Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., May 08, 2008 Iyyar 3, 5768 | | Israel Time: 11:20 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Advertising
Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 10:04 23/12/2007
Time to stop mourning
By Meron Benvenisti
Tags: Nakba, Palestinians, Israel

The celebrations planned to mark Israel's 60th Independence Day have become, as expected, a source of confrontation between the Jewish community, which seeks to foster patriotic feelings and build bridges between its divided populations, and the Palestinian-Israeli community, whose national tragedy it recalls. It is an exact reenactment of the confrontation that occurred 10 years ago, when the celebration of the state's jubilee served as a catalyst and focal point for feelings of mourning and protest, and for designating Nakba Day, which, together with Land Day, became a central date on the Palestinian calendar.

The confrontation is unavoidable. After all, the day of celebration for one side is truly a day of mourning for the other. The pious attempts to find a common denominator are of no avail. It would have been possible to leave the Palestinians alone and not impose an obligatory celebration on them, but Israeli spokespersons cannot remain indifferent to the Palestinian expressions of protest. They see the Palestinian protest as a disguised aspiration to destroy Israel, ostensibly cloaked in "mourning over the establishment of the state."

Only paranoia and a repressed feeling of guilt could produce the shocking sentence uttered by Public Security Minister Avi Dichter: "Those who sit year after year and cry about the Nakba shouldn't be surprised if in the end they really do have a Nakba." The Palestinian community is entitled to express its pain and those, like Dichter, who think it is possible to buy them with "livelihood and education" demonstrate they are still stuck in the thinking of the military government of the 1950s.
Advertisement
The protest and boycott of "the hypocritical celebration" is understandable, but their public and organized expression actually highlights a different facet, which counters the weeping and mourning of Nakba Day. Anyone examining the history of the Palestinian minority in Israel since the establishment of the state cannot but be surprised by its achievements.

It started as a community that numbered less than 200,000 people, who were considered a fifth column by Israelis and as traitors who served the occupier in the eyes of their brethren across the border.

The Palestinian-Israelis lived for many years under a repressive regime and they were mainly concerned with the difficulties of earning a living and the danger of their land being robbed. They had little confidence in themselves and the authorities worked to deepen this feeling.

Under these conditions, one does not focus on collective rights, but rather on the daily struggle for improvement on a limited scope. Slowly, the economic, social and legal situation began to improve, and attention could then turn to the source of the deprivation: the collective discrimination and the ethnic labeling.

The expressions of protest, such as Nakba Day and Land Day, did not develop and become more acute because the deprivation became more severe. The opposite is true: The system became more flexible, the Arab minority grew fivefold and despite the deprivation and discrimination in education and social services, many of its members recorded impressive achievements.

On the eve of the 60th anniversary of the Nakba, the Palestinian-Israeli minority could proudly note the dramatic change that occurred in their community, which transformed from a marginal group into a consolidated minority that recognizes its own value and challenges the majority community by presenting documents demanding collective equality and the rights of an indigenous national minority.

If the Palestinian-Israelis were to liberate themselves from the tradition of mourning the Nakba, they would be free to see how they have changed from a group that was disparaged by their people across the border into a community whose leaders and intellectuals are at the forefront of the Palestinian national movement.

Indeed, while the PLO is changing from being the leader of a national liberation movement into a collection of beggars at international conferences, while Hamas bunkers itself in anachronistic positions that can only lead to tragedy, and while the Palestinian diaspora remains without leadership - the Palestinian-Israeli community becomes the standard bearer of Palestinian democratic nationalism, cognizant of the limitations of its power and intimately familiar with its Jewish-Zionist rival.

If they would only extricate themselves from the sackcloth of the Nakba, the Palestinian-Israelis could celebrate their impressive accomplishments on the 60th anniversary, and thus accord the correct proportions to the celebrations.
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Nakba protest
World Likud chief calls for cancellation of Nakba Day procession.
Perfect match
TA court sentences 'DNA Rapist' to 25 years in prison.
  1.   Have Jews stopped mourning the holocaust? 10:54  |  Israeli Arab 23/12/07
  2.   "Voluntary evacuation" of all Arabs in Israel, Samaria & Judea 12:01  |  a "leftist" idea 23/12/07
  3.   Hello Meron , Counting one`s blessings 12:51  |  Dutch 23/12/07
  4.   #1 is right, it was a tradegy, nobody can change this 13:02  |  Philip 23/12/07
  5.   Isreali Arabs 13:52  |  alan 23/12/07
  6.   What an unreasonable request??? 13:53  |  Joe 23/12/07
  7.   Translated: Just give the "Zionism light"-Israeli a good feeling, 14:00  |  Andreas 23/12/07
  8.   Philip who do you talk to? 14:03  |  Israeli 23/12/07
  9.   The memory of Nakhba. 14:26  |  klas 23/12/07
  10.   Obscene,irrational attempt to equate the Holocaust with Arab war 14:40  |  PETER SM 23/12/07
  11.   Let`s all stop wining? 14:45  |  Ruth 23/12/07
  12.   I asked the same question as No. 1 15:10  |  Marlene N. 23/12/07
  13.   Please get rid of that absurd Zionist argument No. 5 15:24  |  Marlene N. 23/12/07
  14.   Mr. Benvenisti - why do you say "Israeli Arabs" 15:32  |  Marlene N. 23/12/07
  15.   Naqba 15:42  |  alan 23/12/07
  16.   Meron has got it all wrong this time 15:50  |  The Arab Hammer 23/12/07
  17.   Nakba of your own making 15:56  |  PE Haberman 23/12/07
  18.   This is part of a civil rights process.... 16:12  |  Teresa-Maria (Tess) 23/12/07
  19.   there is a difference 16:17  |  Skeptic 23/12/07
  20.   To the Arab Hammer in Jeusalem 16:22  |  Marlene N. 23/12/07
  21.   Where is Yossi Melman? 16:23  |  soa 23/12/07
  22.   Israeli Arab #1 Mourning & Arab Hammer-not to forget but... 16:24  |  Dorothy 23/12/07
  23.   Israeli-Arabs as cartoon characters 16:26  |  FOX 23/12/07
  24.   Arab Hammer 16:32  |  Dorothy 23/12/07
  25.   Marlene 16:45  |  Ehud 23/12/07
  26.   The Palestinians have managed to convince some 16:47  |  Other Voices 23/12/07
  27.   War criminal dichter deserves his Nakba at the ICJ 16:53  |  Labhras 23/12/07
  28.   # 1 Israeli Arab...Celebrating accomplishments is 16:58  |  Lynn 23/12/07
  29.   Nakba/Shoah - let`s not betray the dead 17:00  |  English Resident 23/12/07
  30.   Compare Creation of Israel to Holocaust? 17:03  |  Nik "Banned" Miller 23/12/07
  31.   I wish to ask and receive an honest answer from an Arab: 17:03  |  Avihu 23/12/07
  32.   Mourning "Nakhba" is like mourning Germany`s defeat at WWII 17:18  |  Bob 23/12/07
  33.   Naqba and Holocaust, apples and oranges 17:33  |  Dennis M Starkman 23/12/07
  34.   30. sorry nick with banned intellect 17:47  |  the real deal 23/12/07
  35.   to 1: Naqba and to feel palestinian, not to serve but live here? 17:50  |  Alain 23/12/07
  36.   So hwy do they oppose transfering triangle to Palestine?? 17:51  |  Alain 23/12/07
  37.   to #23, fox 17:52  |  nassim 23/12/07
  38.   To 13, 27. Marlene & Labhras. Arab countries are 18:01  |  Altalena 23/12/07
  39.   Avihu @ 31 Excellent question! 18:16  |  Yedidyah 23/12/07
  40.   #38 Altalena 18:20  |  Labhras 23/12/07
  41.   To Israeli Arab 18:26  |  Bruce 23/12/07
  42.   when do we stop mourning the nakba 18:36  |  Jonathan 23/12/07
  43.   JONATHAN AND ETHNIC CLEANSING 19:04  |  Brant 23/12/07
  44.   35. no one expects zion to do the right thing, never has 19:19  |  but you asked 23/12/07
  45.   Brant the imbecile 20:02  |  Marilyn 23/12/07
  46.   Well if you ask me, 20:05  |  Gil 23/12/07
  47.   just another border, Brant? 20:11  |  Murray 23/12/07
  48.   The next middle east Nakba 20:18  |  Labhras 23/12/07
  49.   #10 PETER SM - great point. Until Arab-Israelis recognize 20:30  |  Marwan مروان خوري 23/12/07
  50.   Marwan regarding PETER SM, I also add my 20:50  |  Fawaz 23/12/07
  51.   Incomplete thought 20:51  |  Colin Wright 23/12/07
  52.   49. since they were there first mossadi 21:05  |  get real 23/12/07
  53.   israeli arab 21:08  |  alfredo 23/12/07
  54.   To Marilyn #35 21:50  |  PE Haberman 23/12/07
  55.   MARILYN: My reply 21:52  |  Brant 23/12/07
  56.   Marlene N. #13 21:58  |  David Israel 23/12/07
  57.   MURRAY: YES JUST ANOTHER BORDER 22:05  |  Brant 23/12/07
  58.   Meron Benvenisti has no right to tell Arabs ... 22:16  |  Boris 23/12/07
  59.   Meron Benvenisti has no right to tell Arabs ... 22:16  |  Boris 23/12/07
  60.   Сколько волка не корми 22:18  |  Boris 23/12/07
  61.   LABHRAS AND WAR CRIMINALS 22:34  |  Brant 23/12/07
  62.   54. PeeWee Herman 22:47  |  facts 23/12/07
  63.   Naqba is real, holocaust is not 23:05  |  Wael Schliefer 23/12/07
  64.   Naqba is real, holocaust is not 23:05  |  Wael Schliefer 23/12/07
  65.   facts 23:08  |  Fact2 23/12/07
  66.   61. earth to brant 23:17  |  the other guy 23/12/07
  67.   let the fith colum feel sorry for themselves I will be partying 23:19  |  zionist forever 23/12/07
  68.   Israeli Arab is an Oxymoron 23:38  |  Yaakov Ish Tam 23/12/07
  69.   #62 facts 23:40  |  Bobby 23/12/07
  70.   Merry Christmas! 23:42  |  Denise 23/12/07
  71.   Marilyn 23:44  |  Bobby 23/12/07
  72.   "FACTS" Lies 00:06  |  Brant 24/12/07
  73.   Dreaming 00:25  |  Ron 24/12/07
  74.   "63 Bobby re Facts. 00:38  |  Labhras 24/12/07
  75.   #65 Bobby re squatters 00:44  |  Labhras 24/12/07
  76.   TO PETER SM # 10 00:44  |  The Teacher/Instruct 24/12/07
  77.   Thank you Marlene for your posts 00:50  |  Janet 24/12/07
  78.   #55 Brant 00:53  |  Labhras - 24/12/07
  79.   To `Israeli Arab` - Jews don`t attack Germans over the holocaust 01:08  |  Steve Randolph 24/12/07
  80.   STOP BEING TRICKED INTO DISCUSSING HOW ISRAEL FORMED. IT`S 2007 01:13  |  Steve Randolph 24/12/07
  81.   # 1 Israeli Arab "Is Arab suffering lesser than Jewish suffering? 01:42  |  17 24/12/07
  82.   Let Arabs to celebrate their little holidays. Vive Naqba 01:49  |  Naqba lover 24/12/07
  83.   Facts - One can not steal anything that is not owned by somebody 02:01  |  17 24/12/07
  84.   US National Day of Mourning 03:00  |  LisaV 24/12/07
  85.   #1 you are wrong comparison. your way leads downhill as up to now 03:22  |  ralph 24/12/07
  86.   grow up become responsible citizens or leave only choice 03:23  |  ralph 24/12/07
  87.   #74 Labhras 03:24  |  Bobby 24/12/07
  88.   #63 Wael Schliefer 03:30  |  Bobby 24/12/07
  89.   JANET`S READING 03:31  |  Brant 24/12/07
  90.   To Labhras on Israel`s High Court Ruling 03:33  |  Dennis M Starkman 24/12/07
  91.   # 8 to israeli 03:46  |  eric 24/12/07
  92.   what a stupid thing to suggest 04:26  |  eric 24/12/07
  93.   Rav Kahane was right... 05:14  |  ariel 24/12/07
  94.   Arabs in Israel would be happier in Jordan (aka Palestine) 06:14  |  Mark Hamil 24/12/07
  95.   # 72 Brant re: "facts" 06:52  |  Phil 24/12/07
  96.   Remember the Jewish Naqba! 06:58  |  Izik 24/12/07
  97.   mourning 07:15  |  EA 24/12/07
  98.   to Alan #5 07:25  |  Otto Rand 24/12/07
  99.   If they don`t like Jews, they are welcome to leave 07:44  |  Efox 24/12/07
  100.   re: Marlene N. 07:50  |  Efox 24/12/07
  101.   Haaretz promotes Arab-Jewish friction, yet again 08:16  |  Gili 24/12/07
  102.   Quote un-quote 08:24  |  David King 24/12/07
  103.   Peter SM 08:26  |  David King 24/12/07
  104.   Oh Come On. There Are Two Kinds Of Arab... 09:21  |  Yosemite 24/12/07
  105.   eric 09:25  |  Israeli 24/12/07
  106.   "DAVID KING"Trying to steal it all crying NAQBA. 09:32  |  PETER SM 24/12/07
  107.   #101 Hardly a call for incitment 09:34  |  John 24/12/07
  108.   Mark Hamil has a way of twisting 60 yrs of the truth 09:48  |  John 24/12/07
  109.   # 96 to izik in CALIFORNIA 10:59  |  eric 24/12/07
  110.   #98 Otto Rand 11:01  |  Sarah 24/12/07
  111.   # 105 to israeli 11:17  |  eric 24/12/07
  112.   #63 14:28  |  steve 24/12/07
  113.   Janet #77 Thanks you made my point 18:31  |  David Israel 24/12/07
  114.   Benvenisti, expresses only his twisted opinion... 18:42  |  Misha 24/12/07
  115.   #109 To Eric in NM 21:57  |  Izik 24/12/07
  116.   To No. 100 23:51  |  Marlene N. 24/12/07
  117.   # 115 to izik 02:31  |  eric 25/12/07
  118.   A false "liberation" 07:02  |  Mimi 25/12/07
  119.   answer to Wael Schliefer on Time to stop mourning 09:09  |  michele 12/02/08
  120.   The Oxymoron : JEWISH DEMOCRACY 20:50  |  L 23/02/08
  121.   CITIZENS OF A COUNTRY HAVE NO RIGHT TO MOURN THE CREATION 15:49  |  someone with a brain 07/05/08
  122.   THE REAL NAKBA TO BE MOURNED 22:24  |  True Leftist 07/05/08
  123.   Nakba Nonsense and Nihilism 07:49  |  Ori 08/05/08
  124.   Tears for Reality 07:52  |  Ori 08/05/08
 Read & React
Bradley Burston: Sixty years of Nakba, sixty years of nothing
Responses: 210
PA official: No Israeli partner in light of latest Olmert probe
Responses: 168
Haaretz Editorial: Israel stronger than its ills; Mideast peace is still possible
Responses: 103
Rosner's Domain: Obama and the Jews: is 61% enough?
Responses: 32
Peres: I didn't imagine Qassams would be fired from Gaza after pullout
Responses: 187


More Headlines
10:13 Peres: Despite Israel's small size, it can be 'daring laboratory'
09:31 Queen Elizabeth congratulates Peres for Israel's 60th year
00:45 Days of Our Lives: 1948-2008
03:45 U.S.: Bush won't hold three-way meet during Mideast visit
12:25 Your guide to Israel's 60th Independence Day celebrations
02:22 Police: Gag order on probe against Olmert to be lifted, partially or fully, on Thursday
10:46 On 60th Independence Day, Israeli Arabs claim rise in racism
10:03 Hezbollah blocks all roads to Beirut airport, paralyzing the city
11:07 Israeli ambassador: Germans should be more sympathetic toward Israel
14:50 Jewish-Iranian lawmaker: Israel's behavior is 'anti-human'
20:11 Olmert: Solution to Mideast conflict is not far out of reach
14:28 Israel sends aid to Myanmar as cyclone death toll surpasses 22,000
21:02 IAEA chief hopes to shed light on alleged Syrian reactor soon
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Dead Sea Products
Buy Dead Sea mineral skin care and beauty products. Coupon code Haaretz for 10% off.
Together Celebrating Israel's 60th
The Jewish Agency and You - together making history
Pardes Institute Summer Sessions
http://www.pardes.org.il/
FAREWELL ISRAEL New Film
The Coming War for Islamic Revival - View Movie Trailer
The interest rates haven't changed
But your profits will!
Learn Hebrew online
with Israel's best teachers Sign up for a trial lesson today
Free the Palestinians from:
Corrupt Kleptocracy, Tyrannical Theocracy, Abysmal Anarchy
Fattal Hotel Chain
Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel
Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
Real Estate in Israel
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved