Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., February 07, 2008 Adar1 1, 5768 | | Israel Time: 11:02 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Advertising
Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Miki Goldwasser. (Dror Artzi / Jini)
Last update - 12:31 10/01/2008
Abducted soldier's mother: Politicians seeking clout off our sons' backs
By Barak Ravid, Haaretz Correspondent
Tags: Palestinians, Israel 

Objection to easing the criteria for the release of Palestinian prisoners stems from politicians' desire to gain favor and political clout in the eyes of constituents, the mother of abducted Israel Defense Forces soldier Ehud Goldwasser said on Tuesday.

Miki Goldwasser, whose son was abducted by Hezbollah militants in the July 2006 incident that sparked the Second Lebanon War, was speaking at a rally held for abducted soldiers at the Emek Yizreel College.

A special ministerial forum examining the criteria for releasing Palestinian security prisoners appeared on Monday to have secured a majority in favor of relaxing the conditions, to include prisoners with "blood on their hands." Several MKs have voiced their opposition, including MK Israel Hasson (Yisrael Beiteinu), who said that "the question is not what the families of the abducted soldiers say, but what the families of fallen soldiers say."
Advertisement

Goldwasser said that she "wants to scream out loud: return our soldiers who have been taken hostage by no fault of their own. Someone was responsible for their abduction. They don't need to bear the consequences. They bear indescribable suffering by groups of cruel people. Who knows what they're going through every second of every day, for a year and a half already."

Goldwasser also addressed efforts to free IDF soldier Gilad Shalit, who was abducted on the Gaza border three weeks before her son was kidnapped in the north. Regarding opposition to relaxing criteria for freeing prisoners, she said, "I ask, how would they react if their child was the one who was abducted, and not my child? It's very easy to reap political profit off of someone else's back."

The current conditions for freeing security prisoners were set by the Shin Bet security service in the prisoner exchange of 2004 that freed Elhanan Tannenbaum.

Defense officials have said that no senior Hamas prisoners could be released in an exchange for kidnapped soldier Gilad Shalit without changing the present criteria that prohibit the release of prisoners with "blood on their hands."

The ministerial forum convened Monday and is expected to meet again on Wednesday. The ministers hope to have their recommendations ready by the end of next week, to present to the ministerial committee on prisoner release and the political-security cabinet.

The forum is authorized to formulate recommendations, not to make operative decisions. "The final decision regarding the criteria will be given a broader forum," a source said.

Monday's meeting included a briefing from Ofer Dekel, the government's point man on efforts to free Israel's kidnapped soldiers, who spoke about his recent talks in Cairo with Egyptian intelligence officials. The meeting was attended by Vice Premier Haim Ramon, Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni, Justice Minister Daniel Friedmann, Public Security Minister Avi Dichter, and Minister without Portfolio Ami Ayalon.

Ramon is willing to be flexible over relaxing the criteria for a prisoner release, Dichter is open to discussion on the matter and Ayalon also supports flexibility, "strictly for the purpose of a deal to release Gilad Shalit," who was abducted by in June 2006 by Gaza Strip militants.

Friedmann is reportedly opposed to easing the criteria, as is the Shin Bet.

Related articles:
  • Gov't delays decision on easing criteria for freeing Palestinians
  • PA Chairman: We will continue to seek the release of all prisoners
  • Israel releases 429 Palestinian prisoners in gesture to Abbas
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Get a job
    The Interior Minister tells the ultra-Orthodox to find work and enlist in the IDF.
    Trapped in Gaza
    An Irish woman and her daughter are stuck in Gaza after Egypt seals the border.
      1.   Such action will encourage Hamas to kidnap more soldiers 05:31  |  Conroy 25/12/07
      2.   Israel should have never kidnapped them in the first place... 05:32  |  PETER SM 25/12/07
      3.   This is so because... 05:36  |  Judith 25/12/07
      4.   The answer should be NO to blackmail by terrorists! 06:42  |  Marabu 25/12/07
      5.   Judith`s response #2. 07:05  |  sandra chitayat 25/12/07
      6.   Hitler, Goering, Goebbels Didn`t Have Blood On Their Hands 07:21  |  Ben Israel 25/12/07
      7.   PETER SM: No, we should have killed them as the custom around us 07:57  |  Israeli 25/12/07
      8.   adapt Saudi islamic law: cut their hands off before release 07:59  |  avigdor 25/12/07
      9.   Settlers & IDF war criminals with blood on their hands 08:21  |  Santa Claus 25/12/07
      10.   Peter SM and others 08:38  |  Otto Rand 25/12/07
      11.   Santa?s Excellent Criterion 08:42  |  Dan 25/12/07
      12.   Two Qassam rockets fired at Sderot 08:43  |  vik 25/12/07
      13.   Completely Insane 09:00  |  Ron 25/12/07
      14.   Is Shalit already at home? 09:11  |  KUTW 25/12/07
      15.   Santa claus 09:14  |  Connie 25/12/07
      16.   Lunatics running the government 09:21  |  Connie 25/12/07
      17.   sadly 09:21  |  rm 25/12/07
      18.   criteria shmiteria - blood on the hands. 09:38  |  Steve the Pals. 25/12/07
      19.   Shakit Shalit Shalit 09:57  |  Fred Locke 25/12/07
      20.   Connie - Sorry we don`t believe in Santa Claus. I have to better 10:32  |  km 25/12/07
      21.   SINCE WHEN VAMPIRES QUESTINIONED "BLOOD ON HANDS" 10:47  |  Atilla Karagözoğlu 25/12/07
      22.   SINCE WHEN VAMPIRES QUESTINIONED "BLOOD ON HANDS" 10:47  |  Atilla Karagözoğlu 25/12/07
      23.   #2 is a faker 10:51  |  can`t you see that? 25/12/07
      24.   Otto you`re a good soul 10:53  |  Israeli 25/12/07
      25.   What Do We Say To The Parents Of Next Year`s Kidnapped Soldier? 10:59  |  dyinglikeflies 25/12/07
      26.   We have a post-zionist PM 11:16  |  Nora 25/12/07
      27.   Reply to Israeli (Post No. 21) 12:00  |  Johnny Weintraub 25/12/07
      28.   BLOOD ON THEIR HEADS, THEN RELEASED 12:17  |  indrajaya 25/12/07
      29.   # 23 no way! it`s known as a "freudian slip" 12:25  |  eric 25/12/07
      30.   Our MORONIC LEADERS..... 12:31  |  SPTZ 25/12/07
      31.   #25, dyinglikeflies 12:48  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 25/12/07
      32.   If the ministers release prisoners with `blood on hands` 13:07  |  Yonatan 25/12/07
      33.   FAKE PETER SM @ 2.Do not Heroic Jihadists shout Victory or Death 13:11  |  PETER SM 25/12/07
      34.   All women,children,political prisoners,especially the members of 13:19  |  lakshmi 25/12/07
      35.   Prisoners of war by definition have blood on their hans 13:32  |  Ivar 25/12/07
      36.   eric looks like you know as much about psychiatry 13:33  |  PETER SM 25/12/07
      37.   OTTO Rand @2 has nothing to do with me,nor have I ever presumed 13:48  |  PETER SM 25/12/07
      38.   # 35 Ivar "Prisoners of war by definition have blood on their han 13:48  |  17 25/12/07
      39.   POWs fight soldiers not attack civillians as Pals. do by choice 13:52  |  PETER SM 25/12/07
      40.   A true enigma, Israel and the "christian" attitude towards enemy 13:57  |  Johnny 25/12/07
      41.   # 36 peter; my apology 14:05  |  eric 25/12/07
      42.   ... and the curse still goes on ..... 14:10  |  Sharif Hafez 25/12/07
      43.   Peace with Palestinians will require release of ALL prisoners 14:27  |  Ivar 25/12/07
      44.   Sharif Hafez, the biggest curse is your religion 14:39  |  Johnny 25/12/07
      45.   Merry Chrismas, Johhny 14:54  |  Ivar 25/12/07
      46.   Exchange Olmert, Peretz & Livni for our soldiers 14:56  |  React 25/12/07
      47.   who all habve blood on their hands? 14:56  |  ravi 25/12/07
      48.   #12 Vik And 20 IDF missiles 14:58  |  Dav 25/12/07
      49.   no 1... what encourages the hamas? 14:59  |  ravi 25/12/07
      50.   I feel badly about Shalit, but he is soldier 15:09  |  The Equalizer 25/12/07
      51.   # 44 Johnny Re: Sharif Hafez 15:12  |  Gil J. Yashar 25/12/07
      52.   # 47 Define your terms Ravi 15:16  |  Gil J. Yashar 25/12/07
      53.   #47 ravi and the equation of idiocy 15:24  |  victor hardman 25/12/07
      54.   What Ever Happened to Trail and Conviction or Not? 15:43  |  Jane 25/12/07
      55.   NO to freeing terrorists and thugs 16:38  |  Brod 25/12/07
      56.   Ivar # 43 It`s More Complicated Than That 16:41  |  Jeff Northridge 25/12/07
      57.   ivar # 43 and what are you guys offering israel for the release 17:04  |  terrornator 25/12/07
      58.   Blood on their hands 17:09  |  Ros 25/12/07
      59.   ravi,pal blood does count,,,it counts about 1 israeli for 17:10  |  terrornator 25/12/07
      60.   #44 Religion is innocent, it is us u can blame! 17:16  |  Sharif Hafez 25/12/07
      61.   ravi # 47 It Depends On The Type Of Blood--Not On How Much 17:39  |  Jeff Northridge 25/12/07
      62.   Dying #25 17:49  |  GABE1 25/12/07
      63.   Deportations to free the hostages 17:49  |  Joe Diaz 25/12/07
      64.   blood on their hands 17:51  |  bill gordon 25/12/07
      65.   Cipora #31 17:58  |  GABE1 25/12/07
      66.   to CJ Kohn #31 18:00  |  zeev 25/12/07
      67.   Need to make a deal 19:29  |  Marty G. 25/12/07
      68.   Send the terrorists parts from their families, leaders 20:12  |  Efox 25/12/07
      69.   A natural definition of POW 20:20  |  Tosefta 25/12/07
      70.   # 35 IvarPrisoners of war by definition have blood on their hans 20:31  |  Kathy 25/12/07
      71.   Vik 21:30  |  chaturanga 25/12/07
      72.   # 63 Joe Diaz..Deportations to free the hostages 21:39  |  Kathy 25/12/07
      73.   Blood on their hands .. Run Forrest Run 21:44  |  Scott Havsy 25/12/07
      74.   Just recognize legitimate POWs 21:46  |  Tosefta 25/12/07
      75.   No, Kathy, prisoners are turned over to Palestinian jurisdiction! 22:01  |  Ivar 25/12/07
      76.   And talking about blood........ 22:20  |  Wiktor 25/12/07
      77.   Ivar 22:37  |  Albert Seligman 25/12/07
      78.   #69, Tosefta 23:02  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 25/12/07
      79.   Sharif Hafez, "source" of judaism is creator of universe 23:11  |  Johnny 25/12/07
      80.   #66, zeev 23:12  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 25/12/07
      81.   Sharif Hafez 23:17  |  Johnny 25/12/07
      82.   Sharif Hafez, "Religion is innocent! It is us, that u have to.." 23:20  |  Johnny 25/12/07
      83.   Hold it right there, Mr. Seligman! 23:30  |  Wiktor 25/12/07
      84.   Unnecessary apologetics (Bird from Outerspace #78) 23:33  |  Tosefta 25/12/07
      85.   Sanctimonius Johnny! 23:37  |  Wiktor 25/12/07
      86.   HAARETZ CENSOR - The Blind One 23:42  |  Barak Ravid 25/12/07
      87.   # 77 Albert Seligman***re:That One! He Had An Earful Yesterday .. 23:53  |  Kathy 25/12/07
      88.   # 75 ESTONIA`S IVAR... GO AND PREACH TO YOUR ELDERS.. 00:07  |  Kathy 26/12/07
      89.   FAST track urgently called for... 00:23  |  Esther 26/12/07
      90.   no prisoner release until shalit freed 00:25  |  real vision 26/12/07
      91.   # 83 Tosefta..YOU SEEM TO WASTE A LOT OF TIME,INSTEAD OF.. 00:44  |  Kathy 26/12/07
      92.   # 84 Victor..Sanctimonious Johnny?I DON`T THINK SO! 00:57  |  Kathy 26/12/07
      93.   #83, Tosefta 00:58  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 26/12/07
      94.   eric.thank you happy new year to you and yours 01:01  |  PETER SM 26/12/07
      95.   Tosefta and Cipora 01:07  |  GABE! 26/12/07
      96.   Tosefta # 74 What Difference Would It Make? 01:15  |  Jeff Northridge 26/12/07
      97.   Nutcracker Time! All nuts, rejoyce.! 01:40  |  17 26/12/07
      98.   if a palestinian spits at the IDF he is a terrorist 01:40  |  Labhras 26/12/07
      99.   Stupid - Stupid - Stupid 01:44  |  Dr David I. Gross 26/12/07
      100.   Albert Seligman Re Ivar #77 01:49  |  GABE1 26/12/07
      101.   Tosefta # 83 We Know What You`re Up To 02:09  |  Jeff Northridge 26/12/07
      102.   Barak Ravid # 85 The Problem Is Yours 02:26  |  Jeff Northridge 26/12/07
      103.   #68-Tosefta & the Protocols 02:53  |  Yitz 26/12/07
      104.   Releasing prisoners only encourages more terror 03:11  |  Marwan مروان خوري 26/12/07
      105.   #35-Ivar & POW`s 03:13  |  Yitz 26/12/07
      106.   Ivar # 75 Which Court Has Jurisdiction? 03:29  |  Jeff Northridge 26/12/07
      107.   # 79, 81, 82 Difference between judding today and Judging Islam 03:42  |  Sharif Hafez 26/12/07
      108.   Jane - we have rejected this concept here 03:57  |  Mark Lincoln 26/12/07
      109.   Barak Ravid - who speaks Java 04:06  |  Mark Lincoln 26/12/07
      110.   She is exactly right 04:24  |  Mark Lincoln 26/12/07
      111.   #107 Sharif Hafez 04:35  |  Judith 26/12/07
      112.   no one knows more than me 04:36  |  GABE! 26/12/07
      113.   #101, Jeff Northridge 05:06  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 26/12/07
      114.   #110, Mark Lincoln 05:12  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 26/12/07
      115.   I support a wife and 5 children by making my stupid statements 05:33  |  Marwan مروان خوري 26/12/07
      116.   #113, Jeff, post script 05:35  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 26/12/07
      117.   off with their hands ! The Queen wanted "off with their heads !" 06:25  |  Alice 26/12/07
      118.   Re #12 08:04  |  Esther 26/12/07
      119.   #98 labarse writes from glocamorra with blarney 08:15  |  victor hardman 26/12/07
      120.   Being abducted is part of a soldier`s job description 08:35  |  Dutch 26/12/07
      121.   # 94 thank you, peter 09:03  |  eric 26/12/07
      122.   post christmas special!!! 10,000 prisoners for shalit! 16:01  |  i still got a deal!! 26/12/07
      123.   #89 Esther..FAST track urgently called for... 16:03  |  Kathy 26/12/07
      124.   61...jeff the cowboy 18:15  |  ravi 26/12/07
      125.   to CJ Kohn #80 18:15  |  zeev 26/12/07
      126.   to CJ Kohn #116 19:11  |  zeev 26/12/07
      127.   #125, zeev 21:30  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 26/12/07
      128.   #125, zeev 08:21  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 27/12/07
      129.   #126, zeev 08:23  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 27/12/07
      130.   to CJ Kohn #129 13:49  |  zeev 28/12/07
      131.   to CJ Kohn #129 - 3rd try 21:45  |  zeev 28/12/07
      132.   Cipora and zeev re:# 126 & 129 03:58  |  American in NY 29/12/07
      133.   chill out santa- your cover is gone 10:42  |  sptz 07/02/08
      134.   NOTICE TO THE GOVERNMENT OF ISRAEL 10:54  |  SPTZ 07/02/08
     Today Online
    Seven Gazans killed in IDF raid; seven Qassams hit Negev
    Responses: 2
    Hamas envoy to Iran: Expect wave of terror attacks in Israel
    Responses: 24
    Senator: U.S. to shun UN racism meet over anti-Israel agenda
    Responses: 10
    Barak refuses to learn from Lebanon war - that only an invasion can stop rockets
    Responses: 5
    Rosner's Domain
    The Jewish vote: Obama carried Massachusetts, Connecticut
    From Super Bowl drama to Super Tuesday drama
    True or false: Obama is pro-Palestinian, McCain will appoint James Baker
    Iraq, remember? (WTR)
    Obama, Clinton and Iran: The vote that made the difference


    More Headlines
    10:37 Seven Palestinians killed in IDF raid in Gaza; seven Qassams hit Negev
    10:17 Hezbollah's Nasrallah: I thank Winograd for his honesty
    09:39 Hamas envoy to Iran: Expect wave of terror attacks in Israel
    09:02 Senator: U.S. to boycott UN anti-racism meet due to anti-Israel agenda
    11:02 Jewish groups slam Vatican over prayer to convert Jews
    08:21 IDF soldier collapses, dies for unknown reasons at training base
    02:25 PM, ministers approve recommendations on streamlined conversion
    06:08 Freed African refugees are expected to flock to Tel Aviv
    09:03 EU envoy warns Gaza could become the next Somalia
    10:09 Scooter-maker Piaggio to begin electric car sales in Israel in one month
    09:38 Education Ministry mulls starting English study as early as 1st grade
    04:22 Justice Min. mulling Knesset panel to probe police in Ramon affair
    04:24 Water Authority: Israel is rapidly losing its water sources
    06:24 Two children lightly hurt in Qassam strike on Negev kibbutz
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Fattal Hotel Chain
    Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
    ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel
    Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th
    Dead Sea Salt
    Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
    U.S. CITIZEN PRESIDENTIAL PRIMARY
    Last chance to vote in Israel, in-person, Democrats-Abroad Global Primary.
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved