that a Palestinian state is in America's best interest, as he recently explained in an article for Foreign Affairs

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	'Bush go home'
	Israeli Arab parties join leftist protests against the Bush visit.


	Peace overture
	Syria says it isn't seeking a military solution with Israel.




1.	Personally	02:28	\|	Chris Linthwaite	05/01/08

2.	And GOP foreign policy is good for Israel...	03:56	\|	Hank Essay	05/01/08

3.	yawn	04:17	\|	politician	05/01/08

4.	Obama	06:12	\|	JJ	05/01/08

5.	Who is more appealing to Americans?	06:31	\|	Mark Lincoln	05/01/08

6.	why is rosner writing about	07:43	\|	david	05/01/08

7.	Lincoln, Re: Hispanics	08:16	\|	politician	05/01/08

8.	Lincoln, Re: Hispanics	08:16	\|	politician	05/01/08

9.	Pick Jack the Spaniel for President	10:30	\|	Clickfool	05/01/08

10.	#9 the clucking fool and blair and brown	10:54	\|	victor hardman	05/01/08

11.	RP	11:30	\|	Thomas	05/01/08

12.	OF COURSE, JUST REMEMBER BUSH AT 2000	16:06	\|	indrajaya	05/01/08

13.	SAME ARTICLE - 2 Sets of Talkbacks	16:29	\|	Mark of Lewiston	05/01/08

14.	No. 5 Mark Lincoln	19:20	\|	Steve	05/01/08

15.	Of course there`s room for both	21:41	\|	Jason_M	05/01/08

16.	McCain & Giuliani	02:32	\|	Shmuelshahcor	06/01/08

17.	McCain and Giuliani	03:11	\|	Brod	06/01/08

18.	Confirmation	03:34	\|	jjvanka	06/01/08

19.	I could live with either as president	03:40	\|	Joe	06/01/08

20.	SAY NO TO PALESTATE!HOLYLAND GIVEN TO ISRAEL JEWS BY GOD ALMIGHTY	12:13	\|	VOICE of MOSHIACH)))	06/01/08

21.	say no to israel	23:24	\|	stop foreign aid	06/01/08

22.	McCain & Gooliani	01:17	\|	Bob	07/01/08

23.	McCaine is nice guy	00:36	\|	Nice guy wins	10/01/08

Today Online


	Bush in Israel: West Bank outposts 'have got to go'
	Responses: 189


	Palestinians: IDF strike kills two civilians in northern Gaza Strip
	Responses: 140


	Bradley Burston: Mr. Bush, you were born to make peace
	Responses: 108


	Early warning system fails to spot Katyusha strike in North
	Responses: 86


	Jewish group asks AG to halt dig in J'lem Muslim Quarter
	Responses: 64

Rosner's Domain

What does "change" mean for Israel?

How many states between the Mediterranean and the Euphrates? (WTR)

Rosner's Guest: Israel at present is not a light unto the nations

2008 race: The marathon is far from over

Rosner's Mailbox: Anti-Semites within Ron Paul's camp

More Headlines
00:23 Bush in Israel: Iran poses threat to world peace


22:14 Israeli Arab parties join leftist protests against Bush visit


23:37 IDF strikes kill two militants in separate Gaza Strip incidents


01:05 57 MKs vow to vote against evacuation-compensation bill


20:50 Coming soon to a Spanish theater: Anne Frank the musical


23:02 Syria says it's not seeking military solution with Israel


15:25 ANALYSIS: Bush can spur peace talks, but can't solve Gaza issue


17:22 Bush quizzes Shas chief Yishai over threat to quit government


21:36 Police recommend indicting Minister Yaakov Edri for breach of trust