Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., February 14, 2008 Adar1 8, 5768 | | Israel Time: 19:24 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Advertising
Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Children playing in the contested Hebron house earlier this year. (Tomer Appelbaum)
Last update - 12:30 26/12/2007
80 years on, massacre victims' kin reclaims Hebron house
By Nadav Shragai
Tags: Israel, Palestinians, Hebron 

Between stretching plastic sheets over the windows and placing buckets exactly under the leaks in the roof, settlers at a contested house between Kiryat Arba and Hebron are trying to maintain some sort of normal routine.

For humanitarian reasons, the Israel Defense Forces were willing to allow them to renovate the house so as to make it more livable. But Defense Minister Ehud Barak decided that the building will remain unchanged as long as it is occupied by the 20 settler families and their dozens of children.

T
Advertisement
en months have passed since the settlers entered the three-story building, which covers an area of over 3,000 square meters. The $700,000 to buy the house came from people in New York who originally wished to remain anonymous. But they are nurturing a grudge against Israeli bureaucracy, and this week, they decided to speak out: The buyer's son, a religious Jewish businessman from New York who agreed to be identified only as B., spoke with Haaretz about his plans for the house and his motives for buying it.

"My paternal great-grandfather lived in Hebron before the riots and the deportation of 1929," said B., referring to the murder of 67 Jews that summer by Arabs incited by false rumors of Jewish-orchestrated massacres of Arab Jerusalemites. "Part of my mother's family also lived there. They experienced the horrors of the massacre and knew many of the victims."

The carnage, 19 years before the creation of the state, had a deep effect on the Jewish community. The survivors were forced to flee Hebron, and their property was seized by local Arabs and occupied until after the Six-Day War of 1967.

"My family survived, and were deported to Jerusalem," said B. He noted that his mother and father, both born in Syria, still visit Hebron regularly.

The idea of buying the building, known as Beit Hashalom ("house of peace"), came up five years ago, he said.

"We were presented with several options for buying houses in Hebron," he explained. "We could have bought a house in Tel Rumeida, in the Avraham Avinu area. But eventually we opted for Beit Hashalom, because it's a bridge between Hebron and Kiryat Arba - which could have a dramatic and welcome effect."

B. said he never dealt with the former Arab owners who sold the house. "We had people working for us to handle that for us," he said. "But I have pictures and video footage that prove everything is legitimate. The Israeli authorities also have the material. They know it's all kosher."

According to B., the video footage shows the former owner receiving the money for the building, counting it and signing the papers to transfer the property.

"If the documents are false, as some have tried to argue, then how come the settlers have been allowed to stay there for the past 10 months?" he asked.

He also complained about the state's insistence on calling the settlers' presence in Beit Hashalom illegal squatting, despite the fact that a police investigation into the affair found that they did not break into the building.

B. said that he and his father are "not particularly wealthy" and that they had to break into their savings to pay for the real estate. "We decided to invest in the future of the people of Israel, because that future is everyone's future: the future of my children and of everyone's children."

B. said he plans to make the top floor of the dilapidated building into a festivities hall that will serve the families living in the lower stories - which he hopes will one day be brought up to standard.

Related articles:
  • Hebron settlers filmed harassing city's Palestinian residents
  • AG: Settlers can petition court against Hebron house eviction
  • Dozens of settlers take over building in Hebron, claiming they bought it

    More Jewish World news and features
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    What's up, doc?
    Hamas airs television show featuring 'Jew-eating' Bugs Bunny look-alike.
    Gaza Trip
    Livni takes 70 ambassadors on a visit to the Gaza Strip as part of diplomatic campaign.
      1.   Well if it`s all legal (including by int. standards) then... 10:01  |  anti-racist 26/12/07
      2.   Hebron house 10:14  |  Justice Lover 26/12/07
      3.   fair enough 10:39  |  Ali 26/12/07
      4.   Did any Arab official appologize for that massacre? 10:42  |  MR 26/12/07
      5.   Philistine "Law": Capital Punishment For SELLING Property To Jews 10:52  |  Yishai Kohen 26/12/07
      6.   He`s lying. 11:08  |  mrmcghoo 26/12/07
      7.   anti-racist #1 -- what if.... 11:15  |  bbl 26/12/07
      8.   Settlers out ! 11:22  |  Fussion 26/12/07
      9.   Mr; B and His Family`s Property 11:33  |  Yaakov Sullivan 26/12/07
      10.   unknown initials from Oxford ME wherever that is 11:33  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 26/12/07
      11.   There are plenty of Palestinians that can make that claim 11:44  |  Natallie Durson 26/12/07
      12.   60 years after the creation 11:46  |  Kris 26/12/07
      13.   All This Talk of Death to Those Selling Land to Jews 11:52  |  Yaakov Sullivan 26/12/07
      14.   The question remains if his claim 11:59  |  Kris 26/12/07
      15.   Desedent of 1929 massacre... 12:12  |  khader herzallah 26/12/07
      16.   Oh Haaretz 12:18  |  bytheway 26/12/07
      17.   Hebron was and is a Jewish city, and no lefties or crazed 12:27  |  Sal 26/12/07
      18.   Giveaway phrase 13:30  |  Murray 26/12/07
      19.   Well the Jews should give back Palestine 13:34  |  Marilyn 26/12/07
      20.   anti racist-- a question that shows how stupid this is 14:00  |  Burned Liberal 26/12/07
      21.   #9 Mr. Yaakov missed the point ! 14:07  |  Alberto Cohen 26/12/07
      22.   Burned Liberal 14:35  |  David Kass 26/12/07
      23.   # 14 I do fear you missed the point 14:44  |  Kris 26/12/07
      24.   Jews think of themselves above the law 14:47  |  American 26/12/07
      25.   Marilyn 14:48  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 26/12/07
      26.   #24 Perhaps This Is What Is Meant By... 15:18  |  Yaakov Sullivan 26/12/07
      27.   #11, Natallie Durson... 16:21  |  Silvienne 26/12/07
      28.   A revelation 16:27  |  Joshua 26/12/07
      29.   Natalie Durson - 1929 led to today`s problems 16:35  |  Avrum 26/12/07
      30.   Sullivan and his anti "jewish" states #36 16:45  |  SHIMON 26/12/07
      31.   Jewish citizens of Palestine 16:56  |  jack 26/12/07
      32.   Difference Between Mr. B and Jackoff Sullivan 16:56  |  Tex 26/12/07
      33.   Silvienne, why do Arab countries/Iran have to interfere in Israel 16:56  |  Genuine Tosefta 26/12/07
      34.   Murray: Giveaway Dumbass 17:01  |  Tex 26/12/07
      35.   #30 SHIMON 17:05  |  tbora 26/12/07
      36.   Dont excpect much from racists like sullivan.... 17:07  |  SHIMON 26/12/07
      37.   Silvienne: Maintaining Palestinian Victimhood 17:10  |  Tex 26/12/07
      38.   Not all settlers are crazy. 17:13  |  jack 26/12/07
      39.   Morons For Zion 17:15  |  J. Abramoff 26/12/07
      40.   tbora - please, read a book (part 1) 17:17  |  SHIMON 26/12/07
      41.   Tbora: Pakistan is Fake 17:18  |  UR Nuts 26/12/07
      42.   tbora - please, read a book (part 2) 17:19  |  SHIMON 26/12/07
      43.   to David Kass & all interested 17:19  |  Burned Liberal 26/12/07
      44.   SHIMON and the misuse of language 17:19  |  Yaakov Sullivan 26/12/07
      45.   I will reclaim my family land one day too 17:21  |  Never give up/in 26/12/07
      46.   Mr. B did not "get" the house, he BOUGHT it 17:25  |  Boris 26/12/07
      47.   Mr. B did not "get" the house, he BOUGHT it 17:25  |  Boris 26/12/07
      48.   really, sullivan?!? Go back and read it yourself!! 17:35  |  SHIMON 26/12/07
      49.   Jews Use Money. Arabs Horde It. 17:35  |  UR Nuts 26/12/07
      50.   SHIMON, slander is slander 17:54  |  Yaakov Sullivan 26/12/07
      51.   Answer for bbl 17:54  |  anti-racist 26/12/07
      52.   marilyn # 19,exactly where is palestine?all through time,there 18:00  |  terrornator 26/12/07
      53.   Answer for Burned Liberal 18:07  |  anti-racist 26/12/07
      54.   Yaakov-Yaakov - VaYomer 18:15  |  Dr David I. Gross 26/12/07
      55.   Sullivan, you know what is funny?!?! 18:24  |  SHIMON 26/12/07
      56.   thank you to anti-racist 18:36  |  Burned Liberal 26/12/07
      57.   Yaakov Sullivan 18:36  |  Albert Seligman 26/12/07
      58.   Burned Liberal 18:38  |  David Kass 26/12/07
      59.   The title implies B`s relatives owned that house, while... 18:38  |  zmogus 26/12/07
      60.   #5, Yishai Kohen. You`ve repeatedly said your "law" is Torah only 19:06  |  zmogus 26/12/07
      61.   re: Never give up/in 19:19  |  Efox 26/12/07
      62.   re: Kris 19:23  |  Efox 26/12/07
      63.   re: jack 19:25  |  Efox 26/12/07
      64.   re: David Kass 19:28  |  Efox 26/12/07
      65.   re: Joshua 19:32  |  Efox 26/12/07
      66.   #37, Tex... 19:37  |  Silvienne 26/12/07
      67.   re: khader herzallah 19:38  |  Efox 26/12/07
      68.   #33, Genuine Tosefta... 19:41  |  Silvienne 26/12/07
      69.   A place to be buried in(Hebron) vs. a place to live in(Jerusalem) 19:41  |  Tosefta 26/12/07
      70.   for David Kass & all interested 19:42  |  Burned Liberal 26/12/07
      71.   Hebron and other disputed land 19:44  |  Gary Pineda 26/12/07
      72.   re: zmogus 19:45  |  Efox 26/12/07
      73.   re: Tosefta 19:49  |  Efox 26/12/07
      74.   re: Gary Pineda 19:52  |  Efox 26/12/07
      75.   to Khader 20:08  |  Goldenberg 26/12/07
      76.   Silvienne, would you give a chance to no one else interfering? 20:12  |  Genuine Tosefta 26/12/07
      77.   same old James Sullivan 20:16  |  Goldenberg 26/12/07
      78.   Double standards here 20:22  |  Juslaaik 26/12/07
      79.   #72, Efox. I say form a support group. 20:29  |  zmogus 26/12/07
      80.   Ali#3 - what you`re saying in unfair, and unjust 20:29  |  William 26/12/07
      81.   Hebron is Israel and Jewish 20:35  |  William 26/12/07
      82.   American#24 - exactly who was the legitimate owner? 20:39  |  William 26/12/07
      83.   HEBRON 21:05  |  RonH 26/12/07
      84.   #81 William 21:14  |  Boycott 26/12/07
      85.   #76, Genuine Tosefta... 21:20  |  Silvienne 26/12/07
      86.   Silvienne 21:29  |  Dr David I. Gross 26/12/07
      87.   Silveine - whos fault? 21:39  |  Dr David I. Gross 26/12/07
      88.   American - the American calling the Jew 21:48  |  Dr David I. Gross 26/12/07
      89.   Tosefta- HUH? 21:57  |  Dr David I. Gross 26/12/07
      90.   This is inspiring 22:18  |  Colin Wright 26/12/07
      91.   `Hebron was and is a Jewish city` 22:44  |  Colin Wright 26/12/07
      92.   #82 William re "segregation" 22:44  |  Labhras 26/12/07
      93.   Marilyn & Natallie 23:02  |  CV 26/12/07
      94.   Colin Wright 23:22  |  Albert Seligman 26/12/07
      95.   # 83 Colin Richmond 23:25  |  Labhras 26/12/07
      96.   #75 Goldenberg re return 2nd try 23:45  |  Labhras 26/12/07
      97.   #71 Gary Pineda re disputed v Occupied 23:52  |  Labhras 26/12/07
      98.   re #59 `The title implies...` 23:54  |  Colin Wright 26/12/07
      99.   re #84 `Colin Wright` 00:05  |  Colin Wright 27/12/07
      100.   Another Case of Jewish Land being Liberated 00:42  |  Mark Hamil 27/12/07
      101.   re: zmogus 00:45  |  Efox 27/12/07
      102.   myth of Arab homes and lost keys 00:52  |  Mark Hamil 27/12/07
      103.   ABOUT TIME the world acknowlged murder/ethnic cleansing Arabs did 01:09  |  PETER SM 27/12/07
      104.   Mark Hamil. 02:05  |  Hubal 27/12/07
      105.   #3 Ali 02:33  |  *BEN JABO 27/12/07
      106.   #8 Fussion 02:35  |  * BEN JABO 27/12/07
      107.   #11 NUT allie Durson 02:37  |  * BEN JABO 27/12/07
      108.   re: Hubal 04:06  |  Efox 27/12/07
      109.   #83, Dr. David... 04:07  |  Silvienne 27/12/07
      110.   re: Colin Wright 04:13  |  Efox 27/12/07
      111.   Mr Goldenberg, please understand... 04:35  |  Ofer Maimon 27/12/07
      112.   #40 Shimon 05:29  |  Franco 27/12/07
      113.   #4 MR gets it right. I haven`t heard a single appology from Arabs 05:46  |  Marwan مروان خوري 27/12/07
      114.   #11 06:08  |  joelle 27/12/07
      115.   playing for time 07:03  |  rm 27/12/07
      116.   to NATTALIE 08:13  |  Judith 27/12/07
      117.   EVERYONE MIND THIER OWN BUSINESS 08:59  |  NGOLAN 27/12/07
      118.   #11 Silvienne: Why Are The Saudis Interfering and Building 09:19  |  Laguna Geno 27/12/07
      119.   #118 Laguna Geno 12:09  |  * BEN JABO 27/12/07
      120.   #101, Efox: Thanks for confirming B`s zero rights to the house. 12:38  |  zmogus 27/12/07
      121.   #101, Efox. Ethnic and familial lineages and property rights. 13:02  |  zmogus 27/12/07
      122.   re: zmogus 07:08  |  Efox 16/01/08
      123.   Maybe we could have more such heartwarming scenes. 19:21  |  Colin Wright 14/02/08
     Today Online
    Israeli embassies on high alert following Mughniyah killing
    Responses: 52
    Yossi Melman: It's not whether Hezbollah will respond, but how
    Responses: 57
    IDF experts suggest 'surprise' roadblocks instead of checkpoints
    Responses: 27
    Ari Shavit: The Israeli Barak is not like the American Barack
    Responses: 21
    Shmuel Rosner: Israel has always been involved in U.S. elections
    Responses: 15
    Rosner's Domain
    The U.S. and Mughniyah / Not just 'who' but also 'where'
    Most blatant example of Israeli interference in American election
    How Lantos was different (WTR)
    Poll: Was killing Mughniyah both justified and wise?
    Guest: Bush is a friend very wise and courageous


    More Headlines
    18:17 Israel issues warning over likely attempts to abduct Israelis abroad
    18:47 Nasrallah: Mughniyah's blood will lead to elimination of Israel
    15:33 IDF bombs Gaza buildings used for launching rockets at Israel
    16:10 Ballistic expert: Israel ignoring option of U.S. anti-rocket system
    15:29 Hamas leader Zahar arrives in Cairo for talks on Gaza border
    19:10 French President sparks row over religion, Holocaust studies
    16:43 Shas: We won't stay in a gov't that scrimps on Israel's children
    11:23 State offers to halve settlers' personal debts to NIS 350M
    12:20 IDF experts suggest 'surprise' roadblocks in place of checkpoints
    08:58 Bush orders new Syria sanctions over Lebanon, Iraq instabilities
    14:18 ADL urges Polish Catholics to decry anti-Semitic Krakow meet
    14:03 Condition improves for Sderot boy severely injured by Qassam
    15:00 Man, son indicted for killing man who allegedly stole their dog
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Fattal Hotel Chain
    Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
    ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel
    Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th
    Dead Sea Salt
    Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
    U.S. CITIZEN IN ISRAEL
    Register now to vote in national election. Do not wait.
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved