In Jerusalem, build up, not out - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Fri., December 21, 2007 Tevet 12, 5768

Israel Time: 09:16 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Rosner's Domain

Diplomacy

Defense

Jewish World

Opinion

National

Print Edition

Advertising

Books

Arts & Leisure

Business

Real Estate

Easy Start

Travel

Week's End

Anglo File

Hanukkah

del.icio.us

Digg It! new

Last update - 09:27 20/12/2007

In Jerusalem, build up, not out

By Haaretz Editorial

Tags: peace process, Jerusalem

We shouldn't envy those who are building the future of Jerusalem. The secular people may be leaving the city, but it is growing by leaps and bounds - though it is not easy to find a place to build. The city cannot develop to the east, in the area known as E1, because of clear-cut pledges to the Americans not to create territorial contiguity between Jerusalem and Ma'aleh Adumim. It cannot expand westward because the Safdie plan has been shelved. A real problem.

The ultra-Orthodox are particularly feeling the pinch. Their natural growth rate is great, therefore so is their demand for housing. The rising housing prices in Jerusalem are pushing many of the ultra-Orthodox toward ultra-Orthodox satellite towns like Betar Illit and Modi'in Illit. New neighborhoods should be built to keep the ultra-Orthodox in Jerusalem. It is no coincidence that the main supporters of the construction of new neighborhoods are ultra-Orthodox politicians like MK Meir Porush and Jerusalem's deputy mayor, Yehoshua Pollack.

However the housing pinch is being taken advantage of for other purposes entirely, with the initiative of the Housing Ministry to receive "permission to plan" in the Atarot area being a prime example.

	Advertisement

Although it is only a preliminary stage, the intention seems quite clear. Senior officials in the ministry over the past few months have already presented a "theoretical plan," albeit by a private architectural firm, that talks about the construction of 10,000 housing units in the Qalandia-Atarot area. For comparison's sake, Gilo has less than 9,000 units.

The construction of a neighborhood of this size has clear political ramifications. It will make it very difficult to implement any arrangement to divide Jerusalem between Israel and the future Palestinian state.

The Clinton plan speaks of the Jewish neighborhoods remaining in Jewish hands and the Arab neighborhoods coming under the aegis of the Palestinian state. Such a huge neighborhood, which would divide the Palestinian neighborhoods in northern Jerusalem from Ramallah, would make the Clinton plan impossible to implement. The Ramon plan, which Prime Minister Ehud Olmert signaled that he accepts, speaks of a similar plan.

The question of Jerusalem is an essential one for the future of any arrangement with the Palestinians. Without an acceptable arrangement in Jerusalem, Mahmoud Abbas cannot sign an agreement even if he wants to. The Arab and the Muslim world will not let him.

The feeling is that officials on the Israeli side who understand this sensitivity see in it the potential to undermine any arrangement with the Palestinians by creating a new controversy in Jerusalem.

The assumption of these officials seems to be that most Israelis view construction in Jerusalem as a natural thing, while for Palestinians it could be a reason to break off the negotiations. Even if additional housing is needed, solutions should be found by building more densely and higher, as accepted in cities elsewhere in the world.

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	Blast from the past
	The donkey is making a comeback as the prevalent form of transportation in Gaza.


	U.S. anti-Semitism
	The ZOA condemns the U.S. government for failing to protect Jewish students.




1.	Israel is building houses for returning Palestinians, period	11:33	\|	Ivar	20/12/07

2.	Ah Jerusalem...	11:39	\|	Esther	20/12/07

3.	Pixie dust	11:53	\|	Xerxes	20/12/07

4.	#1 Ivar from Estonia	13:23	\|	Eugene	20/12/07

5.	IVAR... VERY WELL SAID.	13:37	\|	TrippleJump	20/12/07

6.	They should have thought of that before	18:21	\|	RickD	20/12/07

7.	Haaretz editor wants to prevent Jews from building in Jerusalem	19:12	\|	Jake	20/12/07

8.	More Leftist BS	00:59	\|	Frank	21/12/07

9.	THE WEB WE WEAVE!	08:53	\|	Rob Hill	21/12/07

Today Online


	Experts: Far right will up violence in future settlement evacuation
	Responses: 177


	Israeli Arab group seeks 'supranational regime in historic Palestine'
	Responses: 287


	Harel: Palestinians live in squalid refugee camps by choice
	Responses: 187


	IDF soldier seriously hurt, seven militants killed in Gaza raid
	Responses: 216


	American Zionist group slams U.S. gov't on campus anti-Semitism
	Responses: 220

More Headlines
07:14 Ramon: 70 MKs support settler compensation plan


09:00 Palestinians: IDF soldiers kill Hamas man in south Gaza clash


07:16 Attempt to exchange messages between Israel and Syria fails


03:20 Outgoing senior FM official calls for military pact with Washington


07:33 Jewish Agency to appoint first ever Christian board member


08:58 Rice welcomes Israeli decision to nix building plan in E. J'lem


04:23 Report reveals new details on Gibson's anti-Semitic comments


03:59 ANALYSIS: Is a truce between Israel and Hamas possible?


07:42 Gov't planning to close most ulpans, privatize Hebrew studies


06:58 Striking professors say treasury's offer of 14% is not enough